Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 991 through 1,020 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The non-eBay Sales & Trades thread #12048
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If you want custom game pieces, dockyards, and other cool wood paste Pirates CSG models, check out Cloud of Craft Gaming on Etsy!

    in reply to: Battle Reports #12043
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Today and tomorrow is the 3 year anniversary of starting Command the Oceans.  It lasted over 3 months and became the biggest recorded Pirates CSG game of all time.  If you haven’t checked it out yet, one idea I plan to do in the future is read each battle report on the calendar day it was originally posted.  For example, reading the rules and introduction post today, and then each battle report on the day it was posted, finishing on December 15th.  If you read the reports, that could be a good way of keeping it from being completely overwhelming.  😀

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #12033
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Goncalo Nunes’s last ability is in fact meant to be used off-island

    I would make that more clear then, to make it so that ability can’t be used when the ship is repairing without the need of a shipwright (such as at the home island or a friendly fort).  If it’s meant to be used only at sea, that would have to be specified to avoid being able to use it at random wild islands.

    Do you feel any of the ships/crew are under/overpowered?

    Not if the point costs are adjusted a bit, as noted above.  Without making the changes, Madeira is underpowered and La Pinta might be OP, but most of them are okay.  Since I prefer not to recommend changing a creator’s ideas (sometimes it’s necessary of course, when things are absurdly OP), I like to simply adjust point costs.  It’s not always enough of a fix for some of the crazy stuff like I’ve made, but if something feels too good, I just increase the cost. (and if it’s still OP after that, changes can be made to things other than point cost)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #12028
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Mr. Wick: Neat custom set! 😀 Looking at point costs, here are some changes I’d recommend:
    Madeira: 4 (considerably worse than the Coral from RV)
    Arguim: 4
    Ano-Bom: 4
    La Pinta: 18 (looks like one of the best ships in the set!)
    Santa Clara: 14
    Cabo da Tormentas: 8 (no cargo is a massive negative)
    Sao Filipe: 18 (absolute powerhouse of a hybrid, looks extremely effective! 🙂 )
    Sao Marcos: 10
    Sao Martinho could come down to 20-22 points in games under 100 points build total. Though I do like the higher cost for campaign games.
    Native Canoes: 11-12 (canoes with more than 1 cargo each are extremely good)
    Guzmán: 9
    Vasco da Gama: 4
    Afonso de Albuquerque: 8

    Sao Luis is a tough one to judge and a very interesting ship.
    Goncalo Nunes is quite interesting. Is his final ability meant to only apply when NOT docked at his home island? (ex: from the Shipwright ability)
    I like the touch of having a 0 coin on the oarsman card. 🙂
    Any reason you put the 5 masters at the bottom of the ship section?
    I would also delete the # signs from the non-linked pieces.
    I see you took some liberties with the historical side of things, given that Alonso Pérez de Guzmán was from Spain. (him and the San Martin are LE’s for the Spanish in my Age of Sail set)

    Would you like to have your own tab for the set in the Customs Database?

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #12013
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #12012
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @All: If you had to pick just one, what is your absolute favorite custom ship you’ve made?

     

    I think Conseil makes enough sense as-is.  You just wouldn’t use it on ships that don’t have a proper link.

    @Mr. Wick: The spreadsheet is asking me to request access, so it looks like you need to make the link publicly available for everyone to see in order to share it properly.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #12001
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Thinking this one will go for over $100.  My predictions have consistently been too low this year, so let’s say $465 then.  XD

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11999
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Which led me to believe that a basic 1 masted ship with no ability text or ship type would cost roughly 3 points. So I started there, added the +1 for the Cog ability and then added additional points for the value of abilities I granted the ships.

    I think the problem there is that speed and cargo are two of the most important attributes for any ship.  Size and abilities are part of what make up a vessel’s point cost, but there are a lot of factors.

    I would say that for 1 masters, the cannon is disproportionately not as much of a factor in the cost, since even if it’s a 2L, it’s not likely to be used much or to cause much damage even if it does get used.  (versus a 5 master with all 4S guns or all 2L’s – massive difference)

    in reply to: Photopea #11992
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I should pm him on BGG and see if will do it.

    Any luck?  I have some renewed interest in that kind of thing but I’m not sure what kinds of files can potentially translate into 3D printing.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11991
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Mr. Wick: Whenever posting customs using custom keywords (or even unofficial abbreviations of Wizkids abilities), I recommend posting the keyword text so people don’t have to search for it.

    In general I agree with Xerecs that they are probably a bit underpriced.  Cargo is quite valuable overall and should definitely factor into a ship’s point cost.  What is a “model bonus”?

    Here are the point costs I would recommend for playtesting: Madre de Deus and Santa Catarina at 8, Sao Jao y Felix at 7.  I reckon their fragility and lack of “extremespeed” will prevent them from needing to be in double digits.  Though I haven’t played with Cogs of course, and Wizkids never released a 1 master with more than 4 cargo spaces. (which I like)

    Looking forward to more! 🙂

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11976
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What’s the point cost of Parley and/or Secret Hold?

    Generally Wizkids priced both at 2.  Parley had some variations with crew, sort of costing 1 on the SR version of Captain Mysion (Loyal being -1 is kind of unfathomable), but 3 on Damsel in Distress from PotC.  I prefer Parley at 3 but 2 still feels like a fair cost for it.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11970
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I don’t think you can put Dories on a crew and use it for another crew on the same ship, regardless of any links.

    Looks like the opposite to me – the keyword doesn’t say the game piece with the keyword has to have the link.  As long as the ship’s linked crew is aboard, that should trigger the ability to work.  We just didn’t see Dories on a crew from Wizkids.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11965
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Jack: Have you seen my versions of Anne and Delahaye in Epic Seas?

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11955
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Ochobrazo2298: I do like those, I also have a Necromancer in my Epic Seas set. 🙂

    in reply to: What game piece would you eliminate? #11947
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Not super useful but I play them a fair bit.

    @Jack: I like the way you play… I think you experiment with the “bad” stuff (recruiters/Marines/etc) more than I have!  I think it’s partly because I like using extra generic crew or equipment over some of the less-useful named crew.  Something about spending 3+ points on a named crew that may not affect the game whatsoever… I’d rather just put a bunch of oarsmen on my ships for protection and a little movement insurance.  Though it’s been a while since I played regular games consistently.

    I usually feel like it is just my fault that I don’t play the OP pieces out of principle haha!

    @Randy: Be careful if you match up against Xerecs!  🙂

    We do have a group rule that new players get the BC, but once they win a game, she is off limits!!!

    That is a neat idea!  It also gives them an idea of what top-tier stuff can do.  Sometimes people in the community talk about fleets they’ve used to win consistently, but it’s nowhere near the level of UPS competition/etc.  Though I was totally guilty of that in 2011/2012 lol.  XD  (took me a while to go through the fleets at MT and finally stumble upon darrin’s UPS stuff haha)

    I hate mermaids a lot more than Hidden Cove.  Becalmed is also extremely OP especially for the player going first.  (essentially – go first, twice!!)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11946
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Are there any other concerns or criticisms on the ship types I presented in post #11796. Any issues to discuss with the Cog, Caravel, Carrack, or Drua.

    For Carrack, I would recommend “gets” +1 to its cannon rolls instead of “has”, to be consistent with existing abilities.

    It would be interesting to see the design of a drua in the game.

    If not I’d like to know their possible point costs before I start working on the ship manifest.

    I would put Cog and Drua at 1 point each.  Caravel at 1 or 2.  Carrack seems the most consequential of them and I would probably want to playtest that one starting at 4 points.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #11945
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Jack: Looks like a pretty solid fleet actually with plenty of gold gathering capability.  Looks to me like the Favori would have 3 cargo spaces open instead of 4, though that’s still good for the main “gunship” of course.  🙂  Actually I do want to see this fleet in action.

    You could swap Bordeaux for Gendarmerie Rene Moreau to get 2 extra points.  Lots of good options in that case – helmsman on the Intrepide or Favori, explorers on both of those ships, or maybe oarsmen on the Favori and Bon Marin.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11943
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Is there any link in the game as worthless as Benito de Soto and El Tejon? You can’t even use them together without Jonah! Wth??

    It’s a disaster with them.  Also a great example of why Reverse Captain should have costed 2 points – it’s not as useful as Captain.  If that were the case, Benito would be 5 points, allowing a helmsman on the Tejon (which you want for that ship anyway) and the link would allow for a coin at some point in the game.  Instead, to use the link you have to pay 16 points for a ship moving L that is fragile with no space for any treasure. (and Jonah can only benefit Benito, whereas normally you use Jonah to put a ton of crew on a ship with a lot of cargo)

    in reply to: Miniature Trading Forum Posts Saved? #11932
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #11898
    Ben
    Keymaster

    This seller has a factory set of RV along with a few other things.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #11895
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I’d say I’m 90% wanting to be a player, 10% collector of any English ships I can get cheap. I might have to check out Vasal.

    Welcome aboard!  Sounds somewhat similar to me a while back.  My VASSAL page has a tutorial that should be helpful to start using it.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #11894
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Master Spreadsheet changes: Santa Teresa name fixed in both versions of SM (no “La”), fixed incorrect game piece types in original version of RV.

    Also, some easy link references I made with bit.ly:

    http://bit.ly/PiratesCSGMasterSpreadsheet

    https://bit.ly/CustomsDatabase

    This way, if you’re at all like me, just pop open a new tab and type “customsd” or “piratescsgm” and the browser might automatically give you the URL to quickly access the desired spreadsheet.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11893
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Woelf: Is the Amity from CC supposed to be a common?  She is on the cards but the spreadsheet(s) list her as uncommon, which is normal for her ship type.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11878
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Was looking up the username Alanqsmithee after posting a custom by Riz that the former did flavor text for, and what do you know – a flickr account with customs!  😀   It looks like Pirates of the Tolling Depths, which was at least partially posted on Miniature Trading.  It’s been a number of years since I’ve seen these customs….

    in reply to: Battle Reports #11871
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I typically stick to 40 point games and Marines add up really quickly, but that hasn’t stopped me from using them a lot.

    Wow.  I’ve barely found myself considering using Marines at 80-100 points.  There’s just always something I’d rather have in the fleet it seems.

    Brief CG4 update: Second point count of the game which led to 2 new records being set!  +A modified crew setup and another threat!

    in reply to: Battle Reports #11865
    Ben
    Keymaster

    He flips explosives and it works, sinking my ship… and by rule, magically depositing 4 coin on my HI, allowing me to win next turn.

    That is epic and great strategy!  Reminds me a little of VASSAL Tournament 2 where Xerecs and I had to be aware of where specific amounts of gold were to plan our actions each turn.

    Nice use of L’Hercule as well.  You probably also enjoy/would enjoy the Concordia and Dreadnought.  🙂   I don’t think it would be an optimal crew setup, but both of those ships could also carry a Marine and musketeer, so you could fire with 7 cannons without having any masts up. (and without getting into Carbon Charlie/etc)

    in reply to: What kind of Collector are you? #11864
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Ben’s set reviews are great and I use them to find which ships sound interesting.

    Thank you for checking those out!

    Luckily it seems that rare does not necessarily equate to being the best ship in a set. Lots of solid uncommons and commons.

    Indeed.  It’s one of my favorite aspects of the game.  I also like how you can get more than one rare in a pack.

    in reply to: Game Ideas #11860
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Is there a rule set for solo gameplay? I am lucky, and have a crew for game  nights but would like to get this on my table more.

    Not an official one, but if you really want something to look at, Cadet-Captain Mike has a page for it on his site.

    I’ve played hundreds of solo games, and my best advice is to play each fleet equally as if you’re personally trying to win the game with every single fleet you control.  Put yourself in that fleet’s mindset and strategy when their turn comes up, then shift gears for the next one.  I actually love it because you have so much control over what happens and you can play each fleet however you like.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #11817
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Interesting to put all the crew on one ship.  Tough scenario to win with – just SM and no extra points.  I suppose Harbinger could dismast one runner early and leave it for the Dorado when she eventually gets there, then the Harbinger could go after another ship.  I think I’d prefer swapping out Cat for a helmsman on the Dorado and another oarsman on the Harbinger.  Better to have 3 guaranteed extra actions via Sac than finally get SAT when you need an EA (to move + explore enemy derelict).

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #11816
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What pieces would you put on L’Hercule (22 pts, 3 cargo) to deck her out the best? Overall fleet build total isn’t important here.

    I personally would actually want to prioritize the cannons over boarding, mostly because they can keep firing as the ship takes hits.  There I’d want Barbinais (4 point World Hater) aboard.

    Are you opposed to using RtSS pieces?  If not, I’d probably go with:

    Lady Roimata (6 points for Captain+SAT)
    Barbinais (World Hater)
    Godiva (0LR Reroller primarily for SAT)
    Helmsman
    Oarsman

    Only uses 13 points of the 22 point cap, but here we can have 8 shots at 2S/1L regardless of any masts missing.

    Keep in mind that Jocard’s “doesn’t take up cargo space” ability text is subject to the No-Stacking rule, so the oarsman would have to go to make that setup work.

Viewing 30 posts - 991 through 1,020 (of 2,325 total)