Ranking the Factions

Ranking the Factions

Factions-Overall
1. Pirates
2. Spain
3. France
4. England
5. America
6. Barbary Corsairs
7. Jade Rebellion
8. Cursed
9. Vikings
10. Mercenaries

Factions-Fighting
1. England
2. Pirates
3. France
4. Spain
5. America
6. Cursed
7. Vikings
8. Jade Rebellion
9. Mercenaries
10. Barbary Corsairs

Factions-Gold
1. Pirates
2. Spain
3. France
4. Barbary Corsairs
5. England
6. America
7. Jade Rebellion
8. Cursed
9. Vikings
10. Mercenaries

Leave a Reply

5 Comments

  1. Maybe it was on explained on MT but I’m still surprised to see France listed at #3 in the Top Faction ranking. Particularly because of their relatively weak crew selection. Is it due to the English lacking a strong gold game? I seem to also recall a recent discussion on the Podcasts highlighting France as the 4th among the major Pirate factions so would you consider France and England overall equals with just specific (and perhaps opposite) strengths and weaknesses?

    • @Jeremiah: That’s a good way to put it – they’re not polar opposites as factions, but France is ALWAYS underrated. The community seems to hate the French (especially some of the more prominent members), which has led to them getting trashed in recent years from what I’ve seen. They are a fantastic faction and their named crew options are better than people realize (2 sac captains for example, more than the Spanish and English combined).

      When I listed the French 3rd in this Ranking, I was looking at overall excellence. The French are a lot better at getting gold than the English, and since that wins games, I do believe they’re better than the English in most games. The scale tips the other way in campaign games, where the English have shined and the French have faltered a bit. France has a lot of great gunships too, and they’re definitely better than the English in smallish games (100 points or less). England has the edge in huge/campaign games, but almost nobody plays those, so it’s a little excessive to consider the English better just based on that. (plus I don’t want my English bias to affect the Rankings, and the French deserve more love than they get)

  2. I would also agree with you that the French receive far less love amongst the major factions. Historically speaking, didn’t the French (in general) have larger cannons and faster ships? Regardless of fact, they rank 3rd in my top factions to play.

    • @El Tiburón, Jack: The French may have had larger cannons at some points; I recall reading that either the French or Spanish (possibly both) phased out their 36 and/or 42 pounder cannons later than the British did. (for example, HMS Victory carried 32 pounders on her lower gundeck at Trafalgar.)

      It was generally known that the French were a bit better at ship construction, to the point where the British intentionally copied ship designs from captured French ships. However, the British were the early movers on copper sheathing their hulls, making their ships more durable and a bit faster than without it.

      Thanks for commenting!

  3. The British generally had France’s navy’s number historically. I don’t associate France with having any particular advantages in their navy, but they were probably second in the world from ~1700-1800 and their victory over Britain at Chesapeake Bay sealed Britain’s loss in the American Revolution.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *