Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1,021 through 1,050 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11812
    Ben
    Keymaster

    No love at all for the Dreadnought? I suppose it’s just too expensive.

    I like the ship, but you asked for the best English 5 masters.  I assume you’re mostly talking about regular games, and in those she’s too slow and expensive to match up well with most of the great English 5’s.  RotF Griffin (LE) would be a nice match; with him and MI Hermione Gold and a helmsman aboard, she could move S+S+S with those “eternal cannons” essentially at 1L.

    In a campaign game she can really shine!

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11801
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What are the best English 5 masters? Seems to me they peaked in SM with Titan and Lord Algernon. Goliath is okay. Cheap. Dreadnought is potentially super powerful but basically too expensive (and slow) to play. Swallow is very good.

    Here is my Top 10 English gunships.  HMS Titan was an early peak, but the Endeavour is up there with the best of them.  HMS Victoria, HMS Dauntless and the Apollos are good.  The Aberdeen Baron is also a nice cargo ship.

    in reply to: Battle Reports #11791
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Pirate/Naval Movies #11777
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Just finished the Michiel de Ruyter movie.  Loved it!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11749
    Ben
    Keymaster

    …do face down UTs still count for a cargo space?

    Yes indeed!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11740
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Woelf:

    If I have an ability that moves an enemy ship (like an L-mover on a 5-6), how does the timing of d6 rolls work with sargasso seas when forcing a ship onto one of them?  Do I roll for the ship and that rating stays for my opponent’s next turn?  Or do (only) they roll once it comes back around to them?  If the latter, it must be assumed that the ship is tangled?

    Did Wizkids mess up the ability text for Jailhouse Dog?  It says “you CAN load this treasure face down” (emphasis added of course).  In that case, what’s to stop me from loading it face up and having it not take up cargo space?

    Can players choose UT’s for Pandora’s Box that cannot be loaded?  If the ship is full and face down UT’s are selected, are they tossed out?

    How does “chaining” Pandora’s Boxes work?  If Pandora’s Box brings in another Pandora’s Box, can you get multiple UT’s from each player? (If you had a TON of copies of it, you could just “infinite loop” the UT and hand out UT’s like it’s Christmas morning lol)

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11719
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Ok, Please someone tell me what the resources idea is. I’ve been hearing that idea bounced around but have no clue what it means.

    It’s in reference to cannofury’s Economy Edition rules.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #11712
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Heh, just you wait, you haven’t seen nothing yet.

    XD  Well then right back at ya partner for CG4!!  O_O

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #11707
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Nice reports!!  Awesome pictures as always.  The battle happening in Report 9 is so cool to see.  I’m still just so glad that we document these epic games and big battles.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #11689
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Yes, that’s sir Edward from F&S.

    But that’s the problem and where my confusion comes from.  The name of the crew is Sir Edmund, not “sir Edward”.

    I wonder, did someone actually made a Cursed fleet with 2 – 3 sea monsters, for 80 points, that’s actually playable?

    Not that I recall offhand, though it’s probably been done.  I like using them at 150 though.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11687
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Historical Custom of the Day #430

    HMS Prince
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: English
    Rarity: U
    Point Value: 16
    Number of Masts: 5
    Cargo Space: 4
    Base Move: L
    Cannons: 2S-3L-2L-3L-2S
    Ability: This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against French and Dutch ships.
    Link: John Cox, John Narborough, Cloudesley Shovell

    You can find my custom sets in the Customs Database.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #11686
    Ben
    Keymaster

    With 4 cargo Divine Dragon can carry linked El Fantasma, helmsman, sir Edward and 2x oarsmen.

    The link makes 5 spaces.  4 of those crew take up space, leaving one still open.

    Who is “sir Edward”?  I thought you were talking about Sir Edmund from F&S.  Why would you need a reducer crew if you’re not even close to being over on points?

    The Divine Dragon is actually my favorite ship to use him on normally, but that’s with OE Davy Jones + captain and helmsman.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11680
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What’s the most unlikely string of luck you’ve had in a game? I just had one where I got an extra action off of Admiral Morgan 6-7 times in a row, with no re-rollers. And I still lost lol.

    O_O  Nice.

    Just this past turn in CG4, both the Pirates AND The Cursed got 6’s on their first roll attempts for an ability.  Sure only 2 rolls, but the magnitude of those rolls… beyond belief.  XD

    I’m more prone to getting strings of bad luck.  In Economy Edition, the Black Mamba shot 0/6 including three 1’s to dismast herself without doing any damage to an enemy ship.

    My 10 masters were AWFUL in the first games I used them in.  The Baochuan went 7/20 in a double action in a massive deathmatch despite having World Hater Chang Pao aboard.  This was only a few days after her and the Shui Xian combined to go 2/13 in a single turn of my RISK game.  Including HMS Grand Temple, famous junk ships seem to struggle mightily when they’re first introduced to my fleet.  We might see how some of my custom 10’s fare in CG4….

    Most recently, the Monkey’s Paw shot horribly in Command the Oceans.  With all 3L’s you’d expect about 50% accuracy, especially with the number of shots she was able to make in that game.  She missed constantly and I wouldn’t be surprised if her accuracy in that game sat in the 20-33% range.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #11677
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I assume that’s more of a deathmatch fleet?

    A simple Divine Dragon setup with Fantasma, helmsman, and 3 oarsmen (or 4 since Fantasma links) should do well.  Hellfire is a solid “stock” or “numbers” gunship.  I love the Juggernaut actually, I think she is possibly more underrated than Hellfire.

    RotF Hag wouldn’t stack on the Serpent’s Fang since the abilities are the same.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11675
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Given the above, and assuming it has the Cog keyword, I’d say that’s a 9-10 point ship

    Agreed.  May seem high at first but cargo is very valuable and the Cog ability is quite good.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11664
    Ben
    Keymaster

    This was my initial idea behind the Cog ability, though I’m open to criticism and discussion over whether or not this is a good idea. You suggestion of making it be the cogs action instead only really hinders it by forcing the cog to sit for 1 turn with whatever cargo it gathered, making it fairly vulnerable for a 1 masted ship with no inherent defensive qualities, but I see that unhindered access to this ability could make them significantly valuable if the proper set up was achieved.

    In that case, as a player I would want to try out a “cog chain” similar to the American native canoes and transport a lot of cargo over a big distance without actually needing a lot of ships to do so.  I’m not saying it’s OP (especially without having seen a custom ship with the ability yet), but I think the wording could be more clear.  Woelf is the master of that….

    “Friendly ships within S of this ship can explore this ship as a free action, once per turn each.”  This is probably not optimal, but the best I can come up with right now.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11657
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Cog: Once per turn, a friendly ship within S of this ship may explore her as a free action. (I forgot equipment was a thing)

    This may work, but the free action coming from outside the ship makes it prone to exploitation.  Example: Is the once per turn for each friendly ship exploring this ship?  Or once per turn that ONE friendly ship can explore the ship?  I assume you mean the latter, but when you base effects from outside of the game piece with the actual ability, you may invite additional issues.

    I also must ask how a ship is priced point wise prior to having any extraneous effects.

    I don’t have any formulas Wizkids used, and I’ve never seen any official ones.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #11656
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Since then, I have then been learning all I can about the game. Thanks for creating this site and the podcasts Ben. I assumed it would be a hunt to find information on the game, but you have provided a wealth of it. Amazing job!

    Welcome aboard!  And thank you!  😀

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11650
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Sorry of the long post.

    Don’t be.

    These are interesting ideas.  I think the word you’re looking for is “lateen” sail.  Unless lanteen is an alternate spelling I’m not aware of.

    The only improvements I would suggest are to the wording of the abilities.  It’s best to be as concise and clear as possible, while sticking to what Wizkids wrote so people can easily think about and identify the abilities.  For example:

    Cog: “Once per turn this ship may explore a friendly ship within S of her as a free action.” (unless you need a clause about no equipment transfers)

    Carrack: “When this ship reaches her cargo limit, she gets +S to her base move.”

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11640
    Ben
    Keymaster

    and last but not least @Ben, have you ever tried putting the shell on the Titan Crabs the other way?

    I’ve done it both ways at this point.  I think I like it better the “wrong” way at this point because it makes more sense to me.  I also seem to remember it not working as well from a constructible standpoint but I can’t remember which way.

    in reply to: Pirates Group Meetups Thread (Version 2) #11631
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Hopefully this map will help!  This is something that has been discussed in the community various times over the years, and I just recently stumbled into making one.

    Feel free to add your location with your username (real name if you want, probably shouldn’t be an exact address of course).  I think you should also be able to add a description with contact info. (could just be your profile page URL here)

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11630
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Once per turn when this ship hits an enemy ship, also eliminate one crew from that ship.

    The ability shown above is  3 Points

    But it’s not.  It’s 2 points.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11614
    Ben
    Keymaster

    1: Is there a comprehensive (or moderately so) guide to the creation of custom ships/crew/etc. point wise?

    No.  The first tab of the Customs Database has a bit of what I often price certain abilities at.

    2: Is the custom thread a good place to post new ship type ides for review by experienced players?

    Definitely.  The best place!  😀

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #11613
    Ben
    Keymaster

     I’d love this one to be more active

    Same here!

    … though it’s hard to provide feedback when the information given out is incorrect.  Check the cannons.  I like both ships a lot but I like the Soleil Royal better.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #11581
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Near-complete set of MI.  Just not seeing the LE’s and the actual MiaB pack.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #11580
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I have started a new Category called Miniature Trading Forum Threads where my plan right now is to post one old thread per day from what I have saved.  Each actual post (that is the first one) will be full width with no sidebar, so it will make the text as large as possible and almost look like you’re scrolling through MT.

    I know I’ve already shared these in GDrive and Imgur through the Saved from MT post, but this way they’ll be directly represented on my site with the images easily visible, with a site post title that matches the old thread title for easier searchability and hopefully easier viewing.

    in reply to: Oddities & Unanswered Questions #11575
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Holofernes and Woelf both said they have not seen this before… which means to me that it’s a true mystery.  Anyone know what it’s from?  Maybe that “Terror Trials” was a tournament at a con?

    Ship trophy from Tabitha McWarren's Terror Trials

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11572
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I know at least @Ben kinda hates MI but I love it.

    Just like with the factions, I “like” all the sets at this point.  Feelings of frustration have severely dimmed over time.  🙂   MI to me has drab artwork in a lot of cases (at least for the ships), mediocre ships, and not a ton to get excited about.

    The early sets appear to be based off realistic or fictional regions of the ocean during the age of sail, so what area of the ocean is the crimson coast, judging by the addition of the French I assume the cajun south of america.

    I can’t recall but I remember the flavor text for CC helping out with that.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11562
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Not to be bothersome, but are there additional “keywords” some people use for longer abilities that aren’t on the list.

    I agree with that in general, but not with your specific examples.  I can explain.  🙂

    HI Raiders could probably just have the keyword “Raider”, for example.

    This makes me think of any ability that steals gold.  I know that Filching Gold and Hoard/Hoarding Gold already have keywords, but things like “UT Hoard” and “randomly take as much treasure as this ship can carry” do not.  Raider is very generic.  The HI part in front helps to distinguish it, and also helps to separate it from what I call “HI Hoard” (steal as much treasure as you can from an enemy HI, rather than just 1 coin at a time).

    (This ship ignores the first his she takes as long as she has all her masts)[Ironsides],

    In the past I have seen “Ironsides” used to describe the Acorazado’s 2 hits/mast ability.  It’s too long for my liking, but “Ignores First Hit” would clear up confusion a lot better.

    (This ship cannot be shot at by ships within S of her)[Agile]

    How would you distinguish this from L-immunity? (L-range cannons cannot hit this ship.)

    (After this ship resovles a shoot action, she may move as a free action/Reverse-captain)[Swift]

    Swift implies a speed boost of some kind.  Reverse Captain is extremely logical (the reverse or opposite of Captain) and is one of the least likely to ever be “changed”.

    I hope you see what I mean.  🙂   Many more abilities could have keywords or shortened text, but it’s not worth it if it just confuses people.

    Wizkids did have more ability names when they made things, but I’m glad that some of them didn’t make it into the official game text (for similar reasons).

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11556
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I Don’t know how much this ability is but I’d say that it’s about 10 points;
    Once per turn, One ship within S of this ship cannot use it’s abilities this turn.
    This ship gains that ship’s abilities for this turn.

    That sounds quite powerful.  Are the opposing ship’s abilities cancelled for the user’s turn only, or for the whole round that would include the enemy ship’s turn?

Viewing 30 posts - 1,021 through 1,050 (of 2,325 total)