Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1,051 through 1,080 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #11549
    Ben
    Keymaster

    How the heck are you supposed to make use of the Fear keyword?

    Moved your post here since it’s appropriate.

    It’s not a good ability, but it can be better while submerged.  In that case it could be combined with other abilities that work while submerged, such as cancelling or Marines.  Other than that, make sure to always remember to roll for it when you have multiple enemies in range.  If you can roll for it 3+ times in a turn, there’s a solid chance it will actually affect something.  Though that happens more in crowded battlefields and campaigns than most 1v1 action.

    I would suggest a reroller, but EA/SAT/etc are better abilities to pair a reroller with anyway lol.  Those are the best ways I can think of – try to scare a bunch of enemies at the same time in a crowded space, and/or submerge it so it can possibly survive longer to have more of an effect.  The latter is one of the reasons (along with cost) that Squalo is the one shark I do try to use on occasion.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11545
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Ochobrazo2298: I’m not a big fan of the Limit keyword (especially as a way to “curb” customs when it’s not that much of a restriction), and I’m trying to limit my use of it as much as possible. 🙂

    Some fixes to consider:
    Make it function more like a normal tow-capture, just slightly more efficient. Make it so the opposing ship has to be derelict (or least mastless), so you can’t grab ships that would otherwise still be capable of fighting back. That skips waiting until the next turn, which doesn’t fundamentally change what happens when you capture the ship (compared to moving and towing it on your next turn), but it reduces the time an opponent has to intervene, and it’s getting rid of the requirement of touching the ship’s bow, both of which are nice non-game-breaking benefits.

    I wanted Bellamy to be superior to my version of Bartholomew Roberts, who has the ability you describe.  I think I will change his ability to that of Black Bart and give him Captain.  It is a good point about him being on a 10 master and being able to capture ships at will… and he would probably be on a 10 master.  XD  I also just realized something that I should have thought of sooner – S-boarding and/or grapple shot would just make it that much more broken.  Yikes!

    Thanks for the feedback! (x3)

    Given all the feedback, this is the new version for 10 points: Captain.  This ship can tow a ship by touching a derelict in any location (not just the bow), and can immediately initiate towing after resolving any action.

    in reply to: Pirates Lore #11543
    Ben
    Keymaster

    It was a straight up fight to the death, I think Woelf’s fleet won the challenge.

    Woelf and I were co-winners; I hosted the challenge afterwards because Woelf had hosted the RtSS challenge before lord_denton’s challenge.  I think “canon” is the word you’re looking for.

    I based a lot of my continued lore on fleet challenges or miniature reviews that I liked on MT.

    Neat, I don’t remember knowing that before.

    Also, it would stand to reason that he is at least spiritually based on a Haitian president from the 50-70’s nicknamed “Papa Doc.”

    I’m surprised I hadn’t looked this up until now.  You may not want to give me more custom ideas….  XD

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11537
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Given the age of this game, I’d like to think that at least purposeful cheating at it is a non-issue at this point. Maybe not?

    Definitely not!  XD

    I was asking for CG4.  I double checked a couple of the new 10 master setups to make sure they’re fine, but I might just reveal at least one of them in the next battle report anyway, partly for kicks and also for intimidation purposes.  XD

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11534
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If the UT is one that must be revealed when loaded, it would be flipped back up as soon as it was placed on the new ship.

    In that case it wouldn’t take up cargo space once it was face up… so technically you can use Barrel o’ Monkeys to your advantage where the transferred coin does not ever take up cargo space, correct?  (Ex: If a ship had a full cargo hold and got to take a face up UT via the monkeys, can they take it?  Or does that split second where it’s supposedly face down make that impossible?)

    Can an opponent request or force you to reveal face down crew on a setup with a reducer to prove that it’s legal?

    If you need the reducer’s ability to make the ship legal during setup, you have to reveal it during setup. That ability won’t function if it’s face down.

    I know the reducers have to be face up; my question was if you had to reveal OTHER crew that the reducer is allowing aboard, to prove that the setup is legal.  Ex: The Stump is face up as he has to be.  He allows a bunch of extra crew aboard.  An opponent wants to check the crew on my ship to prove the setup is legal.  Am I required to reveal the rest of the setup (in addition to The Stump) to prove I’m not cheating?

    it does prevent a whole pile of weird issues with certain ability interactions and timing.

    Interesting, I haven’t thought of those possibilities then.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #11528
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Auctions including sealed packs up for grabs… Guichuan already at $157.50 with almost a week left.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11525
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Somehow I sense too many free actions. Maybe make the cargo transfer not optional, you transfer all you can, and the rest is lost.

    Interesting way to think about it.  It’s part of my historical set so I would prefer to let some cargo stay aboard for realism. (in real life I think it would be much more convenient to keep everything aboard)  Perhaps I’ll make it so none of the cargo from the captured ship can be transferred freely to the towing ship.  Thanks for the feedback!

    Also Whydah is Cursed… So Sam should be too.

    I have updated the link to say “Whydah Gally”; that ship is a Pirate historical custom (currently row #566) from the same set, Sam Bellamy isn’t designed to link to the Wizkids version of the Whydah.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11523
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Could use some feedback on this one.  It may be too OP to be workable.

    Black Sam Bellamy
    Pirate
    Crew
    Point Cost: 13?
    Ability: If this ship wins a boarding party by a differential of 3 or higher, you may immediately capture that ship without needing to tow.  You may transfer any cargo from this ship to the captured ship as a free action.  All crew on the captured ship are placed on the nearest wild island.  Any remaining cargo on the enemy ship can stay aboard or be transferred to this ship as a free action.
    Link: Whydah Gally, Paulsgrave Williams, John Julian

    You can find my custom sets in the Customs Database.

    in reply to: Pirates Lore #11517
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What/who exactly are the Loa? Do they have any connection with Davy Jones or El Fantasma?

    There is almost nothing about the Loa in Wizkids flavor text.  Papa Doc’s original flavor text always seemed incredibly sinister and mysterious to me, which is why the Loa became one of my biggest fascinations within the flavor text of the game.  I don’t see any connection with Davy Jones or El Fantasma.

    Lately I have been inspired to finally bring the Loa into the game.  O_O  After a long period of me giving occasional hints as to Loa customs and how they might appear, going back to MT I’m pretty sure.  Which should scare anyone who plays against me.  Back in May, it was announced that The Cursed not only harnessed the power of the Loa, but brought them to their side…  some of them are already in my Epic Seas set, and more are to come….

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #11507
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I have updated the Saved from Miniature Trading post with new gallery links.  The first two Google Drive links now go to folders (first one regular, second one .zip) that have only the biggest pictures from the MT database.  Now there is one folder per set and less clutter.  The third link (“ALL”) can still be used to get every Pirates database picture httrack gave me in 2018.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #11504
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Fixed a few more things in the Master Spreadsheet: Fixed mispelling of Norrington (PotC 080a). Fixed ability text of Spanish Main GS-004. Fixed numbers of OE French ships. Changed “rices” to riches in Thomas Tew’s flavor text.

    in reply to: Pirates Lore #11495
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Before slipping off into retirement


    @CaptainHawkins
    : Not so fast there laddie, you’ve been hired!  What do you think your next mission on your ship, the Warring Tribes, will be?

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11490
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I’m Personally not sure what cost this ship is

    I would say 3 points; there shouldn’t be any “free” game pieces because then there’s no reason not to include it in every fleet. (unless it truly is a net-zero effect)

    in reply to: Battle Reports #11488
    Ben
    Keymaster

    lol, if the cursed get their way and some of their stuff falls into line it’ll be “Mommy I don’t feel good….”

    🙂   I told you it was going to get MORE nuts!!  XD

    in reply to: Battle Reports #11484
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11472
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Woelf: Why does Barrel o’ Monkeys require you to load the transferred UT face down even if the UT transferred is normally always a face up UT?

    Can an opponent request or force you to reveal face down crew on a setup with a reducer to prove that it’s legal?

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #11443
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Ben, How much do you think Unholy Light costs?

    3

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #11442
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Bartek: Welcome aboard matey!! 😀

    And Ben’s site is great.

    Thank you so much!!

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11421
    Ben
    Keymaster

    And by the way @Ben  how do you post ships on the Customs Database?

    Once you have a custom set you can send it to me for review.  At that point I could make a sheet in the database that only you (and I by default) can edit.

    I can’t believe I don’t think I’ve seen a custom of this before!

    Megalodon
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: U
    Type: Sea Creature
    Point Value: 14
    Number of Masts: 2
    Cargo Space: 3
    Base Move: S+L
    Cannons: 1S-1S
    Ability: Sea Monster. Cargo Wrecking. Horror.
    Cargo Wrecking: When this ship hits an enemy ship, you may also eliminate one cargo from that ship.
    Horror: For each enemy ship within S of this ship at the beginning of this ship’s turn, roll a d6. On a result of 3-6, one of the enemy ship’s crew (chosen by the controller of that ship) cannot use their abilities on their turn.

    Flavor text: Long rumored to be an extinct species of giant shark, Megalodon skeletons have been collected by the Skull Reaper and reanimated by Valmung.

    You can find my custom sets in the Customs Database.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11419
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I realize I’m not going to win this argument, but I have a bone to pick with the rules.  🙂

    The sea creature rules state that sea creatures cannot be assigned crew.

    Ex-Patriot

    This crew may use its abilities onboard any ship.

    The Pirate Code, page 5:

    Sea creatures are considered to be ships. Any actions, abilities, or other effects that refer to ships can be applied.

    Pirate Code page 15:

    -This list applies only when two or more abilities conflict. When an ability and a rule conflict the ability always takes precedence regardless of the terms used, unless specifically stated otherwise.

    If abilities take precedence over rules, then Ex-Patriot crew should be able to use their abilities on sea monsters that have cargo. Boom.  XD  😉

    (Woelf’s Asesino de la Nave arriving shortly to kill my crew idea XD)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #11418
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Ochobrazo2298: Neat kraken!  I like the base move especially to set it apart from the others.

    @All: My custom sets are primarily found at the Customs Database from now on; my sets on their original sheet may become out of date for now.  Once I’m done with batches of new customs in the main Database I hope to/might update the sheet that just has my sets.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #11414
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The fleet above is why I’m happy to see posts to this thread.  I don’t know if I’ve ever put anything other than a helmsman and maybe an oarsman on the Artesien.  That linked combo is very cool because it fills out the ship’s point cap space while still saving room for 3 open cargo spaces.  The cancelling is a great thing to have on a gold runner for deterrence.  I’m used to “power gaming” setups with great gold runners like the Artesien, so I’m glad you came up with a more creative way to crew her.

    Nice use of Gaspar Zuan on the Santiago, but it looks like that ship is one over on cargo space.  I’m seeing 5 total spaces but 6 crew that take up a space since the second oarsman doesn’t stack.  I would probably drop the cannoneer and maybe even add helmsmen to the Amity and Deliverance (swapping out the shipwright on the latter).

    in reply to: Bad Quality Prints #11413
    Ben
    Keymaster

    As is often the case, I made a post about this.  I haven’t had many OE cards as bad as you describe though.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11411
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Now I’m confused again. In game 2 between the French fleet and the UPS one, it ends with the Sea Crane establishing the Devil’s Maw. But France can still move. La Courageux is actually a nightmare for the Devil’s Maw to deal with because she can just sit so only one short gun of the fort is in range and fire with impunity. How come the game ended with the fort being built?

    A good question!  I think the reason Xerecs and I stopped playing at that point is because of the extreme odds against the Courageux.  All 3 Pirate ships may have been able to ram and/or fire at her before she got to either of the Pirate forts.  In addition, the Devil’s Maw also has three 3L guns, so it’s unlikely the Courageux would have been able to destroy the fort without taking a reasonable beating in return, especially with other Pirate ships there to assist the fort.

    There may be other reasons behind it as well; not everything discussed on the module or said between the players is in every battle report.  It looks like we should have kept playing.  That said, I’m kind of glad the Quick fleet won that matchup overall or else I might feel weird about it.  (as I said though, there is likely something else that led to the game ending “early” for good reason, and probably a gameplay reason)

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #11409
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Not sure if this question goes here but here goes. I’ve noticed a few “unofficial” keywords when describing semi-common abilities, like “Fog-hopper”. If at all possible is there some kind of general list of unofficial keywords of the like.

    Once upon a time there was a thread with all of the common abbreviations, acronyms, and such. I think that was back at Miniature Trading, but Ben may have saved it.

    The Information and Stats page of the main menu is my continuation/expansion of that.

    You can also check out the first tab of the Customs Database.  That does get into a lot of custom keywords though as you scroll down.

    That’s… distressing. At least the rules apparently changed so I feel less bad about not understanding, but forts are suddenly much less powerful now for me. I feel like they lead to a lot more games ended by stalemate then.

    @Jack: Check out VASSAL Tournament #2 for plenty of battle reports on fort strategy and situations, especially in competitive 1v1 games.  Sometimes it takes a while to play a game out to full completion, but it generally shouldn’t end in a tie.

    in reply to: Pirates Lore #11404
    Ben
    Keymaster

    There are plenty of references though to a main plot, scattered all over the game but no source that really ties it all together.  I’ve done some searching online and I can’t seem to find any real source of official Pirates lore either.

    Maybe putting together the different pieces of flavor text and lining out the story would be a fun project, who knows?

    I assume you’ve seen the Master Spreadsheet?  Flavor text for all the game pieces is to the right of the ability text column.  There is some extra stuff in the Adventure Book.

    Godmason started this wiki that looks almost exactly like what you describe.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #11402
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Bunch of solid auctions up… including both island/terrain sets, PotC SR pack, kraken lot, and some of the PotC SE ships.

    in reply to: I will not be available nearly as much in the Navy #11401
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Somewhat soon I will probably become much busier with the Navy and therefore won’t be nearly as active as usual (again).  However, that may not quite be the case.  Either way, I should actually be MORE active over the next few weeks, so I’m looking forward to getting a lot of stuff done.  😀

    in reply to: Anyone know mr_awesome from MT/etc? #11394
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I’m sure I have the original file kicking around somewhere along with “The Resurrection” set as well. I’ll take a peek and let you know. It might be a fun project to clean up and continue with some of the old ideas I had.

    Most excellent!

    I did also notice you made a comment on the original site asking about the “Admiral” keyword. From what I can guess it looks like I combined the helmsman and captain abilities into one, less wordy, evergreen keyword.

    Hmm.  Woelf has advised against putting keywords within keywords because it needlessly complicates things.  I assumed Admiral would be either the Admiral’s Action (AA) ability seen on Commodore Edward Preble from BC, or Lord Mycron’s ability.

    in reply to: Battle Reports #11387
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Ghost ships are actually ideal for ramming and boarding situations like this.

    You mean to stay ghostly until you need to board?

    Meanwhile El Puerto Blanco was established on an island near the pirate base, with the plan being to use the Bahama to ferry gold there from the pirate HI.

    Nice!  I don’t know if I’ve thought of that before.  Makes me want to try it!

    Very nice report!

Viewing 30 posts - 1,051 through 1,080 (of 2,325 total)