@admin
Active 3 hours, 28 minutes agoForum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterI won’t be able to realistically participate but it sounds like a cool idea! Some of the unreleased stuff looks really good and/or fun. My biggest worry is that UPS fleets would dominate too much so the best fleets would look very similar.
Ben
Keymasterwhoooaaa that sounded freaking awesome!!!!! I didn’t know you played~~~ HYPE!
Thanks!! 😀 Couldn’t get a perfect recording but decided to just go with it.
PS: Bet you didn’t expect that! XD No I am not back yet. 😀 Officer Training Command Newport is on holiday stand-down until the night of January 5th, so luckily I have a little bit of liberty time to take advantage of even though I’m not on leave. Very lucky to have any at all; I won’t be around much but it’s great to see my site running and active on a different computer. 😀
Ben
KeymasterI bid thee farewell (for now)…
If you ever get bored with Pirates CSG or feel it needs more “fresh” content, please take a long look at the massive quantity of stuff here on the site. Especially when you really delve into the categories, tags, Rankings, videos, podcasts, and Battle Reports, the quantity is staggering. Just because it seems “old” doesn’t mean it’s not good. I’ve “been there, done that”, and basically talked about Pirates so much that there isn’t even that much more content left to make that wouldn’t be repetitive and redundant. You can search both the site and the forums for information – both at the upper right, with the site-wide search function above to the right of the menu. Best to search for something first before asking a question that has already been answered. If you want to support the site, consider buying stuff through the affiliate links on the right sidebar or my links in the eBay thread.
Ben
Keymaster10 master alert! 5 total being bid on now, though soon to be 4 punched ones.
Ben
KeymasterNew .xlsx version of the Master Spreadsheet on the homepage. Corrections: Oarsmen>Oarsman in RV UL, fixed ability text for Homemade Flag (both versions of SM).
Ben
KeymasterI could get behind a structured competitive gambling scene for Pirates. With money on the line there may be a need for more strict guidelines on fleet builds. Las Vegas would be the perfect place to test out this theory!!! ?
No kidding! I’m starting to think the idea has some merit. There could be specific tables for various rulesets, with a very basic set of rules (similar to Start Here but slightly modified) being the beginner table people could start out on.
Ben
KeymasterNaturally this has been proposed before, but I hadn’t added it to the main page yet.
-Play with real money
When setting up the game, everyone contributes real coins. This would most likely be pennies/nickels/dimes/quarters, or just one of the above so each island would have the same amount. It would be interesting if there was some way to hide the size/value of the coins, such as a dark sleeve… weight would still be an issue though. It would be much more high stakes if you started involving coins like a half/full dollar, grams or ounces of silver/gold, etc. You could turn Pirates into more of a gambling establishment – get some high rollers to wager up 8+ ounces of gold per game! XD
At the end, everyone keeps their final gold score. This would certainly incentivize people to play with more strategy, but it might lead to too many hyper-competitive fleets if the values went higher and higher.
Ben
KeymasterHaven’t posted the VASSAL standings in a long time… I’m sure this list is missing games, but it should include all of the VASSAL games I’ve been involved in along with a handful of others.
-For this list, games only count as losses if less than 4 players/fleets are involved.

Ben
KeymasterNow up to 42 items being bid on, with a lot of singles. Zeus may actually sell for $110+!
Ben
KeymasterThis does not feel complete without the old thread here somewhere….
Ben
KeymasterAmerican Canoes over Zeus for sure. It’s a big scary ship that’s horribly underpriced, but it’s still a single basket of eggs. The canoes can scatter in five directions, and are quick enough that even without chaining them, they can pull in a lot of gold before an opponent hunts them all down.
Both are extremely good, just hard to compare. I haven’t used the American canoes much in a competitive/tournament setting. In larger games they can help you win, but combining the Zeus with Hidden Cove, a sac captain, and/or Captain Jack Sparrow can be absurdly effective and dangerous.
Tsai’s entry is almost a weird representation of the Sac Captain in general, I just didn’t want to include a ton of extra stuff in the list with so many “duplicates” of the same type. Just went with him because he’s the most versatile, and can really optimize any 10 master to be super nasty.
Ben
KeymasterJust finished rereading the reports for VASSAL Campaign Game 3, certainly one of my all time favorite games.
Ben
KeymasterHere is a version of the Master Spreadsheet with all the sets in one tab. 2652 total game pieces!
You can download it via File>Download, or grab the link at the bottom of the homepage here.
Ben
KeymasterBeing pinned restricts movement, which includes the movement caused by towing, so the Sea Monster has to release it first.
If Fear on a nearby ship hit that same Sea Monster with a 5 roll, that would theoretically release that pinned ship correct? (since then the Sea Monster would be pinned instead with the keyword cancelled) If that happened, would the ship become pinned again once the effect of Fear subsided if the Sea Monster didn’t move away and regained the use of the Sea Monster keyword?
Ben
Keymaster“3D Printing Across All Retail Sectors” section made me think about Pirates a bunch.
Ben
KeymasterJust saved the following URL’s in full page screen capture format and in the Internet Archive:
https://pirateswithben.com/tag/command-the-oceans/Throughout the day/week I will edit this post with more, and then upload them to a Google Photos account too. (certainly not expecting the site to go down, I just want redundancy in protecting my favorite/best content)
Ben
KeymasterPlunder Pack on sale a bit at HWG, but still $15 more than the original MSRP.
Ben
KeymasterWoelf now has editing access to the Master Spreadsheet, so if there are any remaining errors you find in that starting 12/14, he can make the corrections for the shared Google sheet version.
Ben
KeymasterI’m not sure if you’re the first person to figure this out for a campaign or not, but it does represent a sound strategy that few factions can match, since the Spanish have the most of those kind of ships and crew.
I think that’s where the “publicity” aspect of “modern” campaign games comes into play. It’s quite probable that someone played a campaign style game with the Spanish using a lot of gold bonuses, but they either didn’t write about it, or they did but the reports have been lost to the impermanence of internet forums/sites/etc.
It’s possible (or even very likely) that many more hours were spent in the 2000’s playing campaign-style games than in the 2010’s due to the sheer volume of players and games happening compared to today. It’s just that today, you and I record and publish nearly every turn of a campaign game that sees action. XD
Ben
Keymaster@John White: Welcome aboard matey!
@Jeremiah: Some pretty powerful lighthouses! For the Cursed Seas ability, can you place that terrain directly under ships? If you wanted a friendly Cursed ship to enter a fog bank to hide from an enemy, could you?
About The Obelisk…
This treasure can’t be removed from this ship unless she sinks.
For Nemo’s Plans, it seems as though it would be loaded automatically (since it’s loaded face up) and then it can’t be unloaded to a lighthouse afterwards. (without a house rule of course)
I do like the flavor involvement with an existing WK piece though.
Ben
KeymasterI’m also partial to the pregame map from my IRL game with The Keymaster
O_O When I saw this sentence in the email notification without the image under it, I was thrown for a massive loop. XD I’m pretty sure there was a user at Miniature Trading with that exact username (The Keymaster) who wasn’t the admin or anything. I figured you must have played another physical game with someone else from the community. XD
Your Armistice Day game was certainly a classic. Thanks for the link to my video.
Ben & Randy’s Funtime Adventure
I like that better, especially with the pinball and Mandalay Bay shenanigans after. Maybe next time will be “The Commandeering of the Treasure Island Ships”. XD
Thanks for posting here!
Ben
KeymasterIn addition to that lot I mentioned, plenty of interesting stuff being bid on right now. Newest are RV Constitution, big lot of SCS Promos and other stuff, and a sealed 36 pack box of MI.
Edit (12/6): Now a Baochuan too!
Ben
KeymasterRelevant post: Gimmicks For The Win – Unorthodox Strategies for Success
Ben
KeymasterA bit early this year, but the 2019 Year in Review post is up.
Ben
KeymasterPirates CSG Podcast #50: The Call-In Podcast!
You can listen to the audio via ShoutEngine!
You can also listen on Archive.org.
The Pirate Code: https://pirateswithben.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/The-Pirate-Code-FAQ-Dec-2016.pdf
Find all the game pieces in the Master Spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/18Z-x-z9gaWiKFLk-kw1weamc0A1-NxMN3xLjWWKsUmA/edit?usp=sharing
Past podcasts: http://shoutengine.com/PiratesCSGPodcast/
Take the podcast survey! https://goo.gl/forms/CsnwVmi3qhtqik323
Feel free to rate and review the podcast on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060
Pirates packs on eBay: https://goo.gl/MfHBQJ
Sign the Petition! https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/bring-back-pirates-of-the-cursed-seas
Join the Forum at Pirates with Ben! https://pirateswithben.com/forums/forum/pirates-csg/
The following should eventually be updated from ShoutEngine so they will be available when they get the podcast.
iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060
Overcast: https://overcast.fm/itunes1258016060/pirates-csg-podcast
Google Play Music: https://play.google.com/music/m/Imxc6vplvkqlmagcvkxvi2er2wu?t=Pirates_CSG_Podcast
Blubrry: https://www.blubrry.com/piratescsgpodcast/
Stitcher: https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/a7xfanben/pirates-csg-podcast?refid=stpr
Ben
Keymaster@Jeremiah: Awesome!
If other people want to make podcasts about Pirates CSG when I’m not around, please go ahead! I only ask that you call it something other than “Pirates CSG Podcast” to avoid confusion – even just “Blackheart’s Pirates CSG Podcast” would be enough.
Ben
KeymasterThis looks awesome: Lot with many sets including decent quantity and some SE’s.
Ben
KeymasterMy 2019 Pirates CSG Hall of Fame ballot:
Rizz (aka Riz the Bloody)
Rizz has been one of the most helpful community members for many years. He has submitted various documents and uploaded useful files to BGG, including some ship and crew card blanks. He had one of the most entertaining Pirate websites, the Corsairs of Douglas County, until it was taken down around a couple years ago. He did a lot of trades “back in the day” and has various other contributions to the community. (including over 1,000 posts and 16 pages of fleet/MR comments)Piranha
Tony Vigil was the Rules Arbitrator before Woelf took over, and I believe the only other RA. One of the most important people in Pirates CSG history outside of the game designers themselves. You can hear about his experiences in Podcast #46.Ben
KeymasterDuring the game Xerecs and I just played on VASSAL, the Discord chat worked great as John White and another member were able to jump into the audio easily.
Hoping to do the call-in podcast tomorrow 12/3, possibly starting around 7pm EST.
Ben
KeymasterProbably my last physical game for quite a while: Post TG family game
-
AuthorPosts
