@admin
Active 2 hours, 14 minutes agoForum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterVarious pack lots from this seller, some auction and some BIN.
Ben
KeymasterNot sure I understand your question about the Zephyrus; as-is she’s actually cheaper than Le Griffon. If you meant less expensive…then I don’t know
Less expensive is what I meant to type; I was probably so shocked that I was thinking the far better ship had to be more expensive haha.
T2 was a LONG running tournament consisting of competitive fleets that Xerecs and I played; the BR’s were originally on MT (basically from fall 2016 to 12/30/2017).
Ben
Keymaster@JW Darkhurst: Here are my suggestions for the new stuff.
Le Griffon: Could come down in points a little, maybe 14.I don’t think Master Gunner is worth 5 points. The 6 effect is just a cannoneer. Needing a 1/6 roll to get that 5 for Extended Range reminds me of Fear. First off, I would switch the rolls because the higher roll should mean the more powerful effect. (to keep things intuitive with the rest of the game; I realize Fear isn’t like that either lol)
From there I would think about making it better by doubling the odds (3-4 and 5-6 rather than just 5-6), or maybe add World Hater on a 5 if cannoneer works on a 4. It just feels very underwhelming when you can get basic WH for a point less.I would make it clear that Holy Sword only lasts for the turn of the player using it, not the whole round or any enemy Cursed turns. With that being the case, I’m tempted to think it should come down in cost. But there are some big possibilities with it (Eternal, Treasure Ship, etc).
Le Jour de Jugement: Still a good ship with the cost as-is, but 15 would work considering HMS Gallows.
La Gargouille: I would price this at 11.
Tromperie: Couldn’t this just be worded as L-immunity? (L-range cannons cannot hit this ship.)
Petite Epée: Honestly I think 5-7 points would be fair. Slow, hard to put a cannoneer aboard (needs a helmsman), and not a ton of firepower. At 14 this is unplayable.
Lame de I’infini: Fun ship!Zephyrus: I would bump this to at least 16 points. Why is it more expensive than the Griffon?
Caerus: I agree with Xerecs, this is basically a worse version of USS Kentucky from OE.Love Kakusareta Yōsai. I agree with Xerecs about Admiral Rokurōta. But I would take it a step further. The CJS/UPS ability should never been seen again. You could actually switch it out for Island/Ship Treasure Trading and leave the cost the same.
I usually gauge the cannon/boarding bonus at 5 points, so the Admiral is 8 points without the UPS, which is probably around 3-4 points based on Jack Sparrow. If it is deemed necessary, I can officially retcon the cost, but I’d think it doesn’t need too much adjustment.
Oof. Has Xerecs not told you about T2?
Crazy to see another Tartarus custom, I went overboard with mine lol.
Love HMS Terror!Ben
KeymasterThere are a few crew whose names I always have trouble typing or that I wish were shorter… Sean “Cannonball” Gallows from RotF being the main one. He seems too young to be called “Mr. Gallows” perhaps….
Ben
KeymasterThe latest Ranking might have a little too much cleavage for the youngins…. XD ;P
Ben
KeymasterHere is a model of Fort Jefferson that I printed out! I cut out most of the excess material in 3D Builder with a hollow cylinder and blocks. Then I scaled the X axis down to 200mm (I think), so the print would fit on the printer bed. 5 master for scale. In the future I might try another print with it and try to get it more to scale. But for now I really love this! 😀



Ben
KeymasterTwo new attacks. 57 ships launched.
Ben
KeymasterThough I guess I could just toss anything that no one wants.
Whatever you do, don’t do that. I doubt I’m the only one who would gladly pay shipping and handling so the stuff isn’t thrown out, even if it’s not much stuff.
Almost wanted to put the Pearl in Beasties clutches with the Dutchman looking on like some sort of diorama of the movie scene.
Haha, that actually happened naturally in my PotC tribute game.
I guess there weren’t really enough ships actually named in PotC to make a full set of. I’d be curious to know where those came from, like the HMS Adventure and the Empress.
True. Though Empress was Sao Feng’s ship in At World’s End.
Ben
KeymasterIs there a good way to find out what any of this is worth?
That is difficult because the market for Pirates CSG can be so random and volatile. Prices have risen over the past 3 or so years, but my eBay prices spreadsheet might help a little. There’s definitely no established price guide or anything, some ships sell for $20 and $4 in the same week or month for example.
You could try establishing baseline prices per rarity, such as C-$1, U-$2, R-$4, but you could probably get away with more than that for a number of items, especially if you’re willing to wait for some sales.
Ben
KeymasterI think you could be fine posting the story inserts in both places, since they have some lore implications for the next set.
If that happens, I think they should be posted with the customs they’re associated with. I have no problem with extra flavor text, but let’s keep this thread free of flavor-only posts.
@JW_Darkhurst: I do plan to review your latest posts once I finish some other things.
Ben
Keymaster“Concept” Game with 3D Printed Ships, Wooden Ships, AND Wizkids Ships
(better to respond on that post than here)
Ben
KeymasterFinishing up Four Weeks In May by David Hart Dyke. Pretty good overall.
Ben
KeymasterI guess I already know the answer, but Titans can’t repair right?
The Titan keyword allows them to be assigned crew, and explicitly allows them to explore. However, not to repair.
From the Code:
-This list applies only when two or more abilities conflict. When an ability and a rule conflict the ability always takes precedence regardless of the terms used, unless specifically stated otherwise.
Sea creature rules say they can only be given move and shoot actions.
“A titan can be assigned crew.” – an ability!
Ben
KeymasterJust as a warning: don’t use “soft” PLA for printing Pirates CSG stuff – it comes out too soft and is very flexible!
Thanks to Todd C, I just printed out this 5 master from his files he shared! (I just scaled the z axis up to .9mm in Cura before slicing; the printed parts measure about .8mm)


Ben
KeymasterHere’s a big one: Ocean Terrain Contest #3.
Ben
KeymasterBecalmed affects native canoes normally, correct?
Reveal this event at the beginning of one of your turns and place its token anywhere on the play area (except on an island or a ship). No ship within L of the token may be given a move action unless she can move when derelict. Remove Becalmed from the game at the beginning of your next turn.
Also, can titans move over or on top of forts? The keyword just says they can move over islands. If they can, would there be any difference if the fort was friendly or not?
Ben
KeymasterThe classic 2011 facebook message from Lax Chandra thread. This one was quite the big deal for a while.
Ben
KeymasterIndeed, definitely the Sleigh and Whitebeard should stay banned.
I think it would be reasonable to ban anything with the ability CJS has. Or perhaps rewrite it or come up with a new (possibly similar) ability that would allow those few game pieces to have their point costs stay the same.
Ben
KeymasterThe Rankings are back! At least for now! 😀
Ben
KeymasterWhy cheerleaders aren’t useless. If it works out right, it’s like adding extra gunpowder or cannonballs to all the shots of an entire line of gunships! 😀
Ben
KeymasterIs Calypso’s ability supposed to be mandatory?
At the beginning of each of your turns, roll a d6. On a result of 4-6, instead of giving this ship an action, choose two whirlpools from outside the game. Put one L away from this ship and one L away from a wild island. Neither can be placed so that it touches any island or ship. This ship does not have to roll for effect when she uses a whirlpool.
Ben
KeymasterI kinda want 0/The Fool to stay wacky, kinda the Whitebeard of the group.
In that case, I recommend moving them to another part of the spreadsheet. No offense, but if people start looking at your custom set and the first two pieces are completely unplayable or entirely negative in nature, it might make it hard for them to take the rest of the set seriously.
And I think the Linked reword works, I left room for card effects to move crew while requiring the crew to be part of their ship.
The problem is, it’s a keyword only used on the ships. If you don’t use the ship with the keyword, the crew that is linked to that ship can simply be used however the player wants. Maybe that can work if that’s the intention, but it doesn’t solve potential issues like the Jack+Jill one I mentioned.
If the intention is to have all the linked pieces used with ONLY each other and never have those crew on unlinked ships, the crew need to have an ability saying “this crew can only be assigned to their linked ship” for example.
Ben
KeymasterThis podcast with Mike Selinker has some interesting info and questions asked! 😀 Just listened to it for the second time to refresh and still enjoyed it.
Ben
KeymasterDrua: This ship ignores terrain, except Trade Currents, when she is given a move action. This ship treats all Trade currents as friendly.
If you’re looking for a point cost estimate, I’d put this at 2 points. The regular ignoring terrain ability was never really worth 3 points in gameplay, and I don’t think the ability to use enemy trade currents is enough to warrant bumping this one to 3. (though it might be if your entire playgroup uses navigators all the time)
Will they be native canoes?
Ben
KeymasterWhere does the art for much of the series come from.
Vincent Dutrait did some of it for the later sets. Kian Ng (yes the crew in SCS is named after him) did some. From the BGG page you can see Sandra Garavito and Ethan Pasternack listed as the artists.
Is there a good place to find like an Pirates CSG art dump?
When I saved stuff from MT, I made sure to include all of the artwork from the database. 🙂
Ben
KeymasterDumb Question. Comparatively what are the rarity scales between Black (SR), Orange (LE,PR,ETC), and Green (PR, Special). Which are higher in terms of value by order of magnitude (i.e. Crew/Treasure/White -> Common -> Uncommon -> Rare -> X -> X ->X.
I think that’s actually quite a good question, especially since there isn’t really a good or “defined” answer. For example, the DJC SE’s (extremely common and easy to get) are green but so is the Obago Deuce, the rarest ship in the game. (and for a more reasonable comparison, even Sleigh/Whitebeard has just sold for over $90 twice recently)
Your question inspired me to republish this today from the old MT threads. It’s a rough guide but a great thing to read since it’s essentially the same topic.
For additional exceptions – SCS LE’s are extremely common and usually less expensive than SCS rares. However, RotF and F&S LE’s are some of the absolute rarest and most expensive cards in the game. It feels like every week someone talks about pulling an RotF SR pack. But plenty of people are still wanting the DJC or SCS SR’s by comparison. (which are worth much more based on eBay histories)
Quite frankly, it’s complicated and basically random. There are too many exceptions to establish a clear hierarchy of rarities. Even among distribution methods there are wild inconsistencies. Tournament pack LE’s were generally rare and expensive, but not for SCS. Special Edition box ships are generally quite common and not too rare, but MI is a notable exception to some extent. There are even some unpunched versions of SE box ships that are only in factory sets, which would almost definitely go for more money than the (super common) punched version of the same ships! XD 😀
Ben
KeymasterI think you missed a point value or two
Any game pieces I didn’t comment on or suggest a new cost for are fine as-is in my opinion.
Also what lore descriptions did you like best so far?
I only read a few since I was focusing on the point costs and gameplay aspects.
Even with the new wording, you can still use crew without the Linked keyword however you want if their ship is not in your fleet.
Do you know if 0 and The Fool will get a rework?
-
AuthorPosts
