@admin
Active 4 hours, 57 minutes agoForum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterWho rolls the d6 for the ability of Paradis de la Mer, the fort controller or the player shooting at it?
“The first time this fort is shot at each turn, roll a d6. The result is the number of times this fort must be hit that turn before any of its cannons can be eliminated.”
I also think the Pirate Code entry about it is a bit confusing – the ability to me says that if you roll a 4, it ignores the first 4 hits and the 5th hit will take out a flag. But this line indicates otherwise:
-The d6 result is the number of hits required to eliminate the first flag only; it is not the number of hits required to remove each flag. For example, if a result of 4 was rolled, the fourth hit will remove one flag. The fifth hit and every subsequent hit this turn will remove one flag each.
From Tilorfire27:
Does Seleucis move another sea monster Seleucis’ speed or the target monster’s speed?
Can Davy Jones copy Intermediario? It says if this sea creature, but could a vanilla ship copy it?
-Also in the Pirate Code, for the Intermediario entry it lists the ability as “if this sea monster” instead of sea creature. (card does say sea creature)
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterDecember 24, 2023 at 1:38 PM in reply to: PSA: Consider making scans/high quality pictures of cards before punching them #17602Ben
KeymasterHere is the new home for the Scan Project. Going forward, I will be the primary point of contact and steward for it. The Submission Guide remains the same. The Master Scan List has been updated, but there may be some errors. My tentative plan is to update the Master Scan List at least once per quarter. There are still some cards we need scans of – if you check the Master Scan List and it’s empty for something you have, feel free to scan it (preferably a PNG at 600 dpi) and upload to the New Submissions folder.
If you are able to edit and improve the scans in Old Submissions, feel free to upload the “perfect” versions to the folder “Edited Versions of Submissions”. From there I can put them in Finished Scans if adequate and after any potential file renaming is completed. There is an extra folder called PSD files that contains the files that WayofthePixel (formerly thunderbros99) sent me. Feel free to use those and convert them to finished copies if you’re able. (those exported PNGs can also go in the Edited Versions folder)
Here are the links to it that you may want to bookmark for easy reference.
Shortened link: https://bit.ly/PCSGScanProject
Non-shortened link: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1hF0jXYcK-1DssnBUbhG-Von7tvaaPH-I?usp=sharingBen
KeymasterMight be a bit of an odd question, and/or a tough one to answer:
What is your favorite treasure distribution? (standard 8 coins for 15 gold, or otherwise)
Ex: 7,7,1 and 5 specific UT’s, or seven 2’s and a 1, etc.
Ben
KeymasterGiven that, could the point cost come down if I don’t give it a range extender?
I personally think so. I do think the ability will come into play often enough to be useful, but it still doesn’t feel like more than a 10-11 point ship.
Shuri looks like a fun scout hybrid!
Ben
KeymasterGrand Boulder is somewhat powerful, though I still think Repeating Guns should be a cheaper keyword. I know I’m a bad example, but I would almost never get to benefit from it. XD
Based on her flavor text, I think an alternate ability could work too: +1 to cannon rolls when she is given a shoot action (rather than shooting in general, which will usually be as part of a move action). That way the cannons get a bonus when she stays in place to shoot.
Grand Jungle is quite interesting, would make for the cheapest 3 master in the game. In her flavor text, do you mean shallow draft rather than deep draft? (with the hull not sticking as far down, to avoid the weeds)
Ben
KeymasterIn about 2 weeks I’ll be starting the annual End of Year thread. Feel free to start brainstorming some of the categories for your own experience of PCSG this year, such as favorite picture, favorite game/moment, etc. 🙂
Ben
KeymasterIf an L-mover forces a ship onto a whirlpool, which player decides if that ship goes through and where it ends up? (the moving player or the original controller?)
“Give this ship a move action but do not move her. Instead, roll a d6. On a result of 5 or 6, move an enemy ship L in any direction.”
Ben
KeymasterHappy to be on the podium for another BGG monthly photo contest. 🙂 Feel free to vote for my outdoor pic for this month.
Ben
KeymasterThe Wikipedia page for the game has been heavily edited and cut down by others due to the page supposedly not adhering to Wikipedia’s rules. I have preserved the older version with valuable collecting information here in this post.
Ben
KeymasterCan a 0 coin become negative in value (-1) due to the Rats UT?
Ben
KeymasterI would argue that Unique Treasures and rare coins (such as 0’s, shiny silver, etc) are one of the most irreplaceable types of game pieces.
Crew are proxied all the time, and new copies are easily made. They are also usually on the “sidelines” of a game where having a perfect back (showing the faction flag) is often not considered, or can have any discrepancies easily explained. Ships can be 3D printed, whether for proxy or replicas. Custom islands and terrain are arguably better than the official versions, with the cardboard versions extremely cheap and widely available.Special coins, on the other hand, must conform to a certain standard. It’s important that they have identical backs, and preferably a sheen close to what Wizkids produced. Common coins such as 1-6 can be scratched off to make proxy UT’s, but it’s tough to beat the original artwork quality on such a small piece.
Coins also go through more wear and tear than almost any other game piece. This fact is also nearly unavoidable, compared to crew stored in their cards in card sleeves and ship masts that are not taken out for fear of excess wear or breakage. Shuffling coins and moving them around during a game is essential, which can cause some scratching over time, further exacerbating the eventual need for replacements (and most special coins are Rare, if not even higher rarity).
New coins could be 3D printed/etc, but it would be very hard to get them to a distinct quality to where they are indistinguishable from Wizkids coins. If it’s too easy to tell them apart (or if they have rough edges, decals falling off, etc), players can gamify what they see on islands after the treasure distribution is finalized.
Just a random thought I’ve been having for a year or so now. It’s part of why I don’t have many UT’s up for trade – in an ideal world, over the decades I’ll play enough to where I’ll need duplicate UT replacements when a primary copy gets scratched/changed enough to where it’s easy to spot it on an island.
Ben
KeymasterHWG added a lot of sets to their inventory today, and have a small Black Friday sale on RVx9 through Monday!
Ben
KeymasterBlindside feels too cheap. How does Black Mark work on a ship? It’s only worded for crew so I think you’d need to make a new ability. I think I get the general gist, but would it be mandatory to use it? (or declare it’s being used from the start of a game)
Ben
KeymasterSame deal as the above post: HWG PotCx36 (sale through 11/30)
Ben
KeymasterHydra is interesting. Cannon ability is too hard to use with Mercenary, but the last ability could allow it to operate at sea for quite some time.
I think Shadow of Cygnus should be at least 1-2 points higher; it’s probably at least as good as Forward.
Ben
KeymasterCutlass looks like a good specialty ship. Defining “defensive abilities” could get a little ugly, especially with the introduction of new custom abilities. For example, could that ability itself be cancelled? If not, could the ship’s ability shut down an enemy canceller if the canceller was trying to cancel the ship’s Captain?
Hero’s Blade seems like a bit of an unwieldy hybrid. The lightning rod flavor text gave me an idea you may have thought of – perhaps on a 1, the lighting is absorbed into the ship (rather than deflected) and gives it a fire mast. That might bring the cost down to 15-16 and make it slightly more appealing overall (or less appealing in a CG haha). Either way, I definitely see some high-value named crew coming aboard her to optimize, especially folks with Reverse Captain and/or Reroll.
I do wish Wizkids had used different language with similar ability triggers. I think “when this ship shoots” would be easier to understand, because oftentimes when they say “given a shoot action”, they actually meant to include the free shoot action after moving from Captain. That distinction could mean a big difference in how often an ability can and would get used.
Ben
KeymasterLet me know if you’re in Las Vegas and can play Pirates!
We’re looking at a larger-scale meetup at Dice Tower West in early March 2024!
Ben
KeymasterAlgolmantis here and I’m glad to be back in the scene but my username is just my gamertag. I used to play Pirates way back when it first came out and to my delight it made a pretty decent splash at our FLGS.
Welcome aboard matey, glad to have you here!
Ben
KeymasterBoth of those look interesting, and pretty neat. Maybe you’ll use the Vassal on VASSAL in CG4. XD
Ben
KeymasterThe root of the issue is that Ransom was introduced in Crimson Coast, while the 0-Point rule was added later in Revolution, but Ransom was never updated to address it directly.
Interesting, I didn’t know about that part. I could ask Piranha if he remembers any direction from Wizkids about it.
I’m not so sure it should override the 0-point crew rule, since it doesn’t indicate that it’s supposed to. To me any rules updates at this point in the game’s life should be edits, not additions.
Ben
KeymasterThe Mike Mulvihill Supercut podcast is here! No new content vs. the 8 separately released episodes, but I wanted to have it available all in one place and one file. 8+ hours of Pirates info and discussion! 😀
https://pirateswithben.com/pirates-csg-podcast-mike-mulvihill-supercut/October 24, 2023 at 5:33 PM in reply to: Submit your questions for Pirates game piece creator + designer Mike Mulvihill! #17406Ben
KeymasterThe Mike Mulvihill Supercut podcast is here! No new content vs. the 8 separately released episodes, but I wanted to have it available all in one place and one file. 8+ hours of Pirates info and discussion! 😀
https://pirateswithben.com/pirates-csg-podcast-mike-mulvihill-supercut/Ben
KeymasterIt doesn’t explicitly disable the 0-point rule, but that’s implied, because otherwise it largely defeats the purpose of Ransom. You CAN transfer the captured Ransom crew to other ships in your fleet, regardless of nationality, but the only island you can unload it to is your home island.
I’m finding that quite confusing. This is how I see it based on the keyword and Pirate Code (emphasis added):
Ransom: If a crew with this keyword is captured or transferred to a ship opposing to its original owner its other abilities cease to function regardless of nationality…
This would mean abilities like Reroll/etc cease to function.
Ability Conflict Hierarchy: -This list applies only when two or more abilities conflict. When an ability and a rule conflict the ability always takes precedence regardless of the terms used, unless specifically stated otherwise.
Placing Crew rule:
-A zero-point crewmember can be assigned only to a ship of its own nationality. Whether or not some other ability would allow that crew to use its abilities on another ship is irrelevant.
I think the flaw lies in the wording of the Ransom keyword. It should specify that when the ability kicks in, it also disables the 0-point crew rule. It says “its other abilities cease to function”, but makes no mention of essentially cancelling the 0-point crew rule. I understand that abilities override rules, but the Ransom ability specifically refers to other abilities and doesn’t include any rule overrides. Thus, based on what I’m reading, the 0-point crew rule still has to apply.
Rules come before abilities, so usually when an ability takes precedence, it’s quite clear in the ability wording (it’s obvious what rule it’s changing/etc). In this case, it is not clear. I personally don’t think it’s heavily implied enough to read into it so that the 0-point rule would be disregarded. It does make the negative of Ransom less negative, but there is still often quite the incentive to tow the captured ship back to your home island, as the ship might sometimes be more valuable than the 5 gold in the long run.
I totally understand that Ransom would be more thematic with what you’re saying, I just don’t see enough justification in the written rules to warrant that. Maybe there’s something I’m missing though! 🙂
Ben
KeymasterJust to confirm: If you capture an enemy ship that has a Ransom crew on it, and the two ships are of different nationalities, you cannot transfer the Ransom crew to the towing ship due to the rule that 0-point crew can only be assigned to ships of their own nationality?
Why does the Pirate Code make an exception to the above 0-point crew assignment rule for Captain Nemo’s “shanghai” ability? (an ability which says specifically “captive becomes assigned to this ship”)
Do you know if “Shanghai” was the ability shorthand that Wizkids or the community used before 2011? (such as during the production years)
Ben
KeymasterPanda is fun! Nice new little ability twist.
October 20, 2023 at 8:46 PM in reply to: Submit your questions for Prototyping Lead and Ship Designer Ethan Pasternack! #17390Ben
KeymasterHi! I had a “chicken or the egg” style of question referring to the working in parallel with Game Design team on the first set.
Which mechanics arose from the constraints of the physical ships?
Versus:
What changes to the physical ships were made specifically to aid the gameplay mechanics?
Here is the episode – I think it’s mostly answered in the question “For some of the ship designs that had rules integrated into their physicality, which came first?” If you still have the question or a related follow up after checking out the episode, feel free to ask!
Ben
KeymasterUhyggelig feels underwhelming to me. I could see her at 10 points.
Is Abraham’s +2 bonus for cannon and boarding rolls? It might be better to have a semicolon so it doesn’t seem like a separate ability. I could see someone construing it as +2 to d6 rolls against sea creatures. I’m not sure if I love Wizkids’ way of doing it, but it is pretty clear. Ex (Kodiak): This ship gets +1 to her boarding rolls. She gets +2 instead if her opponent is a sea monster.
Solomon Kaine looks quite useful! Name threw me for a second since I just rewatched Mission Impossible 6. XD
-
AuthorPosts
