Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 511 through 540 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #17371
    Ben
    Keymaster

    2 packs of Revolution are on the way to help get my partner into the game. Looking forward to deep diving into the podcast and looking at some of these custom sets!

    Awesome!  Thanks for the kind words and glad to have you aboard matey!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17337
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Namazu and the Trident target an area rather than any ship specifically, so Parley won’t work even if it’s the only ship within that target area.

    That also means that Namazu could effectively “shoot” (just not with its cannons) at ships docked at a home island, correct?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17324
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If a ship has both of these abilities aboard:

    -Masts on this ship cannot be eliminated by shots unless the cannon roll is a 6.

    -Two hits from the same shoot action are required to eliminate one of this ship’s masts.

    Does the first hit of each pair also have to be a 6, or can it be any regular hit because only the second hit would actually eliminate a mast?

    in reply to: The Unboxing Thread #17316
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Not my box, but it was fun to pop these open with Sean!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17267
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can Behemoth benefit from copying All-Powerful from a crew after kraken cancelling shuts down the All-Powerful ability?  (Each turn roll a d6, on a result of 5 or 6 no crew abilities can be used this turn.)

    Can a kraken surround a titan that is on an island? If so, do you move the titan into the kraken once the kraken is as close to the island as possible?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17209
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If a ship with only fire masts is wrecked on a reef, does the ship stay in play with the fire masts still there (permanently until game end), or does the automatic scuttle still happen and take her and her cargo out of play?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17114
    Ben
    Keymaster

    It’s determined by the ship’s current controller, so you make the check when that player starts their turn, regardless of when the ship was actually lit on or fire or when it lost its last non-fire mast.

    Because of this, couldn’t you delay (or eliminate the need for) the automatic scuttle by capturing the ship that only has fire masts?  It seems the requirement to scuttle the ship on its next turn would reset every time the ship changes hands.

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #17108
    Ben
    Keymaster

    How to use Double Shot….

    Once per turn when this ship is given a shoot action, one of her cannons can shoot a double shot. Declare which cannon will shoot the double shot before rolling the d6. If it hits, the cannon can shoot again. If either cannon roll is a 1, remove Double Shot from the game and eliminate a mast from this ship.

    I assume it would be best to use it on the most accurate cannon available, but only at the end of the shoot action. That way, you have the best chance of hitting in order to get the second shot, but if it backfires, you can just eliminate a mast that has already shot (therefore not needlessly losing that shot).

    Of course, that assumes positioning and targets that would allow you to do such a thing – sometimes it might be more optimal to shoot at different targets at the beginning vs. end of the action, or you may only have the most accurate cannons in range of something you’d prefer to hit later in the action vs. right away. Though I think those considerations are more fringe cases than anything else.

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17103
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Another video battle report:

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17096
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The standard rule still applies, but by taking as much as you can carry you’re more likely to get to the good stuff.  You can also take as many zero-space UTs as you want.

    I didn’t clarify enough, or I’m reading into your answer too much heh.

    Ex: Cannibal King (who has the Hoard ability) wins a boarding party against Congress. Congress has crew and treasure. Can the loser choose to just lose one crew, or does Hoard require them to lose all their treasure instead since abilities override rules?  When applying Hoard or Massacre (kill all enemy crew if you win a boarding), I assume those are instead of the result the loser would normally choose?  Or can they choose to lose (in the case of Hoard) crew and then get their treasure taken as well? (potentially making the abilities “in addition to” IF the loser chooses to also lose the opposite type of cargo, for example if they want to sabotage a ship just before capture)

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17085
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Does Hoard override the loser chooses rule?  I think it does but couldn’t recall for sure so I played it the other way against T O’B.

    Can the Maui’s Fishhook use her ability before receiving any segments?  “Once per turn as part of a move action, this ship can randomly take one treasure from any ship up to S away from her.”

    -Ex: First action to go through whirlpool, then second to come back through the same one. Ability was used in between to nab a coin and then flee on the same turn.

    Can the fort Thompson’s Island (+1 to cannon rolls when a ship is docked at it) benefit from a flotilla being docked at it?  Essentially, can flotillas dock as a free action at islands when the towing ship docks even though they have no bow?

    Am I correct in saying that fog hoppers cannot use a second action to go into a fog bank on one turn and move out of a different one with the second action? “If this ship (sea monster) ends her turn in a fog bank, on her next turn she may use her move action to move out of any other fog bank in play.”  Essentially next “ship’s turn” means next player’s turn, not the ship’s next action, right?

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17077
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17028
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Is there any way to bring something “extra” along for a fog hop?  “If this ship (sea monster) ends her turn in a fog bank, on her next turn she may use her move action to move out of any other fog bank in play.”

    It definitely wouldn’t work with flotillas, and I assume not with towing a derelict either. I can think of maybe one possibility – if an oared ship (like a Galley) with no Oarsman had the Fog Hopper ability copied to it and was being towed by a regular Fog Hopper, I assume it would have to be given a separate move action to fog hop with a ship that was towing it? (forcing you to break the tow either way since I think they’d have to hop separately)

    Ben
    Keymaster

    Also, if everything is “costed right” you may need to increase the suggested point limit of standard games from 40 to something else, as a fleet made of costed right ships might get you one or two ships in a fleet (without heavy crew combos) and max out your build total of 40.

    I think it would balance out because of all the overpriced ships – I think there are probably more of those than the underpriced ships.  For example, a ton of ships from Fire and Steel (and other “second half” of production sets) would suddenly drop into single digits for point cost.  Something like USS Shark would go from 13 points of “bleh” to 5-6 points of intrigue.

    Banshee’s Cry might go to 10 or more, but a bunch of ships of the same type (Crete Argentee, Repulsa, etc) would drop into single digits, which would compensate for the OP stuff getting more expensive.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17024
    Ben
    Keymaster

    From The Pirate Code:

    -Abandoned Crew remain facedown until you use their abilities. While face up, they are treated exactly like their corresponding generic crew.

    –They do not count against the point limit of a ship.

    Normally crew do count against the point limit of a ship – are these different because they were not paid for in the build total?

     

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #17023
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If you didn’t have any copies of the Turtles UT, how much would you pay for a full-card Turtles with 10 Turtle coins instead of 1, vs. a regular Turtles UT with just the one turtle coin?

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #17007
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Aigle and Providence both look like good and useful warships.  Only concern is tracking Aigle’s bonus – during a game I’d probably write or type which ships.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #17003
    Ben
    Keymaster

    60 point Jade fleet
    Grand Path + Shap’ng Tsai, Katsura-chan, helmsman
    Virtuous Wind + Captain, helmsman, explorer
    Noble Swan + Li Quin, Captain
    Sea Tiger
    Forts: Ramsgate, Fort Brompton
    UT’s: Bad Maps, Jade

    in reply to: Defeat Davy Jones Fleet Challenge #17002
    Ben
    Keymaster

    When will a winner be announced?

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #16992
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What is the IDEAL number of players in a Pirates game? (a specific quantity, not a range)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #16991
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I really like how unique Isabella and Badbeard are.  Lots of intriguing abilities to have on a gold runner/hybrid.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #16964
    Ben
    Keymaster

    In other words would I require an “extra action” crew over a “same action” crew.

    As long as you have the Captain ability on that ship (“This ship may move and then shoot as part of a single move action.”), it works with either.  SAT (Same Action Twice, same as the Born Leader keyword) allows you to repeat the first action given to the ship.  With a Captain, you can move and shoot twice.

    For the “this ship may be given the same action twice” ability, if I’m 6S away from an enemy ship (and my ship can move 3S) but I want to be able to move and shoot, could I chose to move and “shoot” twice (if I roll a 5 or a 6), “forgo” the option to shoot on my first action, then move and shoot on my second action or is that illegal?

    In that situation, you would need a Captain.  You can choose to only move with the first action, then shoot at the end of the second move action with Captain.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #16915
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I don’t know if I’ll keep the improvement on the Wrench, or at least not make it that good. Re-wording to just a +1 to the roll might be better, especially as I’ve used the once per turn wording, like spying abilities an cancel crew. Given that, would a point increase from 14 to 16 – 17 be ideal, regardless of any changes to the ability?

    Sounds like an improvement!

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #16908
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Once per turn you may roll a d6. On a result of 5-6 repair a mast on every friendly ship within S of this ship. If this ship is assigned a shipwright crew, the roll succeeds on a result of 3-6 instead.

    Especially with that improvement, I think Wrench should be more expensive. It doesn’t take an action and can be made quite useful with an extra 2 point crew.  I could see that being really useful in some larger games, especially on crowded battlefields or in conjunction with a cheerleader.

    In a campaign game I’d probably be willing to spend 18-20+ points on this one.  On the other hand, Peril Koi seems underwhelming.  I’d consider swapping their point costs.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #16904
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Would bringing her down to 25 points be more worth it, or further than that?

    I think 22-23 would be fine.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #16902
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I love the flavor text for Helix.  Not the typical “now the ship has an iron hull” type thing we sometimes see on ships with that ability.

    Holster is likely not quite worth her cost, but it does sound like a fun “command center” type vessel for a decent sized squadron in a large game.  I’d probably go full gunship given her abilities.  Preferably with a “shoot through ships” crew or equipment so she could snipe from within the middle of a pack that she’s increasing ranges for.

    in reply to: The Ultimate PCSG Gunship — Redux #16901
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I have noticed certain ability combinations with certain crew of certain nationalities can be extremely advantageous, even if they require “all nationalities” crew enablers.

    Definitely. I think that’s one of the last “less-explored frontiers” of this game too. There are probably some brilliant international setups and creative ideas that have barely (if ever) been tried.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #16898
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If I have an opponent playing as Spain with a ship carrying Joaquin Vega, and I’m playing England with a ship carrying a crew that allows use of all nationalities crew and my own Joaquin Vega, is that a legal setup or can there be only one Joaquin Vega in the whole game?

    That is legal.  The No-Duplicates rule only applies to each player’s individual fleet, not all game pieces in play between all players.

    From The Pirate Code: “A player cannot have two or more of the same character, ship, sea creature, event token, or fort in their fleet at the same time unless it is captured from an opposing player.”

    For crew abilities that state “one cargo may also be removed when this ship hits an enemy ship”, does this apply only to cargo like treasure, unique treasure etc, or does it also apply to crew since they take up cargo space? I’m only asking since there are crew that specifically have abilities that say “eliminate one crew when this ship is hit”.

    From page 3: “-All crew, equipment, and treasures (including unique treasures) are considered cargo, even if they take up no space.”

    The “Cargo Wrecking” ability can be particularly devastating because it can potentially wipe out everything a ship is carrying in one volley if you get enough hits.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #16895
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Very cool vessels here.  I like how Raider can be quick but requires more than just an auto-include Captain to get the bonus.  She’s likely to be quite an investment, likely at least 28+ points for C+H+Marine.  Good hybrid potential too.

    Specter could be an effective hybrid as well.  Maybe not the best comparison, but almost makes me think of a mini-Guichuan: similar in cost, cargo, cannons and Ghost Ship.  Would be interesting to slide into an enemy formation “unnoticed” and then become “visible” to guarantee first shot advantage.  She also makes me think about the recent podcast about the online game.  Would be neat to see a version someday where that “invisibility” could be translated effectively – where the controlling player can see a translucent version of the ship at all times of course, but the ship legitimately disappears from the other player’s screen and they have no idea where it is until it becomes visible again.  🙂

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #16891
    Ben
    Keymaster

    This may be a dumb question but stacked oarsman start to occupy cargo spaces after the first oarsman even if their designation is “this crew takes up no cargo space” right?

    Correct, due to the No-Stacking rule.

Viewing 30 posts - 511 through 540 (of 2,325 total)