Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterVery cool. Definitely spices up the Mercs quite a bit from what Wizkids gave them. Evan Van Turner could definitely prove useful on some of the original submarines too, being able to shoot as a Marine while submerged.
Ben
KeymasterHow about “The Teacher – Someone who spends their time teaching new players and mostly plays very basic games with less experienced players.”
Great idea! I’ll add it to the first post. I definitely had a run with that, mostly in 2015-2016 teaching a bunch of family members and friends in college.
Ben
KeymasterI’m really big on the combat aspect of PCSG and have done a lot of research on Bens top 10 gunship ranking and the corresponding battle reports.
I love when people read my battle reports, so thank you! 🙂
I’ve used the HMS Endeavor (a relatively recent acquisition) loaded with Affiliated (all nationalities) crew Brother Virgil with DJC Davy Jones. In addition I had Hermione Gold (Captain Helmsman) and three oarsmen.
Only two oarsmen will fit in that setup as-is, because adding a third would put the ship over the point limit (22 for crew vs 21 for the ship) and the cargo limit (only the first oarsman takes up no space).
For example Derrick the Red is a fun near-world hater AND sac ability crew to load onto any other English ship of mine (allowed by Lady Kamaile) and have jones use via endeavors oarsmen when she’s in particularly tough situations.
Derrik is great, but keep in mind that copiers can only copy one ability at a time – you’d have to choose either World Hater or Sac.
Spain and America have no crew that offer all nationality crew use (again, as far as I’ve researched). Surly this could affect the rank of their premier gunships.
That is true, they don’t have crew like that. However, I think it’s kind of shortsighted to knock a faction’s gunship choices simply because they find it hard or impossible to use a very specific (and expensive, with Limit) named crew from a different faction – one that dramatically reduces the existing faction’s named crew you can put on the gunship in question because of the point cost and cargo occupancy.
without too much risk being involved due to lack of other modifiers.
Such as other international crew? You could make a similar case about some of the other best named crew, such as a faction’s access to 058 Captain Jack Sparrow, SS Bianco’s Haulers, or even more common things like Sac or Parley which can transform a ship’s “peak”.
It’d be a heck of a project, one I’ve already kind of looked in to. But I feel like DJC Davy Jones’ ability, all things considered, could potentially radically alter not just gunship rankings but general game winning tactics as well.
Perhaps, but keep in mind that you’re going down a rabbit hole full of theory and hypotheticals. Part of the reason I keep the rankings threads relatively simple is because you can go crazy with the “what ifs”. Maybe Endeavour is the best gunship in the game at 100 points with Davy Jones aboard, but Bonaparte has more relative strength at 60. But hey, not if you use X combo! A lot of this relies on what DJ can copy, which forces you to either more aggressively protect parts of your own fleet from being eliminated, or even delaying sinking an opponent because you need an ability they have in order to dominate. Countertheories are endless. The variables are essentially infinite.
Not trying to throw you off the idea, but I would expect a little pushback from another angle as well – game sizes and types. DJ is usually best on the biggest and most expensive ships. That would lead to those ships being ranked higher. However, a lot of times the best gunships in most “normal” games (40-60 point non-deathmatch) are more budget friendly, such as HMS Oxford, Soleil Royal, Grinder, etc. DJ skews massively towards the big gunship, big build total, and big multiplayer game stuff.
I’ll admit I haven’t used DJ much on non-Cursed ships and non-10 masters. I’m just not sure that the endless hypotheticals of how he can optimize a chunk of specific ships is worth the time investment of the project.
I’ll end with this interesting thought. If Le Bonaparte has a 3 point all nationalities crew alongside DJC Davy Jones, and IF the Jarvis is present in game in an opponents fleet for Jones to mooch its special ability off of… then excluding in range cancellers, you’ve got yourself and actual invulnerable ship…
Not against flotillas with S range cannons and Extended Range. Which the English have two of. 😀 The other problem there is that the French don’t have a 3 point crew like that, though they do have Jordan Dumas but he’s 5. So the ship’s entire cost is taken up by those 2 crew, leaving no point cap space for captain, helmsman, canceller, etc. One canceller would be enough to shut down one of the defensive abilities and then the ship could be shot at normally. See how it’s just a game of endless counters? It’s part of why I like to play so much – anything that can go wrong often will go wrong, so I try not to get overly hyped about specific setups.
Ben
KeymasterOooh, I like Rynah and the linked crew! Definitely would enjoy trying those out.
Ben
KeymasterI know I’ve said it before, but I think Repeating Guns is overpriced. Rarely will all the cannons hit, and even if they do, there is a diminishing return on the second volley, which could end as soon as it begins. Fun to see Dories on a non-10 master. I think Narada could be 22 points.
Ben
KeymasterRegarding the “crew of any nationality may use their abilities on this ship” ability, does that apply across each PCSG faction or just the nation factions. Considering when some of the pieces with this ability were made I’d figure it’d apply to everything, even though factions like the Cursed aren’t technically a “nation” like say Spain or France (though they do function like a nation).
It applies to all the factions. All the factions in this game are nationalities for the purposes of the rules.
Ben
Keymaster@Josh: Great to have you here matey! 😀
Ben
KeymasterAbility: Give this ship a shoot action. Every ship within S of this ship is moved L+L away. Up to two masts are eliminated from every affected ship. This ship cannot be given actions for turns equal to the number of affected ships.
I can almost guarantee The Cursed will launch Morg on their next turn in CG4. 🙂
Ben
KeymasterThere is a market theory called the long tail, which refers to the fact that demand for a product (especially a collectible) never reaches zero.
Reminds me of how Pirates prices have risen the past 5+ years. I hope Wizkids/NECA has seen the higher eBay sale prices, especially this decade.
I don’t want to spend days building and painting an army or a fleet to play.
Agreed, I want to play, not paint!
with Pirates you and your buddy can each buy a pack and play a game. compare that to MTG, where in order to play sealed with 2 people, you have to buy at least 6 packs each. That’s about $30 per person. and even then, you’ll need lands that they assume you already have. To me, it’s a no-brainer.
I’m curious about other forms of packaging and release type. What you get in one pack doesn’t really allow for building a 40 point fleet, let alone one that makes much sense. I could see starter packs in the $10-$20 range, maybe with some guarantee of useful generic crew while still having a collectible aspect as well.
July 28, 2023 at 3:04 PM in reply to: Submit your questions for Pirates Online players RedDragon and Captain Ron! #16800Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterThat 5 master could probably come down in cost a bit, especially with Shipburner being such an all-or-nothing gamble (though you still effectively lose the ship either way). I think playtesting in the 18-22 range would be fair. I think it should say “you may eliminate one of this ship’s non-crew cargo.” Or simply, “you may eliminate one of this ship’s treasure or equipment.” I realize you may want to avoid the latter due to additional types of cargo being present in some campaign games.
For the Shipburner keyword, I would change “within S of enemy ships” to “an enemy ship”, “at least one enemy ship”, etc. At present you could interpret it to mean you have to be within S of at least 2 enemy ships due to the plural nature of ships.
Beni Gabor is interesting!
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterDo you know if there are any free actions that can be used/taken during an opponent’s turn?
I assume not based on this line from the Code (which is mostly for full actions), but just wanted to make sure.
You can give actions only during your own turn and only to members of your own fleet, unless an ability specifically allows otherwise.
Ben
KeymasterIf this ship wins a boarding party, turn this crew face down and eliminate up to three masts from the enemy ship. This crew cannot be turned face up for a number of turns equal to that of the eliminated masts. If this ship loses a boarding party, eliminate this crew and up to three masts from this ship.
Is the “up to three masts” meant to be a choice for both the losing/winning side? Ex: Normally the loser chooses the result after a boarding party. Is this designed to eliminate 3 masts regardless of how many masts are remaining (such as never less than 3), or can you specifically choose to eliminate less?
I think it would be less open to interpretation if you took out the “up to” wording. Especially because the Pirate Code makes it pretty clear that things that eliminate masts (icebergs, 2 masts/hit, etc) don’t sink ships by themselves, and this would fall in that category.
In addition, is the mast effect in addition to the regular boarding result(s), or instead of?
Either way, I think he could be cheaper, maybe 7 points.
Ben
KeymasterI am fascinated by the thought of Pirates CSG and what if it had been released post-economic crash or even if it came out within the last few years. We know that the economic situation of 2008 had an effect, but it has also been shown that interest was still high. Other issues, such as the cost of manufacturing, also played a role.
With the cost of styrene being an issue late in the game’s print run, and global costs having risen since 2008, the MSRP per pack would have to be higher, quite possibly much higher. (2x or more perhaps)
Would it be as popular now as it was then?
The PotC/pirate craze of the 2000’s must have helped sales somewhat. I think the board game industry in general has become more competitive, with so many games available and various crowdfunding sources.
Recently I have been bringing out the Pirates stuff, setting up a table, and asking random people if they want to play. Everyone who plays loves the game, and when I tell them it no longer exists, they can’t understand it.
That’s awesome to hear! Whenever I play at an FLGS/etc there’s pretty much always at least one person that recognizes it and likely still has some ships in storage.
I think it would be pretty wild if they made a PotC6, brought the game back with it, and had Johnny Depp doing a recorded demo of it while in costume in GenCon/Origins/etc. That would be hype. 🙂
Ben
KeymasterI could see AofA getting a cost increase, though I am in “CG4 mode” still. Seems likely she’ll have a World Hater crew aboard. The speed is really the only thing holding her back. Definitely a monster gunship.
Nights Bane is cool too, another one that would be quite good in 80+ point games.
Ben
KeymasterHow does the timing of the automatic scuttle via fire masts work? “When a ship has only fire masts, she must be scuttled on her next turn.”
Ex: Player 1 makes a Player 2 ship have only fire masts on Player 1’s turn. For that ship, is “her next turn” the next Player 2 turn (the same round she was set alight), or the Player 2 turn after that one? It seems that it would depend on when “has only fire masts” is applied – on the controlling player’s turn or the overall player turn when the condition occurred that she only has fire masts left.
Ben
KeymasterIndeed! However if any Nexus Alliance stuff makes it into the Conglomerate it will likely be stuff that is publicly visible, so ships and crew that I’ve posted here or on the Discord.
Makes sense. Just let me know when you want another tab in the Customs Database.
Ben
KeymasterNice core power ships for the new faction!
Will be fun to see how they integrate into the Conglomerate in CG4.
Ben
KeymasterYou’re telling me! This is that set that I mentioned waaay back in…. 2021? 2020? When you came out to visit and we had that game at Applebees.
Two years ago this week!
Ben
KeymasterA new Custom Set is on its way! My brother and I have gone in together on this one, and we bring you Pirates of the Cursed Seas, the Farthest Shore!
Neat, how exciting! I like the uniqueness of the named crew so far. Specifically, Dr. Albert Overton is a pretty wild combo of abilities.
Ben
KeymasterIs the Doctor ability always mandatory to use? I know it doesn’t work with Sac but curious if it’s ever optional (mostly thinking about whirlpools where you’d actually prefer to lose an oarsman rather than a mast).
“When another face-up crew on this ship is would be eliminated turn it face down instead.”
Ben
KeymasterCouple Ocean’s Edge Limited Edition tournament packs ending within 24 hours.
Ben
KeymasterI understand that Jailhouse Dog can only be used once per round of player turns when the same ship also has Nemo’s Plans aboard. How does the timing of trying to reuse it work in a multiplayer game? For example, let’s say it’s a 4 player game and the JD controller is player 2. If they use it on player 3’s turn to essentially “cancel” a UT, can they use it on their next player 2 turn during the next round, or must they wait until at least the next player 3 turn?
Ben
KeymasterSaw CotBP in theater last night on the 20th anniversary. ? Absolutely spectacular. Even some of the quotes gave me goosebumps, not just the music. From when Barbossa throws the apple to the Interceptor blowing up, one of the best action sequences I’ve ever seen ?
Ben
KeymasterI know this has come up before but can’t find anything on it in the Code or forum search.
Can Born Leader/SAT be used to double up on the L-mover ability and use it twice in the same turn by the same ship? “Give this ship a move action but do not move her. Instead, roll a d6. On a result of 5 or 6, move an enemy ship L in any direction.”
Thanks!
Ben
KeymasterNice unpunched lot including the DJC SR’s and some DJC LE’s.
silver66cw has more rare stuff up for grabs, including a Raptor Maw, Message in a Bottle pack, and DJC LE’s.
-
AuthorPosts
