Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterAfter I think 5+ years I think it may be time to retire the second of my primary measuring deckplate cards. At the left you can see that it has finally broken between the edge and bottom pennant hole. It’s also breaking between the pennant hole and main deck. I think this was the main measuring card I used during my epic 2017 campaign game Command the Oceans, so it’s seen it’s share of usage.
The last one (the “original” for me) was an HMS King Edward duplicate deckplate. I think that one got more white from even more severe usage, probably from 2011-2017 including various campaign games. That one broke on the opposite end though I believe, between the S edge and stern flag slot nub.
For the next one, I might try using a “whole” deckplate that is unpunched – I’ve got some orphans that would work well. Though, I think the parts might get accidentally punched out during usage, especially if I try to use it for 5+ years of playing haha!
Maybe the next one should be Spanish – I’ve used English and now French, and the Spanish are next in my “collection faction order” for organizing.

Ben
Keymaster-Can you roll successfully for Born Leader and then give a different ship an action before returning to the ship that got SAT? By extension, can you just roll for all the SAT/EA/etc abilities in your fleet at the beginning of your turn and then use that knowledge to help plan your fleet and action logistics?
-If a ship with both Neptune’s Figurehead and Plague is sunk, the order of operations has Plague removed from play before the ship returns to the home island? (just making sure the Plague wouldn’t prevent the Figurehead from working since you can’t dock)
-The crew that a ship links to is open information, correct? (I assume you can just ask an opponent to see the bottom of a deckplate, rather than it being hidden information like face down crew)
-Can you choose the order in which ship-specific “before giving this ship an action” effects happen? (ex: Born Leader vs. fire mast rolls)
-Do you have to roll for effect on new fire masts during the same pre-action time period in which they are gained? (I would assume not until the next pre-action “phase” for the ship, or else… yikes)Ben
KeymasterSome prize kits and SS boxes available
Ben
KeymasterHey Jeremiah! Here is what Woelf shared with me. I’ll add it to some posts/pages of the site when I have more time.
Ben
KeymasterPotC x36 is down to $199: http://wholesalegaming.biz/pirates/
Ben
KeymasterPirates CSG Podcast #56: Former Wizkids Art Director Shane Hartley!
You can listen to the audio via Anchor!
You can also listen on Archive.org.
Shane’s in-game crew, Thane Hartless from Mysterious Islands (#302, a Limited Edition Mercenary reroller)
Very excited to have Shane Hartley on the podcast! He was the Art Director and one of the graphic designers for Wizkids Pirates CSG throughout the production run, one of the core members of the team. He also made it into the game – you probably already knew him as Thane Hartless from Mysterious Islands!
His website: http://shanehartley.com/portfolio/items/pirates-of-the-spanish-main-csg/
Thane Hartless: https://psmlist.com/public/crew/MI302
Factory prototype cards acquired by Matt P: https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/468973063778730024/1077065658250039388/644D2BEE-B2EE-42E5-A524-EE094057D008.jpg
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/468973063778730024/1077065659013410917/670DB04C-1E67-478D-9435-98B03050E563.jpgWizards of the Coast patent in question: https://patents.google.com/patent/US7201374B2/en
Shuffling the Deck version we mentioned: https://wizkids.com/pirates-of-the-spanish-main/
Mysterious Islands artwork: https://www.previewsworld.com/SiteImage/MainImage/STK315536
MI SE box: https://thumbs.worthpoint.com/zoom/images1/1/0320/22/pirates-csg-mysterious-islands_1_738e5372e7c0d70e7c26f05d86c64481.jpgQuestions thread: https://pirateswithben.com/forums/topic/submit-your-questions-for-graphic-art-and-packaging-designer-shane-hartley/
Disney Lorcana, the latest game he worked on: https://www.disneylorcana.com/en-US
Past podcasts: http://shoutengine.com/PiratesCSGPodcast/
Thanks for listening!
June 11, 2023 at 5:11 PM in reply to: Submit your questions for graphic, art, and packaging designer Shane Hartley! #16654Ben
KeymasterThe podcast is out!
Pirates CSG Podcast #56: Former Wizkids Art Director Shane Hartley!
Ben
KeymasterRare find: Fire and Steel gravity feed box of 24 packs
Ben
KeymasterLet me know if anyone has a good way to share the sheet
I recommend putting it on google drive, then you can just put a link to it here in the forum and people can see what is available in real time.
Ben
KeymasterSome pack sales at HWG ending after June 1st.
Ben
KeymasterTook me a few minutes of following links but I re-found the old Wizkids Pirates forums for the first time in a few years.
Ben
KeymasterAh interesting, I missed that part from the Code. A little surprising to me – I saw there was nothing in Titan that prevents it, but the sea creature rules do, so I defaulted to no. Makes S-Board a weence more appealing. XD
Ben
KeymasterJust confirming: Titans cannot be S-boarded?
Ben
KeymasterCool!
Akaryu is extremely good, similar to HMS Titan for power level. I’m glad you made USS Constellation really good, but as-is I think it could be a bit more expensive. Looks as good or better than the Franklin or SCS Santa Ana, both extremely powerful 4 masters.
Nice Cursed 6 master! She’ll go on my list of vessels the Cursed would like to launch “soon-ish” in CG4. 🙂 I’d bump The Serpent to 8-9 points though, looks like he’s getting Fear for free.
Ben
KeymasterWith Towing Option #1 (on page 10), can you initiate the tow, then have the towed ship explore the towing ship before any move segments are used? In my most recent game I assumed you could not because you have to complete the move action that started the tow in the first place.
Ben
KeymasterWhat the subtle difference in the MKL does is un-break Le Jongleur (MI-209), which technically wouldn’t be able to use its built-in HI-Raider ability at all if you took them exactly as WK had them written. A side effect is that also allows you to put an Ex-Pat on some other ship with that ability and still use it, but that’s minor to the point of being almost irrelevant.
So the MKL wording is the official, correct wording?
Ben
KeymasterIn the Master Keyword List, Mercenary is listed as: “This ship cannot dock at its own home island, and must begin the game S away from its home island.”
In the scans of MI and SS rules, it is listed differently, especially that it cannot dock at any home island. Which one is correct, and when did Wizkids’ intent change if the MKL version is correct?
Thanks!
Ben
KeymasterJust added a new one: Battle Reports Survey
Ben
Keymaster“This ship may be given up to three actions in a single turn.”
To me this leaves ambiguity on whether or not this is saying that the ship is not subject to the 2-action limit, or can simply be given 3 actions in a turn by default (without needing Sac/EA/etc). I assume the intent is the former, but the latter is a fair interpretation as-is. I recommend this instead: “This ship is not subject to the two action limit.” Woelf may have a better wording of course.
Would this be an absurdly OP custom ability?
Either way, yes. I don’t recommend it. Also worth considering the high likelihood that it gets copied to a 10 master; I don’t like feeling that Copiers have to be considered for all the various “potentially OP” abilities, but it’s still worth noting.
Ben
KeymasterThat clears everything up nicely, thanks a ton!
Ben
KeymasterNot sure how accurate but it’s nice to get a response!

Ben
KeymasterIt’s a weird situation, because both the Kraken and the surrounded ship are basically locked in contact with each other from all directions. So while you can technically target either of them independently with that ability, neither can actually be moved without making contact (again) with the other.
In other words, Tsuro’s ability can’t do anything to the kraken or the surrounded ship.
This confuses me a bit. I’m pretty sure there are some ship types (especially 1 masted sloops) that could be pulled from out of the kraken’s grasp without touching any part of it other than the kraken’s base. Is touching the base enough to cause the ship to be immediately “stuck” again? I also figured it would work because in the Code it talks about how outside forces moving a ship can apply even if the target is pinned or entangled.
Related questions from Personofsecrets at the discord server:
How might the Scorpion and Switchblade ships interact with L move?
Does this also mean that L moving always requires at least one path that isn’t blocked by another ship?
Ben
KeymasterIf a kraken is surrounding a ship and is moved L by Tsuro, does the surrounded ship move with it or does it break the surround?
Ben
KeymasterThe Greatest Prize lore – First Time Story Reveal from the Adventure Book scenario
Ben
KeymasterAre the choices on when the additional 5 points from 0LR+5 crew determined in the same order as the player turn order? Just want to make sure I get the order right. Ex: Player 1 places all crew, then adds their +5 (which may include events or equipment). Player 2 places all crew, then their +5 choices. Then both players place any equipment (?). Or does Player 1 get to see the layout of Player 2’s face down crew choices before they decide their +5 choices?
Ben
KeymasterUpdate: Podcast with Shane Hartley is most likely to happen around June or after that.
Ben
KeymasterA historic reveal of rarely before seen items!
Ben
KeymasterIf anyone has extra pack inserts (with the rules/checklist/etc) or loose contents of what they contain and you don’t want them, feel free to contact me; I’ll take ’em. ?
Ben
KeymasterMaster Spreadsheet fix: Fixed spelling of F&S Cannoneers (111-116) (removed extra e’s).
Last new .xlsx file was 1/26/2023.
-
AuthorPosts
