Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterIf a ship with the S-Exploring ability is L away from an island and has a base move of L remaining, can it move to dock with the island, using the S-Explore during the move segment and then taking advantage to explore the island as soon as it docks?
Once per turn, if this ship is within S of an island, you may mark the island as explored without docking at it. The island becomes unexplored in regards to all other players.
If a hoist loads the Trees UT, can it remain onboard? Should it say “must remain face-down”? As is, it seems like a ship (even if not a hoist) could load it (face up I suppose), and then use it in the middle of battle to spring back to life as a free action.
Trees may remain face-down on its island if the ship that explores that island has all of its masts. When Trees is revealed, fully repair this ship, and then remove Trees from the game.
Radix59 had a question from the Discord server:
Captain Charles Richard is worded slightly differently than Jonah, Robinson, and Princess Arii. They all state that crew always take up cargo spaces, while Richards states that they still take up cargo space – without the always. Since this was printed in Savage Shores, after the rest of the others, I would expect that this wording would be deliberately different – thereby allowing crew that don’t take up cargo space to still function aboard the ship. The “still” to me implies that the crew cargo interactions would function normally as if Richards was not aboard. Would this be an accurate way to interpret this?
Ben
KeymasterSandra said she won’t be on the Pirates CSG Podcast since she doesn’t remember enough of it, and because she oversaw all the games at Wizkids during that time so she didn’t have as much direct involvement as Shane Hartley and the other artists.
Ben
KeymasterFrom this answer:
The rule to reveal treasure immediately is carried over from the illustrated rules, and ties into the “more than half” rule for ending the game. It’s not exactly the best way to handle the endgame, so feel free to continue ignoring those rules and keep using the multiplayer rules for everything instead.
1. Was not using the “reveal treasure at HI’s” intended to be official guidance for 1v1 standard? I generally agree, I just want to make sure I play things right when I call a game “competitive standard”/no house rules/etc, for 1v1 games. Do you know if Wizkids’ intent was to use the multiplayer rules for this as well, and it only made it into the Start Here rules because it might help brand new players understand things?
2. Am I correct in saying that the “starting gold value” is always 30? What if a player has 22 gold on their HI but only 12 of it came from the original 30 – does that trigger the “more than half the starting gold” endgame condition in a 2 player game? (Code makes me think no to the second, just want to confirm)
3. An island contains Blood Money, Pandora’s Box, and Jailhouse Dog. Must you load Jailhouse Dog in order to use it (therefore not being able to interrupt and cancel the Pandora’s Box), or can you use it immediately because it’s already revealed per Blood Money?
4. Can you prevent a ram by shooting off a mast that was rammed? (ex: ramming the bowsprit of another ship and then accidentally shooting it away)
Ben
KeymasterI’m not sure if they’re underrated, but I’ve been growing more attached to Galleys recently. Having a pseudo-Oarsman on them is pretty nice as it often forces your opponent to expend extra time to finishing off a mastless Galley. In some cases it’s still better to just have the Oarsman, but it’s nice as a built-in feature.
Agreed. On a similar note, it always surprises me when people underrate and write off the Barbary Corsairs as a faction because they can’t fight that well. The goal of the game is to get the most gold, and they have plenty of cheap, fast and capacious galleys with which to do that. 🙂
Ben
KeymasterI think most players are well aware of how powerful flotillas can be, especially in deathmatch. You need the right ship to drag one around, but there are numerous good options in every nation that has them.
I’ve certainly vouched for them a lot over the years, but I’ve almost never come across someone else using one. Such great bang for the buck, and recently I realized they can be good for whirlpool raids because they can be given a shoot action after emerging from a whirlpool (without the towing ship needing another action).
Ben
Keymaster2023 visibility bump!
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterCurrently up for auction – CC Mega Pack, Zeus, F&S SR’s, MI complete set, OE SR’s, various assorted set lots and pack lots. 🙂
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterPirates CSG Podcast #55: DHolub1!
Questions of the Day:
(Ben) What would it take for you to come to Tampa next January for Gasparilla Pirate Festival and Pirates CSG events the day before and/or after?
(DHolub1) What is your passion? What would it take for you to help bring more interest to Pirates CSG and help the game come back?Audio version: https://anchor.fm/a7xfanben/
You can also listen on Archive.org.
Thanks for listening! Feel free to answer the Questions of the Day below!
Take the podcast survey! https://goo.gl/forms/CsnwVmi3qhtqik323
Feel free to rate and review the podcast on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060
Ben
KeymasterPretty cool to see my Black Pearl picture in the Top 10 (#9 of 55) of the 2022 BGG yearly photo contest! Thanks to all who voted!
Ben
KeymasterHWG’s daily deal for 1/26 is $21 off an RV box: http://wholesalegaming.biz/pirates/
Ben
KeymasterBecause they can only shoot something that’s surrounded, the target will always be within range of every tentacle, and removing specific ones won’t alter its lines of fire any any meaningful way.
Interesting. I was thinking more if the kraken got cancelled, and could therefore shoot at ships it wasn’t surrounding.
Ben
KeymasterEspecially for those that remember the “supercollector” Dholub1 from Miniature Trading, feel free to send me any questions you’d like me to ask him. I hope to meet him in Tampa this weekend and we might do a podcast. ?
Ben
KeymasterHow much does the order of kraken tentacles matter when constructing them? Should it be clockwise from the bottom left corner, or having the middle cannons on the deckplate be the innermost tentacles?
Ben
KeymasterAfter seeing the 100 point Dragon Fleet, and some minor discussion on Discord, I went and created this fleet.
Nice fleet!! I like the inclusion of so many canoes, and the idea of using the “any canoes” part of the English canoe ability text. I think one of the main issues will be that you must place all 20 canoes at the same wild island. If someone has a multi-action 10 master nearby (more than likely at this build total), the first round could get really ugly. Sure the dragons could retaliate, but losing the American and Spanish canoes could be crippling. I think it would make the turn order and home island/terrain placement selections extremely important.
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterThis ship sinks when her last mast is eliminated.
If that ability is cancelled, does the ship sink when the cancelling “resets”, or does it stay afloat as a derelict because at that point, the last mast has already been eliminated (and having it not be cancelled is not triggering the final mast to be eliminated again).
Ben
KeymasterDiscount on PotCx36
Ben
KeymasterDid you ever find any stats on the actual size of that table? Judging from how it looks in comparison to the ships, it’s way too small to play a regulation game on it even after adding a few more islands. You’d need three more to make a 2×2 square just to get a large enough area.
Nope. I agree though, it might not work with the 3L minimum distance.
Ben
KeymasterBen
Keymaster@Skelebone: Great post! Cool to see the progress you’ve made. I say yes to all Fleet Reviews! 😀
Ben
Keymaster@CrazyIvan: Great post and reflections! I didn’t teach new players or play non-solo 4 player games until years after I learned a ton about the game, so I can imagine that being a big deal. Love the lessons learned from playing too.
Ben
KeymasterWith the Born Leader keyword, are you supposed to take an action before rolling for the ability to get SAT? This line from the Code seems to imply that: “-The die roll for this ability is made immediately before giving the action you wish to repeat.” However, the ability text indicates otherwise.
When an American native canoe is exploring, can you use the ability of another canoe within S to take a treasure from the first canoe (while it’s still exploring), thus allowing the first canoe to load additional treasure(s)? (“Once per turn as a free action, you can transfer one treasure from a friendly ship within S of this ship to this ship.”)
Ben
KeymasterNice! I think Antelope could be 4 points, and the Privateers likely 4 as well.
Ben
KeymasterHappy Holidays! Hope some folks can play Pirates this weekend!
Ben
KeymasterSleigh/Whitebeard questions: Can the “Ho Ho Ho” ability be used on every player’s turn? (or just Santa’s turn; I realize it is probably every player’s turn due to your answer on the spying abilities from October, but it just felt too ridiculous to play it that way with this one)
Is the Sleigh’s ability to not be shot at and cannot sink one ability since it’s one sentence? (or separate for copying/cancelling purposes)Can an L mover move a ship out of a fog bank?
Can Runes of Odin be revealed on any player’s turn? (or just the owner’s turn)
Are flotillas automatically “docked” at an island when the towing ship docks? (thinking no because flotillas don’t have bows)
Do you get 1 gold from Ransom if you eliminate your own crew after it was captured by an opponent?
Am I correct in saying that neither of these situations trigger a player to be eliminated for the “half or more” multiplayer endgame rule: derelict with Eternal (can be scuttled), and a ship with Oarsman that is pinned in place by a sea monster.
I may have been moving sea monsters wrong for years. Must you always move them so the white dot is the forwardmost point? I have usually played that they face “forward” with the tentacles of a squid outstretched which helps them be able to pin opponents more quickly. Is this wrong? I’ve noticed that by reversing direction on the dot and turning 180 degrees, it can produce quite a large “flip” as the tentacles reverse direction and cause a big movement jump from one extreme end to the opposite direction.

Ben
KeymasterThank you to everyone who participated in the 2022 Holiday Booty Giveaway Contest! I have read/watched all the submitted Battle Reports and here are the results in regards to the extra prizes. There were only 6-7 total entrants so everyone will get the standard goodies!
Entrants
- Skelebone 1, Skelebone 2, Skelebone 11/29, Skelebone 12/2 (twice as many games played as anyone else and some at relatively high build totals, plus very descriptive and easy to understand reports with great postgame summaries with lessons learned/etc.)
- CrazyIvan 1, CrazyIvan 2 (excellent videos and BR production effort!)
- Captain Vendari 1, Captain Vendari 2 (great pictures and summary)
- Highlander 1, Highlander 2 (nice high quality pictures!)
- Slappin300s/T26E4 (minimal reporting but impressive game scale)
- Ochobrazo2298 (scattered throughout channel) – no top 5 prize due to game not starting or ending in time window, which I should have clarified beforehand as not being much of an issue. Would have been 2nd or 3rd if finished by the end of 12/4, but will receive some kind of extra prize due to size/epicness of game and effort involved with custom stuff included.
There were also some awesome pictures posted by a member of the FB group within the contest time window; I’ve asked if they would like a prize as well even if not originally intending to submit specifically for the contest.
Great job to all and I hope you keep enjoying this game as much as I saw in the BR’s! Let me know if you are able to make good use of the prizes once you have them and we can all continue the pirate traditions of enjoying this game and sharing it!
-
AuthorPosts

