Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 631 through 660 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Game Ideas #15902
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Just added these to the main post:

    -Maelstrom battle from At World’s End. Ex: big whirlpools that ships can get stuck in as they go around it in a circle on bad rolls. +Big whirlpool “black hole” that sucks all game pieces toward it on a roll of 1 each round? Or, have a circular ocean that is one big whirlpool. There are different “lanes” in which concentric circles determine where the ships are each round. At the end of each round of turns they move one section closer to the center of the whirlpool, effectively meaning the game has a timer. Might be best in a 1v1 deathmatch. The goal is to sink the other ship before yours gets sucked in, or simply outrun the whirlpool somehow (maybe tossing cargo gets you one lane towards the outside of the whirlpool). Lots of different ways to do it, and you could make alternate versions that would work in a regular game with gold, or a 1v1 deathmatch that simulates the movie scene as much as possible.

    -Expanding upon the Race scenario linked above: line (“drag race”) vs. circle/oval (or other!), have islands with UT’s on them (power-ups/upgrades/etc), shortcut opportunities, NPC creatures.

    in reply to: Holiday Booty Giveaway Contest! #15898
    Ben
    Keymaster

    December 4th is the last day for submissions!

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #15897
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Something I’ve barely thought of before: utilizing the ships you capture to build new nationalities of forts during a game.  Ex: Start with a pure American fleet, but once you capture a French ship, build Paradis.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #15896
    Ben
    Keymaster

    60 Point American fleet
    USS Constitution + captain, helmsman, tribal chieftain
    Destiny + Wayne Nolan, Brent Rice, captain, chain shot
    Hessian + helmsman, shipwright, oarsman
    American Native Canoes
    UT’s: Weapons, Enemy of the State, Power Cannons, Marines
    Islands: not too far apart due to max speed of L+S, but want some room to flex Destiny’s max cannon ranges.
    Terrain: Likely reefs and a fog bank – all gold runners are immune to reefs here.

    Fun American fleet I used in a game.  You could swap Nolan for Commodore Perry on Constitution, then use the 5 points to add Rattlesnake/etc.

    UT selection was based on the abilities present. Marines are ignored by the canoes and Hessian can repair if she finds them. Weapons helps all three ships with crew quite a bunch. Enemy of the State is easily carried by a “sacrificial” canoe or yanked off Hessian by a canoe that doesn’t need to dock at home. Power Cannons is meant to get Destiny to 4L range cannons, but can be utilized effectively by the Constitution as well.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15878
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If native canoes find the Message in a Bottle UT upon exploring, is only one transferred to the new location?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15873
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If the flotilla keyword is cancelled, can it still shoot through itself?

    Asking for a friend: do derelicts block lines of fire?

    On dismasted ships with Oarsman: are there undesirable outcomes that are avoided by not letting these ships ram other ships?  This has come up frequently this year, where a player feels they should be able to ram and board with a ship that has an oarsman.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #15843
    Ben
    Keymaster

    70 Point Durable Endeavour build
    HMS Endeavour + RotF HGold, Brother Virgil, DJC Davy Jones, 2 points left for Ralph David + oarsman, or RotF TvTyne (up to 12 masts/turn), or Oarsman + Letter of Marque/Lucky the Parrot/etc.
    HMS Lord Kenyon + Robinson, Thomas Gunn (F&S), Lord Mycron, navigator
    +Oarsman on HI

    Idea is to copy Lord Kenyon’s ability to Endeavour to make the beast a more offensively charged version of El Acorazado. Swap out the Eternal crew for others if playing deathmatch with HI’s and/or Eternal banned. Lord Kenyon acts as one of the best cheerleaders ever, giving Endeavour the ability to hit on 2’s, two actions per turn every turn, and sometimes a +S boost to increase chances at initiating combat.

    If Endeavour is lost, LK can drop the navigator for the oarsman and be a somewhat annoying final customer for the opponent with *essentially* 2S guns and 4 hits to dismast.

    With cheese this is adaptable to a non-deathmatch 70 point game too. Just swap navigator on LK and HI oarsman for 0LR+5 Bratley, then for the 8 points left add in whatever you want for gold runners (Banshee’s Cry + explorer, Rover, Mermaid, etc).

    in reply to: The Videos Thread #15841
    Ben
    Keymaster

    My latest unboxing

    Also plenty of game footage up from recent playing!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15833
    Ben
    Keymaster

    For Mysterious Island #7, can the new coin be a UT or a 0 coin?

    5-6: After exploring this island, place a treasure coin from your collection with value equal to or less than one you took on the island.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15828
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Do you skip an eliminated player’s turn with Altar of the Loa if all they have left in play is a fort?

    No.   That player will count toward the endgame condition because they can’t give move actions, but assuming there are enough other players still going to prevent that, the player with the fort still gets their turn in the normal sequence.   If there’s nothing within range of the fort to attack they won’t have anything to do, but that’s not enough to skip them entirely.

    Can it skip that player if they didn’t have a fort? (absolutely no units in play)

    in reply to: Battle Reports #15824
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The Sleigh (proxied by HMS Gallows) went first, as per the Challenge, and moved 6L to the far side of the map, near some thematic Icebergs. My fleet went next, with Jones pinning the Sleigh in place with Whitebeards ability, while the Cygnet and Bazana got underway.

    When Sleigh goes first I think Whitebeard would “hohoho” the Locker into missing her turn (unless the controller guessed wrong which ship to lock up), in which case I think DJ wouldn’t be able to copy Whitebeard and freeze the Sleigh.

    If so, the L-immunity becomes very helpful because you might just be able to run gold and get it all.  Because if Sleigh rams one of your ships, it can’t dismast it (max of 1 damage) and then you just keep it pinned while running gold with the remaining ship.

    A strange challenge; the more I think about it the less I want to attempt it.  The gamification is on such a level that it might just come down to who goes first, or how the Sleigh and Whitebeard’s unique abilities work in relation to others and the Code.  I like how a regular game has a lot more variables where many things can dictate the outcome.  XD

    in reply to: The non-eBay Sales & Trades thread #15823
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #15819
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The “Altar Meta”

    After another game where the Altar of the Loa UT affected various plays and strategy, I think there’s even a chance that if Pirates saw competitive play on a large scale again, an “Altar Meta” could emerge based on the UT.  Through a combination of treasure trading, spying/Maps of Alexandria, and extremely fast ships with explorers, one player can optimize their fleet for finding or using the Altar first.  They can also put other UT’s into the distribution that result in additional sacrifices, such as Abandoned Crew and Castaway.

    In the multiplayer games this year where it saw usage, neither fleet that used it the most ended up winning the game.  It helped their prospects of winning, but mostly by hindering a few opponents (only 1/5 enemy fleets) rather than directly helping themselves.

    However, in a 1v1 setting it becomes far more brutal, and monumental in importance.  If a player can begin an “Altar Loop” where they sac crew to control the enemy, the first turn of control makes it more likely that they can then get more crew to the island to continue the mind control on subsequent turns.  I would estimate that in a 1v1 game, two turns of consecutive control early in the game would be nearly impossible to come back from, simply due to the sheer amount of logistics and enemy sabotage the controlling player can pull off.  Two rounds of full control would essentially amount to 5 consecutive player turns for the controller.

    Building a fort on the Altar island is a high-level trolling move.  It prevents the opponent(s) from docking at the island, effectively meaning the player with the fort is the only one that can use the Altar.  When combined with the potential to build forts extremely early in the game, this could be a devastating double whammy for an opponent – not only are they locked out of any Altar shenanigans, the other gold on the island gets protected and the fort player has bought themselves likely another turn or two of Altar “security” they can use to ferry sacrifices to the island while the fort soaks up hits.

    Multiplayer introduces additional Altar dynamics that can make for a confusing strategic landscape.  If eliminated players are skipped, it changes which player the Altar would grant control over.  This could affect alliances, suicide plays, and players racing to the Altar as fast as possible.  The Altar can be used as a weapon for making threats against other players, such as “do what we say or we’ll run your ships into reefs”.

    However, perhaps recent examples of Altar usage not resulting in wins should be a cautionary tale.  Getting tunnel vision on using the Altar might distract a player from getting enough gold to win, or cause them to control a player that was not contending in the first place.

    in reply to: Holiday Booty Giveaway Contest! #15818
    Ben
    Keymaster

    2 weeks left until the deadline!

    in reply to: Battle Reports #15817
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15810
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Is terrain applied to docking location after Message in a Bottle is triggered?  (I assume it would be on a case by case basis whether or not the terrain rules say “touches” vs. “moves over”)

    Is PotC Dead Man’s Chest automatically unloaded to an HI if you are stating not to use it for any gold? (ex: to keep it on your ship and use it at a later time, or it must be unloaded for 0 gold)

    Are outriggers considered part of the bow for movement/etc purposes? (Catamarans/canoes/etc)

    Can you trigger the Mines UT when a ship already within S starts moving? (regardless of which direction it is going, such as away from the ship with Mines)

    Can a ship still use S-Board if Mines causes it to become derelict?  Can the same ship still shoot before that last cannon gets eliminated by Mines?  For clarity, I assume the wording in the UT “end of her move” means her move action, not move segment?

    Do you skip an eliminated player’s turn with Altar of the Loa if all they have left in play is a fort?

    Can native canoes redock at a wild island that was S-explored on the first turn of a game to take gold from it as a free action? (I assume yes because they’re given move actions, not explore actions)

    If the below theoretically happened: is the flotilla’s movement (straight ahead with the St. Joan) blocked by the tentacle? (knowing that the monster cannot pin the flotilla)

    theoretical

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #15717
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #15714
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Raptor Maw alert (also a Lizard’s Sting and some other rare stuff)

    Nice lot with mostly CC and SCS

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15712
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Does a forfeit affect existing gold scores?  For example, if a player forfeits, does their gold count, or does it automatically become 0?  (asking partly since someone could have an “emergency” and clear their fleet out and leave the venue, at which point they can’t claim to win just because they have more gold at the time)

    in reply to: What kind of player are you? #15696
    Ben
    Keymaster

    A great addition to this topic is The Alignment System.  🙂

     

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #15695
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Lots of good points for discussion – this could almost be a thread entirely on its own.

    I thought about it, but realized how much of it applies to this thread’s topics and wanted to keep it here.

    Thanks for your extended answers, I always love hearing your perspective on these topics.

    I agree with you about some luck in the game being a good thing for sure.  My lesson learned on that is more in regards to caring too much about the result when one d6 roll or playing the game to proper completion would have swung the winner.  When the standings feel flawed as a result, I simply enjoy the game a bit less.  On one hand maybe I should get into a less luck-dependent game, but I think I’d rather just separate some of the recent games I’ve played from the more competitive 1v1 standard games I miss.


    @CrazyIvan
    : Thanks for your input!

    I think it would take quite a lot of work to make the game “fair” at this point in a competitive sense.

    Probably a difference in perspective, but I think fairness is less important at the competitive level, because competition inherently means trying to gain some kind of advantage (whether fair or not) over the opposition.

    From a different angle, I see your point in terms of making a competitive environment fair for a lot of people, especially newer players or people who have small collections lacking competitive game pieces.

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #15690
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Lots of thoughts and reflections on the weekend marathon of multiplayer games.  Would rather post it than have it sit in my mind haha.  Curious if you have any thoughts, or opinions based on your own experiences.  None of it is a condemnation of any of the people I played with; I definitely consider all of them my friends. I think bringing up these topics could further some interesting discussions about the game.  😀

    Questions
    Are ban lists and house rules just a knee-jerk reaction to something that players see as unfair, OP, broken, or “unfun”? Have adequate counters been considered, and if so, are they too much of a chore to include to justify not banning/house ruling things?

    In a game called “Pirates”, how justified is it to bring external morality into the game? Should players get upset when they lose by legal combos? In a brutal game like this (crew killed, ships captured/stolen, plans ruined in round 1, etc), should players be annoyed with each other, or at the game itself? (or their own gameplay/fleet choices?)

    Is the pursuit of winning honorable regardless of the means used to obtain it? I think for players that can separate the game from real life, I would say yes. Of course, if the objective is simply fun and to keep your game group happy, you could argue that the pursuit of winning takes a backseat and the competitive nature of the game (that some players find more fun than others) gets watered down in the pursuit of a (likely subjective) ethical standard.

    Should implied moral judgment be applied more to specific aspects of the game than others? For example, being “ethical” (again, at least partially subjective in this case) in fleet building but then “evil” during gameplay? (or vice versa/etc. Ex: bribing a player before the game with a game piece they don’t have, or making pre-game alliances/etc.)

    Is it wrong to use game pieces that are not on a ban list if players deem them “bad”? (especially during/after their usage in the game vs. before starting play)

    If one player wants to continue playing but another doesn’t, should the person who leaves the game be considered a forfeit regardless of their actual gold score at the end of the game?

    Is it wrong to bring grievances from outside the game into the game?

    What is the best way to establish “last round”? (ex: game with a time limit) Ex: someone has to leave by 7pm. All players need an equal number of turns, AND all players need advance notice of when the last round starts so they know if they need to take their ships out of fog banks/etc to have the gold count.  Solution?  20 minutes (?) before the time deadline, regardless of which player is the current player, all players understand that when the next round begins, it will be the last round of the game.

    Lessons I Learned:
    -I hate “asterisks” (game not finished properly/etc) to the point where I need to stop playing games where they might happen. However, I realize this is a symptom of me sometimes caring too much about winning and not just enjoying the game for what it is. I suppose that this year especially, my enjoyment of the game is tied to the game being played properly by the rules.  I think this is driven by my agony over the “what ifs” that simply don’t matter as much (if even applicable) if the game is played to true completion.
    -Big multiplayer games are a bit overrated. Lots of time in between player turns. More players means more risk that someone will have some emergency or time constraint where they suddenly have to leave. Often not enough time to play the game out before a meal interruption occurs (playing at someone’s house can alleviate this). Games with 6+ players at 60 or more points should generally be the only game scheduled for that day.
    -I personally find the game less enjoyable and less rewarding when players don’t want to play things out per the normal endgame rules. (ex: “calling” it)  I recognize that real life factors sometimes have to play a role, but I think my love for the game overrides most of those.  (whereas it doesn’t for many other players, which is fine and more normal than me haha)
    -So much luck involved that I can’t wrap my ego/energy up in winning. (ex: one treasure coin being on a different island during the coin distribution to islands could change the winner, let alone dozens of other luck-based things that happen during the game)
    -I think it would be useful to establish different “game modes” of Pirates for the community, such as Unlimited (100% normal rules), “Fair Seas” (ban list to eliminate “fun killers”/unfair game pieces, and house rules to enhance fairness, address rule annoyances, and possibly shore up underpowered game pieces), and maybe more.  This is something I plan to work on.

    in reply to: Battle Reports #15688
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15512
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can you tow a tangled derelict out of a sargasso sea?

    Can a ship shoot after freeing itself from a sargasso sea? (by extension, is “its action for the turn” a move action?)

    Does Parley last for the duration of the attacker’s turn or until the owner of Parley starts their turn? (or a whole round)

    Does a roll of 5 with the Fear keyword affect abilities for just the Fear owner’s turn, or the whole round?

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #15511
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15509
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If a crew such as Commodore Matthew Perry (American 0LR +5) is on a shipwreck, I assume that only American ships could load him because he can’t be assigned to ships of other nationalities?  If so and it was not the original owner, would it be considered a captured crew or just a free crew?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15507
    Ben
    Keymaster

    For spying abilities (such as “Once per turn, this ship may look at one face-down cargo on any ship”), is it every player turn or just on that player’s active turn?  (same wording as Canceller so players voted to have it apply to every player turn in last night’s 6 player game)

    If a native canoe gets stuck in a sargasso sea, is it stuck forever because it cannot roll higher than a 6 or not stuck at all because the sargasso sea rules refer to masts which the canoes don’t have?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15505
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I saw your post over on BGG about that too.    That looks like just a side effect of paraphrasing things to save space.  It’s fine for the vast majority of the time, but loses the nuance that covers the remainder.

    I’ve looked through the Winning the Game section of the Complete Game rules for all the sets and cannot find an “eliminated players” endgame condition.  Was it specifically added to The Pirate Code back in the day in order to prevent “simulation” players who wreck an opponent and then “get the rest of the gold”?

    I checked the older versions of the Code that you’ve uploaded to BGG but found no text differences relevant to this topic.  Wondering if it originated in an older FAQ or a specific Multiplayer Rules document perhaps.  For example, where does the current Code ruling come from?  And if it originates from before any of the sets came out, why didn’t it make it into the Complete Game rules for that set and all afterwards?  (which are biased towards 1v1 games, but the immediate vs. start of turn timing matters regardless of player count)

    The reason I’m so curious is because I’ve been playing by the “immediate” version for years now, and want to know why that’s wrong/where it came from.  The Combined Set Rules are great but this is a considerably important discrepancy (anything in the Endgame rules is a big deal), especially since it has probably affected the win/loss outcome of at least a few games I’ve been involved in. (assuming of course)

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15503
    Ben
    Keymaster

    With only two players, it doesn’t end until the eliminated player would start their own turn.

    With more players, it ends at the start of any player’s turn after the minimum number of players have been eliminated.  It doesn’t have to be the start of an eliminated player’s turn.

    Functionally it still amounts to almost the same thing.  The current/active player still gets to finish their own turn before the game would actually end; it doesn’t end the instant enough other players have been eliminated.

    Makes sense!  Thanks for all the answers lately, it’s been very helpful.

    I think part of the confusion stems from the Combined Set rules, which state “The game ends immediately…”, which seems to contradict what the Code says.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #15500
    Ben
    Keymaster

    On a related note, for win condition #3 on page 14, can the phrase “a player” mean the opposing player, or does every “his/her/player” reference in that sentence specifically reference the active player’s turn and no opponents?

    That applies only to the current/active player’s own turn.   If some other player gets wiped out in between, the endgame condition doesn’t trigger until their turn starts.

    Just to make sure I understand: For example, in a 7 player game where 4 players must be “eliminated” to trigger the “half or more” rule.  Players 5-7 are already out.  Another round starts, and Player 1 eliminates Player 4.  Players 2 and 3 then take their full turns, and the game doesn’t end until Player 4’s next “turn” comes around?

     

    Some fort wording minutiae:

    “-An island with a fort is still considered a wild island for the purposes of all other abilities and effects.”

    “-If treasure remains on wild islands but cannot be loaded by any player due to an ability or some other effect, that gold is no longer considered “available” and will not prevent this end condition.”

    My understanding is that fort gold is available gold, but this seems to contradict that because ships cannot dock at or explore islands that have opposing forts on them.  Is it just a quirk of how the rules or Code are worded?

     

    I assume you must build sea creatures in a configuration that matches their deckplate cannons?  For example, Calim has two 2S segments and three 4S’s.  They can physically be placed so that you could have a 2S in slots 1 and 4 or 2 and 5 (looking top down left to right/etc), but is this illegal?

Viewing 30 posts - 631 through 660 (of 2,325 total)