Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 451 through 480 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17748
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I just pulled out an oarsman from a revolution pack to check this for you. It says on the card “If derelict, this ship gains a base move of +S. This crew takes up no cargo space.”

    I’m aware of that, but the question is about whether or not the “takes up no cargo space” ability functions while face down (or if you have to reveal it in order to get that benefit).  Normally crew can only have their abilities apply while face up, but I thought there was an exception to crew that don’t take up cargo space.

    Woelf will be able to provide clarity.  🙂

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17746
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Does a facedown Oarsman crew not take up cargo space?  I seem to remember that being the case from a previous rules question answered long ago, but just want to be sure.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17744
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I did another demo game, and it was a lot more fun and a lot better. I think I’m ready to introduce this game to the party.

    Glad to hear it!

    Sometimes it can be fun to change up the default rules too, beyond the regular 3 islands per player and 4 coins per wild island.  Just depends on how long you have for the game, and how much action you want there to be. (more gold and more islands = usually a longer game)

    in reply to: No Sails Fleet Challenge #17741
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Awesome!

    About 9 days remaining, and we only need 3 more fleets to unlock the prizes!

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #17739
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I collect oceans edge and revolution packs. They’re the ones I have the most fond memories of.

    That should work out well, as RV and OE are often the cheapest sets (and/or most widely available at this point).

    Welcome aboard, and I hope your upcoming game(s) are fun!

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #17735
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Those are pretty powerful abilities on Javelin and Spearhead; it’s possible both should see a point cost increase.  Spearhead would arguably be worth 9 without her ability, so I could see her going to 12-13 for playtesting.  Feels like a high-reward hybrid ripe for World Hater, or even just a cannoneer/musketeer.

    in reply to: No Sails Fleet Challenge #17732
    Ben
    Keymaster

    10 more days left to enter!

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #17731
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Various pack auctions end on Monday, including RotF, DJC, and MI!

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #17730
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Going crazy with fleets this month!  More to come!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17727
    Ben
    Keymaster

    One of Darrin’s old fleets (the Miniature Trading member who invented the UPS fleet archetype as far as I know) made me peruse the Mysterious Islands again and ponder some effects.

    MI #15 seems particularly wild, especially in the case of Unique Treasures. “5-6: Randomly move one treasure coin from this island to your home island.”  Perhaps I’ll start with a question that might put you in a good mood, before this gets ugly.  XD  😉   It’s been rather amusing to think about all of this today.

    Ex: Bad Maps is flung home via the MI. I assume you can look at it since it’s your treasure. An enemy ship then raids your home island, ending up with the Maps (allowing the controller to move their own HI in a 1v1 game). Can you use Bad Maps to “ram” friendly turtles to get a bunch of them home safely all of a sudden without having them move to touch the HI?

    What happens if Cursed Natives is revealed during an HI raid?

    Can flinging home the Altar of the Loa cause it to be operational? It seems that it would work, after giving an explore action to explore your own HI.

    Does the effect of the Rum UT last for all player turns following it being loaded, or just the controller’s next turn?  I’m thinking about it being found during an HI raid after the MI effect gets used, then a 3rd player using All-Powerful to try and force the drunken crew to go back for more with a repeat theft attempt.

    When using Bad Maps, does it function as a linear movement that can be blocked by islands/terrain/ships, or can the opposing player move things up and over/under stuff as long as no contact is made by the end placement?

    -If the island ends up close enough to another island, can a ship (such as a 10 master with a wide bow) dock at multiple islands at the same time?

    A [custom] UT could give itself a negative value, but it would have to explicitly say so.

    Due to that, I assume that Rum can’t be worth negative gold if there are 7+ crew on the ship that finds it?

    Can you unload a facedown Abandoned Crew on your home island, then voluntarily reveal it to make it crew? (including during an opponent’s turn)

    Does the Trees UT get loaded onto a ship using it at all?

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #17726
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Seventeen feels a bit pricey for her effectiveness as a gunship.  I could see her in the 11-13 range. Although, she may be a slightly worse ship than HMS Nautilus (10 points).

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17722
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If Wolves is face up on a wild island, Royal Decree can’t pick anything from that island; it has to pull from elsewhere.

    I think the Code entry for Wolves should probably include a note about needing to keep it face up once revealed.  The part about it needing to be hit for elimination implies that, but it’s a little odd that it doesn’t say so explicitly.  I could also see a newer player finding it, keeping it hidden, and then not taking any treasure from the island while bluffing that they didn’t want to (whereas Wolves should become known to all players).

    Noticing a pretty huge discrepancy in the wording for the Explore Action.  The Start Here rules state:

    If you’re docked at a wild island, you can take treasure.

    Complete Game rules state:

    If a ship begins one of your turns docked at a wild island

    I’ve never played that a ship has to begin a player turn docked at a wild island to explore that turn (even making the distinction to “her” turn as a specific ship would be very important for something like Hidden Cove, a staple of competitive play). She should be able to dock, then potentially get an extra action to explore.

    It’s a bit odd to me that the Complete Game rules should be the incorrect ones here, since normally the Start Here rules contain the annoying discrepancies that got fixed with the Complete Game rules or Code. (Such as not looking at coins while exploring. It’s still odd to me that the wording for that made it into the game – it would make sense for one set if Spanish Main had no UT’s, but if players pull a UT out of their first pack, the game will probably have an asterisk for the “error” caused by the bad rule)

     

    On that note, thanks again as always for keeping up with this so consistently over the years.  The more I dig into things, the more discrepancies and gray areas I find.  I thought by now this thread would be less active, but it seems there will be no end to new rules questions!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17720
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Does anything strange happen if the Wolves UT is teleported straight to your home island? (such as by one of the Royal Decree UT’s, or a Mysterious Island effect)  This old review makes me think not, but I want to be sure.

    I was slightly hopeful it might prevent HI raiding, but it specifies a wild island in the ability text.

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17716
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Super excited to use the chess clock for the first time!  It was great and I’ll continue trying different timers….

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #17711
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Would love your vote in BGG’s 2023 Picture of the Year contest!

    in reply to: No Sails Fleet Challenge #17710
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Less than 3 weeks left to enter the challenge!  (deadline is 1/31)

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #17709
    Ben
    Keymaster

    My latest fleet: Delay of Game
    When you love the game so much, you don’t let it end. XD

    I’ve also recently published some new fleet making videos, and there will be more on the way.  🙂  It’s going to be a great year for making fleets and playing!  😀

    in reply to: The non-eBay Sales & Trades thread #17708
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Mild sales on PotC and SM through 1/25: http://wholesalegaming.biz/pirates/

    in reply to: All Pirates CSG Surveys #17706
    Ben
    Keymaster

    2024 bump!

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #17699
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If you’re looking for point cost recommendations on Foxtrot, I’d probably start at 9 or 10.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #17696
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Big lot including Guichuan and SCS advert from magazine or something. (may have come from the same Scrye magazine I’m seeing pages of)

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17689
    Ben
    Keymaster

    2) A player has unloaded more than half of the game’s starting gold value onto his or her home island.

    –The gold value required to trigger this end condition is determined during setup, before the game begins. Abilities or effects that increase or decrease the actual gold value in play during the game do not change that required value.

    Is the last sentence mainly to reduce confusion? (with lots of +1/+2 abilities and gold-bearing UT’s potentially in play)

    I don’t think it’s a bad rule, but certain competitive fleets that abuse the gold bonus abilities certainly have an interesting way to exploit it (sometimes by flinging gold home that gets increased in value, sometimes allowing a fleet to win with spoils from just one island or a couple original coins).

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17688
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Thank you!

    nextjr is wondering:

    Could a submerged submarine be hit by Neptune’s Trident, and if so if it’s the Nautilus submarine does it take two hull pieces of damage or one because of its defensive ability?

    Would holy water save a submerged submarine being fired upon by a ship that has an ability can shoot submerged ships

    in reply to: No Sails Fleet Challenge #17687
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Looks like I am first?
    Here you go Ben, my 70 point, no sails fleet:
    https://psmlist.com/public/fleet/show/7773692826/mercs__damn_the_sails

    Dive or die . .

    Awesome! Someone from the discord submitted a fleet as well. Thanks for entering!

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17665
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Nice game!  Love the pictures with the effects.  Did you use Photoshop to make them?

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #17663
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I don’t think I’ve allowed factions to suddenly show up; I will have to try that…

    It’s definitely not great for parity or rules, more for the narrative element.  Nowadays I generally prefer to play campaign games 100% “by the book” (rules and custom rules), without random personal elements thrown in.  It’s fun to try a few times though!

    in reply to: What book are you reading? #17645
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Recent finishes include:

    Atomic Habits

    The Daily Stoic

    Deep Work

     

    All highly recommended!

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #17656
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Sleigh holiday pic up for the monthly photo contest at BGG  😀

    Ben
    Keymaster

    To reduce spam from bots and nefarious actors, a new member’s first forum post must be approved by me. This is why you may not see your first post appear immediately; it goes into a queue where I will review it and likely approve it. Once a user has their first forum post approved, subsequent posts they make should appear on the forum right away without requiring approval.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #17638
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Welcome aboard matey!

    I think I love this game because it’s theme, it’s very adaptable (can add or remove rules to make it more simple or complex), gives a high degree of freedom (I can add or change rules and the game keeps working) and can be really fun to play.

    Love this!  I agree completely. It can be a very “modular” game.

    (sometimes I like to spice my games with backgrounds, special objectives for each faction etc, to the point of bend the rules for specific scenarios or even specific situations; the fact that I play 100% solo gave me the idea, it creates a sort of virtual opponent).

    I’ve done that a bit too, especially in my Experimental cumulative game.

Viewing 30 posts - 451 through 480 (of 2,325 total)