@admin
Active 2 hours, 54 minutes agoForum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterHmmmm. I’m kind of all the above.
I’ve been nearly all kinds of players at various points over the years. I think you and I are two of the only people to play that can say “all of the above”. 🙂 With enough sheer volume of games it’s nearly inevitable.
October 30, 2019 at 6:19 AM in reply to: Nastiest 1 master in the game? Hessian is underrated. #10032Ben
KeymasterHMS Rye isn’t nearly as good offensively as the Hessian because as a galley she can’t do damage by ramming and her cannon isn’t accurate, but the Rye is still quite nasty for a 1 master. My ideal setup for her (especially in campaign games) is helmsman, shipwright, oarsman. This allows her to move at a blazing speed of 4S, repair her lone mast (very vulnerable to ramming) at sea, and delay capture with the oarsman. (the latter is important because capturing a canceller and towing it around can be one way to flip a battle on its head if used optimally) Even without a mast, the Rye could row around at S+S as a non-captureable ship that cancels key enemy abilities in a firefight.
As an otherwise unremarkable SCS LE, the Rye is sort of an English secret weapon unlike their main canceller (Lawrence from BC), though not so secret anymore after extensive campaign game play.
Oh, and she makes for a solid English gold runner when empty too! (or nearly empty; oarsman still recommended)
Ben
Keymaster@Woelf: Strictly as a matter of opinion, do you think that ships should be able to tow other friendly ships that are dismasted but have oarsmen?
With the Oarsman keyword as it stands now, it sounds like that would be illegal since the rules say you can only tow derelicts. However, I think having the option of using the oars is more realistic. I’m rereading the BR’s for CG1 and I think some of the English ships did more towing than rowing.
I also wish you could scuttle with no masts remaining, regardless of technical derelict status.
Ben
KeymasterThis thread has given me the motivation to make the Cursed pieces from my custom set as horrifying as possible, so thanks for starting this discussion, Ben.
Cool! The Executioner is definitely one of the nastiest. The Cursed are the most numerous faction in my fantasy custom set. Feel free to share your new customs in the prominent thread here.
Ben
KeymasterPerhaps replacing SAT with that ability to off-load cargo from within S of your HI? Would that be better, and would it affect his current point cost drastically?
Sounds good; in that case I think 4 points would be good.
Ben
KeymasterNormally Pirates get discounts on crew and whatnot, I would say this is one exception where he should cost more than the sum of his abilities.
Thank you for admitting that; that’s exactly what should happen. Helmsman+SAT is not a combo that should really exist on crew due to how absurdly awesome it is. I priced SAT at 5 in my Total Recosting, but even bumping this guy to 7 probably wouldn’t affect how much he’s used.
I think Blackburn could be 4 or 5 points. I like BA at 3, and not taking up space isn’t worth too much.
These crew really illustrate how off some of the WK prices are. In terms of ACTUAL in-game value, I would potentially pay 10 points for Mr. Nautilus, and likely only 3 for Blackburn. If you look at how good each ability is, these crew are pretty much on opposite ends of the value spectrum.
Ben
KeymasterDid something go wrong with Event costs?
Yup, Wizkids massively underpriced many of them. XD I guess I’m overcorrecting, but I can’t help it. I’m fine if people want to make their own recostings or edit mine for their own usage. I just hate certain events too much to not make them obsolete, because I feel that they should never have existed.
Ben
Keymaster@JW: I like the Neverland and would love to use her. Given the costs of the Intrepid (15 points for a better gunship) and others, I think the cost is fine.
I didn’t realize that Armed Merchant can be used in addition to shooting, for basically an extra shot each time the ship shoots. I’m not sure if that should be more clearly stated in the keyword text, or if I’m just not thinking about it optimally. It’s possible I’ve been underrating the ability, since you could use it like a reverse captain too. Hmmm….
Ben
KeymasterShall I assume that this is limited to WizKids pieces?
I wasn’t thinking about customs when I posted it, but go ahead. Makes it pretty easy to have a lot of nasty flavor text; some of mine is arguably offensive, but that’s what you get with a faction like The Cursed….
Ben
KeymasterOne initial thought – I think it would be really helpful to have an additional column next to your revised costs showing the original WK point values, to make it a lot easier to see the adjustments in context and make useful comparisons.
Thanks for the feedback. Just implemented that change in most cases. (sometimes the spreadsheets don’t overlap since I deleted some rows for the TC)
I actually didn’t do that with the first page because so many of those abilities costed different amounts for different game pieces, and there are some that I don’t know the official cost of.
Now that I did that it’s funny to see some of the dramatic swings in point costs. Especially on some of the later sets. XD If someone wanted to, they could calculate which sets were the most overpriced or underpriced by totaling up the differentials. Though I don’t think the results would be very surprising, which F&S likely leading in the “most overpriced” category. I could also do the average cost difference per set, and per game piece in each set. (for example, perhaps each RV game piece is underpriced by 1.4 points, while RotF could be overpriced by 2 points)
That does make me think a little… I’ve never totaled up point costs by set.
Ben
Keymaster@MagExpress: Wow, I don’t think I had seen the flavor text for the Dance before. O_O
Ben
KeymasterCrossing the T is an example of a naval strategy that naturally comes up in a pirates game. Basically maximize your firepower on an enemy ship and minimize the enemies ability to fire back.
Great point, I forgot about that one. Can be especially effective against ships with lesser overall striking range (S speed with S cannons for example), or against a 10 master without an extra action where maneuvering for the counterattack can be a nightmare trying to get cannons in range.
Ben
KeymasterThe Fiendfire is actually the ship I alluded to in a reply to your post about the Combustion on 4-23-19
Do you have any in-depth opinions on her?
I think she looks fine! Was it inspired by the Fiendfyre from Harry Potter?
I like the various limits the ship has. (especially the once per turn and d6 roll so it’s not automatic) 🙂 It would be interesting to try and time that ship’s action for the opportune moment.
Ben
Keymaster12 is pretty cheap for that ability. Would 16-18 be better?
Yeah, I just realized it’s like a moveable Cursed Zone. As usual I like to keep things more expensive to start so games are less likely to be ruined by OP stuff, so 18 sounds good.
Quite the opposite of my own Calamity, which is a 10 masted junk. XD
Ben
KeymasterI can make L-Range happen. About the same points for that as currently?
In addition to that, I think it should be more expensive. That ability makes cannons far less likely to hit, and it makes SAT and EA impossible to use. (among other things)
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterAt this point I think I’d have to see the Ryuk in play to form a better opinion of the ship.
Marra is impressive, though I think the ability should say “within L of this ship” so there’s no confusion. I would probably want her towing a flotilla as part of a battle squadron.
Great flavor text for the Blue Blood, and seems like the right cost too.
Ben
KeymasterHi Captain Randy, glad to have you aboard! Sorry that you weren’t able to post; I’ll be looking at the Pending replies more often from now on. (no idea why yours went there though)
Loved reading your story and how much you love the game! Unique to hear about your relationship with Brachyura. Certainly not a crab you want to mess with! 🙂 I’m a big PotC fan too.
Thanks Ben for all you do, buddy! You are an asset to the game and to people, like myself, trying to navigate its many aspects.
Thank you for your patience, and please reach out to me or one of the moderators (Xerecs, Woelf, and Artisturn) if you have trouble with posts going through again.
Ben
KeymasterFor some reason, random posts seem to be going to the moderation queue rather than showing up in the forum. I don’t know why and I apologize for that issue. I hope to have time to look into it.
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterI used to play some large fleet action games with friends where we would use duplicate ships as others in a “class” based on the namesake.
That makes sense! I would have had a large “Mayfair” and “Birkenhead” class. XD
For me the overall quality of ship type is dependent on how big a game is being played. If it’s a smaller game, most nations can bring something competitive to the table, if it’s a larger action, the strength of some nations for 5-mast vessels does drop off a bit to the point where it does begin to matter.
Great point!
As for 2-3 mast vessels, I need to look into this some more as well. I have some I enjoy a lot for pirates, Britain and Spain, but it’s an area I’ve not given a ton of thought to as a group overall.
It’s part of the reason I ran out of things to discuss in my post. I think there’s considerable balance with 2 masters for the most part, though the Pirates and French are probably still the best.
I feel like most of the factions have a lot of great 3 masters, which is one of my favorite ship sizes due to the competition, point levels, and hybrids. From the Fleet Review I did, I remember the Americans having a weird advantage in some niche 3 master class types – arguably the best hoist (Frontier), longship (Kettering), AND submarine (Mercury). However, they don’t have some of the awesome square-rigged 3 masters that the Big 4 factions have, although their excellent and quick 3 masted schooners make up for it somewhat.
Ben
KeymasterThe ability text for Ryuk could be: “Instead, select one crew assigned to this ship, and one crew with the exact same abilities on any other ship in play.” Not that it helps much. As Woelf said, you could just sit at home and start picking off enemy captains right before they fight your own battle squadron.
I do think Eternal Curse could be 1-2 points more expensive. The Diamond Strike has Sac built-in and essentially has 2S cannons with her ability. This ship is faster with better cannon ranges, in addition to her other ability.
SAC is a very good ability and worth 3 points when on a crew.
It’s pretty much objectively worth more than that, Wizkids just never priced it correctly.
On the other hand, Possession is rather terrible and almost always ineffective. I cut the cost to 4 for my customs, which I think is fair. (less than 3 is probably not enough) I like Eternal at 3 so Aiestel would be cool at 9.
Ben
KeymasterSeems as though the mystery may be solved… I’m so glad I saved this picture from old_man that he posted to Miniature Trading a while back:

Ben
KeymasterNow the first sheet contains all the game pieces (except the 1 of 1’s), with each set still present as well with its own sheet. For the first sheet, I consolidated the info so it is all trade-based and doesn’t include gameplay stats.
I may just leave it as-is; you can hit File>Download to get your own copy! Feedback welcome.
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterLilith
Points: 13/14
Ability: Loyal: The Cursed. (Eternal.) Once per turn, you may choose one friendly ship in play. That ship cannot be affected by the Fear keyword for this turn. Once per turn, give one friendly ship +1 to her cannon rolls for this turn.This actually seems too expensive. I don’t see that Fear immunity being worth more than 2 points, so I think this version could be 11 points even with Eternal.
Ben
KeymasterOnce again I must apologize for all the mistakes in the Master Spreadsheet. Most of them should be fixed now.
Corrections: Divers point cost from 2 to 1, RV #138 from Oarsmen to Oarsman, deleted “showing” from BC Serpiente’s ability text, fixed Admiral Yi’s ability text, SCS 030 cost changed from 6 to 2, added cost of 2 to SCS 085, changed DJC Fantasma ability from Captain to Reverse Captain, gave cost to DJC #062, changed abilities of La Catedral del Mar and Dark Fox to Fear from the written-out keyword text, Santos Romanos masts from 3 to 2, fixed Monte Cristo’s masts and point cost, fixed ability of L’Eroica, added cannons for Baochuan, fixed mispelling of HMS Auckland and San Theodora, changed Grendel’s mast cound from 3 to 2, fixed cost of USS Cheyenne, fixed Squalo’s point cost and segment count, fixed Teach’s segment count, deleted Ochobrazo from RotF sheet, fixed misspellings of Bombardier, added Explorer ability to F&S Scepter.
Ben
KeymasterI think you might be better off making her like Roberto Santana, choosing one ship to give her bonus or whatever to.
Indeed. Anything that gives a bonus to ALL ships in your fleet is usually OP by default. I think you could also make it affect a specific number of ships, such as a maximum of 3 friendly Cursed ships. (when you reveal the crew, or simply from the start of gameplay if you wanted her to start the game face up)
I could limit her ability to just one keyword instead of both?
I don’t think that’s enough, simply because it’s still effectively unlimited. Cargo Master is OP because there’s no cap on it. I can certainly imagine a submerged sea monster squadron in next year’s CoEC swarming around with Fear getting rolled for dozens of times each turn.
Normally I wouldn’t think it is such a big deal, but recall the 2017 game, with all the monsters concentrated in one area, each rolling for Fear for multiple ships. Evey target ship was hit with BOTH outcomes of Fear. Do you see my point?
O_O And I wrote that before even seeing this comment! XD Xerecs’ suggestion would work, though if you want to keep it more similar, I think giving Eternal+Fear to a max of 3 Cursed ships would work too. (and theoretically that cost is in line with 12, since if Eternal and Fear generally come to 4 points combined (maybe 5 but Fear could be 1), 4×3 ships would be the 12 points)
The edits definitely help curb the Cursed craziness. 🙂 If you’re looking for a point cost on the Agramon, I think 30 would be a minimum place to start at. Assuming the cancellation can occur on an enemy turn as soon as their ship moves into range.
I think the Ryuk’s ability text is fine.
-
AuthorPosts
