Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1,381 through 1,410 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Four Ships Come Sailing In #9766
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Indeed, sometimes buying lots on eBay (including punched/used) is a good way to expand a collection without spending a ton of money.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9765
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I just need to get the islands from the frozen north or proxy a fog bank for an iceberg?

    Exactly.  That’s how we’ve done icebergs in VASSAL actually – with fog banks that have a face up coin for the number in the middle.

    in reply to: Four Ships Come Sailing In #9759
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @CaptainPlunder: Those 4 ships are definitely not equal, but there are sort of two “tiers” with the Golden Medusa and Lady’s Scorn at the top (in that order, for me at least) and the Rum Runner and Revenge at the bottom (also in that order).

    I would concentrate more on learning the rules and having fun rather than trying to have completely “equal” fleets.  I’ve certainly lost games where I had the better fleet “on paper”, and I’ve won games against opponents who had a better fleet than me.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2019 #9755
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Wow Voya Nui gone?! That is pretty wild. Sort of reminds me of the volcanic activity during the Experimental cumulative game.
    Wow, the English and Cursed have really gone on impressive launching sprees! I could definitely see a viable strategy being to lay low for most of the game and then launching a ton in the final weeks of play to boost the ship count.
    Oh gosh not Becalmed lol.
    “Lending” 1000 gold?! What is this trickery?? XD
    Love the shot at 7:31
    8:37 is epic, reminds me of the Pirate launches at the fort in CTO.
    11:05 Great picture here too, even if I don’t love the result. XD
    I love the poetic karma of the Phantom being the OP ship that gets eliminated via Runes of Odin. 😀

    in reply to: Four Ships Come Sailing In #9753
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I need some advise on 4 four masted pirate ships that are of equal strength, etc… any recommendations?

    I would simply go with the one that you like the best, or perhaps that looks the coolest.  I assume you’re trying to choose which one to use in an upcoming game?

    in reply to: Play by dealing cards to each player? #9752
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What is the highest you can roll in this game?

    6.

    Never thought of using playing cards, but I’m sure some kind of workable system could be figured out.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9747
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Are you able to customize Forts in Vassal?

    Yes indeed!  Feel free to check out the video tutorial on the main page for it.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9744
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Since most terrain like Icebergs, Sargasso Sea, Trade Current, and Forts (technically not terrain) are hard to come by or out of print, how can noobs like myself fabricate this terrain to incorporate them into our play experience?

    They’re all out of print, but none of those are extremely rare.  Just depends on the set in terms of which packs might have specific terrain or forts (latter of which were only in CC and RV).

    You could cut out paper shapes and color them in and write “Reef”/etc on them.  In addition to printing out pictures.  In the Saved from MT post there is a link to the MT database pictures where some scans can be found. (might be too small for practical printing)

    Don’t ever be sorry for “long” posts!  Imagine what went into some of my stuff.  XD

    Is it possible to grab images of terrain from Vassal to print out for tabletop play including Forts, etc?

    Yup; I would zoom in on the area and use the Snipping Tool or a similar thing on your computer to take a picture of the screen.  RV packs are readily available and there should be more than one fort available for individual sale; the actual forts are very cool.

    By the way, how do I post a new topic in the Forum?

    Go to the bottom of the main forum page and you should see the entry fields to make a new topic.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #9739
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Welcome aboard!  I like the avatar.

    Pirates captures everything I was wanting to do with beauty and simplicity that I would have spent more time and resources trying to do with LEGO. The scale would have been much bigger than Pirates. I prefer the scale Pirates uses freeing up more table space.

    Great points!!

     I also live on the Coast of Georgia near the Pirates House in a town rich in naval colonial history.

    Awesome, sounds like another place I should go so thanks for mentioning that!

    in reply to: Game Advice #9738
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can anyone advise me the best place to get islands for terrain to make my ocean more realistic? I like the idea that Pirates provides islands, but I want something more 3-D.

    Here are the islands made by Ross in AZ.  I have used some of them in my own games and highly recommend them!  I also recommend making your own, though it can be messy and time consuming.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r7nYi7sdJ4U

    He also does trades with them, naturally depending on what you have to offer.

    in reply to: Collection Organization #9732
    Ben
    Keymaster

    How do you organize your collections? What is the best ways to store ships that is efficient but easy to find ships and all their parts?

    You can see my collection in the 2014 Fleet Review and the Collection Review Series.

    To find ships easily, you could try Plano boxes or some kind of divider system that you could use to sort ships individually or by criteria such as “French 5 masters”, “Cursed Pokeships” /etc.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9724
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If a ship with the reverse captain ability also has a captain crew on it can you move shoot and then move again?

    No, not without an extra action.  See Page 20.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2019 #9722
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Very impressive that the Americans managed to sink the various Spanish 10’s.
    4:05 Love this shot. Great angle and height.
    10:26 Wild to see how much open ocean there is, and how much smaller the Spanish operation looks.
    Nice to see the English rising even more! 😀

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #9718
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Recently I stumbled across two 36 pack boxes, one of Revolution and one of Barbary Coast and decided to buy them so I could force my friends to play.

    Even I haven’t done that… I love Pirates, but I don’t think anyone should be forced to play it.  At least those are good sets to garner interest with!

    Glad you’ve found some interesting rules here.  I’ve played over 400 games but still have a ton of rulesets and whatnot to hopefully try out in the future.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #9716
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The Pirates market is alive and well! Some recent auction prices to consider:
    SM island terrain set: $102.50 (new high)
    Zeus: $167.50 (new high, and possibly the highest amount for a 10 master since a Guichuan sold for $175, I think in 2018)
    Dungeon (DJC LE): $24.50
    Booty Finder: $26
    Celtic Fury: $49.79
    Near-complete set of DJC: $325

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9712
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Another question about an unreleased game piece:

    Blackfoot Bill
    Pirate
    2 points
    Ability: When this ship is damaged, remove any crew member, except this one, instead of a mast.

    Would this apply to fire masts?  I would think not, because the intent behind “remove” is more similar to “eliminate” than “replace”.

    Ben
    Keymaster

    It’s great that bbpress comes with the option for adding pictures to forum posts, but I’ve had a few people ask me how to add pictures to forum posts.

    At the far right of the Visual post editor, you can click the button for inserting an image.

    Source: This will be the image URL’s direct link.  Generally a url generated by the image host followed by the .jpg/.png/etc file extension.

    Image description: This is optional.

    Dimensions: This field is auto-filled and please leave the “constrain proportions” checkbox active, because your image may be cut off otherwise.  (or so big in rendering that it could slow down the topic loading speed)

    And there you have it!  The mighty Zeus.

    Zeus, 10 masted junk ship

    I cannot recommend a high quality image hosting site that is free, because they are unreliable.  I recommend backing up any pictures you have in at least 2 places overall to account for potential file loss.

    in reply to: STEM teaching with Pirates #9709
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Long story short: I want to use a modified (and very simplifgied) version of Pirates CSG to teach the first module of a short linear algebra course.

    Certainly a unique approach!  I like how you’re combining the game with something they’ll be learning regardless.  Definitely “never woulda thought o’ that!”  😀

    How to Post Pictures in this Forum

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #9708
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Welcome aboard!

    I’m a university teacher and stumbled across Pirates CSG while searching for miniatures to use as teaching aids in a class of linear algebra for biologists. Sorry to say I haven’t played it yet but I hope I can dupe my better half into playing next weekend :-D.

    Feel free to use my tutorial videos since you’re new.   You can also post the results of your games in the Battle Reports thread.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9703
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What exactly counts as a defensive ability here? Specifically, ships that need to be hit twice in the same shoot action to lose a mast, would those be “immune” to Broadsides Attack or would the keyword cancel that ability?

    BA ignores that ability, but doesn’t cancel it. (since it would still work against other ships not using BA on that same turn)

    In the Pirate Code entry, I think the defensive abilities listed are all of the things that prevent BA from working.  Anything else gets ignored. (AFAIK)

    As a dramatic example, (spoiler alert) HMS Bretwalda hit on a Broadsides Attack against El Acorazado at the end of my giant Defence of St. Helens game to effectively clinch the game for the attackers.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #9700
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Celtic Fury and others ending soon!  Also a Neptuno being bid on at $22.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2019 #9699
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Very impressive effort by the Galeon de Gibraltar.
    Some of those Spanish customs look absolutely amazing. The Bretwalda’s sails really make any ship look epic. I’m surprised by how much I like the contrast of the red and white sails on at least one of the custom Spanish 5’s.
    Pirate raid on the French reminds me of CTO, though not with as hasty of a retreat. XD
    If the Grinder’s loss was an accident, shouldn’t they get a free replacement of the same point cost? (not that they have a better ship haha) If she’s “totaled”, that’s a nasty real life loss too, financially and in terms of future gameplay… I’m really lucky all three of the 10 masters on my EE ocean survived that disaster intact in 2015.
    I’m a little disappointed by the lack of support the Swallow and Valiant had… it seems like an ongoing trend that the English send a gunship or a few through the Portal to smash the French, but inevitably lose those ships after being outnumbered. Makes more sense to make a concerted effort with a full battle squadron (perhaps to replace that French fort with their own for a base of operations, actually take territory) or not attack the French at all. (or attack from a different angle as they may start doing soon)
    I think I’m rooting for the French against the Pirates. The Pirates’ strategy and gameplay actually mystifies me as much as the Cursed, not that it’s a bad thing.
    The pictures starting at 8:30 are just crazy. Weird but neat to see such a strange arrangement of masts and flames on the SX.
    The pictures that follow are some of the more epic I’ve seen for any game. Also really helps viewers to remember the HI locations in relation to each other, which can get lost in the carnage and chaos.
    (possibly will be answered on YT) Have you had trouble managing deckplate space for the fleets? (obviously a huge issue for me in CTO haha) I just had the idea of low-depth drawers stacked on top of each other to store fleets in a tower. Though it would be annoying to move them in and out to see crew setups and ability text, and crew chips would probably slide around too much.
    Pretty cool to see so many fire masts, makes it look cool and prompts some interesting decisions.
    Great report!
    Looking forward to playing my CG4 turn tomorrow. 😀

    in reply to: Game Advice #9698
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Instead of galleys not being able to ram I was going to change it to only galleys can ram. It seems to make sense to me thematically and for gameplay reasons, makes 1 masters better. But does this make the Barbary pirates too powerful?

    I think all ships should definitely be ABLE to ram, because it’s historically accurate and boarding should be part of the game.  Perhaps you mean ram damage, which I like to do away with as well because it makes less sense and can be too powerful.

    If this is a house rule you use with players, just make sure that you say “ships cannot do damage by ramming”, because within the context of the regular rules “can’t ram” also means “can’t board” (for the most part) which affects a lot of other things and even makes towing seem difficult.

    Reversing it so only galleys do ram damage is viable.  I think it would be reasonable to increase the point costs of galleys by 1 point as a result, but I think you could test it with regular point costs too.  You could see if players like it and make adjustments from there.

    in reply to: Game Advice #9694
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Vax: Welcome aboard!  Glad you’re back into it!

    You could try Points in play + gold for the win.  Emphasizes captures and combat.

    Assuming your friends have not played before, I would keep the build total to no more than 50 points. (30 or 40 might work better for their first game)  With teaching, rules questions, and building ships/fleets, it could take a while.

    I like sticking to nationality-based fleets, but it depends on how you build fleets.  Based on the draft style you describe, I think mixed makes more sense so people aren’t forced to choose lesser ships based on the faction of their first ship.  I also recommend allowing generic crew to use their abilities on ships of any nationality.

    Have fun!


    @daddygarand
    : I’ll have to add the objective-based points system to the Game Ideas page if something like that isn’t already there.  Thanks for mentioning my videos.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #9686
    Ben
    Keymaster

    For those of you that enjoy playing deathmatches, the Defence of St. Helens scenario is a good one.

    The previous post in this thread was a preview for a game I completed in September 2019: 6×150

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2019 #9670
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Love the photography even more on this one, great thumbnail too!
    Neat to see the sea monster squadron again after a few years.
    4:34 Beautiful and epic!
    Interesting to see the rise of the Pirates… looks like the English could do some megalaunches if they really want to go after the French.
    For a moment in that picture where the English are sailing past the Guichuan, I thought an English-Cursed alliance could be in the making. XD That pair could definitely do some damage against the Spanish.
    Great report as usual!!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #9668
    Ben
    Keymaster

    My question concerns using the unreleased Fort St. Phillip (in a draft of Revolution) in conjunction with native canoes.  (now that I think about it, El Puerto Blanco has the same ability)

    Fort St. Phillip
    4 gold
    3S-3S-3S-3L-3L-3L
    A ship docked here may use its action to look at one face-down cargo on each island.

    Do all of the canoes sacrifice their action at once in order to use the ability regardless of how many are docked there?  Or does it only require one canoe?  Do they all have to be docked there at once?  If it only requires one, can the other canoes be given their (same) actions normally?  If 5 canoes are docked at the fort, can you use the ability 5 times?

    (sorry if these questions are all basically the same idea)

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #9666
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Apologies for the errors in the Master Spreadsheet.  I just uploaded a new .xlsx file to the homepage with the following corrections: Duex-Deux, The Red Skull instead of The Cursed, Alquimista speed from L to S+L, added Fort Brompton’s cannons, changed CC #123 from “Specialist” to Cannoneer.

    The shared spreadsheet is always corrected first so that has the most up to date corrections.  If you see any mistakes, please let me know.  (even tiny stuff like an extra space between words)

    in reply to: Miniature Trading on the Internet Archive #9663
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Fort Brompton review.  Captain Nemo is online.  XD  Also fun to see the old menu format again.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #9659
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @DaddyGarand: Feel free to post in the Game Ideas thread!

Viewing 30 posts - 1,381 through 1,410 (of 2,325 total)