Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 841 through 870 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #13307
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can Windcatcher be copied to a 10 master to allow it the 180 rotation?

    The Code says: “-If part of a keyword refers to a specific ship type, such as catamaran or submarine, that part can be used only by ships of that ship type. Copying a keyword does not change a ship’s type.”  Windcatcher starts with “when a ship with this keyword”….

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #13306
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Inspired by Tilorfire27’s video…

    31 point Hai Peng combo: Captain Jack Sparrow (common version), Jonah, Anamaria, LE Griffin, helmsman.  S+L+S+L+S speed.  Probably coming to a UPS fleet near you someday.   XD

     

    Trying to think of the fastest 10 master.  Even including Zhanfu is an option doesn’t really help since she can’t crew combo like other factions.

    Delusion + DJC Davy Jones (copying Hai Peng’s +L captain bonus), captain, helmsman, Cavendish, LE Griffin gets her to L+S+L+S, which is only S slower than the Hai Peng’s potential max.  Only 26 points worth of crew so there’s additional opportunity for maxing out the setup overall – maybe OE Fantasma for Sac Captain, or go wild with Nemo/etc….

    Shui Xian can do this with Brother Virgil, but since she’s only 25 points you have to add Robinson to make it work.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #13304
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I think Corodum could be simplified in the wording.  Something like “For every turn this ship is not docked at your home island, add 1 gold to the value of this treasure to maximum of +5” to eliminate some of the redundant verbiage.  You also don’t need the word “but” at the beginning of any sentences.

    I assume Turkish Delight has a minimum value of 0 and cannot be negative?  I don’t think my fleets would ever get much value out of it heh, but not bad for a swarm fleet with minimal crew.

    All three look fair and playable!

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13299
    Ben
    Keymaster

    (spoiler alert) I like how the strategy makes sense – that the Pirates would wait until the opportune moment to strike, and that the Spanish and French might be able to make amends seeing a common foe.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13295
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Nice action.  The pileup in that fog bank reminds me of my current CG4 turn.

    Someday (likely for me in CG4) there will be a “customsgeddon” where there are far more customs in play than Wizkids ships, and nobody watching will have any idea what’s going on because they haven’t heard of any ships mentioned in a battle report.  XD  I like the 4 master with the Frontier masts, neat look.

    Maybe I’m biased since they’re winning, but I think I’m rooting for Spain but still happy for the French for not being passive savers to the end.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #13287
    Ben
    Keymaster

    HUGE thank you’s to Tilorfire27 (discord username) for his online database, and to jetmoto-1996 for his Full Catalog he so graciously shared and is allowing me to put on the site!  I have put links to both databases (which include pictures of the game pieces) on both my homepage and the Information and Stats page which is linked from the main menu.

    in reply to: The Nostalgia Thread #13276
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Found my childhood collection the other way while organizing

    Nice!  The video link isn’t working for me – looks like it’s on a manage/edit setting rather than a shareable URL.

    in reply to: A 2020 Pirates Initiative? #13273
    Ben
    Keymaster

    My wife is sewing/quilting a playmat for me complete with non-skid backing. I plan on teaching her the game once that is finished.

    Did it happen?

    I would love to buy another booster box! There’s something so cathartic about cracking 36 packs! I am also considering buying a plunder pack- I currently have no 10 masters,

    Did you buy both?

     

    For me this year, I’d like to 3D print one of my custom ships and apply a decal to it that has custom artwork on it that I designed.

    How about you?

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13271
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Really interesting French attack on The Devil’s Maw.

    I’m interested in that Acorazado setup with Blanco.

    in reply to: Fallen Heroes Thread #13268
    Ben
    Keymaster

    RIP to the first Inquisition ship both that I owned and that The Inquisitor did. I know I had a second one but pretty sure its sails broke too years ago. Inquisition fleets will never be the same.

    At least it’s a common ship you can probably find for cheap!

    in reply to: The Nostalgia Thread #13267
    Ben
    Keymaster
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I would also like to have seen player tins which would come with packs containing everything you need to build a 40 point fleet for a specific faction.

    This is a neat idea that accomplishes the starter deck mission without giving everyone the exact same fleet to work with.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #13265
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Load this treasure face-down. You may reveal it at the beginning of one of your turns and roll a d6. On a result of 6 this ship may take it’s turn twice. On a result of 1-3 this ship may not be given any actions this turn, and it’s next turn. Once revealed this treasure cannot be removed from this ship, if this treasure is removed from play, the game ends immediately.

    This is so different that now it might be more of a negative UT than an OP one.  Now that it only affects the ship carrying it, it would probably be better to define it as “this ship may be given an extra/no actions”, since ship “turns” aren’t defined in the rules.

    Is the game supposed to end if the ship is sunk when the UT is still face down?

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #13262
    Ben
    Keymaster

    At the beginning of your turn you may roll a d6. On a result of 6, you may take two turns in a row. On a result of 1, your turn ends immediately, and you lose your next turn. This treasure cannot be removed from this ship. If this ship sinks, the game ends.

    O_O  What?!  Yikes… this is on another level.  I could easily use this in CG4 with the Arcane and auto-6’s to dominate that game even more, but this is so crazy that I’m going to draw a line and not even touch it.  O_O  (that’s saying something heh)

    Even without the combos I have available in CG4 to exploit this, in normal games it could still spell a lot of trouble.  It’s generally best to not have the outcome of a game decided by one d6 roll… strategy should trump luck.  The last part is interesting – if you know you’re in the lead, just send this ship to the depths!

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13256
    Ben
    Keymaster

    That Spanish Eternal fleet could be interesting if it changes how an adversary fights.  An opponent will want to strip those ships of crew (oarsmen) or need extra cancelling help to deal with them.  As long as those Spanish ships have plenty of support, it could be a real pain to deal with.

    in reply to: Game Ideas #13253
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Derrick Derksen: Wow that sounds awesome!  Glad it went well.

    The good – The game types are challenging and require a lot of planning and strategy to win.

    This sounds great and right up my alley.  I hope to try them sometime!  😀  Thanks again for sharing.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #13252
    Ben
    Keymaster

    stuff will eventually get to that level.

    Good good, let the broken flow through you.  XD

    Interesting UT’s, I like some of these.  They might be ready for an “exploit”….

    The Kaukau: At the beginning of your turn, roll a d6. The result is the number of turns this ship may use the Seafloor Traveler keyword.

    Echoing what Woelf said, since you can’t roll a 0, this is basically a permanent effect as-is.  Even if you rolled at the beginning of every turn, it wouldn’t matter what you got.

    in reply to: Game Ideas #13249
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Quite interesting.  Why can you scuttle the derelict normally if that is the win condition?  Any method of sinking it could cause a draw.

    King of the Hill sounds even cooler to me.  I like it!  A variant could be the first player to capture the fort using some boarding over land metric (such as the fort has a boarding score of 8).

    I like how both would probably lead to a lot of chaotic fighting over the central theme and objective.

     

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #13248
    Ben
    Keymaster

     I feel like Nordic Raiders is the rarer of the two… but message in a bottle has better pieces?

    Not sure which one is rarer.  Both have some very unique game pieces.  USS Mercury is one of the best submarines in the game, and the combos available for the Slipstream are undoubtedly amazing (some combos probably still out there that may not have been tried in games yet).  Abandoned Crew is more fun than Odin’s Revenge.

    I get a little obsessed with the Serpent’s Fang – she’s such a favorite of mine that I overrate her lol.

    in reply to: Contacting NECA/Wizkids #13247
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If they were only licensing it from someone it’s far enough out at this point that they may not have the legal rights anymore.

    Hmmm.  I’m not even sure what to think anymore.

    If they do fully own the license, it’s been sitting long enough that it would take a massively increased general interest in pirate things for them to dig that treasure back up.   A new Pirates of the Caribbean movie (assuming it still happens, and is good) might give some push in that direction, but it would probably still take more than that.

    Based on how mum they were with DMTNT in 2017, I don’t think they’ll be doing anything.  Kind of frustrating that the pirate craze came and went for a lot of folks in the 2000’s.  I’m more an Age of Sail/naval warfare enthusiast than just pirate stuff so my interest doesn’t wane with pop culture trends.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13246
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Some interesting developments for sure.  It would be neat to see a 3 way battle with Pirates vs. French vs. Spanish.  The French do actually have a lot of firepower in play, they just haven’t fought as much as the other two so far.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13241
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Yes….. did it seem like I implied otherwise?

    I think you said “at the end of the current resource round”, which for a second made me think it meant the current round overall.

    in reply to: The Videos Thread #13230
    Ben
    Keymaster

    So which custom ships do you like better? The wooden variety from Cloud of Craft? Or the 3D printed versions offered by Vulkan?

    3D printed materials are just more durable than thin wood, so they’ll work better for gameplay.  Plus the full art is nice, though I suppose a decal/colored art solution for wood paste might be feasible.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #13229
    Ben
    Keymaster

    This may be the wrong place to ask, but is there a thread for custom game rules?

    Game Ideas is the place!

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13228
    Ben
    Keymaster

    No reason for the French to be confused – the victory conditions are quite clear. If they don’t feel they can win a war with the Pirates and/or Spanish, they need to launch to make up for that deficit.

    The Blood Islands sinking (at the end of 11 turns right, not this current round?) reminds me of Water World a little and a new question for both – how to treat Titans that are touching ONLY an island that is supposed to sink. Do they sink with the island, or float? XD
    I would want them to float if any part of them touched water.

    I just realized you posted Report 10 exactly one year after your first posted the intro thread on PwB.

    Definitely some parallels to other games here. The Spanish being a little disorganized reminds me of them towards the end of CG1, with the Pirates their likely foe here instead of the English.  Spanish should eliminate the Americans, which happened in CG1.  Will be interesting to see if a classic rivalry is soon renewed….

    Ben
    Keymaster

    There are divots on the sides, bisecting the magnets, that mark the movement/range distance.

    Makes sense now, thanks for the picture!  And nice quilt!  😀

    in reply to: Contacting NECA/Wizkids #13213
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Huh? I thought they had the rights, or had part of the rights.

    As far as I’ve ever understood, they still do.  Who knows who actually sent that latest message to me.

    in reply to: Contacting NECA/Wizkids #13208
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Not sure what to make of this.

    NECA response May 2021

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #13206
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I’m not sure if this is better or worse than the previous version, but this is closer to what the source does.

    Definitely less OP than the original.  And therefore, slightly less likely to get yanked into CG4.  XD

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #13200
    Ben
    Keymaster

    No, I didn’t realized the in game iteration of the Dauntless was a 5 master, I remember the ship having 4 masts in the movie, but I could have been mistaken.  If the in game Dauntless is a 5 master, then my version would also be a 5 master.

    Technically in the movie the Dauntless has 3 masts, but for the game Wizkids made it a 5 master.

Viewing 30 posts - 841 through 870 (of 2,325 total)