Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 811 through 840 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Battle Reports #13651
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The latest VASSAL Campaign Game 4 battle report is finally here!  https://pirateswithben.com/the-biggest-game-of-all-time-the-reign-of-terror-has-begun/

    Ben
    Keymaster

    Basically anytime a ship is about to be rammed the opponent may roll 1 d6. If the die roll is higher than the number of masts their ship starts with (e.g. a 2 master must roll higher than a 2) the ship receives no ram damage and the ramming ship is not pinned but both ships remain touching.

    It will definitely make smaller ships better, but I feel like it’s just an extra d6 roll (on top of the regular ones associated with ramming, boarding, etc) to say “no ram damage” 83% of the time (at least for 1 masters).

    Ben
    Keymaster

    I suspect it’s a game balance issue, it gives the smaller ships a slight chance against the bigger ones, especially in swarm fleets.

    But it works against smaller ships more so than against big ones.  Ram damage is one of the biggest reasons small ships aren’t always viable – one ram can dismast a 1 master.  Eliminate that, and various crappy 1 masters become more viable. (especially Turtle Ships)

    Pinning makes a little bit of thematic sense, since ships of the time couldn’t really move sideways.

    I agree that it makes thematic sense especially regarding rigging/spars/ropes issues, but I think it would be worth doing away with to make boarding more appealing.  It’s partly to offset the no ram damage rule, which makes boarding less appealing in a way since ramming is less appealing.  If there’s less incentive to ram, there will be less boarding… unless other things make boarding MORE appealing than usual.

    Is this for every form of boarding roll bonus? Or just for the ‘”regular” this ship gets +1 to her boarding rolls.

    Only the regular bonuses.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #13588
    Ben
    Keymaster

    From this post last year:   (emphasis added in both quotes)

    If you had an extra/second action available you could use that to attempt to get unstuck on the same turn you were tangled, or you could use your normal first action to make the attempt and then use the extra/second action to do whatever you want with it.

    That makes perfect sense to me, and seems to be the way it should work.

    If a game piece is tangled, you can use its action for the turn to try to free it. Roll a d6 and add the current number of masts or segments on the tangled game piece to the result. If the result is morethan 6, the game piece is untangled. Orient it in any direction, facing away from the Sargasso Sea and touching any edge of the Sargasso Sea. It can be given a move action to move normally next turn.

    This means if you free your ship with your first action, you can’t use a second action to move away.  Which I think proves how horribly written the sargasso sea rules are.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #13587
    Ben
    Keymaster

    -In certain rare situations it is possible for a ship to occupy the exact same position as an iceberg. When this occurs, the ship loses one mast as normal. If the ship moves first it must move entirely off of the iceberg if possible; if the iceberg moves first, the ship remains in place and does not move with the iceberg. In either case, the ship will not take additional damage from that iceberg until they leave contact completely and then move back into contact.

    What “rare situations” other than the Lost UT could make this occur?

    in reply to: The Videos Thread #13585
    Ben
    Keymaster

    One of my favorite ideas I’ve had for this game:

    in reply to: Battle Reports #13584
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Just finished the reports from my trip to Vegas and LA! I played with Captain Randy plus Xerecs and his brothers!  😀

    Ben
    Keymaster

    I typically play 3 player games (when not in campaign mode), and determine player order a couple of ways. All players roll dice and highest goes first, with play continuing to the left.

    I think that’s the best way to do it.  Once in a while you have the issue of whoever goes first gets attacked (since the starting player can’t shoot at anyone docked at their home islands), but I think it might be too confusing or variable to let the highest-rolling player CHOOSE where they go in the turn order (such as choosing to go second, or 3rd out of 5 players, etc).

    Not long ago I was in favor of having the player order determined by all the initiative rolls, with the second-highest roll going second and so on.  However, I think continuing to the left from the first player will have win out, especially seeing that 77% of respondents think that way.

    Ben
    Keymaster

    Boarding in general should/could be overhauled.

    I definitely want any future rules to have the house rule that the winner gets to choose whether to eliminate crew or steal treasure, and choose which treasure gets stolen.  However, I’m also in favor of doing away with ram damage, which might make boarding even less likely to happen.  A pretty drastic measure would be to have Hoard/Massacre be the default results – make it all treasure/crew, rather than just 1.  That could apply to the loser of the boarding party too.

    Maybe doing away with pinning could make boarding more viable as well.

    Personally I think S-Board should be left alone as an ability.  The only thing I would do there is make it cheap, like 2-3 points instead of 4-5.

    Thanks for the feedback!

    Ben
    Keymaster

    From reading this, it seems I’ve been playing gold bonus ships and crew wrong. When a ship unloads treasure and has a bonus, I get a new coin to represent that bonus and place it on the home island.

    For example: La Santa Isabel docks at home and unloads 3 coins. The gold bonus kicks in, giving one of them a +2 to value. I go and get a spare 2 coin from outside the game and add it to the home island.

    I keep track of bonus coins by placing them face-up, since I never place normal gold face-up during games.

    That’s what I remember doing in T1/T2 and completely fine.  The Pirate Code details the options on page 15.

    in reply to: Looking for Opinions and Discussion on Rules/etc. #13568
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I do believe that fixing, or clarifying rulings would be slightly more important, especially where Creatures are concerned.

    What fixes or clarifications would you make there?

    Furthermore, players don’t input the gold, the “house” does. We agree upon a number of coins per island, and if and how many random UT’s we use.

    During T1 and T2, did you enjoy having some control over your half of the gold contribution?

    I’ve literally never used it, and it makes the game go too quickly as well as putting an emphasis on quick capacious gold ships.

    We used it in the VASSAL tournaments, but I definitely get your points.  I don’t think I’ve played enough games with totally randomized gold to get a good feel for how the strategy differs.  I did enjoy a lot of the strategic elements of the VASSAL tournaments, partly because I like the math side of it and how chesslike it became at times.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2021 #13564
    Ben
    Keymaster

    We are back! Report 5 is now up!

    Exciting stuff, glad to know that things are progressing!  😉

    Ben
    Keymaster

    On the other hand, there are things like suicide fleets designed specifically to end the game as quickly as possible, with just enough of an advantage to claim the win, or simply to irritate other players who had longer-term plans.

    Have you seen fleets like that be effective at winning games?  Unless there are always icebergs around, it seems like it would be tough to suicide at the right time after getting enough gold.

    I love your idea about fixing the gold bonus abilities.

    Connecting that back to the above issue, unloading treasure to your home island could be made entirely optional as long as other endgame triggers are used.   The gold on ships can counts the same as gold at home or in forts, ships could carry it around as long as they wanted.

    Do you think that only one player being able to give future move actions would be the optimal endgame trigger if gold on ships counted towards victory?  I’m wondering about how to tie that in to the points in play house rule.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #13394
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @georgee: Great story, thanks for sharing!

    Maybe see if anyone still does any gaming with it too, though I am completely out of the loop on how I would even go about that.

    The VASSAL module is a way to play Pirates CSG virtually.

    If you’re looking for physical games in your local area, the Player Locator map might help.  🙂  Welcome aboard!

    in reply to: The Videos Thread #13389
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Here is the first of a bunch of random short videos from my trip to Las Vegas and Los Angeles.  🙂

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2021 #13364
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can’t wait to see this game in person in a few days!  😀

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2021 #13361
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Hyped that the game has begun!  😀

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #13359
    Ben
    Keymaster

    From my game with Captain Randy and Curren in Las Vegas today:

    Can you target a ship that cannot be shot at while docked with Neptune’s Trident?

    Can you finish taking treasures from an island that the Whirlpool UT is found on?

    Can turtles be moved under the hull of a 10 master to essentially stop it when it has to move and immediately hits a turtle?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #13356
    Ben
    Keymaster

    It’s probably not even remotely worth the effort/cost required to do it, but it is possible.

    And then you get the Eye of Maru aboard (from RtSS) for a 16L freak cannon?  XD

    in reply to: All Pirates CSG Surveys #13352
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Feel free to take any of the surveys you haven’t already!

    in reply to: Miniature Trading on the Internet Archive #13351
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: The Nostalgia Thread #13350
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Today is June 27th 2021.  10 years ago today I joined Miniature Trading!  Although the site shut down on July 1st 2019, it was the hub of Pirates CSG on the internet for about the full 11 years since Wizkids shut down on November 10th 2008.

    I made a youtube video of MT in its final days: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yNUolUn2s3w

    A7XfanBen June 2019 Miniature Trading profile card

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2021 #13347
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Privateer pieces are not eliminated if they dock at an island that shares a port and a fort.

    Is that only possible/relevant at Voya Nui?

    Is it ever confusing switching back and forth between CoEC and CG4 due to the rules differences?  Though I suppose the digital vs. physical aspect might make it easier.  Maybe some aspects of CoEC could be adapted into CG4, though I’d prefer unanimous agreement among all 3 of us for that to happen.

    I like the CTO-esque twist with the map.  Should make for some fun exploration moments!

    I’m excited to see this in person in a few weeks, and maybe observe a turn!

    Do you mind revealing who controls each faction?  I need to know who to bribe…. 😉

    in reply to: Important Reading #13343
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Just updated my “legal post” with a bunch of good links at the top.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13332
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I controlled the Spanish and the Cursed.

    Congrats and huzzah!

    However, he’s controlling them again for this year and has literally been plotting and strategizing since they were eliminated.

    Nice, hopefully I’ll see them in action before too long.

    It’ll be weird starting CG5 for when Cg4 eventually ends.

    That might be an if….

    …something has only barely begun…. O_O

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13326
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Absolutely staggering.  O_O  That is amazing that only THIS turn (that I’m currently working on) in CG4 will beat either of those fleets for ship and point counts (with the Pirates of course).  Insane that you had two fleets in one game that were BOTH bigger than ANY previous fleets ever seen, by both ship (previous high 131 by Pirates in CTO, or 148 by CG4 Pirates last round) and point count (previous high 2533 by CG4 Pirates, though it was likely higher than these CoEC 2020 Pirates by the end of the last round).

    I have updated the All Time Records post.  You three now have the second biggest game ever, in addition to the two biggest fleets ever seen!  Of course, CG4 and my Pirates in that game are poised to take over both of those records in a matter of days…. though I’m not sure if CG4 will top CTO for biggest game ever this round.

    Who controlled each of the 6 factions?  Would be great to know for updating our all time data spreadsheet.

    in reply to: Arrrr!!! What be ye favorite Sea Monster? #13323
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Good questions… for gameplay, tough to pick between Behemoth, Raninoidea, and Namazu.

    For looks: Ophidious

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13317
    Ben
    Keymaster

    How the hell did Spain get their 1000 gold coin from the Branwen??!

    I won’t be too happy with the Spanish if the Pirates narrowly beat them in ship count at the end partly as a result of this truce… all very interesting nonetheless.  And maybe the Spanish didn’t know at the time that the end was near….

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13313
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I said whoa out loud like 3 times when I saw that Branwen move.  THAT’S THE KINDA PLAY I’M TALKING ABOUT!! XD  😀

    I love how the Spanish protected El Acorazado.

    Really impressed by that random group of Furia, Antamasia, and Clear Wind.  They did a great job.

    17:19 is a picture of the year candidate IMO.  Especially at full screen.  Not only showing the forest of masts, but colorful, sunlight, and lots of interesting stuff to look at.

    GREAT use of Periscope!!  Impressive how it can go through the double defenses like that.

    Have you considered having fire stuff only work with the 2 hits/mast rule?  Like we’re doing in CG4, where fire stuff doesn’t bypass that rule like it normally does.

    in reply to: Century of Economy 2020 #13311
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Glad the Spanish are trying hard to preserve the Santisima Trinidad.

    That Baochuan town capture was epic to me, nice appearance all of a sudden and coup by the Pirates.

    Wow the Zeus is basically running over the VW and Divine Wind!

Viewing 30 posts - 811 through 840 (of 2,325 total)