Thanks Woelf, had an idea about getting Explosives on the Skin Flayer. Should be fun to try it out…..

What would happen if you got Explosives onto a switchblade? If it hits more than one ship with it’s blades and rams another ship, which ship can Explosives be applied to? Could it be applied to all of the affected ships, or just to one of them? If just to one of them, which one?

On a similar tangent, would an Eternal ship that used Explosives…[Read more]

Has playing the fleets started yet?

Sadly no, not yet. However I do have everything set-up on VASSAL, I just need some time to run the fleets and record it.

“Infin8Ouroboros said”

To be clear, a “ghostly” ghost ship only ignores terrain while physically in motion, not during the entire move action(and associated free actions), correct?

This has generated some rules discussion on Discord, including whether a Ghostly Ship can shoot from within a terrain (such as an iceberg or Fog) while said ship is…[Read more]

Does towing an enemy derelict count as “capturing” that ship, for the purposes of meeting the requirements of the Ransom keyword?

old_man tells me he has sold his entire Pirates CSG collection with the exception of his custom made Vieil Homme.

That…… is very sad to hear. First Holo, now old_man. 🙁

What other questionable ones are out there that need it, besides the Runes and the Cross?

Has this already been covered with the orange text?

“The Code, Nemo’s Plans”

If a UT applies to, modifies, or is triggered by a specific action or situation (other than exploring the wild island) it may be used once, each time that action or situation occurs.

Does this mean that if Cross of Coronado (or a similar treasure) were on the same ship as the Plans, you could use the Cross every time…[Read more]

Once each time this ship is given an action, you can roll 2d6 any time you would roll a d6. Choose the result you want to use.

Can this ability be applied to extra action, SAT, or other such die-rolling ability? The Code is not clear.

“Code entry for Intermediario”

Placing the treasure is treated as if the target ship loaded it directly from the island. If the target ship does not have at least once cargo space open or some other ability would prevent it from loading the treasure, it cannot be targeted by this ability.

I assume that the “cannot load treasure” part of the…[Read more]

Suppose that Jonah is on the same ship as Papa Doc. Would Jonah’s ability force any possessed crew to take up cargo space, or would the possessed crew not take up cargo space, per the Code entry?

For reference,

Ability of Jonah:
“Always place this crew face up; it cannot be eliminated unless its ship sinks. Crew placed on this ship cost no…[Read more]

Suppose you decide to cancel a friendly Submarine to the surface. At the end of your turn what happens to the submarine? Does it return to a submerged status or does it remain on the surface?

deadline tonight

Deadline is tomorrow night, when the 1st becomes the 2nd, so you’ve still got some time.

If I choose to use the ability of the English Native canoes (below), would I have to apply it to all of them in the set, or however many I chose, since all of the canoes are technically being given a move action.

Give this ship a move action but do not move her. Instead, roll a d6. On a result of 5 or 6, you may repair one mast on ships within S…

[Read more]

I don’t want to reveal the whole ability yet, but you’re close with that first guess. I’ll probably redo bits of the main ability before the reveal. However, this might be some time from now, as the UT involved is part of the SR set for my next set.

You’ll need to edit that fleet Ben, Castro is part of the Dread Fleet and cannot be used.

You may not use an alternate version of any crew or ship that has been “ensnared” by Davy Jones, and you may not use any of the ensnared ships or crew.

Looks interesting though, taking advantage of the number of cancelers available to you.

That would depend entirely on what else the UT did.

Something that stayed face-up on an island once revealed.