Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1,981 through 2,010 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3451
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Luz de Vida
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Spanish
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 22
    Number of Masts: 3
    Cargo Space: 4
    Base Move: L
    Cannons: 2S-4L-2S
    Ability: All ships within S of this ship get -1 to their cannon rolls.
    Link: Alonso Guños

    Flavor text: The “Light of Life” is so inspiring that hardened cannoneers lay down their weapons to stare in amazement at her adornments and perfection.

    I know this is kind of a “dumb” ability to put on a custom. I’m thinking that if you sandwiched it between enemy gunships it would be sunk in short order. Willing to change it to something like 1 enemy ship within S, or maybe the nearest ship regardless of allegiance.

    Alonso Guños
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Spanish
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 6
    Ability: Captain. Island treasure trading. [After looking at treasure on a wild island, you may trade any one treasure from that island for a random treasure on any other wild island. This ship must load the traded treasure.] Ship treasure trading. [Once per turn, if this ship carries treasure and is within S of an enemy ship, you may randomly trade one treasure with that ship.]
    Link: Luz de Vida

    Flavor text: Alonso is a sailor’s sailor. Having simply risen through the ranks from age 18 to 30, he knows what every position on the ship feels like. This gives him an edge in his operations, which are mostly related to commerce.

    Historical Custom of the Day #387

    Isaac Smith
    English
    Crew
    5 points
    Ability: Captain. Explorer. This ship gets +1 to her boarding rolls against French ships.
    Link: HMS Weazel, HMS Perseverance, James Cook

    That boarding bonus isn’t really even worth a full point, but Captain+Explorer for 4 is just one of those combos that shouldn’t really exist in my opinion. (I may also make him worse since he’s still kinda “gamey” in a way, but at least he’s not part of a better gold running faction.)

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: 2019 State of the Pirates Community Address #3437
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I hadn’t heard about the MT crisis until like last week. It’s sad to hear :/ There’s definitely plenty of Pirates fans out there but as you said the MT scare seems to have scattered people.

    Yeah, I’ve directed people from there to here with a sticky thread at MT along with updates on just about all the Pirates sites I know of, but between the ubiquity of facebook and MT still up, the migration is somewhat slow and random.  I’ve just done what I can and people can decide what they want to do.

    in reply to: A game in every pack! #3435
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Has anyone actually played a game with the contents of a single pack?

    I can’t remember exactly how my first “games” went down back in 2005, but it’s possible that I played out of just one pack because that’s what the Start Here rules suggest.  However, my first purchase was 2 packs of SM, so it’s likely I learned with both of them.

    I agree that it’s a cool feature of the game/distribution, but if the game was relaunched I would probably want at least 4 ships per pack to have a much better chance of balancing point costs/factions/etc.  Or a starter pack/box with either 8 or 10 ships total.

    Thanks for starting a new thread topic too.  The forum could use more topics started by someone other than me.  XD

    in reply to: The Favorites Thread #3429
    Ben
    Keymaster

    France always seemed like the best all-around nation to me and in any strategy game like this I like to go for versatility.

    The Pirates are the best, but you can make a solid case for the French in 2nd place.  I like their versatility as well, in addition to their underrated named crew selection (for example: 2 sac captains; England and Spain combined have 0) and their aesthetic appeal.

    Side note but I have never ever built a 40 point Cursed fleet that seemed good, and I have plenty of Cursed ships/crew

    They are easily the worst faction of the Big 6, and best used in more casual games at higher build totals (80+, etc).  To make them remotely competitive at 40 points you have to limit yourself to a tiny handful of game pieces: Grinder, Skwaluck (wrong spelling) from RtSS, and sac captain Fantasma from OE.

    in reply to: 2019 State of the Pirates Community Address #3428
    Ben
    Keymaster

    How do you feel about the number of packs floating around? Mass produced sets like OE are still easy to find, but obviously the supply of even those is not infinite.

    It feels like a very long and very slow decline into reasonable pack scarcity.  With people still getting into the game or coming back to it, it seems that packs are still being opened at a decent rate.  However, the quantity of online retailers show that it will be many years before serious scarcity sets in.  Perhaps in the long-term future every single set will average more than the original MSRP of $3.99 per pack.

    Thanks for asking; how do you feel about it?

    in reply to: The scale of Pirates CSG is PERFECT!! #3427
    Ben
    Keymaster

    not really sure if they should be called “pocket models”. Sounds like a good way to break a mast!

    Indeed!  I like that idea more for action figures or something that is all one piece, that doesn’t get disassembled.  The cards would fit nicely in a pocket, but I wouldn’t want to risk ships in there….

    Ben
    Keymaster

    I think they are pretty sturdy for what they are. Plus this is probably the most economical option.

    Agreed.  In the Podcast with James Ernest, he talked about how expensive it was to make the ships, which corroborates what people reported in the past with the “styrene format being cost-prohibitive to produce”.

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #3420
    Ben
    Keymaster

    However, I joined up just to find more people who loved the originals as much as I did.

    Hello fellow pirate!  That’s what this site is for – the love of Pirates CSG!  😀  Feel free to jump into the other topics on the game to provide your insight and opinion.

    in reply to: The Favorites Thread #3419
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Jack: Yay for the French!  🙂  They are really good.  It seems like a lot of people in the current Pirates CSG community have some disdain for the French, so even though the English are my favorite I find myself sticking up for the underrated French more than I should have to.

    The Miniature Reviews section at MT has been somewhat dormant for some years now.  I reinvigorated it a little with the Miniature Review Contest, but then I ran one of those where nobody submitted an entry by the deadline.  🙁

    Not sure how you got the SM version of Ghostly Encounter in a pack, since it’s the ghost version unlike the rare from CC.

    I like your list.  🙂  Guy LaPlante is interesting, and he did get a better version eventually.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3405
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Queen’s Ghost
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: French
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 12
    Number of Masts: 2
    Cargo Space: 3
    Base Move: S+L
    Cannons: 3L-2S
    Ability: Schooner. Ghost Ship. This ship may dock at an enemy home island and take as much treasure as she can carry. If able, she must leave on your next turn. This ship can only shoot when she carries treasure.

    Flavor text: This incredible but strange vessel is adept at getting into trouble, and then getting out of it. She flits about, then strikes with agility. Although her cannons are excellent, they are normally only employed when she has made off with ill-gotten loot.

    Historical Custom of the Day #386

    Charles Saunders
    English
    Crew
    8 points
    Ability: Captain. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against French and Spanish ships. This ship gets +1 cargo spaces. This crew does not take up cargo space.
    Link: HMS Gloucester, HMS Plymouth, HMS Dunkirk, HMS Yarmouth, HMS Tiger

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3397
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I don’t see it as pat of his abilities, so I’m assuming he doesn’t have Ex-Pat?

    Nope, he does his own thing but isn’t really for hire.

    Mink
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: American
    Rarity: R
    Point Value: 3
    Number of Masts: 1
    Cargo Space: 1
    Base Move: S+S
    Cannons: 4S
    Ability: None.

    Flavor text: With a just 10 full-time sailors, the Mink is normally used as a tug or temporary holding station until the cargo in question can be transferred to a more important ship.

    Hesitant to go below some of the cheapest factional thresholds, but too late I suppose….

    Historical Custom of the Day #385

    Richard Spry
    English
    Crew
    3 points
    Ability: This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against forts within S of her. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls when she’s within S of her home island.

    I can’t give all the admirals the AA/SAT/EA ability. I also have made a lot of English named captains lately, so in cases like this where there’s not a lot of bio info, I’ll sometimes just do the additional abilities without the “obligatory” ones that just increase the cost.

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3389
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Great Robbery
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Barbary Corsair
    Rarity: R
    Point Value: 17
    Number of Masts: 4
    Cargo Space: 5
    Base Move: S+L
    Cannons: 3L-4S-4L-5L
    Ability: Galley. This ship may dock at an enemy home island and take as much treasure as she can carry. If able, she must leave on your next turn.
    Link: Zagras of Yammas

    Flavor text: The “great” Zagras comes aboard the Great Robbery to perform his captain duties on about half of the ship’s voyages. Although the crew occasionally grumble that he acts as though he is above them, they almost always come home from his trips with double the profits.

    Zagras of Yammas
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Barbary Corsair/Mercenary
    Rarity: U
    Point Value: 10
    Ability: EA. [Extra Action: Once per turn, roll a d6. On a 5-6, this ship may be given an extra action.] Hoard.
    Link: Great Robbery

    Flavor text: An accomplished thief turned occasional Mercenary warlord, Zagras “of Yammas” is one of the leading Barbary Corsairs. That is, when he puts on his Corsair attire and actually sails in the Mediterranean. Half the time he is off on undisclosed voyages, rumored to be in the South China Sea and South Pacific.

    Historical Custom of the Day #384

    Shirley
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: English
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 7
    Number of Masts: 2
    Cargo Space: 3
    Base Move: S+L
    Cannons: 3S-3S
    Ability: This ship’s linked crew can use his abilities on this ship regardless of point costs.
    Link: John Rous

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    Ben
    Keymaster

    It is here! Thanks for the questions!

    in reply to: The Podcast Thread #3387
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Pirates CSG Podcast #41: GAME DESIGNER JAMES ERNEST!!!!

    Check out this very special episode of the Pirates CSG Podcast with original game designer James Ernest!

    Listen to it on ShoutEngine: http://shoutengine.com/PiratesCSGPodcast/pirates-csg-podcast-41-game-designer-james-ernest-74495

    James Ernest is one of the original game designers for Pirates CSG. He has his own Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Ernest
    Website: https://cheapass.com/
    Bio: https://cheapass.com/about-james-ernest/
    Check out his free pirate game called Cagway Bay! https://cheapass.com/free-games/cagway-bay/
    Rules: https://cheapass.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Cagway-Bay-Rules.pdf

    His YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyVH4H2qhHwmuPFQ5HMPgqw
    Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/cheapassgames/
    Twitter: https://twitter.com/Cheapassjames
    At BoardGameGeek: https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgamedesigner/61/james-ernest

    Today we talk about Pirates CSG and his own piratey projects! Here is the list of questions submitted at Pirates with Ben: https://pirateswithben.com/forums/topic/submit-your-questions-for-pirates-csg-game-designer-james-ernest/#post-3363

    Question of the Day: Have you played Cagway Bay? What do you think of it?

     

    Take the podcast survey! https://goo.gl/forms/CsnwVmi3qhtqik323

    Feel free to rate and review the podcast on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060

    Pirates packs on eBay: https://goo.gl/MfHBQJ

    Sign the Petition! https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/bring-back-pirates-of-the-cursed-seas

    Join the Forum at Pirates with Ben! https://pirateswithben.com/forums/forum/pirates-csg/

    The following should eventually be updated from ShoutEngine so they will be available when they get the podcast.
    iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060
    Overcast: https://overcast.fm/itunes1258016060/pirates-csg-podcast
    Google Play Music: https://play.google.com/music/m/Imxc6vplvkqlmagcvkxvi2er2wu?t=Pirates_CSG_Podcast
    Blubrry: https://www.blubrry.com/piratescsgpodcast/
    Stitcher: https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/a7xfanben/pirates-csg-podcast?refid=stpr

    Thanks for listening!

    -Admiral A7XfanBen

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #3380
    Ben
    Keymaster

    On Saturday I asked Wizkids and NECA on Facebook “What would it take to bring back Pirates Constructible Strategy Game?”

    They responded this morning with the same message they sent me in March 2017 when I inquired about whether or not they had the license/rights to Pirates CSG.

    Hi Ben,

    At this time I do not have nay information about the Pirates CSG/Pirate of the Spanish Main.

    Thank you,

    The WK Team

    in reply to: Rules for Thought #19 #3372
    Ben
    Keymaster

    However, I think the flotilla rules are easier to abuse, so using the derelict towing rule would make the game more balanced overall.

    I agree.  Hooking up a line and getting the towed object behind the towing ship is already easy enough.  Towing a heavy object behind a ship should definitely slow the ship down considerably.  Speed is already powerful enough in the game, so letting ships with fast base moves tow derelicts at that same speed would just make them even more of an obvious choice when building a fleet.  I think applying the derelict towing rules to flotillas would actually make for more interesting fleet builds, as the slower ships would benefit instead.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3371
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Grand Flower
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Jade Rebellion
    Rarity: R
    Point Value: 13
    Number of Masts: 6
    Cargo Space: 4
    Base Move: S+S
    Cannons: 4L-4L-5L-5L-4L-4L
    Ability: Junk. Parley. L-range cannons targeting this ship always hit. [no roll required]

    Flavor text: Although this vessel is able to use her beauty to escape some otherwise deadly encounters, the sheer amount of aesthetic appeal has made her a very inviting target for gun crews.

    Historical Custom of the Day #383

    John Rous
    English
    Crew
    10 points
    Ability: Captain. This ship gets +1 to her cannon and boarding rolls against the French. Once per turn you may give one friendly ship within S of this ship +1 to her cannon rolls.
    Link: HMS Ruby, Shirley, HMS Sutherland

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: 3 ships in an OE pack? #3368
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I still don’t think that’s happened to me, but it certainly has happened to others plenty of times unfortunately.

    Ben
    Keymaster

    Any idea how long the interview will last?

    No, and I’m not sure we’ll get to all of the questions, or at least not as in-depth as we could go with no time limit.

    Ben
    Keymaster

    Questions for James Ernest

    When and how did you get involved with the Pirates project?

    What is your collection like?

    General overview of how sets were designed and finalized.

    What sets did he work on?

    Favorite set and game piece you designed or worked on?  Least favorites?

    At the game’s apex, how many people were working on the game?

    What other designers and artists did you work with?

    Did multiple people work on the flavor text, or was one person mainly in charge of the game’s lore?

    How did Wizkids make the ships?  How were they printed and stamped?

    How did Wizkids decide on points and ship stats and in general come up with the ships?

    What thoughts/concept went behind the development of the ships and crew?

    What were the main inspirations for the different expansions?

    How did they determine what strategies were “good” for a pack?

    What, in your opinion, are the most OP ships or strategies?

    What were some of his ideas that never made it into the game?

    Does he recall any sets/plans or potential directions Wizkids had in the works? What was the direction they had planned for the game? (other than more fantasy/less historical as reported by Kelly Bonilla)

    How much did PotC affect DJC/OE/etc?

    After the Pirates of the Caribbean expansion, were there any plans to do another cross-over?

    What were some of the future ideas for special ships? (more Pokeships/etc? Or less extreme stuff)

    Favorite memories of Pirates and his experience?

    What are things he would have changed in hindsight?

    How did you get out of Pirates?

    Where did it all go wrong with Pirates?

    What do you think is the biggest reason that Pirates CSG went out of print?

    Opinion on the effect of 2008 recession and general economics on the game?

    Do you have any idea how the Shuffling the Deck card game did in sales? Is NECA wanting to do more with pirates in general?

    Do you think the game has a chance to come back in the future?

    How do you think it could come back – digital vs. physical?

    Do you happen to know exactly what patent concerns the rights to produce Pirates CSG?  Have you had experience with the patents for other games expiring and being open to anyone reproducing the game?

    If Pirates CSG came back, would you want to return to it?

    What are you doing now?

    Where can people find you online?

     

    Other: Cagway Bay similarities to Pirates, there was a Pirates event at PAX Unplugged in November 2017, Gencon festivities, great YouTube channel.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3355
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Do you house rule that Turtle ships can’t have their masts rammed off while they still have panels?

    In general yes.  In fact my Basic Rules do away with ram damage altogether.  Opal Shrine not Shine.

    Queenstorm
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: French
    Rarity: LE
    Point Value: 44
    Number of Masts: 10
    Cargo Space: 5
    Base Move: L
    Cannons: 2S-4L-3L-3L-3L-4S-4L-4L-3S-3S
    Ability: Junk. Grapple Shot. This ship can shoot at submerged ships within S of her. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against non-French/English/Spanish/American/Dutch targets. Specialist crew take up no cargo space on this ship.
    Link: Jean-Claude DuPierre

    Flavor text: Judging by her name, it is no surprise that the French have used this monstrosity for warfare only. Designed to combat all the scourges of the seven seas, the Queenstorm is equipped with both the artillery and ammunition to put an end to criminality. However, her crew are not prepared to deal with the complex international relations that their “enemies” have formed in the buildup to the grand war of the age….

    Jean-Claude DuPierre
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: French
    Rarity: LE
    Point Value: 8
    Ability: Loyal: France. Hostile: Pirate, Cursed, Barbary Corsair, Jade Rebellion, Viking, Mercenary. Captain. Broadsides Attack. This ship gets +1 to her boarding rolls.
    Link: Queenstorm

    Flavor text: With rigid discipline, Capitaine DuPierre keeps his ship ready for combat at all times during every mission. His hatred of scoundrels is becoming legendary. He can be a bit chaotic, sometimes manning a massive 42 pounder on the lower gun deck, and other times leading his men in a courageous boarding party.

    Not the best combo, but that’s not really the point. What fun will be had….

    ~~~~~

    Historical Custom of the Day #382

    John Aldred
    English
    Crew
    4 points
    Ability: Captain. Shipwright. Pirate ships get +1 to their cannon rolls against this ship.
    Link: Essex Prize

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3347
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Opal Shrine
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: R
    Point Value: 11
    Number of Masts: 1
    Cargo Space: 3
    Base Move: S+S+S
    Cannons: 4L
    Ability: Turtle Ship. Extended Range. One of this ship’s treasures is worth +1 gold when she docks at your home island.

    Flavor text: This ship’s crew is always searching for opals, but they find opportunities for long-distance potshots now and then.

    Already one of the more visible ships in THC, but not publicly revealed on a forum until now.

    Historical Custom of the Day #381

    Duke of Clarence (first version listed)
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: English
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 6
    Number of Masts: 2
    Cargo Space: 3
    Base Move: L
    Cannons: 4S-5L
    Ability: This ship gets -1 to her initial sandbar rolls.
    Link: John Hayes

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    Ben
    Keymaster

    The podcast has been scheduled for Monday 2/25 at 7pm EST!  Get your questions in this weekend!

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3335
    Ben
    Keymaster

     I also like Dories, I think it should be on more ships, and not just mercenary ships.

    That’s something that’s on my customs to do list!

    Van Damme is cool, and makes for an interesting combo on his own ship, since he won’t take up cargo space, and add one because of his link, giving the ME a total of 5 cargo to stash stolen goodies in.

    Yikes, I can’t remember if I thought of that when I made him.  I’m starting to think this is too good of a combo.

    King’s Ghost
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: English
    Rarity: LE
    Point Value: 10
    Number of Masts: 1
    Cargo Space: 2
    Base Move: L+L
    Cannons: 1L
    Ability: Eternal. This ship may use the effects of any equipment with “shot” in the name.

    Flavor text: Like the purported “ghost” of Henry VIII himself, this ship comes and goes over the years. Hundreds of witnesses have claimed to see her go down in battle, but long afterwards she’ll be seen sailing out of a port on the southern coast of England.

    Historical Custom of the Day #380

    John Hayes
    English
    Crew
    2 points
    Ability: S-Explorer.
    Link: Duke of Clarence

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Pirates: 2018 Year in Review #3334
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Sounds like a great question for James Ernest!

    It is being added to the list!

    It would be exciting to see an article be published reviewing the game in 2019. It would seem fitting since the 10 year anniversary of its cancellation just passed.

    I did that, but my opinion isn’t exactly objective at this point…. XD

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3325
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Oooh. I like the Crystal Shroud. It sounds cool, and has an interesting function, I’d probably use it on a heavyweight named crew, or what I’d consider the most important named crew on a gunship. Might be difficult in that respect, since big gunships usually get built to the point limit.

    Indeed; perhaps it would work for named crew that have multiple abilities that are so good they don’t require many other crew to be on the ship.  Such as Stern, Victor de Alva from F&S, sac captains, etc.

    Might as well put the “epic” in Epic Seas! XD

    Marvelous Escape
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: SE
    Point Value: 25
    Number of Masts: 5
    Cargo Space: 4
    Base Move: S+L
    Cannons: 4L+L-3S-3S-3S-4L+L
    Ability: Mercenary. Dories. Crew assigned to this ship don’t take up cargo space; this ship can be assigned a maximum of three crew. | If this ship is within S of an enemy ship when this ship is given a move action, she gets +S to her base move. | Once per turn when this ship is given a shoot action, one of her cannons can shoot a chain shot. Declare which cannon will shoot the chain shot before rolling the d6. If the shot hits, do not eliminate a mast; instead the target can’t move on her next turn.
    Link: Bar Van Damme

    Flavor text: Bar Van Damme’s ship, the Marvelous Escape is so named for her many raids and successful getaways. Using chain shot and studding sails to their advantage, the crew are experts at getting in and out of ports quickly.

    Bar Van Damme
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: SE
    Point Value: 9
    Ability: Captain. This ship may dock at an enemy home island and take as much treasure as she can carry. If able, she must leave on your next turn.
    Link: Marvelous Escape

    Flavor text: This swashbuckling character has a reputation unlike any other. After escaping the Tower of London and fighting off the Demon King in a swordfight, he has realized that friends will be few in his life. However, his loyal crew have assissted him in numerous heists, and he enjoys his fortunes at leisure.

    Historical Custom of the Day #379

    Henry Waterhouse
    English
    Crew
    3 points
    Ability: Cannoneer. Explorer.
    Link: HMS Reliance, George Bass

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Pirates: 2018 Year in Review #3324
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Hi Ben, do you have any specific ideas on what we can do in order to try to help to bring back the game? Besides telling my friends and signing petitions of course.

    Contacting NECA through Facebook/email/Instagram/etc.  Tell or show them your interest level in the game and how you’d love to see it in stores again.  Given the legal cesspool that prevents anyone from doing much in the way of production, they may only be swayed by obvious demand (of a serious quantity, far beyond petitioning) and straight cash.  I’ve thought about trying to buy the rights away from them, but it would likely take far more money than the entire community could come up with together.

    I know of several tabletop websites that like to do features on “retro” games that maybe we could reach out to and have them do a piece on the game?

    Sounds cool!  Feel free to list them here or contact them about it of course.  If they allow guest posting, it could allow them to save time if a Pirates fan did the writing.

    Thanks for asking and it’s a question I’ve thought about.  Outside of hiring legal help to actually get to the bottom of the patent/IP issue, it’s tough to do much that would help directly.  I also like the idea of getting some of the game’s past fans back into the community, but that hasn’t worked for me so far.  I hope the rights can simply expire at some point, but until then, I feel it’s just a case of stimulating demand in the market so they’d feel financially incentivized to actually do something about the product.

    I’m not nearly the only one with ideas though!  I’d love to hear what other people think are good ways to try and restart the game.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #3321
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I’ve been re-listening to several of the review podcasts where one of the most common complaints said about ships or keywords are their illogical point costs.

    Thanks for that!  It’s flattering to hear that anyone has gotten through some of the longer podcasts more than once.

    Perhaps a forum page should be dedicated to rule change suggestions?

    Sounds good.  I might have time to start that today.  Sometimes it just gets complicated to determine what is being talked about – rule changes vs. point cost changes vs. Pirate Code/etc changes (changes to how the original official rules are interpreted without changing the original rules).

    Also, I forgot to mention in my initial reply two others things that make me hesitant.  For one, I’ve got a lot of other big long-term Pirates CSG projects I’m already working on or would prefer to work on.  Second, between the rules of CG4, the Caribbean game, and Game Ideas, I already have a lot of alternative rules things to test out and find what I like best/etc.  I’d rather play (and have fun testing various rules/rulesets) than come up with even more rules alternatives (the World/Caribbean game rulesets was already a massive undertaking in that regard, and is still basically untested…), but finding time and players for campaign games has only gotten more difficult.  If a potential relaunch was more possible or imminent, my tone would be a bit different I think.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #3318
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Crystal Shroud
    Type: Equipment
    Rarity: R
    Point Value: 4
    Ability: Parley. When revealed, this equipment becomes linked to a named crew of your choice on this ship. If that crew would be eliminated, instead place them and this equipment on your home island.

    Flavor text: A dazzling robe that doesn’t grant the wearer invisibility, but can extract someone from sticky situations.

    Historical Custom of the Day #378

    Charles Hardy
    English
    Crew
    6 points
    Ability: Captain. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against the French. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against forts within S of her.
    Link: HMS Rye

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #3317
    Ben
    Keymaster

    So I remember back on MT there was a discussion (mentioned by Ben I believe) about formulating an “updated” pirates code based upon the the experience and opinions of the present fan base.

    What are your thoughts on creating an alternative Pirate CSG code that only seeks to balance out and address some of the key issues we routinely see?

    I like the idea of a “community ruleset” (not so much FAQ, although maybe I said something about that?), but it’s impossible to please everyone.  If all somewhat experienced players took the following surveys, it would help towards determining a consensus of sorts.

    Rules Survey: https://goo.gl/forms/dDV50a3yVQHVrNG03

    Ability Costs Survey: https://goo.gl/forms/MS4gufdXBBSRbqX43

     

    I don’t think the Pirate Code is the problem, the problem is that Wizkids NEEDED a massive FAQ to explain their rules and to even make the game playable on a reasonably complex or competitive level for fairness.  I have disagreed with a few things in the PC, but for the most part it makes a lot of sense and has helped me countless times when playing.

    It sounds like you’re talking more about a massive rules/game overhaul than just changing how a few specific things work.

    This would mean alternative point costs for ships and crew (not every piece just the most egregious pieces) as well as modifications of some keywords.

    I still feel that this opens up a can of worms and is difficult to stop.  If you make the Banshee’s Cry 10 points, maybe Bloody Jewel is suddenly the best Pirate gold runner.  Should she go up in cost too?  It might help curb some of the blatantly OP game pieces, but it would probably just make others replace them.  I’m more in favor of simply banning events, and then discussing with your opponents prior to the game whether it will be more towards competitive or casual. (so the fleets aren’t unbalanced to an extreme)

    I foresee an improvement in factions such as the Cursed where their general tournament weakness may be improved by cheaper point-costs and more realistic keywords.

    I can’t speak for Woelf of course, but him and I would both agree that the Cursed don’t need to suddenly be viable for competitive tournaments.  They just kinda stink in small games, and I’m fine with that.  It’s good to have unique factions, and the Cursed are arguably the most unique in a lot of ways.  I wouldn’t want to lose that by basically giving them steroids like some custom creators have done. 🙂 (I know I have a lot of crazy Cursed customs, but they’re mostly gimmicky or ludicrously expensive, not so much competitive/cheap stuff)

    I’m fine with making the keywords have more realistic costs when making customs (Fear at 2 instead of 6 for example), but trying to retcon existing WK stuff gets confusing in a hurry, and starts to invalidate all sorts of stuff like fleets at MT, the database/Master Spreadsheet, etc etc.  Also, the Cursed are more viable in large/campaign games, and giving them cheap gold runners and whatnot would make them much more like other factions in those games in addition to tournament relevance.  Outside of (in my opinion) France and Spain, the factions are all quite different with their own strengths and weaknesses, and I’m just one of those people in the camp that is fine with things staying that way.  I never really hear about people playing competitive tournaments anymore either, so unless there was a restart, I think fun and engaging customs are more important than boosting underpowered stuff that Wizkids made.  🙂

    I like my Basic Rules, and at this point it’s hard to see myself purposely going away from that to conform to a “community ruleset” that I might never use if people don’t want to or can’t play on VASSAL anyway.  At this point it seems like everyone has their own rulesets or preferred house rules, so a lot of things would be hard to iron out.  Even if something was “finalized”, people coming back to the community in a year or an influx of new players might completely disagree with a lot of the changes made.  You’d also have serious confusion for new players not knowing what to look at, and there’s already more than one rules document to look at when trying to play a game. (I tried to improve that somewhat by combining the best of the Start Here rules with the Complete Game rules, but the Code is important too)

    Sorry to kinda be debbie downer or whatever it’s called.  I think it’s an idea worth discussing, just one that may not result in much of a consensus or participation rate.  I do think it warrants its own thread, so if you want I could perhaps work some kind of forum magic to make it appear that way.

Viewing 30 posts - 1,981 through 2,010 (of 2,325 total)