Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterDoes anybody ever try to run a Viking Fleet from time to time?
Not often, but sometimes in less competitive games. Sometimes I like to combine them with other factions, including a minor faction alliance like the one used in this crazy game. I am playing them as a single faction in both CG4 and THC so we’ll see how that goes in the long run.
Ethan the Farseeker – 4 points (no cargo)
He links to all Viking ships, which does not have the same effect as taking up no cargo space. That’s important because if he didn’t take up cargo space, that specific ability wouldn’t stack with the Oarsman.
I think the fleet would struggle quite a lot with no helmsmen. All 3 ships really need one to stay competitive. A good rule of thumb is that ships with less than S+L base move generally need a helmsman to stay competitive in most games. Of course that depends on the opposition – if they’re not using helmsmen either, speed becomes less important. I will say I’ve had some success with Muninn, and you could make a case that she’s their best gunship.
I actually suggest do a combination of things to alleviate the lack of generic crew problem – let generics use their abilities on ships of any nationality, and even make/print paper crew chips that say “Helmsman” for use as proxies. (such as found on this page) Wizkids never got the generic crew distribution right, so I don’t like when random pack draws determine someone’s competitive play standing in the game.
Ben
KeymasterI just do what feels right to me. Kind of a balance of “would I use this at this cost” combined with “will Ben have an aneurysm looking at what I just typed” lol. Not too much of a science to it.
Nice. 😀 I think that’s a good way to do it (not that people need to think of me when making customs haha), and I think it’s fine to come up with costs quickly and not try to come up with some exotic catch-all formula that probably will be broken in the long run anyway.
The Garmr is fantastic and I do think she should be more expensive. 13 sounds like a good minimum to start at. I think the other one might be fine at 20; I don’t think she should be less between the speed and firepower. She’s arguably on par with the Kettering, which could easily be more expensive.
~~~~~
Haltharad
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Barbary Corsair
Rarity: U
Point Value: 8
Ability: Once per turn give any ship in your fleet +1 to all of her cannon rolls. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls when using firepots/fire shot.Flavor text: Promoted to the position of “Master Gunner of the Fleet”, this North African has helped dozens of Corsair gun crews improve their accuracy. For a fleet normally concerned with barbarity and boarding parties, his expertise has been much welcomed.
Xelomenos
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Barbary Corsair
Rarity: U
Point Value: 7
Ability: Loyal: Mercenary. Eternal. All of this ship’s cannons have L range.Flavor text: Xelomenos is supposedly an ex-patriate from the Jade Rebellion who amicably left some of his comrades in the Indian Ocean to join with the Corsairs. He loves their philosophy and fighting style, yet brings his own distinct and mysterious flair to the naval battlefield.
My Epic Seas set marks somewhat of a return to uncommon named crew. I like making the most important/expensive crew for each faction rare (unless SE/LE due to being “special” or tied to a ship of that rarity such as a 10 master’s linked crew), with uncommons ahead of commons for good reason as well. Though I made so many crew characters that it’s tough to have so many commons when I feel I could have more rares/uncommons haha. Some of the rarities are one thing I might change in the spreadsheet sometime, but it’s not important at all compared to the actual gameplay stuff.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterPost by Holofernes at MT quoting Tiffany O’Brien saying there was a 15th set planned for after Return to Savage Shores, predicted to be released around September 2009.
Ben
Keymaster@Captain Vendari: Great to see you here!
@Jet: Thanks for the kind words! Interesting to hear from someone who likes the middle sets specifically.
Ben
Ben
Keymaster(should I edit the post they are in as well?).
Not unless you want to.
Ben, that is a unique Titan! I don’t use sea creatures much, but it is pretty cool to see one geared towards treasure hunting. Also think that crew is pretty neat as well! I can see that driving the enemy just a little crazy.
Thanks!
The Black Jack is an awesome ship, similar to the Greed’s Hammer, one of my favorite Pirate ships. La Empresa looks decent, and I think the point costs are fair.
Mystic Arts
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Jade Rebellion
Rarity: C
Point Value: 13
Number of Masts: 3
Cargo Space: 4
Base Move: S+S
Cannons: 3L-4S-4L
Ability: Junk. Ghost Ship. This ship cannot be shot at while docked.Flavor text: Most Jade officers have never met the crew of the Mystic Arts. Almost never docking at the mainland, the ship is a bit of a shadow. Some pessimistic sailors have assumed the crew are in league with some of the deadly mercenaries of the South Pacific.
Valonar
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Jade Rebellion
Rarity: C
Point Value: 6
Ability: Cannoneer. Once per turn, roll a d6. On a 6, give any ship in your fleet +L to her base move this turn.Flavor text: Described as a “mystic mage”, Valonar has knowledge of historical cults and their ways of influencing their surroundings. He claims to be capable of driving ocean currents at a faster rate than nature provides.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterIt is here! One of the biggest, longest, and most outrageous battle reports I’ve ever done! 354 pictures, so it might take time to load! XD
Ben
KeymasterThe fort’s ability combined with spamming those crew abilities could easily tip the balance of a large/campaign game in the favor of the Cursed.
I don’t think it would happen easily. The right rolls can be hard to come by, and opponents will know to stay away from the fort or attack in en masse to destroy it. I think it would be more OP when involved with a TON of mover abilities (like more than my Cursed had even in CG1) or the MI’s that allow you to move enemy ships. Thanks for the feedback!
Welcome back, CaptainJack! 🙂 Compare the Vesuvius to the original Harbinger, who has the same ability. Although that 5 master is arguably a little too cheap, it shows that the Vesuvius could easily come down to perhaps 16 points. Wizkids completely screwed up Bombardier point costs; they’re not much more than glorified 3 masters with an extra firepot specialist. I agree with Xerecs that HMS Seaford could go up to 12 points.
More from Epic Seas:
Aramantis
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: U
Point Value: 15
Number of Masts: 4
Cargo Space: 4
Base Move: S+S
Cannons: 4L-4L-4L-4L
Ability: Titan. S-Explorer. [Once per turn, if this ship is within S of an island, you can mark the island as explored without docking at it. The island becomes unexplored in regards to all other players.] This titan cannot be shot at while docked.Flavor text: A “friendly” crab who only attacks when provoked, Aramantas nevertheless serves The Cursed. His peculiar nature is detested by the other crabs, with Raninoidea nearly succeeding in a murder long ago.
Magnesis
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: R
Point Value: 9
Ability: Captain. Once per turn roll a d6. On a 4-6, you may move an enemy ship S in any direction.Flavor text: Another “new” Cursed Overlord, Magnesis resembles a behemoth. He claims that his unnatural powers come from giant magnets under the sea that he can move with his huge hands. Jealous of the power bestowed upon the highest-ranking Fiends, he is trying to work his way up the Cursed ranks.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterPersonally, the ability of the Kingdom of Horrors throws me off of it a bit, but I would totally use it as a well-armed staging area for combat-oriented ships.
Which one? (if not all)
I feel a little strange trying to “import” Helm’s Deep into Pirates; either way I think it should cost 5 gold even with that negative ability.
Durinsong is like a sister ship to the Matuku, which is one I like and a good thing for the Mercs to have. Deathless is solid.
Nice flavor text on these!
Ben
KeymasterBold added for emphasis, do you mean fort here instead of ship?
Yes exactly, thanks, fixing it.
May 12, 2019 at 12:08 PM in reply to: Rules for Thought #28 – Mercenaries could pay to dock/repair #4996Ben
KeymasterIn suggesting that they pay to dock, I didn’t mean that they’d have to eliminate gold to do so, but to deposit gold in their HI like any other faction, the difference being that France doesn’t have to deposit gold when they want to repair, they just do it.
I understood that, I was suggesting it as yet another potential house rule allowing Mercs to repair.
I also think it would be thematic if the Mercs had more named crew of a warfare/killer variety, something I explore in my custom set.
Ben
Keymaster@ktulu: Interesting combo, I see the Fleeting Star as a support ship on the back lines of a battle. Would be a good ship to accompany a Mercenary 10 master, maybe include some extra sac food material to supply a crew like SS Tsai when he runs low on the 10 master.
Ben
KeymasterKingdom of Horrors
Type: Fort
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: LE
Gold Cost: 10 gold
Cannons: 3L-3L-2L-2L-3L-3L
Ability: When this fort hits an enemy ship, also eliminate one crew from that ship. If an enemy ship is within S of this fort you can roll a d6. On a result of 6, one target crew is immediately assigned to this ship. Its nationality changes to match the nationality of this ship. If any ship is moved into contact with this island, that ship and all crew aboard have their nationality changed to Cursed and become part of this fleet.Flavor text: Like a fear “festival” of terrible things, this “kingdom” is the defintion of sailor’s nightmares. It is said that the Cursed devils manning the fort are adept not only at killing anyone who comes close, but taking their souls as well.
Lucifer’s Serpent
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: LE
Point Value: 14
Number of Masts: 4
Cargo Space: 2
Base Move: S+S
Cannons: 2S-2S-3S-3S
Ability: Sea Monster. Once per turn when this sea monster rams an enemy ship, eliminate one mast and one crew from the enemy ship.Flavor text: A calling from above the waves awakened this creature from its ancient slumber….
Ben
KeymasterI think the treacherous waters would make more sense if a roll of 1 meant something bad (as it usually does in this game). Maybe a 1 roll would be a reef effect with a 5 or 6 being no effect. The variability is interesting because you could enter it on purpose and try to game the whirlpool effect for an improbable escape.
And to Ben I would turn that into a fortress I dunno why or how it just screams fortress to me
Indeed, that’s one of the main ideas I had in mind. I think I have 4 cardboard moldings in that shape so I have options as to what I want to make in the future if I use them.
Ben
KeymasterEasily my biggest purchase for pirates as well but I think it was well worth it, I have two games planned this weekend so I’ll be trying them out.
Awesome! Feel free to post about the games in Battle Reports.
Ben
KeymasterWhat do you think this could be turned into?

I also picked up a piece of aluminum flashing from the hardware store for less than a dollar. Lots of things I could do with it.

Ben
KeymasterOk cool, out of the 32 I was able to find I recieved almost all of the Jade Rebellion ships (including several 6 masters) and most of their named crew. That and I went through the list and was able to get 85% of the whole expansion. I’ve never had any Jade Rebellion ships so it was pretty exciting for me to make this find.
That is awesome!! SCS is one of the best sets and one of my favorites. The Jades are a really cool minor faction. The big lot of SCS I got in late 2014 was one of the biggest Pirates purchases I’ve done, but I don’t regret it at all.
May 9, 2019 at 3:24 PM in reply to: What do you consider the biggest missing thematic element in Pirates CSG? #4474Ben
Keymaster@Countupyourcoyne: Sounds interesting, and reminds me of cannonfury’s Economy Edition and a little of Merchants and Marauders. If you do flesh out full house rules or an entire alternative ruleset, feel free to post about it in Game Ideas.
May 8, 2019 at 8:51 PM in reply to: Would you ever trade a non-duplicate to get something you really wanted? #4469Ben
KeymasterOh yeah for sure if I was better at making ships I would play a whole fleet of my own design lol
The more you make, the better you’ll get at it! You never know when you’ll end up better then you expected to be.
Ben
KeymasterI’m excited to say that I am planning to finally play a few physical games again. As of now my plan is to play one physical solo game per month for the next 3 months (no promises though). Might not sound like much, but I’m planning to put a potentially inordinate amount of effort into each game and its associated battle report. Hoping to debut a new thing or two and possibly mark a personal “first” in the BR realm of it.
First game will probably be 5-7 fleets at 60 points, another game with 4 fleets at 100 points (in a possibly futile attempt to recreate magic), and possibly a game at over 100 points with 4 or more fleets.
PS: The Zeus will be loose. XD
Ben
KeymasterI recently made a great find, several dozen sealed South China Sea boosters. I have been looking for reasonable lots of them for a while and I know they are rare but exaxtly how rare I’m not sure. What have been you all’s experience with searching for South China Sea packs?
SCS is the rarest expansion for packs and correspondingly the most expensive. There are usually expensive single packs on eBay for $10+ but finding a bunch in a lot is rare. There was a foreign site selling them not long ago but some folks said they ended up selling most or all of their stock to DAcardworld.
May 8, 2019 at 7:21 PM in reply to: Would you ever trade a non-duplicate to get something you really wanted? #4465Ben
KeymasterIm not so much a stat guy since I can play with whatever stats I want but i can’t change the shape of the models.
I get what you’re saying. That makes me think that perhaps you play with proxies and/or customs more than other people would?
Ben
Keymaster@Woelf: Yet another interesting take on modifying BA. My initial thought is that it might be too powerful, or at least worth the ~5 points it was costed at.
Ben
KeymasterWhat if you had you knock out the oars per the flotilla hit rules (two hits within the same shoot action) and then they can only be replaced as a repair action at a home island.
That does make sense. Allow them to be repaired, possibly even as a free action if you pay 1 gold.
Ben
KeymasterI now will not be able to derelict the ship in one shoot action, but I am guaranteed at least 1 hit for performing broadsides attack. So rolling 0 hits will result in 1 hit, rolling 1 hit will also result in 1 hit, rolling 2 hits will result in 2 hits.
I realize this applies to existing BA game pieces that are paying for the keyword, but guaranteed hits are likely to be a problem for some people. As you can see from the survey results linked in the original post, 68% of respondents so far think that a roll of 1 should always miss. Personally, I’m not fond of getting 1 hit whether you roll for 0 hits or 1 hit. Each result of the rolls should be different.
I can’t say I’d ever want to roll even more dice while shooting either, unless perhaps the entire combat system was completely revamped. I think the second example overcomplicates the shooting process, but I’m not someone who has played more complicated games outside of complex Pirates situations.
Glad to see some seriously in-depth ideas and discussion in this thread!
Ben
KeymasterIve been pondering how to not only play co-op pirates but to have a lot of fun doing so. The main criteria I see for a successful game of friendly pirates is difficulty and randomness.
Interesting idea. You’re trying to play games where the players are incentivized to work together rather than against each other?
I’ve never really thought of that, but it could be an interesting way to change things up and decrease potential bitterness in intense games. Though I must say I get a thrill out of strategizing against a real opponent that doesn’t come in solo games.
Ben
KeymasterInstead of rolling an additional die and dropping a hit, the attack could lose a die for a guaranteed hit. So your maximum damage on a 4 masted ship would be 3 hits, and your minimum would be 1 (even if rolling all misses). This achieves the same result as the above proposed rule, just with absolute consistency.
Sorry to be so dumb, but could you provide an example? It sounds like you wouldn’t need to roll if you’re getting guaranteed hits by forfeiting rolls. It’s starting to sound more like a regular shoot action to me.
Ben
KeymasterThe bribes exist mostly to add just a touch more flavor. However, it could also allow for very interesting game decisions. Deciding whether to spend precious gold to bribe during an important capture could either win you the game by giving you the edge in the next engagement, or lose you the game due to the loss of coin. Tough choices like these are what make games interesting, and Pirates is missing these sorts of decisions in my opinion.
That makes a lot of sense, thanks for the additional info! Good point about bribes in larger games; makes me want to try it out sometime.
Ben
KeymasterLe Tireur d’Élite could come down in cost by a handful of points. The Selkie (one of my favorite ships) has much better cannons for 4 less points, and is arguably costed correctly. I think this ship could be 8-9.
Wow, heckuva ship thee with the Calamity. I imagine that she’d only make an appearance in a huge game, in excess of 100 points, since I’m not even sue if 100 points would be enough to fit this thing.
The entire combo comes to 56 points, so put aboard a few crew to “protect”/supplement the mighty Acronius and you could fit it easily.
Revokt
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Pirate
Rarity: C
Point Value: 10
Number of Masts: 2
Cargo Space: 4
Base Move: L
Cannons: 2S-2L
Ability: S-Board.
Link: Infant BuccaneersFlavor text: Crewed by multigenerational pirates, the Revokt will never be exceptional, but has what she needs to be successful while avoiding priority lists of pirate hunters.
Infant Buccaneers
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Pirate
Rarity: C
Point Value: 3
Ability: Helmsman. Shipwright. This ship gets -1 to her cannon and boarding rolls.
Link: RevoktFlavor text: Getting their name from enemies who were astounded to see little boys and girls crewing a pirate ship, these offspring of the Revokt’s pirates have taken a liking to sea life. Although they’ve learned to crew the ship effectively, their weak muscles and small stature are often liabilities during boarding parties.
Ben
KeymasterThanks so much for doing what you can to get these folks on the podcast!
You’re welcome! My plan now is to wait perhaps a week in between each new person I’ve messaged before trying a new one. (I’d be overwhelmed if a bunch of people were willing to be on all at once)
Ben
Keymaster@Ed: Any specific crew artwork you find weird, not just the actual photos of the PotC characters? (though I can admit Damsel in Distress was a weird crew to make for the game in general)
-
AuthorPosts
