Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1,681 through 1,710 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #5554
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @Xerecs: I thought about making the Red Butterfly a point or two less, but couldn’t quite justify it with the abilities.  Now that I see her again I think it might make sense.

    Time for a crew day!

    Kadrax Dalibor
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 9
    Ability: Ex-Patriot. Ghost Ship. World Hater. [This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against any [non-faction] ship.]

    Flavor text: Dalibor has spent time as both a Cursed operative and a tortured pirate captive. He thus knows how to get the most out of what he is given. With a hardened mindset from years of committing or witnessing atrocities, he is ready to make a killing in any upcoming wars of the world, knowing his services will be in high demand.

    Quindrick Pylindra
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 5
    Ability: Ex-Patriot. Reverse Captain. [After this ship resolves a shoot action, she may move as a free action.] UT Hoard. [Once per turn, if this ship is touching another ship, reveal all face-down treasure aboard the other ship. This ship can take as much unique treasure from the other ship as she can carry.]

    Flavor text: This man is an oddity that no one is able to explain. He comes and goes as he pleases, speaks little, and occasionally helps out. Some days he wears a cape and hood, others normal sailing attire or nearly no clothing. He is such a mystery that some sailors are stunned speechless when meeting him.

    Maybe a bit like Professor Quirrell one day, Radagast the next, and something entirely different another day. XD  Might go to 4 points.

    Gervorio
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 6
    Ability: Ex-Patriot. Ransom. This ship may dock at an enemy home island and take as much treasure as she can carry. If able, she must leave on your next turn.

    Flavor text: A cunning bearded man whose reputation as a criminal mastermind drove him out of Italy, Gervorio now provides his services to any crown with treasure. Only after being paid huge sums does he go to work. His incredible thefts have landed him on the wanted list of many rich men.

    Lotta wild combos available with this guy….

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #5553
    Ben
    Keymaster

    how is wholesalegaming?

    HWG is excellent.  I have purchased from them multiple times and things have gone well.

    in reply to: Pulls/Purchases Thread #5549
    Ben
    Keymaster

    its awesome that you put so much effort into Pirates!

    The love seems to be neverending!  XD   Getting really excited to play some physical games again after Legend of the Giant Turtle was pretty memorable.  Actually I just got out fleets this morning for the next game, though it won’t start quite yet.

    They only got a few 5 masters, but the Cursed make up for it a bit with a good set of 4 masters.  Some of them are underrated in my opinion, including slow ones like the Whydah and Juggernaut.

    Ben
    Keymaster

    A crew ability might work. For example, something like this:

    “When any cannon on this ship shoots, if it can draw a single line of fire through two or more masts on the target at the same time, this ship gets [whatever the bonus is goes here]”

    Good point!  Another idea for customs.  The hits in question could eliminate cargo if it was up to me.  That can also help make L-range guns better, since they would be more likely to “hit” multiple masts, simulating that they are more powerful or are being used with extra gunpowder.

    I do agree that a lot of realism has to be compromised in order to have a functioning game that is fun and not too long.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #5493
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @uadoom: Interesting, they’ve been one of the bigger sellers of Pirates CSG stuff the past few years.

    in reply to: Pulls/Purchases Thread #5491
    Ben
    Keymaster

    After watching Bens collection Video on the Cursed i went out and got Hades’ Realm.  Awesome ship!

    Cool!  Thanks for watching.  She is a really neat ship for them, one of their few that can achieve a high max speed.  I like to run her with captain+helmsman and maybe oarsman, to keep a few spots open for gold.  Now I want to use her again, so perhaps I’ll be able to fit her into one of the summer games I hope to play.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #5452
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Red Butterfly
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 13
    Number of Masts: 2
    Cargo Space: 4
    Base Move: S+S
    Cannons: 3L-4S
    Ability: Mercenary. Galley. Crew Killing. [Once per turn when this ship hits an enemy ship, also eliminate one crew from that ship.] If this ship is within S of an enemy ship when this ship is given a move action, she gets +S to her base move.
    Link: Red Radish

    Flavor text: The Red Butterfly got her name when her captain led an attack that stained the ship’s oars and sails with blood. Although a multipurpose ship with adequate cargo capacity, she is at her finest when facing imminent danger, largely thanks to her excitable captain.

    Red Radish
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 7
    Ability: Ex-Patriot. Captain. HI Raider. [This ship may dock at an enemy home island and load one treasure. If able, she must leave on your next turn.] If this crew is assigned to their linked ship, that ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls.
    Link: Red Butterfly

    Flavor text: The Red Radish is one of the more passionate and animated captains of the sea. His reputation is that of a “happy warmonger”. When things break right, he can make the Red Butterfly one of the most formidable galleys afloat.

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    Ben
    Keymaster

    Raking could give -1 to connon roll and deal 2 masts if you can shoot their stern, I think a crew with that ability would be nice and cheep or maybe just beef up the cannoneer

    I suppose, but I don’t think that would be thematic enough.  It was more about getting the perpendicular angle so cannon shots would travel along the entire length of the enemy ship.  A mast bonus could work, but it was really devastating to the cargo (especially crew) inside, hence my suggestion.

    I remember reading about the Royal Sovereign raking the Santa as the first ship to break the line at Trafalgar, with catastrophic effect.

    Ben
    Keymaster

    @uadoom: Just got word from Jason that although he didn’t work at Wizkids after 2006, he was contracted to write flavor text until the second to last set (Fire and Steel).  So perhaps he’ll have more insight into your question after all!

    Ben
    Keymaster

    The game started with Historical fleets and toward the end of the game, it shifted in a more fantasy direction. was that a change direction to gain a bigger audience or a way for the team to express their ideas?

    Good question in general, but possibly better for a game designer who was there throughout the later sets.  Mical stopped working for Wizkids in March 2006, one month after South China Seas came out.  So although he was probably around for some or all of the design process for DJC, there’s a chance that the time frame doesn’t quite match up.  Still looking forward to asking the question though, thanks!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #5393
    Ben
    Keymaster

    (merged to this thread)

    This is the sticky thread for ALL Rules questions, so please post any future questions in this thread.

    I ask because I have the HMS GT and I have Crimson Angel. would I be able to move and shoot (captain) than use the same action, to move no distance (In case I was within S range) and shoot again? or is this not allowed? I did not see that a ship had to move it’s full distance.

    Technically you must be given the Same Action Twice as the ability states.  However, there is really no “minimum” distance required for movement, so you could move a fraction of a millimeter and then shoot with all the cannons still in range.  It’s one of those “fudgey” things that doesn’t matter a whole lot, since you can kind of “simulate” the movement and basically keep the ship in the same place.  A little funky, but for official purposes you could just bump the ship a tiny bit forward or whatever to satisfy the “move action”.

    in reply to: Pulls/Purchases Thread #5388
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Sooo, I think I have a problem.  Just picked up a booster box of RV. now, this I will be making video for the unpacking.

    Great!  Feel free to post a link to the video once you’ve got it!  RV is a great set so you should get some exciting pulls.

    in reply to: The Podcast Thread #5364
    Ben
    Keymaster

    If anyone would like to do a podcast episode with me in June or July, let me know!  So far I’m striking out with the recent contacts I’ve been making, so I’m looking to record some more “normal” episodes again.  (latest message was to Mike Mulvihill, he saw it but hasn’t responded)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #5356
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I feel like I’ve already seen the Sentence and Kontos….

    When I get a “theme” or idea I like, I tend to go a little crazy with it.  XD  (_ Fiend, Demon _, Devil’s __, etc)  Using the forum search, I saw that I have released “The Sentencing”, which is a different ship.  I don’t see either of these though, and I’m pretty sure I haven’t messed up any (or hardly any) of the numbers on the spreadsheet for things I have or haven’t released.  Maybe you saw them on the spreadsheet itself. (which is ridiculously overwhelming at this point with 1000 total game pieces lol)

    Yeah I find the Sentence bizarre because you can’t conceivably run it as a good gunship or gold runner due to the crew dying as soon as you’re alone.  I guess you could use it as an empty gold runner until a battle occurred.

    Would Kontos be able to use his ability in conjunction with range extenders, like traditional sniping or Extended range?

    Great point!  Although sniping requires a successful hit on that range, so it wouldn’t apply to that ability since his ability is not part of shooting.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #5354
    Ben
    Keymaster

    This is directly contradictory to the complete game rules as the Keyword states that sea monsters CAN ram while the complete game rules say that they cannot ram.

    Absolutely.  Wizkids’ handling of the sea creature rules vs. creature “type” keywords (Titan, Sea Dragon, etc) was a colossal mistake.  The sea creature rules are the base rules that apply to all the different creature types.  The sea creature keywords (like Sea Monster) were written specifically for each type, which is where you get exceptions.  Honestly it’s a disaster.

    in reply to: Pulls/Purchases Thread #5353
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Pretty neat, I’ve never calculated my completion percentages by set but it’s cool.  Across all the sets I’m nearly “pack complete”, mostly just missing some SR’s and probably a few random things.   Taking LE’s/etc into account I’m probably at least 90% complete for the sets, with the possible exception of something like RotF which has a high percentage of LE’s since it was a small set but with plenty of rare stuff at the end.  Although, I’ve never bothered to keep track of generic crew and probably never will.  (much more of a player, though someday in the distant future maybe I’ll try to see if there are some I don’t have)

    Elsinore is actually a pretty interesting ship.

    Love the 6 masted junks, the OE ones are some of the best.

    in reply to: Would you PREFER if everything was costed perfectly? #5352
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I think if the game was still in production then I might have a different opinion, but with the game so far out of production, calling for ‘fixes’ to pieces seems silly and possibly a waste of time. If people feel strongly about it, then they should communicate with their playgroup well before hand if the game is to be taken in a more casual manner or if it will be hyper competitive.

    Agreed!  I am very in favor of discussing what “level” of game will be played before going in.  Of course, that also requires that the players know the level of meta fleets that are out there for comparison.  I think at least once on VASSAL I was trounced in a game because my opponent showed up with a fleet far better than I was expecting.

    Even though I’m fine with the costs as-is, I keep thinking about doing a “flash recosting” very quickly.  I shouldn’t bother with that in the next few months…  lol.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #5351
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Weirdness continues. When I’m on the main forum page, I’m shown as not logged in. However, once I click on a thread and go in, I’m suddenly logged in. I haven’t checked the Customs thread yet though. I’m fairly sue that the oddity is on my end, though I’m not sue what to do about it, since I’ve already removed some cookies and stuff.

    Please let me know if it continues or affects your participation/enjoyment here.  I had a somewhat similar issue a few days ago when the hosting company had to change a few things to get the site back online.  Glad to see you post in CS again.

    If you want I can report your issue to the hosting support system, but it is weird that it seems to only be affecting your account.  (that we know of)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #5350
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Huzzah!   Glad to see you back here, and glad you enjoyed the latest pieces.

    Sentence
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 14
    Number of Masts: 2
    Cargo Space: 5
    Base Move: S+S
    Cannons: 2S-2S
    Ability: Once per turn you must eliminate one crew from this ship or any ship within S of this ship.

    Flavor text: The executioner’s bell tolls. He takes the living to their death, even if they happen to be on his ship. Your Sentence awaits!

    Kontos Bevian
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: C
    Point Value: 3
    Ability: Once per turn you may eliminate one of this ship’s crew to eliminate one mast on an enemy ship in range of this ship’s cannons. [independent of shooting]

    Flavor text: One of the few true humans who works directly with the Cursed aboard their foul vessels, Bevian is adept at tricking his enemies into felling their own masts.

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #5336
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Maybe i missed the thread for this but I need an answer to this question as it has been a point of contention in my play group for a long time.

    Merged with this sticky thread since this is the thread for all Rules questions.

    The game rules are very unclear about sea monsters, can they explore and get treasure or not?

    Check out the rules for Sea Creatures in the Complete Game Rules.

    Sea creatures can’t be rammed, pinned, or boarded. Nor can they ram, load treasure, tow, or be assigned crew. Sea creatures can be given only move and shoot actions.

    Titan is the only sea creature keyword that allows for exploring an island.  Other creature types can dock but not explore, per the Code.

    -A sea creature is docked if any part of it (including a segment) touches an island.

    in reply to: Would you PREFER if everything was costed perfectly? #5332
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I HATE meta gaming and I feel like one of the best ways to avoid it is by nerfs and occasional buffs for example why not try costing musketeers at 2 and helmsman at 3?

    That makes sense, I just like the idea of keeping captains and helmsmen at their current costs as a “base” level.  Mainly to simply drive down the cost of other crew – I really like the idea of crew being less expensive in general, since that could result in much more fun crew setups and combos.  (which I’ve found to almost always be a good thing, using lots of crew is fun)  Honestly I think I might someday do a “rapid fire” “total recosting” and create an alternate Master Spreadsheet with changed costs.  It wouldn’t be perfect, but I know the game so well and have memorized a ton of the game pieces to the point where I could probably knock it out in a couple days as a fun exercise, even if it never got used (even by me).

    I like unbalanced game. I’m a person who loves to play against a meta and playing non efficient models in effective ways.

    I can vibe with that too.  I think the problem with Pirates becomes when things are nearly mandatory to stay competitive.  Captain Jack Sparrow (common version), Banshee’s Cry, and (if you don’t ban events) Mermaids/Favor of the Gods/arguably Becalmed are nearly impossible to go without if you intend to win all the time.  The absolute top-tier metagame is so OP that using great ships like HMS Gallows or the Providence will basically prevent you from winning, which is kinda sad.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #5293
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can a player choose the order with a Switchblade ram when there’s a blade ram and a regular ram? (or must blades come first)

    Can you explore two friendly ships at once with one explore action? (between three ships at once for a double/three-way transfer)

    When towing, can you move S, drop the derelict/flotilla, and then continue with the rest of the segments you’d normally have? (and if so, can you use a helmsman bonus after dropping the flotilla)

    in reply to: Pulls/Purchases Thread #5290
    Ben
    Keymaster

    @uadoom: Nice!  The Pawtucket was involved in my latest game.  Good ships overall, the Paul Revere is one of my favorites.


    @Countupyourcoyne
    : Sounds like a large influx of ships!  One of the things I miss about being mostly complete (at least with stuff from packs) is the thrill of the hunt and opening packs to get stuff I don’t already have.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #5276
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I suspect this has something to do on my end with cookies and stuff.

    It might be, I had to clear some histories yesterday to get logged into the forum page properly.  However, there were a few issues with the site 2 days ago, so there’s a chance it’s a leftover problem from that.  That said, it’s strange that you can post here not there.  Try clearing your history or cookies/etc from a recent time and maybe try posting after going to the thread straight from the forum (while already logged in).

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #5274
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I’m having a problem with the Custom Ships thread, it keeps logging me out when I click on it. Could be a problem on my end, but heads up.

    Are you accessing the thread from the main forum, from the notification in the top right corner, or from an email notification link?

    I was just able to post there after going to the latest post from the main forum, but that might just be because I’m the admin.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #5273
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Gunos Fortress
    Type: Fort
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: R
    Gold Cost: 8 gold
    Cannons: 3L-3L-3L-3S-3S
    Ability: This fort can only be built on a whirlpool when a Cursed ship is touching the whirlpool. Enemy ships using this whirlpool must pay a toll of 2 gold to this fort (gold may come from the ship or that player’s home island). If this fort has at least 18 total gold in it, it may use the whirlpool to be placed at another whirlpool. (roll for damage as you would a ship)

    Flavor text: The first experiment in the Cursed plan to dominate every corner of the seas. With enough resources gathered from ships passing through its whirlpool, this fortress may have the power to transfer locations to a different whirlpool. If the Cursed can perfect their method of madness, it could lead to a superweapon that not even the Royal Navy can contend with….

    Figlar Castle
    Type: Fort
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: R
    Gold Cost: 10 gold
    Cannons: 3S-3S-3S-3S-3S-3S
    Ability: This fort can only be built on a whirlpool when a Cursed ship is touching the whirlpool. Starting the turn after construction, this fort can travel through whirlpools like a ship, but without having to roll for damage. Cursed crew can use their abilities in this fort.

    Flavor text: The Cursed have built this monstrosity, which could spell doom for all humanity. They have now created a water-borne fortress that can harness the power of the sea to warp into various locales. Hearing of the shocking development, some sailors have already given up hope, preferring to simply stay on land.

    Partially inspired by Figaro Castle from Final Fantasy VI.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #5270
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Huzzah!  I currently seem to be ranking #2 in google for “Pirates CSG” behind only Miniature Trading!  😀

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #5237
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Former Wizkids Communication Manager Jason Mical’s LinkedIn profile says:

    Developed and executed a traditional and new media PR campaign for a new game with expected lifetime sales of $400,000; the game became an evergreen product that grossed $3,000,000 per year.

    Can’t help but wonder if that’s about Pirates…. O_O  Certainly interesting to do some serious “digging” around the internet for info about stuff.  Would be cool to somehow get some financial data about the game.   (not that it’s referencing Pirates CSG, but at $3.99/pack that comes out to 750,000+ packs in a year!  2 ships/pack=1.5million, x~4.5 years of production=6.5+ million ships produced?  XD)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #5229
    Ben
    Keymaster

    repository has some interesting potential, I’d have to look at all the crew with ‘Fiend’ in their name, though I think some might not function efficiently in a fort.

    I did take a peek after posting it, and the combos were little more disappointing than I expected.  XD  Even the ones that had applicable abilities would probably be better on ships, especially since some of them had additional abilities that would only work on ships.

    IT IS TIME!!!!!  The “final” 10 master! One of the craziest and most expensive customs of all time!!

    Chimeratron Legacy
    Type: Ship
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: LE
    Point Value: 90
    Number of Masts: 10
    Cargo Space: 12
    Base Move: L
    Cannons: 2S-2S-3L-3L-3L-3L-3L-3L-2S-2S
    Ability: Junk. Eternal. Turbine. Sniping.* Two hits from the same shoot action are required to eliminate one of this ship’s masts. This ship gets +1 to her equipment rolls. This ship must be assigned at least 7 crew at the start of play.
    Link: Any 1 10+ point Cursed named crew, (and) Aliktoril Bellen

    *Sniping: You may double the range of this ship’s cannons each turn, but you must roll a 6 to hit.

    Flavor text: Filled to the brim, with a ludicrously massive cargo hold, technical innovations aplenty, and well over a thousand fiends to defend her, this ship is the best of all worlds. No one knows where the ship came from, or if it was built in a visible shipyard somewhere in the world. The ship is said to be the heaviest afloat, with huge amounts of metal aboard given the technological aspects that seem to indicate that the Cursed are growing at a faster rate than even the English. With enough gunpowder to supply an entire small fleet, and some steel plating on her hull, the vessel could be the first truly “unsinkable” ship. Although her crew is made up of demons and fiends, the despicable and vicious Aliktoril Bellen has come aboard to provide a steadying hand. He plans to drive the ship to unparalleled heights of power as the Cursed machine of death revs up for a grand campaign of terror that will end human existence.

    From my notes: “God mode 10 master with defenses”; End of All Things

    90 point ship!  LOL!  XD  (and she might need to be more!!)

    Aliktoril Bellen
    Type: Crew
    Faction Affiliation: Cursed
    Rarity: LE
    Point Value: 10
    Ability: Loyal: Cursed. Hostile: Non-Cursed factions. SAT.* Massacre.* Once per turn you may give any Cursed ship in play +1 to its boarding rolls this turn.
    Link: Chimeratron Legacy

    *SAT: Same Action Twice: Once per turn before you give this ship an action, roll a d6. On a 5 or 6, this ship may be given the same action twice.
    *Massacre: If this ship succeeds at a boarding party, she can eliminate all of the other ship’s crew.

    Flavor text: Uncomparable malice and evil drives this sadistic “man” to new heights within the Cursed ranks. His influence touches all aspects of Cursed culture, and he has ordered dozens of massacres. One of the only Cursed officers to not be a “demon” or “fiend”, his unique cunning and charming style have given him more power over naval affairs than minor monarchs of Europe.

    Feel free to give feedback!  That makes 29 different 10 masters in Epic Seas; I thought I had 30, so I’ll have to make at least one more!  XD

    You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas

    in reply to: Is Miniatures Trading down? #5223
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Does the Miniaturetrading site not accept new users? I have tried creating an account and the captcha never matches and I have not been able to create an account in the last three days…

    I would assume they are still accepting new users, but who knows given how weird the site has been.

    Anyone know a way to contact them about this?

    As far as I know, the new owners are CardMarket (assuming they’ve taken over by now) and I’ve already posted contact info and whatnot in the thread.

Viewing 30 posts - 1,681 through 1,710 (of 2,325 total)