Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 16, 2019 at 5:07 PM in reply to: Rules for Thought #33 – Bigger Islands with more exploring #6048
Ben
KeymasterI think this woks best with the large custom, three dimensional islands that people make. For the regular game pack islands, I think exploring works fine as-is, since not every game is a grand epic.
Exactly, agreed 100%.
Ben
KeymasterHit the “Subscribe” link to the upper right of “Pirates CSG” towards the top of the main forum page to get notified when new threads are posted!
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterThese questions come from my latest game.
If you have Filching Gold but also want to board a ship to steal an additional coin, which happens first? (I assumed the Filching Gold; perhaps the owner of the ship can decide?)
If Neptune’s Figurehead kicks in right after scuttling, can that ship be given a move action right away? (more of a clarification; in this case the ship sunk via scuttling at the beginning of the turn, then appeared at the HI fully repaired and immediately sailed out and rammed a ship!)
Can you activate Ghost Ship while that ship is being towed? (for example, to prevent opponents from ramming a towed derelict to steal gold from it)
What do you think of letting submerged game pieces ignore fog banks while submerged?
Ben
KeymasterI’ve checked around he site and the web but can not wind what ‘Trade Currents’ do. what are they?
You can see in Page 10 of the Combined Set Rules. (which I have linked on the homepage for convenience)
Ben
KeymasterLooking around and found some stuff. Punched Guichuan: https://ebay.to/2wTPHV0
Small SM lot worth bidding on: https://ebay.to/2WFdck9
Random CC crew lot with a couple Promo/LE’s: https://ebay.to/2MOT5eR
Ben
KeymasterSigned up for Teespring and now you can get some Pirates CSG shirts! 😀
There’s a wide variety of colors and types, and I plan to keep adding stuff to the store in the near future.
Ben
KeymasterPicked up this thin and flimsy but interesting plastic molding from work today. That’s the Ville de Paris on a hard card sleeve suspended above the valleys. It reminds me of the table that was posted on Miniature Trading a while back. (haven’t found the post yet)

SO many options. I’m thinking about attaching a piece of plexiglass to the top of it, and have it be a small alternate ocean where ships arrive and can send crew down to shipwrecks or something below. I could also make it more realistic by having the higher parts be reefs or sandbars, with the deeper area the only part where ships can sail safely. The lower parts could be made to look like a cool underwater area.
I also thought about enclosing the sides to make a “box” and then fill it with water! Then the plexiglass/etc could go on top and ships could go over it, possibly even dropping custom anchors into the depths.


This could get wild haha. A flashlight below could illuminate the waters, perhaps signaling the arrival of a deadly beast? Imagine it over the top of some blue LED lights or something.

As you probably already know, the above cardboard molding turned into a Giant Turtle! 😀
Ben
KeymasterGreat! I fondly remember those times when I was consistently adding new ships and crew to my collection.
That is unfortunate about the Mega Packs, and one thing I don’t miss as much lol. (getting lots of dupes, and ones that aren’t that useful in some cases like Squalo)
It is a nice deal on F&S, I’ve thought about it a few times the past few weeks haha. (just that I already have pretty much everything I could pull from the packs of that set)
Ben
KeymasterI really like the concept of Cancelers but I was unsure about a one masted ship. thanks for the insight.
Of course! Cancellers are fantastic but of course on a 1 masted ship you have the usual ramming problem, where one easily successful ram can often ruin a 1 master’s chances of impacting a game. In the unique case of the Hessian, that’s where a shipwright and Eternal could come in handy.
Ben
KeymasterPirates CSG Podcast #43: Jason Mical! (former Wizkids Communications Manager)
You can listen to the audio via ShoutEngine!
You can also listen on Archive.org: https://archive.org/details/PiratesCSGPodcast43JasonMical
Jason Mical was the Wizkids Communications Manager from 2003-2006. Questions list on Pirates with Ben: https://pirateswithben.com/forums/topic/submit-your-questions-for-former-wk-communications-manager-jason-mical/
Questions of the Day: If you were to name a Pirate ship, what would you name it and why? (from Jason Mical)
What is your favorite flavor text of any game piece? (from Ben)
His website: https://www.jasonmicalwrites.com/
His YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/ClassicLetsPlay/videos
Expanse RPG: https://greenronin.com/expanse/
Find all the game pieces here:
Master Spreadsheet (stuff from Wizkids): https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/18Z-x-z9gaWiKFLk-kw1weamc0A1-NxMN3xLjWWKsUmA/edit?usp=sharing
Past podcasts: http://shoutengine.com/PiratesCSGPodcast/
Take the podcast survey! https://goo.gl/forms/CsnwVmi3qhtqik323
Feel free to rate and review the podcast on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060
Pirates packs on eBay: https://goo.gl/MfHBQJ
Sign the Petition! https://www.ipetitions.com/petition/bring-back-pirates-of-the-cursed-seas
Join the Forum at Pirates with Ben! https://pirateswithben.com/forums/forum/pirates-csg/
The following should eventually be updated from ShoutEngine so they will be available when they get the podcast.
iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pirates-csg-podcast/id1258016060
Overcast: https://overcast.fm/itunes1258016060/pirates-csg-podcast
Google Play Music: https://play.google.com/music/m/Imxc6vplvkqlmagcvkxvi2er2wu?t=Pirates_CSG_Podcast
Blubrry: https://www.blubrry.com/piratescsgpodcast/
Stitcher: https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/a7xfanben/pirates-csg-podcast?refid=stpr
Thanks for listening! Feel free to answer the Questions of the Day below!

Ben
KeymasterThat was such a good podcast. It feels really good to be a part of this.
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it. Happy you’re enjoying Pirates CSG too!! 😀
Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterSounds like a potentially fun ability.
It is, I actually used that custom in at least one game in 2015 or 2016. (hope to republish the battle report this year here on the site)
Ben
KeymasterThanks, I’m looking forward to it as well. This Summer our time is constrained more than ever, so the victory condition number 2 is most likely to occur. However, (small spoiler) we have the least amount of islands this year than ever before, so that should force more combat and competition for islands.
Ah yes, I forgot to mention that at least it’s not most total gold as the win condition. XD Less islands does sound like a good idea, especially for a time-restricted game. Looking forward to seeing the custom islands in action!
As a site note, I don’t think the site likes copying and pasting in from a word Doc. I had to edit the main post twice since a bunch of code looking stuff was intermixed with the text. I’m not sue what caused it, but a heads up.
Yeah, sorry the forum doesn’t always work optimally. In the past I’ve had success just pasting into the Visual tab, which usually keeps the formatting from the original document. If pasting to the Text tab, some of it may not be recognized correctly.
June 10, 2019 at 10:04 PM in reply to: Submit your Questions for former WK Communications Manager Jason Mical! #5691Ben
KeymasterWe are planning to do the podcast around 4pm EST tomorrow (6/11), and I plan to stream it live on youtube!
Ben
KeymasterAwesome, looking forward to it as I do every year!! 😀 Should be interesting with some custom islands/etc in the mix as well.
Ben
KeymasterCould the Mountain Banshee be turned into a Double Catamaran? That’s what her ability makes me think of. Not a huge fan of having to roll again each time the ship gets hit, but Wizkids started that problem.
I wouldn’t be surprised if the other ships needed a small cost increase. However, Niko Ren’s ability seems very niche and I could see him coming down to 6.
Hazy Wasteland
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: C
Point Value: 7
Number of Masts: 2
Cargo Space: 3
Base Move: L
Cannons: 4S-4L
Ability: Galley. Smokepot Specialist. [Once per turn when this ship is given a shoot action, you may declare that one of her cannons is shooting a smokepot instead of a cannon; you do not need to target a ship. Simply place the center of a fog bank within S of this ship; it may not touch an island or any ship docked at an island. Remove the fog bank at the beginning of your next turn.]Flavor text: Slow and innacurate, the Hazy Wasteland nevertheless seems more than capable of finding her way out of encounters with enemies. Smoke and deception makes up for her overall mediocrity.
Figor
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: C
Point Value: 7
Ability: World Hater. [This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against any non-Cursed ship.] This ship gets +1 to her boarding rolls. This crew can use its abilities on Pirate and Mercenary ships. This crew can use its abilities in forts.Flavor text: A giant brute of a man, Figor is a “Russian monster” out to “get people”. His aggressive nature has already caused many deaths, and he is still on his first mission.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterLooking at King Fergus, I could probably ditch the Crew Protection to keep him at a usable price? Between that and a re-cost, what do y’all think would be better to do?
I think that makes sense. I just checked my Epic Seas spreadsheet and I have one crew with the ability. Palamides is an American crew with no other abilities for 10 points. I think the ability is worth at least 8 points, so King Fergus could be 9 with Ex-Patriot. He’d likely be on a 10 master, which makes it scarier because then there are more things to give the bonus to. (cannons, All Powerful, etc etc….)
Balrog seems somewhat powerful but 18 seems like a fair start for playtesting.
Wondrous Voyage
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
Rarity: C
Point Value: 17
Number of Masts: 3
Cargo Space: 6
Base Move: L
Cannons: 3S-4L-5S
Ability: Mercenary. Junk. Shipwright. This ship ignores the first hit she takes each turn as long as she has all of her masts. This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls when she carries gold.Flavor text: Often experiencing “miracles” on their long journeys, most of this ship’s crew have circumnavigated the world at least twice over. They know how to take great care of their capacious junk, and defend it with all arms when she has a valuable load inside her.
King Tharsis
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
Rarity: U
Point Value: 7
Ability: Captain. Ramming cannot eliminate this ship’s masts. Once per turn you may give +1 to any d6 roll made for this ship, after rolling.Flavor text: Apparently this man was once a prince in the Spanish royal family. Having been cast out over a dramatic and complicated dispute, he found peace in a quieter part of the world. That area has now become infested with the Europeans he was happy to escape, and so he has taken up arms as a mercenary “king” in order to preserve his freedom.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterAgreed with Xerecs for the most part.
King Fergus really needs to be more expensive. Crew Protect is worth 4 points, but +1 to all d6 rolls on the ship is worth a bunch more. World Hater is fine at 4, but including all other rolls (especially boarding, ramming, and SAT/EA/etc) has to probably double it to 8 or more. It would also help against reefs, and ideally whirlpools using my house rule. Throw in Ex-Patriot and I think he needs to be at least 13.
Devil’s Child
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: C
Point Value: 11
Number of Masts: 2
Cargo Space: 3
Base Move: S+S+S
Cannons: 2L-4S
Ability: Junk. Fear. Filching Gold.Flavor text: This small ship surprises enemies as one of the fastest Cursed vessels afloat. It was as if the Devil himself had a child and set her loose upon his enemies as a pest.
The Necromancer
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: U
Point Value: 11
Ability: Once per turn roll a d6. On a 4-6, you may move an enemy ship S in any direction. If an enemy ship is within S of this ship, you can use this ship’s action for the turn to try to possess a target crew on that ship. Roll a d6; on a result of 6, the target is immediately assigned to this ship. Its nationality changes to match the nationality of this ship. This crew can use its abilities in Cursed forts. If this crew would be eliminated, place it on your home island instead.Flavor text: A master spellcaster who has been trained extensively by experts of the dark arts, the “Necromancer” has taken up residency at most of the Cursed forts around the world. He manages to travel with speed almost unheard of, and causes mysterious things to happen around enemies of the Devil. Now he turns his attention to possessing foreign souls, desperate to woo them to El Fantasma’s cause.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterMost of my points wee made on the FB group, but one more thing I liked was the inclusion of some of the Young Jack Sparrow book series stuff. Pieces like the Grand Barnacle, and Fluer de la Mort came directly from those books.
I’m happy about that too, rather than inserting random stuff not from any PotC content.
I suspect the didn’t include much from those books due to lack of publicity around them, and huge amounts of publicity on the movies.
Indeed, I knew about the extra fiction but never read any of the books. It made the set a little more confusing, but in a good way – like “ooo, more PotC stuff, nice!” 😀
Some of that stuff sounds like a great customs idea. Between that and the two movies released since 2008, a small set could be designed. I’ve got my DMTNT customs in the Epic Seas set, but might have to add some OST stuff sometime too.
Ben
KeymasterFinally was able to message selvaxri about this because he actually made a custom (the Froide Vengeance) with the ability to tow icebergs!
Ben
KeymasterWhat would you put the value of a lot with Grinder and Terrox at?
They’re both somewhat rare, but nothing too crazy. I wouldn’t want to pay more than $5-$10 for either of them personally. There have been a bunch of those lots up with a huge range in final bid price.
Ben
KeymasterGreat points!
It is a weirdly imbalanced set, even between the 2 factions. I usually jump to HMS Endeavour as evening things out, but really the Pirates made out way better. (though the English benefited arguably as much or more compared to the other sets, since some of their best gold runners are from the set)
I did find the abundance of random/non-movie ships kinda strange.
I guess I never thought about all of Jack Hawkins’ versions combing before PotC. Since he got so many versions (and most of them playable), I never had an issue with it. Mission is an oddity but quite interesting in my opinion. I never would have predicted it, but I’m probably his biggest fan at this point. XD
June 6, 2019 at 1:17 PM in reply to: Rules for Thought #31 – Doubling the gold and islands for standard games? #5594Ben
KeymasterMany years ago I’d made scans of a couple terrain pieces and then printed them large enough to fill an entire Letter-sized (8.5″ x 11″) sheet of paper.
I remember seeing pictures of that! I think they’re in the pictures section at BGG. (might have been a different user though) I hope to do something like that sometime as well, could even do a massive iceberg that the Vikings could build a fort on.
Ben
KeymasterI have watched your podcast on the barbary coast and read the post.
Awesome thanks, great to hear that.
there is a sense of disappoint with the set. maybe it is because you guys have played the game for a long time and there is a lot of comparison to ships from other nations and sets.
Indeed. Part of that disappointment comes from direct comparison (even if slightly unfair) to the previous 3 sets. Which, apart from SCS, were never even approached again in terms of quality in my opinion and the opinions of many others. It’s not like BC is WAY worse than SM/CC/RV, but when you’ve peaked so high early on, it’s hard not to be a bit let down by quality decreases thereafter.
It doesn’t help that SCS is generally better and was right after BC. My view of BC has shifted downwards over time, while my view of SCS has only gone up due to how incredible it is. I’m a little biased because 5 masters are my favorite ship type and the one set without a single 5 master (other than the small and unique SS) will always be slightly dinged or “more lame” as a result.
I really like the look of the Barbary Galleys though.
They are amazing. Generally the prettiest faction, or at least on par with the French. You can see most of them in my Fleet Review. Although there weren’t 5 masters, I think it was really cool that Wizkids gave a 4 masted galley to most of the major factions. (Americans didn’t get one but made up for it with the Intrepid and President, not to mention stellar named crew)
As a random positive to the set, I’ve hardly broken any ships from BC that I can think of. They may have a better lamination job/etc than some of the other sets (especially DJC and OE of course, which can be pretty rough and brittle), as the cards seem very high quality as well. (though there could be some differences across the wide range of packs of course)
June 6, 2019 at 8:33 AM in reply to: Why did they change the explorer artwork to the musketeer artwork? #5578Ben
KeymasterI wish they kept the generic crew art exactly the same for all factions and sets, except perhaps the minor factions and Cursed. I don’t think it was worth it to go to faction-specific in the later sets, as I have far more generic crew from the earlier sets (that were better and therefore more likely to be purchased anyway).
Identical crew also make it easier to justify using generic crew on ships of any nationality, which is a very good house rule for newer players and/or those with small collections.
No surprises from me I suppose; I still have some nostalgia for the original artwork and EXPLORER in the Windlass font. 🙂 Whenever I make fleets I almost always try to use the oldest generic crew possible, especially using all-caps SM crew on ships from the early days of SM/CC/RV. 04-05 was the golden age for releases; I’m so glad I got into the game early enough to see it briefly.
Ben
KeymasterYou can see my thoughts on the set in my review. Quite a good set, though not top tier like SM/CC/RV/SCS.
June 6, 2019 at 8:06 AM in reply to: Rules for Thought #31 – Doubling the gold and islands for standard games? #5576Ben
Keymaster@Woelf: I agree with pretty much all of that and do those types of things in most of my games nowadays.
One way we talked about was having a narrow causeway that you have to pay a toll to secure passage, having a cost for a single ship or a much larger cost as a pass for your entire fleet.
That sounds very similar to something I’ve been thinking of trying for years now… 😀
We also played with idea of having “npc” forts or flotillas that act as a deterrent until there is no other option then to engage them.
Sounds like Circle of Blood!
I’ve done plenty of games where at least one island is surrounded by terrain, sometimes including reefs. Off the top of my head I can think of at least two past battle reports that will be republished where I did something like that. (hopefully I will get them up here at PwB this year)
Ben
KeymasterHey Matt, thanks for doing that. Makes me like CC and RV even more because 5 masters are my favorite ship type. : )
-
AuthorPosts
