Ben

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 391 through 420 (of 2,325 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #18039
    Ben
    Keymaster

    When your ship docks at an island, on the next turn, place this fort, it now acts as a second home island.

    It sounds like the Nexus Tower is mandatory to build?  Ex: Once you have at least 30 gold on your HI, you would have to build it at the next opportunity after docking.

    I can’t quite tell if it’s supposed to get around the regular fort rules where a ship has to be docked there to build it.  Does the ship in question have to stay at the island on the following turn, or can it leave and the fort is still built at the end of your next turn anyway?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #18033
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I don’t think it’s specified one way or the other if the removed treasure is revealed, but because the “more than half” rule isn’t used, there’s no real need to reveal it.   Unless something else forces it, or the group/person running the event decides otherwise, it’s safe to assume it does not get revealed.

    In that case, I assume that treasure eliminated via an Isle of Fire would have to be revealed in a 1v1 standard game?

    I would think it still doesn’t get revealed, because since abilities that add to the original 30 gold don’t change the requirements of the more than half rule (16 gold), it seems like subtractions from the total amount of starting gold would also not affect the required total of 16+.  Eliminating treasure just makes that endgame condition less likely (or impossible if a lot of coins are eliminated), so the game is more likely to end with all treasure unloaded to HI’s or no future move actions.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #18030
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Pretty sure I’ve asked this but not seeing it via the forum search: If you start your turn on a sargasso sea but you didn’t get stuck last turn, do you have to roll since you’re sailing over it?  Or would you only roll if you contact a NEW sargasso sea during that action?

    You don’t get stuck (or have to roll) immediately if you start on it, but when you move if any part of the ship is still touching the terrain after any segment, you will have to roll again.

    I assume that’s the case for reefs as well?  For example, if I start a move action on a reef with S+S speed, and after the first segment the ship is still touching the reef – it has to roll for effect/take damage again, even if it doesn’t end the move action on the reef?

    I’m pretty sure you said in the past that when a ship is sunk in a multiplayer game, any treasure aboard that gets removed from the game remains a secret to the other players (unless the player chooses to say/reveal what it is I suppose).  Is that also the case when random treasures are eliminated from the game, such as via the Isle of Fire MI’s?  For the Isle of Fire MI’s specifically, would the player whose roll eliminates the treasure be able to check what coin it is, or must it remain hidden to all players? (even those whose turn it is)

    Does the Explore Action order of operations on page 62 of the Code always take precedence over Unique Treasure ability text?

    Ex: I explore an island and find Pirate Globe, Pirata Codex, and Savage Natives. I want to apply them in that order, so all treasure is flipped up and then all UT’s are wiped out, including Savage Natives before the Savage Natives can take effect.  However, Savage Natives says “when revealed”, and seems to imply that you cannot load it.  All 3 say “when revealed” so I suppose it wouldn’t matter and the explorer would still get to choose the order they’re applied in.  I suppose my question is if there are any UT’s in the game that force you to apply their effects before you can do step 7 and load face up UT’s? (maybe Wolves?)

    ~~~~~

    Gold Capture: If this ship wins a boarding party, she may capture the crew with the highest point cost instead of eliminating it. A captured crew becomes cargo worth its point cost in gold when unloaded at your home island.

    What happens if a Gold Capture crew steals a Marine, and then that ship gets wrecked on a reef with both crew still aboard?  For example, if a player other than the original owner is able to explore the wreck with a ship capable of using the Gold Capture ability (such as loading Bonny Peel onto an opposing Pirate ship), does it matter which order in which they load the crew?  Theoretically if they load the Gold Capture crew first and the Marine afterwards, they can unload the Marine at home for a gold payout?  Perhaps the order doesn’t matter, unless loading the Marine first causes it to revert to being a full Marine before the Gold Capture ability can be applied.

    Can you unload crew captured via Gold Capture at a wild island?

    If the original Gold Capture crew (such as Bonny Peel) is eliminated or removed from the game when there are captives still aboard, are those captives automatically unloaded at your home island when docking there, or can you choose to keep them aboard because they’re generic cargo?  If you had another Gold Capture crew such as Blackbeard at your home island when docking in this manner, could you load Blackbeard via the free transfer rules and then automatically unload the captives for a payout, or would you have to redock at the HI or explore it in order to unload the captives? (similar to how gold is only automatically unloaded upon docking, not if transferred to a ship already docked at home)

    -If a captured crew is taken or stolen by an opponent other than the original owner, or this ability is cancelled, eliminated, turned facedown, or removed from this ship, the previously captured crew remain generic cargo, cannot use any abilities, and will not count against the ship’s point or cargo limits. They will be worth zero gold when unloaded, unless some source of this ability is also present and active (not cancelled) on the ship.

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #18017
    Ben
    Keymaster

    BIG lot with some complete sets.  The MI LE’s in the pictures make it more interesting, but if I were going for it I would definitely ask them if the CC and DJC sets include the LE’s.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #18016
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Some neat customs!  I do like some of the implications of those Ex-Patriot crew.  Erickson might see usage on a ship with Dories or a Hoist.

    Rynah seems like a really extreme fort.  She has a high gold cost to match, but it will be interesting to see if it might be broken despite that.  It would be the ultimate game extender in 2 player games, because an opponent is extremely unlikely to be able to destroy it. (making it harder to reach a gold endgame condition)

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #18013
    Ben
    Keymaster

    For the purposes of measuring the “S away from home island” for the Mercenary keyword, is that measured from a point on the ship that touches the water (playing surface), or from any point on the ship?  In a recent game Randy and I noticed that it could give Celtic Fury a bigger jump if measuring from the edge of the aftermost stern deck rather than at the waterline.

    If you can measure from any point on the ship, is that measured from the height of that part of the ship to the edge of the island’s height, or just an over-the-top measurement that doesn’t factor in the height differential between the ship part and the height of the home island?

    Do you recall if there was ever a defined “width” of a cannon shot for the purposes of measuring lines of fire in tight spaces?  A few years ago Spence brought up that it should probably be the ~1mm width of a deckplate card since that’s the default measuring device for cannon arcs (which makes a lot of sense to me).

    I know these questions are irrelevant in 99% of games, but hopefully some of them break new ground.  It’s getting to the point where I’ve played so much that the really nitty gritty tiny details get exposed now that so many other (sometimes more basic/consequential) questions have been answered!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17970
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I think Woelf should probably clarify a bit more on the subject. It seems like he’s saying the choices should be made at the same time unless there is an issue where timing is relevant.

    It is an odd gray area. In a competitive environment or with experienced players, the timing will almost always be relevant. At a minimum, player 2 will always want to bring in their +5 selections after player 1 brings in theirs.  Ex: If P1 has no events in their starting fleet but brings in one face down via the +5, P2 is more likely to potentially use their +5 to bring in Favor of the Gods or an event/events of their own to stay more competitive.  Or if P1 brings in a Black Mark crew face up to turn a ship Cursed, P2 might bring in Soul Mark with their +5.

    Considering that it’s usually going to be just crew being added and they generally aren’t getting revealed immediately, all players with a +5 can usually make their choices simultaneously without it really mattering too much.  However, if it is an issue somehow, the choice and placement of the extras should follow the same player order established for initial fleet placement.

     

    In a lot of casual games it won’t matter when +5 stuff is brought in, especially since in my experience a lot of people don’t really consider their +5 selections to be modular based on an enemy fleet – they just built a 65 point fleet in the first place for a 60 point game (with 5 points still separate of course).  The rules are quite vague on it, so I suppose a play group could play it either way.

    I prefer to have it be in turn order rather than at the same time, because the “simultaneous” option could easily get gamey if one player just happens to already have all their crew out and obvious and the other player intentionally delays getting their stuff out and secretly changes some selections based on what they observe.

     

    If a player has both the Hoard ability and “eliminate all of the other ship’s crew” boarding Massacre ability on the same ship and wins a boarding party, can they steal all treasure and eliminate all the enemy crew?  (this is distinct from the RtSS Headhunter, who gives an either/or choice)

    in reply to: Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread #17964
    Ben
    Keymaster

    I only have one copy each of SS 051+052, but both crew chips on them (Shap’ng Tsai and Eileen Brigid O’Brien) have the flag/background art extend to the edge of the chip. Since they both have it, I assume everyone else’s crew chips from those cards are like that as well.  Outside of misprints/miscuts, I think they are the only crew in the game like that. As a result, if you see one of them on an enemy ship, you know it has to be one of those two crew.  Fun little tidbit detail that might help for knowledge purposes once in a great while, especially if trying to determine what kind of Ex-Patriot might be on a non-Mercenary ship.  (such as Tsai on San Cristobal in a competitive game)

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17958
    Ben
    Keymaster

    When are game pieces brought in by 0LR+5 crew chosen, and are they chosen in turn order or at the same time?

    Chosen when on the Placing Crew part of the rules, so after home islands have been chosen and before placing treasure. (theoretically before placing equipment as well, but it seems odd to place them separately from crew in the order of operations)

    They are chosen in turn order.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17936
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can gold from the Gold Capture ability be used to build a fort?

    If this ship wins a boarding party, she may capture the crew with the highest point cost instead of eliminating it. This captured crew becomes cargo worth its point cost in gold when unloaded at your home island.

    If a player uses the Altar of the Loa UT to force an opponent’s ship to explore an island and the Castaway UT is found, I assume that the Altar user chooses which crew is brought into the game based on this line from the Code? (because the Castaway ability only even happens because of the explore action itself)

    The owner of the ship may choose to reveal and use abilities normally, however, if the ability applies specifically to the action you have given to the ship you determine how it is applied.

    Castaway: “Place any one crew with point cost 3 or less on this ship, using standard cargo capacity rules. That crew assumes this ship’s nationality. Remove Castaway from the game.”

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17931
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can you flip an abandoned crew face up just to make it crew so you can use the free transfer rule with it?  Normally you can only flip a crew when using it’s abilities I think, but this seems like a good exception to that since you may want the abandoned crew to be treated as crew as soon as possible after loading them onto a ship.

    No, you can only flip them by using their abilities.

    I can’t find anything in the normal rules or The Pirate Code that forbids a player from turning a crew face up (whether abandoned crew, or regular crew). I find it a little strange that crew cannot be revealed, because in general you may actually want to reveal a crew to an opponent to prove you’re not bluffing about someone you have assigned to a ship. (ex: you can tell them verbally and even pick up the chip and show it to them, but apparently you cannot keep the chip face up on the deckplate)

    You must reveal (turn face up) a crew when using its ability, and it must remain face up the remainder of the game.

    It doesn’t say you can’t reveal them when not using their abilities.

     

    The above discussion about Abandoned Crew has me now wondering, if a Native Canoe finds an abandoned crew, can the canoe use the abandoned crew, seeing the crew doesn’t have a point cost?

    They could carry one face down because it’s treated like treasure that way, but it cannot be face up.    Individual canoes don’t have defined points cost at all, so nothing with a value can be assigned, even if it’s worth 0.

    If Rollando touched a native canoe that was carrying an abandoned crew and chose not to take it, would the abandoned crew be removed from the game because it cannot be face up on the canoe?

    Once per turn, if this ship is touching another ship, reveal all face-down treasure aboard the other ship. This ship can take as much unique treasure from the other ship as she can carry.

    -If a unique treasure is revealed by this ability it does not have to be used immediately, but it remains face up.

    Since Rollando’s ability says “once per turn” (similar to things like the spyer abilities that can be used on any and every player’s turn), could he use his ability on an opponent’s turn?  (ex: if a cancelled native canoe rammed his ship to board and steal a face down abandoned crew, then activate his ability to reveal the abandoned crew and force its removal from the game)

    In the Official Tournament Rules, it talks about a standard round being 30 minutes. Do you know if that was 30 minutes per player in a game, or 30 minutes for the entire game?

    It’s interesting that the victory condition doesn’t include gold in forts.

    A league is a special type of tournament that extends game play throughout an entire month. At this time, the Pirates of the Cursed Seas PocketModel game League format rules are under review, and will be presented again later this year.

    Do you happen to know if the League format rules ever came out, or if you have them? (would be from 2008)

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17926
    Ben
    Keymaster

    T3 continues with its second matchup.

    Today I played the third matchup and it was a doozy… Game 2 got kinda crazy, especially with the sheer volume of options I had to consider before finalizing a potential “path to victory” for one of the fleets….

    Expecting those games to be published this coming Friday through Sunday.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17922
    Ben
    Keymaster

    They’re not as clearly addressed in the rules as forts/events/etc., but are still prominent enough that any organized event needs to account for them one way or another.  If there’s no mention of them, you have to assume they’re legal to use even if some players may not like them.

    Hm. I’ve been using the previous answer about the d6 rolloff method for Tournament #3 games so far, so I might just stick with that method for consistency the rest of the tournament (if MI’s come up again).

    If the island treasure trading ability is used to receive a UT that can’t be loaded, does the UT still apply? (and stay on the island, for example with Altar of the Loa)

    The trading ability takes place immediately before revealing UTs, so if you received the Altar or any other UT that can’t be loaded (Wolves, etc.), it applies normally as if it had been on your current island from the start.

    Does that answer hold if the UT has already been revealed? Ex: I assumed you couldn’t trade for a face-up Altar of the Loa based on the below related entry for Wolves. When I wanted to make the trade, Altar was the only coin on the wild island being targeted, so it wouldn’t have been random.

    -If a ship has the ability to trade treasure from one island to another, it cannot target treasure on an island where Wolves has been revealed because that ability requires the traded treasure to be loaded, which Wolves prevents. If Wolves has not been revealed, even if one or more players know it is there (due to other abilities), the island may be targeted for the swap normally.

    From the entry on Island Treasure Trading:

    -If the island chosen for the trade contains more than one treasure, the choice of token must be random. If one or more of the treasures have been previously revealed and/or they have distinctive backs, it may become necessary to use a draw bag, roll a die, or find some other suitable method to ensure that the choice is random.

    I would contend that a d6 roll is almost a must to determine the random selection (such as 1-2: face up Altar, 3-4: face down coin #1, 5-6: face down coin #2).  If it’s a draw bag, does the treasure that was face up get placed back face up?  If so, it would require an outside entity to ensure that the face down treasures stay hidden. (or have a player that already explored that island look at them to find the coin that needs to be face up and flip it, but the treasure situation on the island could have changed, and could give them an advantage if they had forgotten what else was on the island but then were reminded of it)

    If it’s a draw bag where the coins get essentially shuffled face down and there is no “referee” to oversee the correct treasure getting flipped face up again, is this a way to potentially force a face up treasure to go face down again? (and therefore making it a possible target of future trades again. Quite a specific situation, but adds to my point above about why a reshuffling/draw bag would be problematic in many cases)

    Are all ships affected by the Foul Winds event moved in the exact same direction? I assume so, but it does say “any ship” instead of “all ships”.

    Reveal this event at the beginning of one of your turns and place its token anywhere on the play area (except on an island or a ship). Any ship (except docked ships) within L of the token is moved L in one direction chosen by the player to the left of that ship’s controller. If a ship touches an island, eliminate one of her masts. Remove Foul Winds from the game.

    Can you flip an abandoned crew face up just to make it crew so you can use the free transfer rule with it?  Normally you can only flip a crew when using it’s abilities I think, but this seems like a good exception to that since you may want the abandoned crew to be treated as crew as soon as possible after loading them onto a ship.

    I just want to confirm I have the “Explorer loophole” correct: Ship with 3 total cargo spaces docks at island. She has helmsman and explorer. She unloads the helmsman as part of the explore action and then loads two coins. Explore action ends. Then she uses the free transfer rule to swap out the explorer and get her helmsman back.

    I think that’s the main gist of it?  I’ve had to repeatedly dig into the Explore Action order of operations with some of the tournament games, and the last part really stands out because it doesn’t require loading treasure before unloading crew.

    11) Load or unload facedown UTs, non-unique treasure, and any other cargo as desired and as cargo space allows.

    Thanks!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17914
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Otherwise it sets a precedent and could potentially lead to “I don’t want to play against forts/events in this game. Let’s roll off”.

    The difference between those and MI’s is that forts/events never have their legality or usage in doubt from the standard rules – they’re always fair game.  The rules make specific concessions on Mysterious Islands that create a sort of gray area, which makes me understand the dilemma a bit better.  Ex:

    You can also choose to play them as regular islands with no special effects.

    Mysterious islands chosen as home islands might show game text when placed with the face up. Before starting your game, choose whether or not you want to use that island’s special effects.

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #17909
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Excited to see Universal Pirate Swan in tournament action starting tomorrow.

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17904
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Can a Navigator place a trade current within S of a friendly ship that is lost in a fog bank? If so, is it measured from any part of the fog bank?

    My guess is that it can’t because it’s a fixed range, but it’s not technically being used against or by the lost ship. (instead, “for” it)

    -If an ability, action, or other effect has a fixed range, requires line of sight, affects an area, or requires direct contact between ships, it cannot be used against (or by) a ship that is “lost” in a fog bank. If an ability does not have one or more of those requirements, it may be used against (or by) a ship in a fog bank.

    in reply to: News and Updates Thread #17900
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Sad to hear that Kelly Bonilla passed away. (she was lead designer on Rise of the Fiends, Fire and Steel, and Savage Shores + Return to Savage Shores)

    https://icv2.com/articles/columns/view/56156/rolling-initiative-invoices-lists-rip-kelly-borilla

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17896
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #17885
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The current Fleet Challenge is called Convoy Defense!  Deadline to submit is 3/14. (invite link if you haven’t already joined the discord server)

    in reply to: The eBay Sales thread #17884
    Ben
    Keymaster
    in reply to: Battle Reports #17881
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Here is the series between UPS 4.1 and Kill that UPS!

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17870
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Technically it will trigger, but because it’s happening simultaneously with the sinking and neither specifies priority, the current player can choose to roll for the crew ejection before the ship sinks or to just let it sink first (which will prevent the roll).

    The current player should be the one shooting, so this is an exception to the loser chooses default rule?  (not sure that it matters who rolls for Jonah’s ability)

    -When a crew with this keyword is placed on a ship, that ship immediately gains the Mercenary keyword; if this occurs during setup the ship must immediately be relocated to a position S away from your home island.

    If a ship relocated via this method must be on top of a terrain piece due to space constraints*, is there any interaction with the terrain when the ship is given a move action? (especially if it’s a ship that is entirely contained within an iceberg after the iceberg moves farther “underneath” the ship)  Or is it probably ignored entirely under the “make space if necessary” clause similar to other situations where the only space a game piece could occupy would create an illegal situation?

    *Ex: A huge build total game where 20+ ships surrounded the home island and all had the Mercenary or Ex-Patriot keyword, so terrain nearby was an obstacle to placing them not in contact with terrain.

    Does the L+L range for a swoop attack ignore all other game pieces and islands/terrain that might be in the way for line of fire?

    Can a Sea Dragon land on an iceberg?  Getting really intrigued by this section of the Code:

    -In certain rare situations it is possible for a ship to occupy the exact same position as an iceberg. When this occurs, the ship loses one mast as normal. If the ship moves first it must move entirely off of the iceberg if possible; if the iceberg moves first, the ship remains in place and does not move with the iceberg. In either case, the ship will not take additional damage from that iceberg until they leave contact completely and then move back into contact.

    If you get the Mysterious Island effect “Move an opposing ship using her base move”, can you target an enemy flotilla in order to essentially avoid using the effect?  Or must you choose a ship that can actually move?

    What happens if a Sea Dragon is moved via Mysterious Island on top of an enemy fort?  To me, what takes precedence gets pretty crazy.  Since it’s not considered docked as you can’t dock at an island an enemy fort is on, I thought the fort would be able to shoot in on itself to hit the dragon.  However, there’s also all this:

    If a sea dragon lands in the center of an island, that island will block line of fire to and from the sea dragon except where parts of it (particularly the wingtips) extend outside of the island.

    Lines of fire drawn to and from the fort are not blocked by ships, the island, or any part of the fort itself, but they are blocked by fog banks and icebergs.

    -This list applies only when two or more abilities conflict. When an ability and a rule conflict the ability always takes precedence regardless of the terms used, unless specifically stated otherwise.

    This is a clarification on the Sea Dragon keyword vs. the fort shooting rules, so the dragon can’t be shot at unless the fort’s cannons can hit any parts of the dragon that might be extending past the edge(s) of the island?  (this might take the cake for the most confusing rules question I’ve thought about in some months)

    When using an L-mover, do you have to move the full L, or can you move the ship a partial amount like with a move segment? (“move an enemy ship L in any direction”)

    Where in the rules does it say that icebergs block lines of fire? I didn’t see it in the Code, or scanned copies of the FN or OE rules.  (I’m thinking about trying to protect a ship by somehow getting it to overlap an iceberg, then having an ally keep it entirely contained in the ice with “mover” stuff and using Nemo’s Plans with Runes of Thor/Loki to move the iceberg in a specific direction)

    If a fog bank placed by a smokepot specialist is the exact same size and shape as an existing piece of terrain already in play and the smokebank is placed in exactly the same spot, when a ship comes into contact with this “layered terrain”, I assume they choose which terrain to apply to the ship? (ability doesn’t forbid placing the smokebank in contact with other terrain. Edit: I now see the Code ruling about not placing it in contact with other game pieces, but game piece could be construed as something playable (point/gold cost) rather than an island/terrain, as I don’t see a formal definition of game piece in the Code)

    If a whirlpool is completely surrounded/covered by icebergs, does a ship exiting from that whirlpool have to lose a mast upon exit?  (with no way to place the ship touching the whirlpool while also not touching any of the icebergs)

    I know this is silly, but nothing in the whirlpool rules forbids a player from jumping from one whirlpool to another, back and forth as a stall tactic.

    When any part of your ship or sea creature touches a whirlpool, you may choose to place it so that it touches any other whirlpool on the play area. If you do, roll a d6 after it is moved. On a result of 4-6, eliminate either one mast or segment, one treasure, or one crew from the game piece.

    Using a whirlpool to jump to another whirlpool ends the ship’s entire move action. It cannot shoot (via a Captain), ram, board, or use any other effects that require a move action, until it is given another move action after exiting the second whirlpool.

    It may not have been given a move action….

    A smokebank is created. Calypso then creates a whirlpool touching the smokebank. A ship is moved into the smokebank. On the beginning of a player’s next turn, the smokebank disappears, forcing the ship out.

    -When the smoke (fog bank) is to be removed, if there are any ships “lost” inside the player whose turn it is should roll for each of their exit locations, place them accordingly, and then remove the fog bank.

    The ship ends up touching the whirlpool created by Calypso. Which player decides if the ship goes through to a different whirlpool – the player whose turn it is, or the player who controls the ship being placed by the player whose turn it is?

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17867
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Does Jonah’s ability apply to a hit that sinks a ship?  Or does the ship sink without needing to roll one last time for the ability?

    When this ship is hit, roll a d6. On a result of 5 or 6, move the crew on this ship with the highest point cost to a wild island chosen by the player to your left.

    Is Ghostly Encounter still worth gold if the ship has the ability of “This ship’s crew cannot be eliminated”? (I assume you just wouldn’t bother rolling, but wanted to make sure the UT still functions)

    Once after revealing, roll a d6 for each crew on the ship. On a result of 1, that crew is eliminated. Ghostly Encounter is worth gold equal to the crew remaining on the ship after all dice are rolled.

    Can you bring in a 0 point crew with the +5 selection of a 0LR+5 crew? If so, can you go through part of the Setup phase (I think only when going second and an opponent chooses their +5 selections before you do) with an illegal situation on a ship that is then resolved by a crew like Jonah coming in via the +5?  Or must the point cap restriction element be fully resolved by the initial X points of your fleet? (very niche use case, and only good for a very brief deke of which crew are on a ship while your opponent might be considering your fleet while making their own +5 selections, with them going first)

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17861
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Planning to go live tomorrow at 8am PST for the first game of Tournament #3. The live streamed game in January went fine, so I scheduled this one. Hopefully will go off without a hitch.  Once all the games of the play-in matchup have been posted, I’ll show the updated tournament bracket.

    in reply to: Battle Reports #17859
    Ben
    Keymaster

    The first competitive series of the year was a doozy!  Here’s Game 1:

    in reply to: The Fleets Thread #17848
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Here’s my latest:

    Video(s) of it in action coming this Sunday!

    in reply to: Introduce Yourself! Join the Crew! #17846
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Hi there. I just got back into this game after (somewhat foolishly) donating my old collection back in 2017 (but I’m making plans to get it back). Pirates was my childhood and I still love it to this day, and I’m glad I finally found a group that is still interested in it as well

    Welcome aboard, glad to have you here!  😀

    in reply to: Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code #17840
    Ben
    Keymaster

    What if both players only bring Isles of Fire MI’s? (no islands can be HI’s)  Would you have to just ignore the ability text for all of them?

    Isle of Fire: This island can be used only as a wild island. At the beginning of his or her turn, the active player rolls a d6. On a result of 6, randomly eliminate one treasure coin from this island.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #17837
    Ben
    Keymaster

    Yeah I think that would work, I would just change the last sentence slightly: “This ship gets +1 to her cannon rolls against the target ship and +S to her base move when moving in a direct line toward the target ship.”

    I could still see some rules questions coming up. I think you would need to move all segments in the direct line, including the +S or else it could get gamey.

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #17834
    Ben
    Keymaster

    You wouldn’t have to use it every turn. Yes the +S is treated like a regular movement bonus, you wouldn’t be required to move in a straight line toward the target ship, but you would be required to move toward the target every turn that ship is a target. I suspect the language might need to be cleared up a bit….

    In my opinion, custom creators (myself included as many of mine are probably not this way) should get in the habit of saying “you may”/etc to make abilities sound less mandatory. Based on how many original abilities are optional, it’s a bit of an odd aspect of the game that I think Wizkids got wrong.

    The +S gets extremely subjective.  If not in a straight line, what determines whether or not the ship is moving towards the target?  An opponent could demand a certain angle of approach requirement is met.  Then you have whirlpool “shortcuts” that could expedite the travel by heading in the opposite direction.

    If you’re looking for a cost on Destiny’s Shadow, I would start at 12+ depending on the cannons (seems similar to Black Arrow from RotF). I recommend adding “of her” to the end of the ability text so players can’t interpret it as “within S of whatever I want”.

Viewing 30 posts - 391 through 420 (of 2,325 total)