@admin
Active 4 hours, 4 minutes ago-
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
Santa Slaughter – Christmas Evil
12/18/2022
For years I have wanted to play a holiday themed game in December using the Sleigh and Captain Whitebeard. I’ve never liked the game pieces because they’re broken […]
-
Ben commented on the post, The Importance of using proper L and S measurements vs. full card lengths. 3 years, 11 months ago
Indeed, I’ve thought about the rounded corners before and how they make it somewhat ambiguous for the full card length method to be used. Due to that and other reasons, I don’t think groups should allow full card measuring. I think it misleads new players, it lies about what S and L actually are when compared to the rules (since it’s actually…[Read more]
-
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
Measurements of L and S compared to full card measurements
This year I’ve noticed many players measuring L and S incorrectly, usually by using a full card length of a ship deckplate on the top side or using a […]
-
Edge versus bar is an important distinction to make. At a 1:1 comparison they’re really not that different, but the slightly greater width of the card would add up significantly over the course of several measurements.
I can think of at least two good reasons for why WK used the printed bars instead of the full physical edge. First, it’s possible for the actual length/width of a card to vary slightly. Maybe not within a single set, and in hindsight I don’t think they did change much, but the potential was always there, whether intentional or not. Plenty of other game publishers have had issues in the past where cards in an expansion set didn’t quite match with cards from the base game, simply because they used a different printing company, or the same printing company changed their equipment in between. The other reason is that the rounded corners of the cards make it hard to find the exact corner, which in turn makes it difficult to determine the actual full size of the card along the edge where the measurement is actually happening. Cutting it back to a continuous bar avoids that issue.
As for how close is “close enough”, I think the black lines are definitely within that margin of error, especially considering how much fudge factor is inherent within any measurement made with the game. Subtle differences in how you place your ship along the bar, or even the physical shape of the ship’s hull can technically affect the distance it gets moved, not to mention any shifts that happen just from being bumped into by something else, even from removing the measuring card/tool itself.
If certain players or even groups insist upon using the full length/width of a card instead of the bars, or custom measuring tools that match the full sizes of the cards, it can be allowed, but only if everyone playing gets to do the same. That’s a big part of why the Pirate Code includes a note that says custom things are allowed as long as they’re made available to all players (Peripherals, Page 6). If you’re playing with a new player or new group, it’s a good idea to watch closely for the first turn or two to see how they’re measuring things, so don’t find out halfway through the game that someone was gaining an advantage, even if unintentional.
The most important thing is to be consistent on a group/game level. As long everyone is measuring the same way, it should be fine. The trouble starts when measuring methods get mixed up.
-
Indeed, I’ve thought about the rounded corners before and how they make it somewhat ambiguous for the full card length method to be used. Due to that and other reasons, I don’t think groups should allow full card measuring. I think it misleads new players, it lies about what S and L actually are when compared to the rules (since it’s actually S+6mm), it increases fudge factor due to the rounded card edges, and it takes players even more away from the base game in an era where I’ve seen more house rules and playgroup confusion than ever. (different house rules lead to very different expectations, which gets ugly because that in turn affects fleet building happening prior to the game. I always do a lot to mitigate that, but sometimes people don’t bother reading a group’s house rules or they bring a “surprise” player that isn’t aware of any of them) In addition, although the difference may be minimal, technically if my calculations are correct, S gets about a +.6mm relative “bonus” compared to L when using full card lengths instead (63.5mm-57.5mm vs 89.2mm-83.8mm).
-
-
-
Ben commented on the post, Gaming in Seattle – 5 players, 60 points! (December 9th, 2022) 3 years, 11 months ago
Agreed! I’d love to do a larger meetup in LA and Vegas at different points.
-
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
Gaming in Seattle – 5×60
12/9/2022
This report is a summary of a 5 player, 6o point game played at Oasis Tea Zone in Seattle Washington as part of a U-District Board Game Meetup. We use these house rules, and g […]
-
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
2×60 on VASSAL
12/7/2022
This game was Kyle’s first on the VASSAL module! We set up for a 2×60 game using our regular Seattle Pirates house rules. All game pieces can be found in the Master Spreadsheet. He […]
-
Ben replied to the topic Holiday Booty Giveaway Contest! in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
Thank you to everyone who participated in the 2022 Holiday Booty Giveaway Contest! I have read/watched all the submitted Battle Reports and here are the results in regards to the extra prizes. There were only 6-7 total entrants so everyone will get the standard goodies!
Entrants- Skelebone 1, Skelebone 2, Skelebone 11/29, Skelebone 12/2 (twice…
-
Ben replied to the topic Game Ideas in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
Just added these to the main post:
-Maelstrom battle from At World’s End. Ex: big whirlpools that ships can get stuck in as they go around it in a circle on bad rolls. +Big whirlpool “black hole” that sucks all game pieces toward it on a roll of 1 each round? Or, have a circular ocean that is one big whirlpool. There are different “lanes” in…[Read more]
-
Ben replied to the topic Holiday Booty Giveaway Contest! in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
December 4th is the last day for submissions!
-
Ben replied to the topic Strategy/Gameplay discussion thread in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
Something I’ve barely thought of before: utilizing the ships you capture to build new nationalities of forts during a game. Ex: Start with a pure American fleet, but once you capture a French ship, build Paradis.
-
Ben replied to the topic The Fleets Thread in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
60 Point American fleet
USS Constitution + captain, helmsman, tribal chieftain
Destiny + Wayne Nolan, Brent Rice, captain, chain shot
Hessian + helmsman, shipwright, oarsman
American Native Canoes
UT’s: Weapons, Enemy of the State, Power Cannons, Marines
Islands: not too far apart due to max speed of L+S, but want some room to flex Destiny’s max…[Read more] -
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
Americans vs. Pirates
11/30/2022
I played against a friend in another game heavy on learning and introducing new game mechanics/keywords/etc. We mostly used these house rules, and all the game pieces can be f […]
-
Ben replied to the topic Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
If native canoes find the Message in a Bottle UT upon exploring, is only one transferred to the new location?
-
Ben replied to the topic Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
If the flotilla keyword is cancelled, can it still shoot through itself?
Asking for a friend: do derelicts block lines of fire?
On dismasted ships with Oarsman: are there undesirable outcomes that are avoided by not letting these ships ram other ships? This has come up frequently this year, where a player feels they should be able to ram and…[Read more]
-
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
Pair of 3 Player Games
11/26/2022
I met up with Witch and Phillip for some 60 point action in Tacoma Washington! We ended up with a pair of 3 player games, though the second would be short and sweet due to […]
-
Ben commented on the post, Game Modes for playing Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
Exactly, we both agree she’s not worth banning even in a “Limited” setting.
-
Ben replied to the topic The Fleets Thread in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
70 Point Durable Endeavour build
HMS Endeavour + RotF HGold, Brother Virgil, DJC Davy Jones, 2 points left for Ralph David + oarsman, or RotF TvTyne (up to 12 masts/turn), or Oarsman + Letter of Marque/Lucky the Parrot/etc.
HMS Lord Kenyon + Robinson, Thomas Gunn (F&S), Lord Mycron, navigator
+Oarsman on HIIdea is to copy Lord Kenyon’s ability…[Read more]
-
Ben commented on the post, Game Modes for playing Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
Thanks for the feedback!
Longshanks is a reasonable candidate for Limited, but I didn’t want to go too far down the rabbit hole of banning treasure runners that are “too good”. Generally stopped at Bloody Jewel. If you ban Longshanks, Bonnie Liz probably gets banned too, and then it opens up Monarca and various others. I know it’s subjective,…[Read more] -
Ben replied to the topic The Videos Thread in the forum Pirates CSG 3 years, 11 months ago
Also plenty of game footage up from recent playing!
-
Ben wrote a new post 3 years, 11 months ago
Game Modes for playing Pirates CSG
Important to note: None of this is official.Through the years many complaints have been lodged by the Pirates CSG community regarding game pieces that are “too good”, […]
-
I think these formats looked to be very well thought out and I like the bans in each. I like that the Semi-Limited format only deals with the most egregious pieces, but still leaves most things untouched and would be far more enthusiastic about potentially playing in more serious events with those rules settings. Personally I feel that “how Wizkids intended” is more that they just had a hands off approach to the game, which has always put me off trying to play the game more competitively.
I’m actually surprised at how many things you’ve hit in the Limited format, but it definitely includes a lot of the biggest players so it would actually be quite interesting to see what people might come up with in this format as well.
A few ships that didn’t make your list that I had on a list I’d already made myself were Longshanks, HMS Oxford and La Bonne Chance. The first two are just too cheap for how good they are in my opinion and I think the speed of La Bonne Chance makes it too overbearing against smaller ships. Arguably all these ships are still a step down from a lot of the ships you’ve banned for Limited though so I’m not sure they necessarily need dealing with.
-
Thanks for the feedback!
Longshanks is a reasonable candidate for Limited, but I didn’t want to go too far down the rabbit hole of banning treasure runners that are “too good”. Generally stopped at Bloody Jewel. If you ban Longshanks, Bonnie Liz probably gets banned too, and then it opens up Monarca and various others. I know it’s subjective, but wanted to not ban a ton of ships simply for being good.I don’t think Oxford or Bonne Chance should be considered for Limited. Neither are all that overpowered, and Oxford brings up a similar rabbit hole to Longshanks – if Oxford is banned, then Dover and London probably need it too. Bonne Chance to me is just a simple and good gunship. Other ships are capable of similar damage outputs for the same total cost (Raven, Executioner, etc).
-
Statistically the La Bonne Chance does much more damage than both of those examples when you consider the built-in reroll and she also has an extra mast. I’d argue she’s more like a faster version of the HMS Nautilus. Like I said before though I do still think she’s a step down from the Limited bans you currently have so I wouldn’t really push much for her inclusion.
-
Exactly, we both agree she’s not worth banning even in a “Limited” setting.
-
-
-
-
I would amend the section on Shipwrights in Limited to read “Shipwrights gain the text ‘This crew does does not take up cargo space.'” Gets the same point across, but reads more like it gains the ability rather than a simple rule change.
-
Good point, but that originated from the Seattle house rules where the intention was for it to be a rule rather than an ability. Partly so it wouldn’t violate the No-Stacking Rule with Oarsman that also doesn’t take up cargo space. I understand the distinction could be a little confusing. I think I’d prefer to play more games with the house rule before changing anything.
-
-
Have you considered a draft game mode? I know the logistics would be rather expensive with the packs not being cheap anymore. But I was considering something like players get 3 packs. They open each pack and select 1 ship or crew from each pack. Then the rest go into an open pot. Players roll off for selection once everyone has selected roll off again till the pot is gone? Heck maybe even play a little game of liars dice for it if you want and have time. Lol open to suggestions.
-
Brian,
Sounds like fun! That seems to be a hybrid of a couple different things I’ve seen done in the past – a sealed pack game (where people build a fleet from the packs they open), and a Draft format. On page 6 of the old tournament rules, there is a section about sealed events. At Miniature Trading we had both a Draft Fleet Challenge and a Sealed Pack Fleet Challenge, but unfortunately most of the threads involving them seem to be lost to the depths.I don’t think I’ve heard of the idea of combining both though. I can add that to the Game Ideas page.
-
Cool ya it just so happens that I bought a whole bunch of boxes of packs. Cuse I make smart financial decisions without impulsive actions. And I just wanted to see what you thought.
-
Sealed pack games would be a fun way to break some of them out! Especially if you plan to open all of them soon anyway – might as well get the experience of a sealed format before doing so again requires a further purchase.
-
-
-
-
- Load More
