@admin
Active 1 hour, 20 minutes agoForum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Ben
KeymasterWhen I first read the heading I thought this would be more about running up the score after it was obvious the game had already been decided.
That might be one of the only reasons to reveal gold when it’s unloaded at HI’s. Sometimes the game can seem close but in reality it’s a blowout, which isn’t known until the end. Which is why I sometimes like to have all the players peek at the last coin or two in play – if the final 1 gold in play won’t decide who wins, it can be better to save the 20 minute ram and board festivities and start another game or something.
As far as taking just enough risks to squeeze out a win, to me that’s the whole point of the game. If you always play it safe, you might have a more consistent win/loss record over a large number of games, but you’ll be on the losing side when someone takes the extra risk and pulls it off.
Perhaps that’s what happened in some of the tournament games, or just the big games at the end to celebrate the tournaments and fleets. Though since I don’t have more evidence of it (yet), maybe just a coincidence. It would be a largely pointless project to go through my BR’s to find more evidence of this happening… but interesting haha.
I’m yet to see a perfect system for it, but that’s largely what’s being attempted by the various house rules where remaining ships are factored into victory conditions along with gold collected.
Exactly. I love “points in play + gold” for the win, in terms of realism. Just need to test it out more… I wasn’t going to use that in the big game I hope to play within the next 2 months, but I think I’ll consider it. (biggest problem is the amount of gold required… 6 fleets at 150 points XD. Could have low gold values but multiplied by 10; 3 3’s could be worth 90 gold.)
Ben
KeymasterDrop that boost (or make it just 1 point instead of 2)
Huh. I think Wizkids placed Marine at 6 points, which is shown with crew like Grim the Savage from F&S (one of the super basic Marines). The boost seems like 1 point, while the 5 point Marines have -1 from Hostile. “Benoit de Marsilles” (original spelling from BC “final” WK spreadsheet) was one of the early basic Marines and costs 6 points even in that spreadsheet. Just saw an early version of the keyword where you could put it on islands containing enemy forts. 🙂
I would definitely like Marines at 3 and Musketeers at 2. I also think that if the entire game or crew were recosted, captain and helmsman should be the only off-limits abilities, to keep things simple and not have them based on the opposite instead (requiring both of those to go to 5+ points). Compared to the usefulness of captain and helmsman, I could see Musketeer at 1 and Marine at 2-3.
You make good points as always. I think it’s good to have lots of options so people can experiment with house rules if they want. I could certainly live with Marines having +1 to boarding in addition to their existing keyword for a base of 5 points. A little less incentive to drop them at an island, but they have never been very successful on land for me anyway.
Part of the reason I suggested a 1S gun is because Marines are rather lame and ineffective in the game, while they arguably should be one of the more elite crew units. Plus, I’ve rolled a ton of 1’s while shooting, so to me the better odds are almost needed to feel decent about the shot I’m paying a premium for. XD
Ben
Keymaster@Holofernes: Huzzah! Was afraid you might have been washed out to sea with the tide or drowned in the sinking of the Miniature Trading. 😉 But not really. 😀
Super happy to see you here.
Ben
KeymasterHere is a seller with a lot of Spanish Main stuff. Plus a custom made island/terrain set.
Ben
KeymasterLet the bidding continue! Some new listings up: https://ebay.to/2NVjS9W
Ben
KeymasterBunch of nice auctions ending today/tonight!
Edit: Overall a few things went for a little more than I expected. Big lot of OE for $89. The common/uncommon lot of OE/RotF was weird, since it went for $35, whereas the previous similar lot with a bunch of rares only went for $15.
Ben
KeymasterThe original idea was for a generic marine as it was written by WK, but costed at 4-5 points. I’ll run some of the ideas here past JW. At the worst we just go with the first option, a generic marine at 4-5 points, with no other abilities or extra stuff.
Cool, I think 4 points would be a good starting place since 5 is a lot to pay for what they do.
In my opinion, I like the idea of Marines being able to target specific crew. It makes sense to me if they ignore defensive abilities on an island, but I think if they’re on a ship, maybe count as one of the ship’s cannons/guns, at least in the way of the Vega/Algernon ability. However, I think for a generic crew, what WK made might work on its own. I could see it either way, house-ruling to include the add-ons, or remaining as WK made them.
Indeed. These ideas are with the goal of making them more useful, since even the 5 point Marines are almost never worth the cost to use.
Glad to see some responses, thank you!
Ben
KeymasterIt’s funny you mentioned Marines, JW and I are thinking about giving every faction a Generic Marine in one of his upcoming Custom sets. We could implement these ideas to make a “new” marine crew.
Makes sense to me. They’re more special than Musketeers but I think it would make sense if there were a lot more of them. The real trouble lies in the costing; Marine would be fine at 3 or 4 points if only Musketeer had been accurately priced at 2 (or even 1?) by Wizkids from the start. Of course, Marines are theoretically going to be more effective anyway, so perhaps they can just be better crew. XD I must say I like the idea of giving them +1 to boarding rolls, even if that’s not an ability I care much about.
I see you haven’t quite given up the customs game just yet. 😉 😛
Ben
KeymasterThis is why I love the internet. Today alone I have messaged and gotten responses from Woelf, Holofernes, and Tiffany O’Brien. I also got in contact with Piranha (Tony Vigil, the original Rules Arbitrator) within the past week. 😀
Now we just need more people posting on the Forum! ^
Ben
KeymasterI actually did retcon it to this. I think you wee the one who said that hiding LIMIT inside the keyword was silly, and so I changed it to that version.
Cool; I thought so but wanted to post things the way I did in case that hadn’t happened yet.
Carronades are incredible. I’ve read enough naval history books to know that those abilities should be pretty fitting. If anything it could be more devastating, but I like the cost of 3. I thought about a point-blank range bonus (like eliminating cargo instead of crew, or 2 crew, etc), but I don’t want to force people to get into measuring half-S or new made-up ranges just to use it.
Halgeren is a strange crew, designed to be powerful mostly by combining a bunch of reasonably decent but not great abilities into one crew for a cost that could be competitive. I see him being used on a high-cargo hybrid or a 10 master with Dories, maybe even something fast like HMS Swallow to take advantage of Unholy Light for scouting. (World Hater would be great of course because of that nice offensive ability)
Ben
KeymasterHistorical Custom of the Day #428
Carronade
Equipment
3 points
Ability: This ship gains one 2S cannon that can fire from any mast (even an eliminated mast), but cannot have its range increased. When this cannon hits, eliminate one mast and one crew from the enemy ship. This cannon may be used with other equipment. Ships may use up to two Carronades in one turn.Really excited about this. One of the more important weapons in the late stages of sailing naval combat. Absolutely devastating at short range and when combined with grape shot.
Amethyst
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
Rarity: R
Point Value: 10
Number of Masts: 1
Cargo Space: 2
Base Move: S+S
Cannons: 3L+L
Ability: Mercenary. Schooner. Hidden Gold. [This ship has 2 extra cargo spaces that may only be assigned treasure.] (Modified version of original keyword by Xerecs)Flavor text: The Amethyst is a tricky opponent. As her name implies, she is often laden with valuable cargo. However, sometimes she carries even more than can be expected of a ship her size, leading pirates to pass her up in favor of large treasure galleons. When an approach is made, the Amethyst is usually able to deter the ship by using her surprisingly long-range cannons as a warning.
Deilzenar Halgeren
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
Rarity: U
Point Value: 8
Ability: Ex-Patriot. Unholy Light. Once per turn, you may eliminate TWO of this ship’s crew to give her an extra action. When this ship rolls a 6 to hit, also eliminate one cargo from the enemy ship.Flavor text: The son of wealthy Austrian parents, Halgeren left Europe to pursue massive profits on the high seas. He may soon attain that goal when wars break out all over the oceans. His greed has led to a few chance encounters with Fitzgerald, who seemingly taught him a thing or two.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterThe crew elimination ability seems useful, and makes the most sense. I’ve always found the Marine and Musketeer ability to eliminate masts rather comical, since you’d expect them to be carrying, well, a musket.
Haha! Exactly! The concept of mast elimination (and how it doesn’t slow down ship speeds) has always been rather strange in this game. That reminds me, I still need to finish making my custom Carronade equipment.
One change I would make is how they’re eliminated. Instead of two hits in the same turn, I think it should be two hits from the same shoot action (ignoring any ship or crew abilities that eliminate crew during shoot actions). In my mind, that would give them a bit more durability and make them more worth the investment.
I agree with that as well! I think a combination of small changes could be an interesting way to go about it as well. Perhaps adding that change, +1 to boarding rolls, AND making the cannon 1S would make them worth 6 points. (barely? XD)
Adding your idea to the main post! Thanks for commenting!
Ben
KeymasterExecration
Type: Ship
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: C
Point Value: 14
Number of Masts: 3
Cargo Space: 2
Base Move: L
Cannons: 2S-3L-2L
Ability: Fear. L-range cannons cannot hit this ship.Flavor text: Foul misdeeds follow those who have lived through an encounter with the Execration. It seems as though anyone who loses a battle with the ship’s crew but survives is cursed to commit sin. For some, that can be worse than simply getting slaughtered. Case in point – a man who mistakenly murdered his young daughter in a fit of rage.
Illmeth
Type: Crew
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: C
Point Value: 4
Ability: Fear. Every time this ship hits an enemy ship, you may choose whether to eliminate masts or crew.
Link: Devil’s SlumberFlavor text: His name strikes fear into he hearts of sailors. For it should – Illmeth is personally responsible for over a thousand deaths, and he’s only a Master Gunner!
Demon’s Den
Type: Fort
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: C
Gold Cost: 8 gold
Cannons: 2L-2L-2L-2L
Ability: Crew with “demon” in their names can use their abilities while in this fort, if applicable.Flavor text: Unlike the Repository, the Archfiend Demoncense only lets the best of the best into this fort. Demons treat the fort like a sanctum, always prepared to worship at the shrine.
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterBig win today. Managed to increase the speed of the home page and main forum page – Google’s PageSpeed Insights tool now shows a perfect 100 score on desktop for both. Mobile is only at 74, but lately it’s been in the 27-34 range, so still a big improvement. So for now I might kinda rest on that since it can get technical, confusing, and time-consuming, but I hope to optimize the speed of the site more in the future. (now it’s kind of a “ain’t broke, don’t fix it” thing, as some of my efforts to improve the site in the past backfired and I had to revert back.) I’m not sure that the page speeds will be better on all pages, but those 2 are the main ones that get a lot of traffic, and are of course the most important ones in general. Sometime I’ll probably test out speeds on other pages as well. If certain things don’t load immediately (especially avatars), just be aware that the deferred stuff is making the rest of the stuff faster as far as I know.
I’ve also been adding the eBay RSS feed to pretty much all of the sidebars. Sometimes that may depend on how hot eBay is; right now there are a bunch of quality auctions up, so I don’t feel shy about advertising the good deals to be had. (of course they might not end up selling for cheap with sniping haha)
Ben
KeymasterMaking the rounds and finding a few things:
4 pounds of cards, total mystery lot: https://ebay.to/2JEfE0Z
Same thing but 8 pounds: https://ebay.to/2XKlQto
Lot with some useful crew: https://ebay.to/2JEEkX5
Roanoke: https://ebay.to/2SelcTz
HMS Titan: https://ebay.to/30taHPeBen
KeymasterI have to admit I was wrong about the DJC LE’s. Thought there might be a bit less demand nowadays. The roundup:
Tarantula: $31
Pandora’s Box: $10.50
Judas: $36
Blackgate: $31.50
Dance: $6.50
Salem: $29.50
Black Gentleman: $24.50
El Pluton: $10.50Grand Wind: $26
Guess attention now shifts to the kendarus auctions: https://ebay.to/30xZz3H
Starting to wonder if a bunch of those will get crazy too… though much less rare stuff in most of them.Ben
KeymasterBen
KeymasterAlthough, it might be a little difficult to make a physical model for this, since forts only have room for 8 flags…. I suppose you could squeeze some in on the sides.
Definitely should be simple because of how the slotted flags should sit on the non-slotted fort walls. It’s also the type of thing that would deserve a custom fort with a special configuration.
I think I have heard that song; it’s ironic because I may have seen the Fantasia show at Disney World in Florida in 2000. XD (if not, a year right around then)
Ben
KeymasterResponding to Report 7:
Love that midsize American launch. Especially the Mohican setup; one of the most underrated 3 masters. Love the maxed out crew setups in general, makes a lot of sense given the gold available.
Notre Dame looks cool and intimidating. Love the realistic shadows at 6:42.
Love the grand wide angle shots showing pretty much the whole ocean; those are still my favorites for the most part. Really gives me a better idea of where all the factions are and the HI locations/etc, not to mention the big scale.
I hope the French don’t just sit on the gold and get a worse position in the standings simply because they didn’t launch enough.
No don’t kill Marty! XD
So funny to see Ophidious decapitated! Glad they did that though, I think someone needed to hit those English Mycrons.
Just when the Pirates started to look down and out, they get some capital ships (including the Zeus), and then a trio of Merc cancellers. Whoa. 🙂
24:46: Wow, they’ve basically got an assembly line factory going on. XD Along with lines of battle to partition off their waters. Amazing. Brilliant use of the hoist. They have more gold than they can realistically spend. The English battle fleet of CG1 with ~800 gold was extremely powerful. Spanish have like 4x the spending power. O_O
Cursed ConcH, btw not Conk. 🙂
Wow that English turn of shooting reminds me of some of my worst turns in big games from 2011/2012. Now I see what JW was talking about. XD
30:19 A perspective I’m not used to seeing; makes me think the French should launch gunships and start whittling away at the Spanish gold fleet from around the island.Ben
KeymasterIn addition to that some of the factions need to be SHOWN that the Spanish are a threat, and others are hesitant to fight an ally.
I think it’s pretty obvious – even if they don’t have a ton of gunships in the water, they could quickly and easily. Their biggest obstacle might actually be logistics and space constraints, but they could get a launch point in more open waters if they wanted to.
If I do a point count I might only post it here and on the FB group, since I don’t really want to make a video about it. I don’t think I’ll have surpassed CG1 o CG3 though.
I think it would make sense to at least mention it in a video at the beginning or end of a report, since people might see the reports for years to come without seeing a text writeup. I think the recorded high of 3,516 points from CG1 is very much within reach, but more launching probably needs to happen first.
Ah, Pirates and Spanish as possible friends. Quite the alien concept in my games. XD
Ben
KeymasterMI packs and some singles including the DJC LE’s ending today! (depending on time zone)
Also, kendarus may have lowered their prices on some lots. Some of them look pretty solid for someone getting started that’s looking to play, especially the punched BC lot. (look at description – looks like only deckplates for most of the punched lots)
Ben
KeymasterI’ll admit this is dumb, but I couldn’t help it after discovering it through a fittingly WICKED EPIC SONG. (found the name of this “fort” in youtube comment and looked it up) (That will be one of the songs of The World Game if it ever gets played)
Showed this to my dog. It now has three heads and guards the gates of Tartarus.
Tartarus
Type: Fort
Faction Affiliation: Cursed
Rarity: LE
Gold Cost: 500 gold
Cannons: 3L-3L-2S-2S-2S-2S-2S-2S-3L-3L
Ability: Fear. Sea creatures may repair at this fort. Sea creatures within L of this fort get +4 to their d6 rolls. Sea creatures may be launched from this fort regardless of game rules. Enemy ships that come within S of this fort lose all their masts and cargo. This fort’s cannons cannot be eliminated. If a non-Cursed ship docks at this fort, replace all of that ship’s masts with fire masts.Flavor text: “In Greek mythology, Tartarus is the deep abyss that is used as a dungeon of torment and suffering for the wicked and as the prison for the Titans.”
Absurd and silly, but perhaps some things are too epic to be used in Pirates? XD
You can find my custom sets here: Pirates of the Age of Sail and Pirates of the Epic Seas
Ben
KeymasterPlaying around with the top menu a bit. It was time for Blog to get demoted, but that made the bottom row about half empty, so I added the Information category down there. Might add one more thing soon to fill it out. I’m at 113 pages and 521 posts, so lots of content to attempt to prioritize!
Edit: Just updated the Information and Stats page. Removed most links to Miniature Trading + updated some other links. Also added the rules and a note about the MT saved post. Plus some other minor changes. Feedback welcome as always.
Ben
KeymasterHi everyone, I’m the same Phymatine who was on Miniature Trading. Thanks for setting this up, Ben!
Ahoy matey, great to see you here as well!!
Ben
Keymaster(reposted from youtube)
Love it!! Lots of great grand shots at the beginning.
Spanish should basically run away with the game, especially since some of the other factions are fighting each other and not forming an anti-Spanish coalition. (which hasn’t been discussed?)
Nice to see your factions going at it. This gave me a new idea for a dumb custom. XDThe Spanish chain exploring is super long, but that can make it incredibly vulnerable. Wondering if a faction will be daring enough to suicide a ship into the line and make it falter. Then all the ships have to regroup or add a new one to replace. XD Makes me wonder what I wondered back when I may have been the first to do it – it’s possible that you could profit more from regular gold running. But of course, chain exploring is super convenient since you don’t have to move those ships every turn, which speeds things up. I think that’s actually why the Spanish did it in the 2011 cumulative game – it was a novel idea, and probably helped me get through some of their long turns lol. XD
Looks like the Cursed are this year’s French. ?? (massive eye rolling) That player could be booted from the game with other people taking over their factions. I mean don’t the Cursed want to win? You all know what you’re getting into with these games at this point; there should be no surprise at all at the time commitment.
Though I like how the Chum Maker is just casually showing up. XD Forgot you had her. “hey I kinda stink but I’m worth way more than you guys!” ? (though not the Guichuan)Hate Pirata Codex, such a fun ruiner. Does make things simple and easier to (not) remember though.
Do you guys always play all together, or do people sometimes take their faction turns alone or with 1 other person around as well? Quite the time feat if it’s always everyone there.
Looks like at least 3000+ points in play. If you do a point count it would be cool to record if you surpass CG1 as the second biggest game ever. If the Spanish go on a long launching spree and fill their area with massed ships they could surpass the CG3 American fleet as the biggest ever.
Love how grand the ocean is. I know it must be annoying sometimes reaching into the middle area. Someday I hope to have an ocean with a big hole in the middle where I can crawl under and pop up in the middle for easier playing on a big ocean. XD (along with tables that move/slide easily in order to get to stuff.)
Not really sure who to root for. The Pirates seem to be in trouble. I like what the Americans have been doing. Kinda hoping the Cursed or someone will start to get reckless against the Spanish.
Ben
KeymasterMy Turtle Mania game featured a bizarre and extremely niche new gameplay idea.
And that is where a new (?) concept or game idea was born: chain capturing. At the upper right, the Floating Stone of Tsai’s fleet was able to capture the remaining two ships of the other Jade fleet by herself (Hansan Island had been recently sunk). Back and forth they went, with each fleet controlling 1 or 2 ships each turn of the three pictured. Eventually Tsai’s fleet was able to chain together enough successful moves, and the captured Dragon’s Talon was within capturing distance (S+S rowing distance in this case) of Tsai’s own ship, the Proud Tortoise. The PT was reclaimed for his own Jade fleet (this is hard to even put into words because of how confusing it is lol), completing the chain of captures that led to the elimination of the other Jade fleet! XD This is one of those bizarre occurrences that would only happen in a very similar situation, with lots of oared ships that are “capturable” (aka no oarsmen) and moving amongst each other and jockeying for towing position on just about every turn.

Ben
KeymasterIn a long-overdue experiment, I have added an eBay RSS feed to the Forum sidebar at the bottom. Apparently there isn’t a way to make the images for the listings display there, but that would probably just slow the pages down anyway. I checked the speed of the forum page after the change and it didn’t show any slowdown. I will probably simplify it again soon since the Buy and Watch List buttons don’t link out to eBay.
This is not an endorsement of the deals that show up. Just another way to hopefully monetize the site. (assuming the affiliate links work properly)
I am hoping to only ever have ads on PwB that are hyper-relevant – meaning mostly Pirates CSG stuff. The only other ads I might try at some point would be to similar interests, such as PotC movies/music and naval history books.
Ben
KeymasterThat’s why they get “removed from the game” instead of “eliminated”. They’re not dead, and they could very well find their way home again, but it won’t happen quickly enough to affect the current game.
Interesting insight.
If there weren’t any friendly ships nearby, maybe the enemy ship that just blasted the sinking ship could take prisoners that are worth gold or something like that (although this would be better suited to an actual crew/ship ability rather than a full-time option).
I do think Ransom and Gold Capture could have been much more frequently seen abilities. Game pieces of the Pirate faction could perhaps “press” the survivors into service. But perhaps other things would be changed along the way so crew might die more frequently – perhaps cannon rolls of 6 eliminate crew or cargo.
I feel like this game has an endless amount of potential tweaks and small house rules that you could play around with for decades of playing. Kinda overwhelming to think about though.
Ben
KeymastereBay heating up
guardian958 has changed some of their items to auctions. If they continue to do that as they relist things, could be a big bidding bonanza on eBay soon. ? Also seeing a Delusion up for grabs.
https://ebay.to/2JjzpMi -
AuthorPosts
