Ed

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 1 through 30 (of 76 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Named crew based on users #10565
    Ed
    Participant

    This is an awesome idea my friends and i have been making custom crew of eachother for a while

    in reply to: Collection Organization #9745
    Ed
    Participant

    I sort them by nationality then ship type so I just look for the flags and ship type I want exp.pirate 3 last gunner I have a lot of those but now I only have to search through 20 ships and not 100+

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #6205
    Ed
    Participant

    *puts hands in pockets and anxiously looks around* I ALSO DONT KNOW IF THERE IS A 3RD PARTY…

    in reply to: Game Ideas #6204
    Ed
    Participant

    I like the idea of using flat cardstock of the propper shape to represent sunken stuff that would especially be cool to be underneath a fogbank or mabye iceberg.

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #6170
    Ed
    Participant

    Those are some great shirts!

    Ed
    Participant

    I love this idea, it reminds me a lot of mysterious islands but way better.

    Ed
    Participant

    Yeah that musketeers is a man of many hats, I have a few oarsman explorers lol

    Ed
    Participant

    I should have been more clear that by raking I mean pulling up to a ship in L or T position and targeting the stern.

    in reply to: Would you PREFER if everything was costed perfectly? #5400
    Ed
    Participant

    I see where your coming from xerecs but there are lots of obvious balances to be made I cant remember names but there is alot of ships that have the exact same stats but one has a lower cost or a much more useful ability and the same cost.(the former is much more jarring to me than the latter)

    Ed
    Participant

    Raking could give -1 to connon roll and deal 2 masts if you can shoot their stern, I think a crew with that ability would be nice and cheep or maybe just beef up the cannoneer

    in reply to: Would you PREFER if everything was costed perfectly? #5329
    Ed
    Participant

    I HATE meta gaming and I feel like one of the best ways to avoid it is by nerfs and occasional buffs for example why not try costing musketeers at 2 and helmsman at 3?

    in reply to: The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread #5090
    Ed
    Participant

    Ever since my group saw the unique crew trevor(spacing on his full name) we decided to make musketeers 2 points not 3

    in reply to: Play by dealing cards to each player? #5049
    Ed
    Participant

    This is one of my favorite ways to build fleets i also like to have everyone choose 1 ship then the next person does the same ect…

    in reply to: Thoughts on Sea Dragons #5040
    Ed
    Participant

    Sea dragons can be powerful but I haven’t gotten to use mine yet

     

    Ed
    Participant

    I like that idea, this may be off topic a bit but my group has been developing an additional rule. I kinda ripped off carbon Charlie in that you can spend a gold coin when docking to repair an extra mast so that could be used in conjunction with your mercenary rule.(thematically its like hiring more builder or maybe just paying them to work overtime)

    in reply to: Custom Islands and Terrain #4488
    Ed
    Participant

    I love the treacherous waters idea!

     

    And to Ben I would turn that into a fortress I dunno why or how it just screams fortress to me

    Ed
    Participant

    Oh yeah for sure if I was better at making ships I would play a whole fleet of my own design lol

    in reply to: How do you value the box topper display stuff? #4463
    Ed
    Participant

    I totally agree that its a nice freebie

    in reply to: Julius Caesar #4461
    Ed
    Participant

    I just got my own Caesar in my recent order 😀

    Ed
    Participant

    In a heartbeat I would trade nearly anything for a ten master, switchblade, kraken, bombardeir,turbine or hoist. My reason is that I don’t have a single ship with these designs. Im not so much a stat guy since I can play with whatever stats I want but i can’t change the shape of the models.

    in reply to: Fun ways to play co-op #4458
    Ed
    Participant

    I definitely like the idea of an intelligent AI. The way I intended to handle the enemy ships was to have them pursue the closest ship at all cost but that was because my group and I were imagining the bloodthirsty cursed faction of ghosts and etc…

    in reply to: The Podcast Thread #4429
    Ed
    Participant

    Thanks so much for doing what you can to get these folks on the podcast!

    in reply to: Rules for Thought #27 – Capturing Crew house rule #4428
    Ed
    Participant

    I LOVE this idea maybe a lol complex but it gives great depth!

    in reply to: Weird crew artwork? #4427
    Ed
    Participant

    Cap’n Jack Sparrow is awesome along with the rest of the cast but c’mon Johnny Depp on a card…top notch stuff lol

    in reply to: Rules for Thought #26 – Broadsides Attack #4378
    Ed
    Participant

    Something I always think of for interesting abilities like broadsides is making whole scenarios around it for example everyship has broadsides as an ability.

    in reply to: What is the dumbest/silliest/most pointless combo? #4368
    Ed
    Participant

    Ha that would be so funny to try and put 2 doctors on each boat.

    in reply to: Julius Caesar #4367
    Ed
    Participant

    I think its just specifying that unlike other broadsides she might not look like she can broadside but that it DEFINITELY can.(thats what I think at least)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #4340
    Ed
    Participant

    Nayalitu is a nice crew, great use of an ability that I didnt see as very viable on the crew I saw wizkids produce(this crew must be the first eliminated.)

    I don’t recall seeing her negative ability on a Wizkids crew, but thanks!

    What I was remembering was the dummy ability(you may eliminate this crew instead of another crew you would eliminate)

    Jerrison and Darren are each crew I would be happy to find in a booster pack.Jerrison would be a great way to save cargo with his 2 in 1 ability plus his link and Darrens ability excites me with the idea of having a fleet based around stopping the enemy from getting home and either HI raiding or boarding/flitching gold or really anyway to rob em blind lol

    in reply to: What is the dumbest/silliest/most pointless combo? #4338
    Ed
    Participant

    Exactly I always thought it was funny that they made a crazy number of masts on ships without having even close to a realistic number of cannons lol(from what I understand and 10 masted ships are debatibly legend and myth)

    in reply to: Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) #4335
    Ed
    Participant

    Nayalitu is a nice crew, great use of an ability that I didnt see as very viable on the crew I saw wizkids produce(this crew must be the first eliminated.)

Viewing 30 posts - 1 through 30 (of 76 total)