@admin
Active 9 hours, 23 minutes ago-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
The action continues
As I play the final part of the game, it is mostly just a giant deathmatch at this point. Too many ships and crew are being lost on a per-turn basis for me to have time to keep track and […]

-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
Setting a new record for pictures in one battle report… (12/12/2017)
Setting a new record for pictures in one battle report… Command the Oceans –Continue reading→ -
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
The Cursed finally play one of their secret weapons!
Necklace of the Sky teleports the Delusion to the Pirate gold island, behind Pirate lines!!
The Seref, Empress, and Lady Newport were sunk […]

-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
THE FINAL REPORT
12/15/2017Turn 85
The Pirates sink the Beowulf, and the Jade Rebellion has been eliminated!!
The Shui Xian comes under fire from three different Pirate ships:
The Delusion […]

-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
Pirates at Ocean's Edge – Mini Set Review
Pirates at Ocean’s Edge Mini Set Review Product: Pirates at Ocean’sContinue reading→-
@Chris K: Ahoy! Great to “have you back aboard”. 😉
Spanish Main is a great set, especially for beginners. Awesome to hear you might be able to get your younger siblings into piracy! XD (the puns/etc never end haha)
The Zeus was a mail-in promotional LE that doesn’t come in any type of OE pack (even the oversized megapacks that she could theoretically fit inside). Your best bet might be to watch eBay, but I don’t see any there now. I do see some folks with the ship at Miniature Trading though, so you could reach out to them. I just got mine recently and look forward to using her in a physical game for the first time. (already used her on the VASSAL module)
Also, the Master Spreadsheet has some good information on the distribution of the irregular rarity game pieces. (those that are not C/U/R/SR)
Thanks for commenting!
Ben -
@James: Thanks for commenting! I like to be honest in my reviews of the various game pieces. Some of the ships aren’t as good for gameplay as others, or they might not look too good on the gaming table. But it makes it funny in my opinion haha!
I have exactly what you describe: Beginner’s Guide to Pirates CSG. Embedded on that page are the Rules tutorials videos that explains how to play.
Have fun,
Ben
-
-
Ben replied to the topic Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
Huk de Plentein (“uke” not “uck”; H is silent)
Faction Affiliation: Mercenary
Rarity: SE
Type: Ship
Point Value: 15
Number of Masts: 2
Cargo Space: 5
Base Move: S+L
Cannons: 2S-2L
Ability: Mercenary. Catamaran. Once per turn, this ship may move S after loading treasure.
Link: Ja Mo’hanFlavor text: The flagship of a tribal leader in the…[Read more]
-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
VASSAL Campaign Game 4
VASSAL Campaign Game 4 With considerable interest from various players, the fourthContinue reading→ -
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
This game was played on 11/21/2015.
This was a game with 4 fleets at 100 points each. After being completely astounded throughout, I can honestly say that in my 240+ games of Pirates up to this point (400+ as […]

-
Ben replied to the topic The non-eBay Sales & Trades thread in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
Alright, looks like it’s time for the annual Black Friday week sale at Hill’s Wholesale Gaming! (HWG)
http://www.wholesalegaming.biz/pirates/As of this post, 4 items marked down a decent amount; RV is probably the best deal of those that are on sale. (they used to sell OE for $38/36 packs, so that one isn’t as good in hindsight, but still…[Read more]
-
Ben posted a new activity comment 8 years ago
Great to see you here, thanks for joining!
Ben -
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
A7XfanBen’s Entry for Ocean Terrain Contest #3
Ocean Terrain Contest #3Introduction
Literally my entire goal in the whole process was to $ave Dat Money. (Normally I hate songs with autotune but tha […]

-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
VASSAL Tournament #2
9/30/2016
Welcome to the second VASSAL tournament! The winner of the tournament will be declared the best fleet of all time!!
Just like Tournament #1, each matchup consists of 2 […]

-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
Pirates of the Frozen North – Mini Set Review
Pirates of the Frozen North Mini Set Review Product: Pirates of theContinue reading→ -
Ben replied to the topic Questions About Game Rules & The Pirate Code in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
Awesome Woelf, thanks for making this!
The Master Spreadsheet contains all of the game pieces released, in addition to RtSS and Unreleased stuff – a good reference for anyone wondering what is being discussed.
I’ll start things off! Xerecs and I had some questions during the SS 10th anniversary game, and another random question came up during…[Read more]
-
Ben replied to the topic Custom Ships (post your custom game pieces here!) in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
Through a somewhat complicated and actually legal means, I have recovered some of the data from my phone’s Notepad!
Awesome! And I love forts, so wow am I in for some fun times here! O_O And I thought some of my forts were expensive! XD
Piraka Stronghold is fascinating, though I’d want to find some way to increase the cannon ranges so…[Read more]
-
Ben replied to the topic Obago Deuce in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
I’m slightly confused – you’re asking if someone here has an OD they’d be willing to sell for $150?
That seems like a solid starting point for discussion. I don’t have one, but if I did, I’d either keep it regardless of price, or only sell if I got an offer of $300+. XD (I changed the topic name from “Odago” to Obago so people wouldn’t be…[Read more]
-
Ben replied to the topic The Random (PCSG) Topic Thread in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
As a random note: if you hit the “Subscribe” button in the forum directory chain of links near the top of the forum pages, you should get emails about new topics being created. (I just did for old_man’s new topic) 🙂
I think I’ll repost the above question as a thread sometime soon.
-
Ben started the topic The Podcast Thread in the forum Pirates CSG 8 years ago
For reference:
2009 podcast with game designer Mike Selinker: http://ninjavspirates.libsyn.com/nv_p_3x04_pirates_of_the_spanish_main_with_mike_selinker
Then you have the online-based radio show hosted by RedDragon and Captain Ron:
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/RedDragonHere is the latest episode of the Pirates CSG Podcast!
Pirates CSG…[Read more]
-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
The World Game
Two of the greatest admirals in history, A7XfanBen and Xerecs, have begun planning the grandest adventure of all-time! After playing many campaign games over the years, including four tog […]

-
So, I know that there are plenty of problems and delays, but I wanted to know, if the possibility does open up, are you planning on actually playing the world game? Or are you just going to make the Caribbean game replace it? Also, what is the limiting factor? Does it just not fit in VASSAL or something?
-
Ahoy there! If and when Xerecs and I can play The World Game, we certainly want to play it and plan to someday. Someday could be 30 years from now. 🙂 Back around 2018, the Caribbean game certainly functioned as the replacement for The World Game. However, now our focus is on CG4, which we’re playing with PirateAJ14. That game has become so time consuming that we are unlikely to resume the Caribbean game while CG4 is still active. (it may not look like even CG4 is active either, but Xerecs just finished his turn and now that I’m back, I will soon begin another one of my supermassive epic turns)
The limiting factor was severe lag and loading issues. Even back when we could load the game, it was so slow as to be unplayable. The map was too big, so we compromised with playing just in the Caribbean instead. I looked into it a bunch and couldn’t find a good solution yet. It might be partly a hardware limitation – sometime I hope to try loading the World file on a high-end laptop.
Thanks for your interest! Have you played any Pirates CSG campaign games?
Ben
-
No. I very much want to, but I don’t know how to get started, particularly since I don’t know anyone who shares my passion for very long games.
-
I’ve got the perfect thing for you: Guide to Huge Games
The players of CG4 share your passion for very long games! However, it would be even harder to find someone to play a physical campaign game with, if you’re not looking for something on VASSAL.-
I accidentally started a new comment thread, so I’m coping it here:
Well, VASSAL would be alright for me, but I can’t guarantee consistent attendance, which makes remote play difficult regardless of the game. The link you posted is one I found, but I don’t see any specific rulesets. I found the links on this page though, it just took a bit to figure out how to interpret it all. I’m finding that the roleplaying aspect you guys are using in the Caribbean Game makes it even more interesting, and even opens up options for solitaire, but I think I’m going to try and convince my brother to play with me. Is there anywhere I can get the map for the Caribbean game for VASSAL? I really want to try doing one of my own. Is it possible to import maps, or will I have to build the map myself?
-
Indeed, Game Ideas is the page with the rulesets. I have to say, looking at The World Game rules is probably the most overwhelming thing someone new to the game could do. 😀 But I’m glad you’re interested!
I can send you the Caribbean map file. You can import VASSAL saved game files (.vsav) which for Pirates CSG are the maps/oceans. You can also build your own ocean of course. You may not need it at this point, but my VASSAL tutorial might be useful. Building a big ocean takes a little time since you have to make sure it comes out right by establishing the proper borders and corners. You can actually edit the module to upload a bigger ocean picture file, but that didn’t work well when I experimented with that for this game.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Honestly, The World Game rules was probably the most straightforward ruleset I’ve seen. Or at least the one that has the least holes. It makes sense anyway.
Yeah, I did some experimenting too. I even tried to recreate the map from the pictures, but for whatever reason, despite following what was written (10×20 ocean and double borders) the map was too big. Thank you so much for the file.
-
Cool! I’m worried there might be holes in the ruleset, Xerecs and I just haven’t found them yet since we haven’t started the game haha.
Sometime I can probably show you on video how I would make a big map if you want.
Ben
-
Well, there almost always are, but at least they aren’t immediately obvious, unlike many games.
That would be really cool. I’ve tried making large maps and while I’m capable of all the tasks, I struggle with design aspects, such as how to arrange all the island and reefs and other terrain in such a way that it is playable. I have that problem with small islands too actually. I have a feeling I’ll mainly use VASSAL for large games anyway.
-
For making playable maps, it’s generally good to have islands at similar distances from each other. That can make an ocean a bit boring, so I like to include archipelagos or clusters sometimes – with the caveat that all of them have to be wild islands. That way a faction can’t pick their HI right next to a bunch of wild islands.
-
That makes sense. Thanks for the tip. How do you go about arranging your oceans? Are there steps you take to create a good design, or do you just place things randomly and then adjust them?
-
For arranging an ocean, I usually just try to include some interesting features or things I haven’t done before. Sometimes that involves stringing terrain together in new or old ways. An island surrounded by terrain (often a single type, like reefs to make a lagoon of sorts) might get extra gold on it, and probably shouldn’t be a location that someone can pick for their home island (not that they would want to of course). The ocean for CG4 is probably my best one yet for a fictional ocean, partly since I had more room to work with than I did for CG1-CG3. Maybe the islands are a little too far apart given how large the ocean is, but I think it has worked out well enough and was arguably a slightly needed change compared to CG1-CG3. Tightly packed islands in a campaign game usually just mean that factions will be able to collect gold/resources more quickly, which can lead to fast paced launch cycles. That has happened for a very different reason in CG4, but it can feel a little artificial when factions are launching many ships per turn and the game size quickly spirals into crazy levels where turns start taking many many hours to play. (which I don’t mind, it just makes the game a big time commitment to keep consistent with)
Things that generally make oceans more fun to play on are stringing together terrain (sometimes with islands too) and using round earth rules for the game itself. From a gameplay perspective, I pretty much adore whirlpools at this point. I think that’s more of a convenience/play style factor than what makes a good ocean though, especially since they can be used to bypass ocean/terrain features haha. It can be fun to have whirlpools used as the only access point for certain areas – such as a separate ocean (Command the Oceans heavily featured this as a necessity of physical limitations), or a treasure laden “danger area” that seems mysterious to the factions.
Sometimes I place things randomly using the random placement method in VASSAL, but it usually doesn’t work that well so I just place things where I think they should go. I normally just use random rotation of things so they don’t look identical (how they are rotated on their x/y axis).
Overall, I guess I basically try to make things interesting (new features, connecting islands/terrain, and having at least 1-2 wild island (only) clusters) while trying to keep it as fair as possible for all players regarding home island location advantages.
-
-
-
-
-
-
I didn’t know that the random rotation or placement function was a thing. That’s awesome. I think part of my problem is that the oceans always look too artificial. The trick with the whirlpools to alleviate space constraints is pretty brilliant though. Is it better or worse to start different factions in different zones? Different zones would allow for a calmer start, but I feel like it would also mean that it would make things far too easy for a defender.
-
Indeed, right clicking on items when they’re selected gives you a nice list of options. Having an ocean that looks artificial might be almost inevitable with a fair setup, unless there is a huge amount of terrain to distract from the islands or landmasses to make it more “realistic in terms of island scale.
I think starting different factions/fleets in different zones is better because it allows people to start the game on relatively even footing. If someone brings a gunship in their starting fleet and start near an opposing player that only has gold runners, it could mean that a faction is eliminated extremely early in a campaign game, which in general just feels lame and anticlimactic. I guess the CG’s I’ve played in have the opposite problem (a general gold/arms race that can be somewhat predictable at times, depending on alliances and strategy), but I’d rather have that than get knocked out early or have players quit because their only shot at winning was doomed so early on.
Also, no need to repost comments, one is fine.
-
-
-
Ben wrote a new post 8 years ago
The Caribbean Game
Two of the greatest admirals in history, Admiral A7XfanBen and Xerecs, The Lord Sentinel, have begun their grandest adventure yet! After playing many campaign games over the years, in […]

- Load More
