3. Santa Ana
4. Intrepid
The rest of this feels like a tossup.
6. Akua Lapu
9. White Rose
10. Revenant / USS Constitution
Just missed: Ghost Walker , HMS Durham
Nubian Prince is not nearly as effective as the Bonaparte, thankfully. She can be more of a nuisance than a ship that is actually effective at doing things. That said, she could jump to #4 if I face her again. Not sure how to rank her properly. Just such a horrid ability.
Other honorable mentions not seen in this thread yet:
Huginn
La Charlemagne
Lady’s Scorn
Paul Revere
Original thread on Miniature Trading