I’ve been writing Battle Reports since late July 2011. I played at least a dozen games (probably more) in 2005-2006 when I first got into Pirates CSG, but since getting back into it in 2011 I’ve recorded almost every game I’ve played in some way. In this blog I will be posting battle reports of my adventures. Check out my best battle reports in the Compendium and my biggest games in Huge Game Legacy.
The Pirates aboard the smaller ships are curious about the Tunnel:
At the other end, the Revenant gets a 6 to emerge from the fog and turn around! The other Pirate gunships are now nearly caught up.
The damaged Pirates in the Sea of Karkuda suffer an abysmal turn, doing almost no damage to American ships.
After the Lady’s Scorn sank due to her fire masts, the opening allowed the Delight to charge forward and ram the President! Preble’s ship was under attack by a third Pirate gunship during this battle. The Delight scored a hit but lost the boarding party.
The Ballista and Jape roll well for their fire masts, but in their weakened state they are unable to keep up an effective rate of fire against their adversaries.
The Paladin is hit again with Fear along with shots from the Centurion, but the Americans will be able to do major damage on their turn.
Returning from the northern part of Karkuda where the American-French battle has begun, the Mystic tells her fellow HI raiders that the French are not a good faction to steal from either. At this point the Pirates have encountered difficulty trying to raid the Americans, French, and even English to a lesser degree.
No less than 7 Jade ships have been repairing at their HI:
However, between recent launches and some already-healthy ships, the Jades have an 8-ship squadron heading out to counter any potential Cursed invasion:
And indeed, the Cursed are building back up and are hungry for a true victory in this bloody but inconclusive war.
The English HI becomes busy, with a few ships repairing and the Eternally scuttled Ark Royal joining them along with some cargo ships.
The captains of the Lord Kettering and Voz de Dios nearly agreed to a short truce to the hostilities, but negotiations didn’t last long! After a short conversation the English carried on, with the LK continuing to tow the captured Extremadura. The Granville, Resistance, and Orkney teamed up to score 5 hits on the Voz, nearly dismasting her!
The Spanish don’t have enough for a great counterattack, but the Corazon del Mar proves surprisingly successful, hitting 3/3 to set the Granville aflame! At the left, the Cristal will be the first ship to explore Paradise Island since Fortaleza Dorada was destroyed. The island holds the Spanish gold used to build the fort, but it may produce a new resource again too….
The Spanish bring the captured Royal and damaged Armada back to their HI, where the Santa Ana finishes repairing with an EA. At the right, the newest Spanish warships have sailed out, and it looks like they’re heading towards Paradise Island….
The French have a nice turn against the Americans! At the right, the Delacroix and Bonaparte flee for repairs, with the Hercule and Felicite replacing them. At the lower left, the Ville de Paris gets an EA to cripple the Grampus, while the Cleveland and Saratoga are hit with firepots. The Superbe is in an excellent position where she can shoot through friendly ships to hit hostile ships beyond. So far, the large French capital ships have plugged and held the gap, not allowing for American ships to reach the fort or advance their long supply chain of ships. At the bottom, the Solitaire and Crete Argentee have arrived, so next turn their bonuses should really help the French stay accurate.
The Dauphin Royal has extinguished her fire mast and reversed direction, while just above her you can see a major development: the Royal Louis was given an EA from Deleflote to unload the French fort upgrade at Paradis de la Mer!
Tomorrow I hope to finish this turn with the Americans and finish all of Turn 56!
Due to a surprise resource change and some real-life logistics, I wasn’t able to finish all of Turn 56. However, what did happen was pretty interesting.
Previously shrouded in fog, the Americans and French didn’t even realize that their battle nearly bumped up against some huge unknown structure south of The Flat!! O_O
The Carolina and Jackson dock at the northwest end of The Flat that had been explored by the Peacock, and unload 6 army units!! The War for The Flat is on! This could be the first time in this game where we see true land warfare, though ships can easily pick them off.
The Seattle hits 3/5 to smash the Felicite, while the Yankee and Franklin team up to set the Hercule aflame.
A rather poor American turn on this side. The ships south and west of The Flat cannot break the French line and are stuck behind each other.
However, the Americans cripple the Pirates in the southwest, and have all but won that battle! The Springfield’s ability came in quite handy, allowing the Minuteman flotilla to hit all 4 times against the Thirty Tyrants (at the far left).
The Delight is dismasted, and the Americans capture no less than 4 ships on the turn! The Ballista, Bruja, Jape, and Centurion will join the American fleet if they are not scuttled.
USS Appalachian reaches the whirlpool amid incredible amounts of wreckage:
Looking up at the mass of ships beyond, though the battle has become quieter and less chaotic as Pirate ships strike their colors.
Various derelicts float about in the devastation, while at the top, the Concordia cannot even move away from the HI due to the busiest scene of the game so far. (and the RV Saratoga could hardly tow the Ballista, who is at a weird angle facing the President in this picture)
I rolled another one at the beginning of Turn 56, which meant a random resource change would occur! I rolled a 2 after, which meant the change would only affect this one turn. Then, I rolled another 2, which was the first time a 2 was rolled for resource values!! Suddenly lumber was worth 6 gold apiece, luxuries 5, and finally, spices were in the top half of values at 4 apiece! This benefited the Cursed, French, and Americans the most with their luxury stockpiles, which is part of the reason I couldn’t finish the turn.
The Pirates come around the huge fog banks surrounding the Tunnel and discover the Jade Rebellion!! O_O
Words and not shots are exchanged!! Calico Cat has a shouted conversation with the captain of the Wiglaf, who hates the Cursed lol. The captain tells Calico Cat that the Cursed are a horrible menace of unspeakable power and hatred, and that the Jades would like an ally with which to combat them. Calico responds that the Pirates are merely humble explorers (lol, not that the Jades bought that, as the Pirate squadron contains 3 of their best gunships XD) and will not be able to assist anyone in war efforts. The captain of the Wiglaf is disappointed to hear this, and will pass it on to his superiors in the rapidly approaching Grand Temple. However, the Jades are hell-bent on eliminating the Cursed presence from the Sea of Allost, and between recent launches and repairs, think they will be able to do that before too long.
The Pirates had just gotten word of the Cursed, but in the meantime they also had a first-hand experience with them! The captain of the Golden Medusa had been growing bored for quite some time with whirlpool patrol, and after being egged on by his Pirate comrades on the HI-raiding ships, decided to have a look west of the whirlpool. The Pirates quickly sighted a strange vessel anchored off an island, and lo and behold it was the Cursed!! The Soul Crusher has been guarding that island for quite a while now. Wraith quickly started gesturing at the Golden Medusa, hissing like mad! Not understanding a “word” of it, the captain of the Golden Medusa deduced that all of his crewmen would be killed if they went further or tried to find out what was on the island. His intuition was correct! XD
Now you can finally understand the general layout in the Sea of Allost, but to think that is the end of developments there would be VERY wrong… hhehe.
At the end of their turn, the Pirates spend 32 gold on what I think is a potentially clever combo with Jonah. Usually I just put Blackbeard and a helmsman on Blackbeard’s linked ship, the Queen Anne’s Revenge (QAR), since that maxes out the ship’s point limit but still leaves room for gold. However, with so many points available and a great resource system already in play, the Pirates went overboard and used Jonah to bring aboard Sean Cannonball Gallows and Lady Baptiste to give the QAR EA with reroll abilities. This could make the ship quite dangerous and capable of nabbing more than one crew in a turn.
The QAR was launched at Dead Man’s Point, where three Pirate ships repair from their awful trip to the Sea of Karkuda. The nice blue hull of the Lady’s Scorn is visible at the top, nearly blending into the ocean. At the left, the Gruesome looks to join the HI raider ships anchored off the whirlpool.
Bartholomew Roberts enters the Tunnel! In addition, the Deliverance has finished repairing, which means that the Pirate whirlpool squadron is ready to go again! However, Havana Black might be “hungry” for more oarsmen, in which case he might leave the squadron to go home first. In between those two developments you can see the considerable Pirate defense squadron, which now consists of 11 2 masted gunships and two flotillas.
The Jades are gearing up for yet another battle with the Cursed! With Calico Cat not offering Pirate help, the Vikings on the outside line have dismissed the Pirates to a degree, ignoring them in favor of fleet maneuvers. The Jade squadron will only grow stronger as more and more ships finish repairing.
But the Cursed grow stronger as well! They cash in less than half of their luxuries for 80 gold, which nets them the Juggernaut, Whydah, Strix, and Fiddler’s Green (with F&S L-mover Tabitha McWarren aboard).
Back in the Caribbean, the Lord Algernon fires somewhat of a cheap shot at the Voz de Dios, setting her alight and dooming the Spaniard. The Orkney begins towing the dismasted Corazon del Mar, while the repaired Durham is returning to the war effort. At the bottom you can also see the hull of the Extremadura, a ship the English are lucky to bring back home.
But in a big surprise move, the Spanish open up another theater of the war!! Attacking the much-diminished English presence southwest of Diamond Rock, the newest Spanish warships veer to starboard and open fire! The Serpiente hits 2/2 to take a mast off the Burma. The Ebro only hit 1/4, but the Acorazado bailed out her fleetmate by going 3/5 (with double shot, the last cannon wasn’t in range) to damage the Duke of York.
With the Santa Catalina, Profeta, Asesino, and Habana all coming over from the HI to help, the Spanish suddenly have a pretty solid presence where the First Battle of Diamond Rock took place. The English were caught unawares, and although they have two more gunships and the Tower flotilla nearby, look to be at a disadvantage.
Up north, the First Battle of Paradise Island is pretty much completely over. It was inconclusive but with notable losses and victories on both sides. Similar to the JR-Cursed war, this war is beginning to resemble two factions beating the carp out of each other with little gains. XD The Cristal del Obispo explored the island, finding textiles! The Granada is still stuck, while the Santa Ana has returned to the scene as the Spanish don’t want to lose control of the island despite starting a new battle off to the south. The Spanish hope to distract the English and win a battle near Diamond Rock, simultaneously weakening English control of the central area of the Caribbean and buying time to get another fort on Paradise Island. It seems like a good strategy, between the English being battle-weary and not getting great returns on their spices for at least a few more turns. (worth 4 on this turn but the English want to wait until they’re worth 5 or 6 to cash in)
Back in the Sea of Karkuda, you can just see the tail ends of the Mobilis and Devil Ray entering the sub hideout!
This is what it looks like once they’ve surfaced inside, but the Mercs will have to wait at least one turn to cash in their new resources since food and textiles crashed with the random change.
That is all for now! With luxuries becoming valuable, the French and Americans will both have a LOT of stuff to do on their turns, between the large battles, various logistics, and definitely some launches. I hope to play out those mammoth turns tomorrow! The point count has obviously been delayed even further, but it will be coming eventually haha.
Here are the American and French turns of Turn 56.
The French utterly dominate the Americans at The Flat!
The Cleveland, Saratoga, and Delaware are finished, while the Minuteman has one mast left but is burning. The Dauphin Royal got an AA from Gaston to shoot twice, using Lenoir to cancel the L-immunity of the Jarvis.
Paradis was very ineffective, but one shot hit to take out an American infantry unit, the first land-to-land combat of this game. The Hercule and Bonaparte join the Delacroix in extinguishing their flames at the fort, with the Hercule also dismasting the Seattle.
From the previous pictures you may have noticed a few new ships at The Flat! That’s right, the French were saving gold in order to launch from their newly upgraded fort! However, between the battle, the Americans having staked out the northern end of the island, and the handful of ships docking at The Flat for repairs, they only had room to launch two ships there this first time. However, those two ships are two more French capital ships – the 5 masters Neptune and Monaque.
Now we see the extent of the French spending spree – they didn’t come close to spending all of their gold, but they still spent a bunch! The Aube, Tepant, Epee, Orient, Aquilon, Cleopatre, Heros and Atalante come into play, all with fighting crew aboard.
Here is most of the French deckplate area, with new launches joining the other existing ships.
Cleaning up their victory, the Americans deal damage to the remaining Pirate ships near their HI, which at this point are only the Ranger, Thirty Tyrants, and Rickets. Much towing and awkward turning logistics ensue.
Definitely one of the most wreckage-filled battles I’ve had in a game of Pirates CSG. In many spots there are simply masts on top of masts, so it’s like a dense layer of wreckage, with ships sailing over it with some difficulty. O_O
The Americans retreat, and the French have won the Second Fight at The Flat!! This may seem premature and even lame from a reader’s point of view, but there were various reasons behind the decision. First off, the French still don’t want war with the Americans, and were not the ones to initiate this conflict. The French senior officers talked down to the American captains on the attacking ships, telling them that not only have they launched two brand-new powerful warships at The Flat, but they have more on the way very soon. The French then threatened to spend even more gold next turn on more new ships, as they still have 204 gold! Compounding matters further, the host of American ships have been absolutely stopped by the French line, with not a single French 5 master dismasted or sunk thus far and various American ships dismasted or fleeing with 1 mast standing. The Turn 50 megalaunches saw the Americans purchase more ships, but the French got the best of their best, with various top-of-the-line 5 masters defending The Flat and some (like the Charlemagne) not even getting in action yet. Notice the troop transports loading up the army units, taking them off The Flat.
And thus, the Truce of The Flat is now in effect! Indeed, this is the first official truce or treaty in this game, and a concept that has been underutilized by me in my past campaign games. This is not a full peace treaty, but a truce that the Americans and French agreed to. The terms dictate that the Americans can retreat from the area in peace if the derelict American ships strike their colors. The Americans considered this a fine deal, as their long-term plans have been severely hampered by the French and they will have to re-evaluate their strategy going forward.
The Americans retreat west, but they are already formulating grand plans for the future, though that future is more distant than they hoped or anticipated it to be. Various possibilities exist: with two powerful foes (Pirates and French), the Americans may look for an ally to aid in their war efforts. Since the Americans know their way around the whirlpools pretty well at this point, reaching out to other factions is a possibility, though the Americans assume the Spanish are as weak as they were earlier in the game and they don’t have any idea about the Jades and Cursed. In addition, with a possible peace with France suddenly materializing, the Americans may be able to throw their full might against the Pirates. An extended whirlpool trip could be costly, but with two large-scale battles just recently going on simultaneously, the Americans have shown the financial power needed for such an endeavor.
With the battle against the French over, a few healthy gunships try to find a shortcut home, going along the side of the large structure that will be officially revealed when it is fully explored.
From the mainmast of USS Mercury:
The Americans spend big as well! In fact, they cash in ALL of their luxuries and combine it with some gold and cashed in lumber to spend a whopping 228 gold! A full dozen ships are purchased, among them the Congress and Concord, which are relaunched in the same round that the French traded them in. There is a thing happening: The Mobilization of the American Navy. Preble coined the phrase after learning of the Truce of The Flat, and it represents a period of change for the Americans. They have won their first battle, a serious effort against the Pirates. However, the French are far stronger and defensive than they anticipated, leading to a major loss that would likely be far worse if not for the sudden truce and retreat. At this point, the Americans need to repair, regroup, and mobilize. Many plans are being considered in addition to the possibilities above.
Clearly I’m going a little overboard with the thematics with the Americans in this game, possibly since they go last in the turn order and therefore usually last in the reports. However, I think it’s fun to give a full insight into the mind of one of the factions, as the reader doesn’t know all the strategies being considered by the other factions. That’s not to say that each faction has strategic thinking as deep as the Americans lately – for example, the Jades and Cursed have been in pure war mode for a while and are simply concerned with eliminating the other. However, it’s fun to give you the full breakdown for at least one of the factions’ thoughts, and hopefully I can expand on more of the others.
The super-accurate Blackwatch highlights the additions, while that ship, the Paul Revere, and the Julius Caesar are some of my favorite American ships.
With that, I look forward to some amount of action tomorrow, and a point count within the next 2 or 3 days. However, Saturday-Tuesday will see considerably less action so I will likely just play “faction turns” when I’m able to on those days. Thanks for reading, and feel free to comment!
Turn 57! The day’s action begins with Pirate activities at the Tunnel, where Mission is returning to Pirate waters. Bartholomew Roberts is exploring the Tunnel, amazed at both the height and length of it.
With a VERY rare shot looking from north to south in the Sea of Allost, here is a view of the Golden Medusa checking out the outside north wall of the huge Tunnel.
The Pirate whirlpool squadron emerges back in the Sea of Karkuda! After repairing from their sneak attack on the English in the Caribbean, the squadron has headed back to Karkuda after getting wind of the American/French “dispute” XD. The Feathered Hat, generally the flagship of the squadron when Havana Black and the Deliverance aren’t around, was given an AA to approach the French ships near The Flat. The other ships of the squadron followed the FH through when the FH didn’t return to Pirate waters, as she would have if the situation didn’t look good. The captain of the Feathered Hat speaks with various Frenchmen, including Michael Bordeaux and Guy LaPlante. Finding a commonality in their anti-American sentiments, the Pirates and French agree to an alliance!!
Spending time for the Jades! They buy some very expensive and very fragile firepower, since they’re running out of ships to purchase. Many of the Viking 1 masters are launched, along with the Donar and Sea Crane. At this point I have even run out of the paper crew chips for new players, so I’ve been writing “C 3” (for captains) and whatnot on index cards which are then cut into little bits so I can fit as many deckplates in the deckplate areas as possible.
The VERY busy Jade HI, which is also looking like a fortress due to their slow but steady accumulation of army units.
The large and powerful JR squadron on patrol duty has set a clear boundary against the Cursed.
The Cursed answer with launches of their own! The first kraken is now in play: Terrox is here!
The Executioner and Poor Adams are two more additions, while the Jikininki has finished repairing. The Demon Gate and Sea Rat are also launched.
After the surprise Spanish attack to open the Second Battle of Diamond Rock, the English strike back with very accurate gunnery! The Tower flotilla and the Burma do most of the damage, as the Ebro and Acorazado lose two masts each.
But the Spanish have a numerical advantage in that area right now! The Santa Catalina, Profeta, Asesino, and Habana enter the fray to back up their fleetmates! However, their shooting percentage is far lower than the English on this turn, though the sheer number of shots taken mean that the Burma and Duke of York lose additional masts.
Similar to the English at the First Battle of Paradise Island, the Spanish break the English “line” to advance their squadron. However, the farther the Spanish advance, the more English ships they will encounter, not to mention the cannons on the shore of Diamond Rock’s only beach.
With the resources going back to normal and food and textiles becoming valuable again, the Mercenaries are able to cash in!! They spend all 38 gold from their first haul and launch the first 10 master of the game!!
The Celtic Fury is here!!
You may have noticed those giant guns protruding from the bow of the CF. They are extra bombardier cannon pieces that I can use as a physical representation of Bow Chasers, a custom equipment of mine partially inspired by PotC.
Bow Chasers
Faction Affiliation: Neutral
Type: Equipment
Point Value: 5
This ship gains two additional cannons that can only shoot from the foremost mast of the ship. The cannons have 4L rank/range and the Extended Range keyword. The cannons can only fire in a straight line directly forward of the ship’s bow. Other pieces of equipment cannot be used with Bow Chasers, and Bow Chasers cannot have their range or rank improved.
Especially when viewed from deck or land level, the Celtic Fury suddenly becomes the most imposing ship on the seas:
Nemo’s Mercenary Submarine Hideout can only accommodate submarines, but the Mercenaries can still launch ships S away from the hideout. I’m inclined to allow their sailing ships to dock at the hideout, but for now they can only unload resources and gold when they surface inside the hideout.
Check out the crew setup on the CF. Ms. O’Brien has left the Mobilis to command the largest ship currently in play. The Bow Chasers and the crew fill out the 13 points the Mercs spent.
And so this begins an interesting period of international Mercenary relations. That is clear….
Continuing the theme of major launches (the third faction in the turn to spend 100+ gold), the French spend ALL of their 246 gold to get a dozen new ships!! Those three ships at the top are currently troop transports, while the Conquerant represents a slight change of policy for France in this game. As they cement their (very) strong position in the Sea of Karkuda and gold continues to flow in from their various islands, the French are able to experiment a little bit. The first “flamethrower” of the game shows up with some hesitancy and anticipation.
O_O Whoa… intrigued by Nemo’s desertion and change of heart, Gaston himself pays the Mercenaries a visit! However, the French go after the Mercenaries, so the Bourbon is blocked from seeing the submerged Nautilus by the giant new junk! O’Brien and Gaston have a very amicable conversation, with O’Brien following orders from Nemo to lie about Nemo’s true intentions. O’Brien tells Gaston that Nemo is doing all of this in the employ of France, and that the Celtic Fury will be joining the French fleet defending The Flat! Gaston eats it up, and everything is going according to plan for Nemo. He glimpsed the Bourbon on the horizon last turn, and the resources changing back was the perfect time to get a pro-France ally out there to talk up Gaston. O’Brien has long been the favorite Mercenary of France, serving them well over the years. She also speaks fluent French, something most other Mercs struggle mightily with. After the pleasant conversation, Gaston heads back to his cabin, impressed with Nemo’s direction. Nemo is playing things perfectly, using O’Brien to delay French knowledge of the Mercenaries being their own independent faction.
Nearly the entire French situation:
The ships launched last turn are barely getting out of the Harbor when another batch of new ships arrives! At the left, notice the Westminster has entered the Harbor! The French have agreed to help the English a little: the Westminster can use the French Harbor to repair, but no alliance has been agreed to. At the right, the Conquerant is using the “flamestrike” cannon but I think I’ll leave the flame part off when it’s not being used, to make things more realistic and make it easier to move the ship around.
The Americans continue to explore the structure they recently found!
The Brandywine uses her ability and an AA from Preble to look at the entire south side of the structure!
Introducing: The Castle!
Hidden on all sides by a variety of reefs, fog, and sargasso seas, the Castle is an abandoned castle built long ago in the Sea of Karkuda. The enormous structure has been decaying for quite some time, but it could make a decent location for a faction if they were inclined to restore it to its former glory….
The next three pictures show the massive American fleet in sections.
The Americans have disabled the last of the Pirate ships in the southwest corner of Karkuda, officially sealing their commanding victory!
The first Pirate captures have been docked at the home island, while some new American ships head out, sailing northeast.
Here you can see 5 American ships heading home for repairs after the Second Fight at The Flat. At the top, a few gunships and the 4 troop transports have been laid up “in reserve” west of The Flat. They are guarding against French intrusion in addition to awaiting further orders. With a huge fleet and very complex logistics, in addition to some newfound uncertainty as to their long-term strategy, there are some American captains that don’t know what to do right now.
O_O With the Castle officially revealed at last, you can finally see nearly ALL of the Sea of Karkuda!! Here you can really get an idea of just how MASSIVE my custom stuff is. The Harbor is so large that it utterly dominates the entire northeast quadrant of this ocean, which is about 5 feet by 3 feet. The Castle has been an obstacle to my picture-taking until now, and you can notice how I purposely left any clip of it out of pictures near The Flat. I also didn’t want the sub hideout so close to the other stuff, but I couldn’t realistically have a bigger ocean. In addition, you can see just how crowded Karkuda has become, with GIANT French and American fleets being joined by Pirates and Mercenaries of late. Formerly a mostly dormant ocean when the Sea of Allost had the majority of the points in play and when we witnessed the First Battle of Diamond Rock, the Sea of Karkuda is now incredibly busy and HOT! XD
The most epic and shocking point count of all time
After anticipating a major ship and point count since the big launches on Turn 50, the time has finally come!! It took a little over a full hour just to tally up all the points and ships in play. As with the previous counts, only deckplate areas were considered for this. Forts, army units, and existing caches of gold are not counted at all.
Without further ado, here are the numbers.
10/6/2017 point and ship count as of the end of Turn 57:
Unsurprising at this point, but Command the Oceans has officially become the biggest game in the history of Pirates CSG!!!!
In much more shocking news, this game has completely obliterated any and ALL point and ship records in any Pirates CSG game you can imagine. It is almost incomprehensible to think about. Most people only play games with a total of 80, or 120, or 200. This game is about to exceed SIX THOUSAND TOTAL POINTS. O_O After it reached around 4,600 after Turn 50, I realized that it would not only be the first game to reach the 4,000 point level, but also the first ever to hit 5,000 points! However, things have kept ballooning to the point of total insanity, with 6,000 points within reach less than 10 turns later. O_O Just for reference, the previous record for a game was 3,516 total points for VASSAL Campaign Game 1. This game has exceeded that game by nearly an additional 2,500 points, which by itself would make a HUGE game!! Finally, the record for a physical game was 2,846 total points for Economy Edition. That record has now been more than doubled. O_O In the past, my biggest games have sometimes featured the winning fleet peaking at over 1,000 points. In this game, there are THREE fleets at 1,000+ points, with no end in sight!!
I will admit that a handful of factors have contributed to the astronomical point total. First off, three oceans is quite a lot, and it means I have more square footage on which to play than any other CG I’ve played outside of the 2011 cumulative game, where I used my whole room in a setting I would not repeat today. Secondly, the mast elimination and sinking house rules have resulted in many less sunken ships than EE or CG1. Finally, there has still not been extremely long and drawn-out combat between two factions outside of the Jades and Cursed, who do have lower ship and point totals as a result of that war.
More stats and figures:
Points per ship:
Pirates: 16.4 points/ship
Jade Rebellion: 19.1
Cursed: 17.8
English: 15.2
Spanish: 15.1
Mercenaries: 25 (Celtic Fury is one of four Merc ships XD)
French: 18
Americans: 17.7
Overall: 17.35 points/ship (almost the same as my 17.46 number from EE’s near-peak, so this is a very good gauge for CG’s)
Here you can see the difference between a fleet of 6 masted junks and Viking longships, two of the most expensive ship types in the game, as the JR fleet has the same number of ships as the English but 132 more points.
By ocean: (with some give or take necessary due to whirlpool traveling)
Sea of Allost: 143 ships, 2,504 points
Caribbean: 55 ships, 835 points
Sea of Karkuda: 144 ships, 2,594 points
-Almost the same numbers in Allost and Karkuda!
Percentage of points in play:
Pirates: 17.7% (1,052/5,933)
JR: 10.9%
Cursed: 13.5%
English: 8.7%
Spanish: 5.3%
French: 19.1%
Americans: 22.9%
From that you can see that if the Pirate/French alliance is very fruitful, they could combine to control around 37% of the total points in play… however, the current strongest faction is at war with both of them haha. You can also crunch the numbers various ways in an attempt to come up with a majority alliance….
Now for an extended look at the considerable area in the two rooms that I have dedicated to deckplate areas.
With three columns for the Pirates and Cursed, this is the main deckplate area for the Sea of Allost. However, the Pirates have grown out of this area and have spilled over into the other room, with the Cursed threatening to do the same soon.
Wall of text? How about a wall of deckplates and crew! XD
At the upper right, Wraith has been repossessing crew for a while now aboard the Soul Crusher.
A few more Pirate deckplates left of their main area, also previewing the JR area…
… which are partially under the Caribbean table.
The rest of the JR section, which are pretty difficult to get to at this point.
The English and the Spanish are near the Caribbean:
The small primary Spanish area is next to the coin tin and the resources bag.
But similar to the other factions, the Spanish have now spilled over into a new area underneath the Caribbean. (underwater lol)
Here we see extra Pirate and English stuff (their more recent launches) along with the new Mercenary faction.
Here is the huge French area, which is basically full at this point. This is the same area where the huge Franco-Spanish fleet from Economy Edition was.
Finally, the Americans with the biggest fleet of them all. Note that without the 7 recently captured Pirate ships, the Pirates would have a narrow lead in ships at 71-70. Alas, with a decisive American victory the Americans have the largest fleet.
I also started Turn 58 with the Pirates!
Another random resource change! For this turn only, metals would be the most valuable resource, with the fish market crashing temporarily.
Using an EA from Calico Cat to travel through most of the Tunnel, the Revenant approaches Pirate waters. The Silver Dagger is given an AA to get close to the Revenant, and an exchange will take place next turn.
The Pirates buy another ladder in order to give two oarsmen to the Deliverance. Havana Black has restocked his supply of sacrificial crew.
The Pirates spent 95 total gold on their turn, launching 5 additional gunships.
With 88 additional points of ships and crew in play, this game reaches 6,021 total points!!! O_O
This shows the entire Jade fleet, with their battle squadron becoming stronger by the turn.
The JR wild island had run out of resources briefly, but then began producing food again! This marked the second time the island has had food, which was the main source of Jade wealth in the early part of the game.
The Cursed fleet, with more cargo ships than ever running resources to support the war effort against the Jades.
Looking up at the imposing Roost and the giant dragon:
Shal-Bala is ready to take flight again!!
But this won’t be a raid! It will be a reconnaissance flyover!
Here you “become the dragon” and get Shal-Bala’s view of things. A treat indeed! XD The beast flies higher and higher above the sea….
Shal-Bala picks up speed and heads east!
Flying over the Tunnel!
Those two “moving shots” were fun to get, but here’s a more static shot of the top of the Tunnel! At first glance it looks to be somewhat barren but covered with some grass and rocks. Also, both ends and both sides of the Tunnel’s top are different than the other.
Shal-Bala flies all the way over to Mission’s Pirate Kingdom! This gives the Cursed full knowledge of the piratical activities being carried out! XD However, the Pirates spot the dragon flying above! At this point the Pirates are aware of the Cursed beast, and certainly assume the Cursed are a powerful faction as a result.
The experiments have been completed, and Devereaux has succeeded!!! Originally a French privateer, Devereaux has lost his sanity to his obsession with finding the Dragon’s Eye, a gem that legend says grants the owner immortality. Devereaux found his great obsession, the Eye of the Dragon. It’s power was everything he hoped it was – and more: Its power condemned him to a living death under its control. But not only that, it inspired him to combine two amazing UT’s into one bizarre and hideous creation!!
THE EYE!!!!
O_O
After finding both the Eye of Insanity (considered to be the same as the Eye of the Dragon for this game) and the Cursed Conch early in the game, Devereaux left his ship (the Boneyard at the time) to focus his efforts on some “experiments”. After MANY turns (almost the whole game so far lol), he finally succeeded in planting the Eye inside the Cursed Conch! The freakish creation has resulted in a Cursed gimmick that could alter how they play the game.
Rules for The Eye: The Cursed can use the Eye on their turns to see anything and everything on ALL oceans.
O_O
I know there are some parallels between this and the Eye of Sauron, but between the Cursed finding those two UT’s on the northern island that used to produce gold and Devereaux’s flavor text, it was too good to pass up. It is an “all-knowing” or omniscient Eye that can see everyone at all times! O_O
With that, here we go! Since you can see what the factions see and the Cursed now have the Eye, the entirety of all three oceans will finally be revealed!
The Sea of Allost:
The Caribbean, looking from southeast to northwest:
Looking from southwest to northeast:
The Sea of Karkuda:
I did still leave something out of the picture to the southeast… it’s not a big deal and nothing to get super excited about, but it seems like there should be at least one more “reveal” when the stuff there is found.
With that, I move to the Caribbean next, and hope to play more Wednesday-Friday this week than I did these past few days.
The game is about as peaceful as it’s been for quite some time, but not in the Caribbean! The English strike back hard against the Spanish, getting some quality shots in with firepots from the Guy Fawkes and Durham setting the Ebro and Santa Catalina ablaze. The Duke of York and Burma are trying to leave the battlefield to repair at home, while the Meresman, Platagenet and Metal Dragon are coming up from the south to replace them. So far the accuracy of the English cannons has negated the Spanish numbers advantage, which is dwindling as a result.
Back at the English HI, many repairs are being carried out. The Resolution, Ark Royal, Lord Kettering and Extremadura are all being operated on. The Granville, Resistance, and Corazon del Mar will join them shortly. The Wycliffe has finished repairing and speeds out to assist in the war effort against Spain.
The Spanish take their turn in the combat zone, doing solid damage. The Ebro burns to a crisp, and the Santa Catalina will next turn since she rolled poorly for her fire. However, the Burma and King John are dismasted, with the KJ losing both her crew to the Asesino’s cargo-wrecking ability. The Serpiente hits 2/2 to down the mainmast of the Guy Fawkes.
A view from above showing the slow but steady Spanish advance. The battle isn’t as loud or crowded as the First Battle of Diamond Rock, but the engagement is important to keep Spanish morale high after their (debatable) victory at Paradise Island not long ago.
Cashing in textiles, the Spanish launch one of their best ships, the Santo Columba! This ship was my original Spanish flagship, as it was the largest Spanish ship I owned in my original collection of 49 ships “back in the day”. She is well-equipped for war and will likely sail straight to the ongoing battle.
Just like the Santa Ana, the ship is bristling with a powerful broadside. You can see the fine layer of dust just forward of the mainmast – this ship has been in a LOT of battles over the years!
On the Merc turn the Celtic Fury moved west. The French had an easy turn without combat or launches, but it still took me almost 15 minutes to move all of their 60+ ships. The Conquerant succeeded at her first EA roll to move towards the front of the pack. Remember that the French launched considerable amounts of firepower the last two turns and now it is departing from the Harbor.
The French discover the Castle!! This occurred when the fog bank the Ville de Paris was in lifted as the ship rolled to come out of the fog right into the outer wall of the castle! The ship’s durability prevented the loss of any masts.
Similar but less complicated than the American situation in the southwest, the French face a towing and repairing dilemma at The Flat. The Dauphin Royal goes to the other end to repair, with the Superbe guarding her against any American foolishness. Other ships dock or attempt to dock at the southern end of the island. The Seattle is captured now that the Hercule has been repaired.
With the biggest fleet in the game almost entirely confined to the western 1/3 of Karkuda following that line of reefs, the Americans continue to face logistical difficulties. At the scene of their battle they are towing derelicts and captures around to get them home. More damaged ships have begun arriving from the fight at The Flat. Preble has finally set sail again, and for now he is guarding the whirlpool with the help of a flotilla. His long-term plans have been put on hold by the big battles and the logistics of the cleanup effort. At the far right, the Brandywine and other ships continue to scout the Castle.
Turn 59 begins with the Pirate whirlpool squadron advancing! With an alliance with the French secured, the Pirates now feel confident about exploring the Sea of Karkuda. The Sunrise Fire uses her ability to explore The Flat, where the Madagascar and Otter may dock next turn to load textiles.
The French inform the captain of the Feathered Hat about their Mercenary ties, a faction the Pirates didn’t previously know about. The FH sails south to greet O’Brien on the Celtic Fury.
Potential problems for the English in the Caribbean! Blackbeard is here! Returning to one of his old real-life stomping grounds, the feared pirate arrives in the Caribbean.
Using Lady Baptiste’s reroll for Sean Gallows’ EA, the Queen Anne’s Revenge rams HMS Apollo! Shots are fired into the hull of the poor English ship, with two finding their mark to fell a mast.Blackbeard commands a boarding party and wins to capture the English captain!!
Back to the Sea of Allost!
The transfer is complete!! The Silver Dagger gave a ladder to the Revenant, and Calico Cat used an EA to hoist it up high in the air from the mainmast! The Pirates are experimenting with the Tunnel, trying to reach the ceiling of it with ladders. Now it becomes obvious why the Silver Dagger was launched with 3 ladders aboard: Mission intends to carry out some operations at the Tunnel. The Revenant was chosen since her mainmast reaches higher in the air than the masts of smaller ships like the Silver Dagger and Mission’s own Crusher. However, the height is still not enough to reach the ceiling of the Tunnel.
The Silver Dagger tries the same thing with one of her ladders. Men clamber up to the top, but are unable to do anything with the steep and curved sides of the Tunnel. It may be possible to hang from the top if a hook is affixed to the ceiling in the middle, but the curved sides leading there are too difficult to use, while the men on the ladder from the Revenant cannot reach the wide ceiling part. Much to the Pirates’ dismay, it seems that neither option will work.
Bartholomew Roberts and Captain Mission watch from their shorter ships as Calico Cat and Griffin aboard the Revenant become frustrated.
Here you can see that it really is a high Tunnel, with the height exceeding the height of two main masts of a 5 master stacked on top of each other.
Long shadows in the Tunnel, where the Pirates have been stopped by nature:
The Pirates don’t know it yet, but thanks to Shal-Bala and the Eye, we know what lies above! XD
The Pirates continue to get metals from Pistol Island, with their southern whirlpool looking as deserted as ever. The Deliverance may join back up with the whirlpool squadron now that Havana Black has replenished his stores of sacrificial oarsmen.
Up north, Captain Villanueva was puzzled why the Pirates hadn’t explored the Sultan shipwreck near the other whirlpool. Taking his ship over the reef, he quickly discovers why, with the Rum Runner losing a mast. The 5 Pirate gunships launched last turn will join the HI raiders at the whirlpool where they await further orders. The Pirates are considering another assault on the Americans, but they are understandably nervous that it will go as badly as the last attack. In addition, the Feathered Hat was going to come back through a whirlpool to inform the Pirates at home of the new alliance with the French, but the FH’s captain is off to meet O’Brien instead. With no ships from the whirlpool squadron returning yet, Mission himself and the other Pirates in the Sea of Allost are unaware of the alliance, which could prove very helpful if the Pirates combine a squadron with the French ships near The Flat, or coordinate a pincer strike from both Karkuda whirlpools.
The Pirates also launch three ships from Dead Man’s Point: the Kirbac and Venture are cheap gunships for home defense, while the Revenge will be the first ship to load lumber from that island! The Revenge is a nice option for cheap firepower as well, but with three cargo spaces open with a helmsman aboard, the Pirates are looking to use her ability (move S after unloading cargo) to help in their resource efforts. That ability will allow the ship to get a bit of a jump back out of the kingdom, which may help to not clog the entrances as much.
The Jades and Cursed had uneventful turns, with both sides continuing to wait and wait until their next battle erupts. However, although the Jades still have “tunnel vision” (pun intended) on the Cursed, the Cursed are now more indecisive and hesitant than ever. Seeing everything in play with the Eye has led them to become scattered in their thoughts, as they have so many more options. With three factions currently larger than them (Pirates, Americans, French), the Cursed are worried that continual war with the Jade Rebellion will wear away and diminish any chance of them winning the game overall. It does appear that some Cursed gunships are headed east around the fog banks instead of gathering at the entrance to the Roost. At the far right, the Sea Crane and Naegling are in fog banks due to Tsuro and Tabby (McWarren), as the Cursed L-movers have been pretty effective the last few turns. Unfortunately for the Cursed there aren’t many reefs nearby to toss ships onto. Also, somehow I haven’t even mentioned this yet, but I’m using the version of flat earth where ships cannot be moved off the ocean and removed from play. This is partly because thematically there is “more out there” beyond the boundaries (recall the Jades and Americans arriving in the oceans rather than starting at a HI), and because with so many HI’s right next to the edges, I don’t want the Cursed to have another advantage by moving newly launched ships straight out of play. Plus the Cursed already have house rules working in their favor, and now they have the Eye as well.
The Jades launched the Yggdrasil at the end of their turn and the Cursed cashed in a few textiles to complete the crew complement of the Executioner.
Things are a bit dormant right now, but who knows what will happen next? Stay tuned!
The Second Battle of Diamond Rock in the Caribbean, showing an effective English turn:
Both the Serpiente and Asesino de la Nave were set on fire, while the Profeta was dismasted.
Off to the right, the Burma has been chain towed out of the area by a trio of English ships, while the Duke of York heads home for repairs.
At last, the Lord Algernon and Orkney have docked home the towed ships.
A truce has been agreed to!! It is a lengthy 10 turn truce, with neither side firing at opposing ships for 10 turns total. This happened after some negotiations between the English and Spanish. Both sides are utterly exhausted by the war effort, and both have seen many gunships sunk or captured. They are on the verge of losing points in their fleet instead of gaining them long-term with how things have been going. Both fleets are also among the weakest in the game right now (in fact they are the two smallest by point count of the starting factions), and although they don’t know that, they do know that continual warfare will likely result in neither of them winning much of anything. In addition, the goal of commanding Diamond Rock has seemed overly ambitious and not even that beneficial to the Spanish, who have been doing alright running gold and resources from Paradise Island. Meanwhile, the English vastly underestimated the Spanish and find it hard to believe the Spaniards nearly won a battle and have put up a great fight in the latest one. The English are eager to retire, though here it was the Spanish who opened the negotiations as they likely would have lost the battle if they had continued fighting.
The French sail out of their Harbor in force!
Preble gives his AA to the USS Mercury, who explores the Castle for the first time!! However, exploring the Castle and what it has to offer fully may take a few turns, similar to Diamond Rock. At the right, the Brandywine continues to scout the eastern side of the Castle, nearly glimpsing the Celtic Fury through the fog.
The huge American fleet continues to operate, though with less defined objectives than they’ve had for around 20+ turns now. They finally moved their artillery unit on the lumber island to the east, and it points directly at The Flat. Just west of that island, notice the American troop transports rounding the island and beginning to head south. At the bottom, a small “super squadron” heads northeast, led by the Blackwatch and Concordia. At the left, a full half-dozen American gunships simply wait out the logjam and await further orders. Those ships are simply getting out of the way at this point – the Americans have so many ships that they don’t know what to do with them all! However, with declarations of war against the other two strongest factions in the game (Pirates and French), they will surely need them eventually.
The United States, Appalachian, and Vermont join Preble’s President on whirlpool guard duty. The towing and repairing efforts are mostly sorted out by now, and you can see that Ruby Island is finally being visited by cargo ships once more.
The American home island, crowded as usual. The James Madison and Louisiana are not on fire; I’m using those flames to represent exploding shot. The Americans used 15 gold to purchase 5 of them, which they intend to use against the reefs. With significant logjams still present near the lumber island, and the big discovery of the Castle just recently, the Americans will once again try to clear a path for ships. In the long term, one could argue that the reefs could serve as a defensive line if a faction tries to eliminate the Americans at their HI. However, the Americans are quite ambitious in this game and would like to do the opposite – drive opponents away from their own home islands, so they don’t have to play defense in the first place! Plus, with a major Pirate incursion via the whirlpool, there is a way to hit the Americans near home without passing over the reefs.
No less than 11 ships are repairing at the American HI, 5 of them Pirate captures and more ships joining them soon. As is typical for me in these types of games, once a battle ends I will sometimes gather a ship’s masts and place them on the deck once the ship begins repairing, rather than finding each one individually among the wreckage on the turns it repairs.
With a Caribbean Truce in effect, the two most recently active wars have been put on hold. However, the wars between the JR/Cursed and Americans/Pirates could erupt again at any time. Possibly even more interesting, Turn 60 will see the resources finally change again! The most recent change was for 5 turns but was extended to 7 through two random changes when I rolled 1’s. Many factions are sitting on large stockpiles of spices, so if those happen to skyrocket in value it could change things big-time.
A 2 roll for 5 turns! The 2 was the first time that came up for a regular roll, though it did occur on one of the random one turn changes. Lumber was worth 6, with luxuries 5 and spices 4. Not only that, but the duration roll was for exactly 5 turns, the 4th time in the last 5 changes that a 5 was rolled for duration!
Captain Villanueva’s hunch pays off! The Rum Runner loads newly discovered gold from the Sultan shipwreck! Northwest of her, Blackbeard returns from the Caribbean, satisfied with his captive English captain. He would have liked to abduct more crew, but the English gunships turning around from battle would have wrecked the QAR quickly.
The Pirates have a solid position within the Tunnel. The Harbinger and Victoire are still guarding the western approach while hiding in the fog. The Sea Nymph and Royal Rover are patrolling inside the Tunnel, while Mission (in the Crusher) and Calico Cat (in the Revenant) head east on important business.
The Silver Dagger is also speeding east after her quick trip out with the ladders.
Not the French turn yet, but the Pirate whirlpool squadron is busy in the Sea of Karkuda. At the right, the Feathered Hat meets up with the Celtic Fury, and the Pirate captain has a discussion with Eileen Brigid O’Brien. The FH’s captain makes sure to emphasize how rich and powerful the Pirates are, and how they have a golden island right near their “huge” kingdom. O’Brien is impressed and will inform Nemo but not the French, who are still unaware of the Mercenary situation. At the left, the Madagascar and Otter will soon take textiles from The Flat but French repair and regroup efforts are blocking their path somewhat.
With a rare view seen from the Noble Swan’s only mast, you see what the crew of the NS doesn’t: the Sea Crane has rolled to emerge from the fog on the OTHER side, exposing the huge southern wall of the Tunnel. The Sea Crane is the first Jade ship to go east of the fog! Funny thing is, it happened by accident. The SC was only in the fog after a Cursed L-mover put her there. Who knows what this will result in – possibly some Jade scouting of the Tunnel, or the full scope of the Pirate operations finally revealed to them.
The Cursed are on the move! About six gunships appear to be making a break for the Tunnel! Just above them, you can see a cargo ship logjam.
Fog hoppers attack!! Using the Eye on a tactical strike for the first time, the Sea Hag, Needle, and Hangman’s Joke emerge in the Sea of Karkuda! This is the first time the Cursed have showed up in that ocean!! The Sea Hag somehow hit 4/4, making it easy for the Hangman’s Joke to capture the Brandywine!
The Needle was going to capture the ship, but she got a bad fog roll so the Hangman’s Joke hopped between oceans as well.
Just when you thought the Cursed turn couldn’t get any better, the Gold ship appears! …
… at both of their wild islands!! However, both times the ship disappears just as suddenly, with the Cursed unable to communicate with it or fire at it.
The Cursed have been gathering lumber, and combined some of that with a large chunk of saved up luxuries and spices that were cashed in! They spent all 213 gold on a megalaunch! No less than 5 new sea creatures emerge from the depths, including the Super Rare version of Brachyura, who will (tentatively) have Eternal built-in to accommodate for the sparklyness. XD
The Flying Dutchman is a new Cursed flagship, as they’ve been operating with multiple flagships throughout this game. The Monkey’s Paw and Soul Crusher (where Wraith lies) have been the others in general, though the Soul Crusher has not been in combat yet. The Roost is quite crowded! In addition, this launch likely put the Cursed at just over 1,000 total points in their fleet, making them the fourth fleet to reach that huge milestone! O_O (FOUR 1,000 point fleets in one game… wow…)
The Poor Adams does a fog hop of her own, getting a nice roll out of the one where the Executioner now sits to move to the next one, taking advantage of a break in the JR line of battle. This gets the Poor Adams pretty close to the Jade HI, and she’s a ship with the HI raiding ability. The Executioner may be looking to do the same next turn if the Jades don’t close that gap.
It was a quiet day in the Caribbean, with the first turn of a 10 turn truce passing peacefully. Both fleets took their final derelicts under tow and began the journey home for repairs.
French operations with their huge fleet. At the lower right, the Ange and Bourbon look to defend the eastern food island and possibly explore new territory. At the end of their turn, the French cashed in a lot of luxuries but didn’t spend any gold, an uncommon occurrence in this game of hyper-spending and megalaunches.
The extremely strong French position at The Flat, which now stands at nine 5 masted capital ships with many more gunships sailing in from the east. The French wanted to put their best fleet forward, and they’ve done that. It’s slightly similar to another cumulative game I played a while back, when the French had a line of battle with just 5 masters from end to end. An impressive display of firepower, and ANY faction would now be very hard-pressed to dislodge the French from The Flat. Thinking the Mercs are still on their side, French ships make sure a path is clear for the Celtic Fury’s move action next turn.
Hearing gunfire and commotion to the east, and wanting to help, the captain of the York sails his ship towards what eventually becomes evident as a Cursed incursion! The Americans are shocked and unhappy to see the Cursed in the game. The York misses her only shot against the Sea Hag.
As you may have seen from the previous picture, the Castle has some openings that are perfect for schooners to sail through, which the Gold Eagle takes advantage of here. The Mercury’s crew are still exploring the Castle, and are finding it rather dilapidated. The Philadelphia’s crew call for help across the reef barrier! They fear the worst for the Brandywine, who has disappeared.
Preble himself hears the call, and sends the lumbering United States over the reef! Improbably, that ship rolls a 6 to avoid damage but the Saratoga (RotF version, all three versions are in play haha) rolls a 1 to lose two masts! With such unpredictable results, Preble is not likely to risk the President on the reefs, especially when 5 new exploding shot barrels will be arriving shortly.
The Americans are sending some gunships and their troop transports south towards the Castle. At the right you can see the foresail of the Mercury as if the ship sits in drydock, while the Gold Eagle ducks under the narrow arch built long ago as part of the Castle.
A rare view showing how long the western wall of the Castle is, with various American ships visible.
A possibly unprecedented situation at the American home island, with 14 ships at various stages in the repair process. The logistics have become so hampered by the cleanup of the two battles that various ships cannot even dock. The canoes, Lynx, Pawtucket, and others must wait their turn. The continual difficulties have led to frustration for Preble and the rest of the Americans. Preble is intrigued by the Castle as a possible second base of operations, and may dedicate considerable spending to renovate and restore it. That’s his best case scenario, but interference by the French, Pirates, or even Cursed may hinder his plans. He is proceeding with cautious optimism and plans to oversee things at home and at the Castle from his current post near Ruby Island in between the two areas.
Turn 61 begins with a surprising random resource change! Just a turn after the regular change, I rolled a 1 to change things yet again. The two means the new change would only last for a turn, just like the previous random changes, as I haven’t rolled two 1’s in a row yet for this. However, the final die was a 1 as well, the first time in the game that a 1 came up for resource values! Everything would be worth its face value, with lumber plummeting to 1 for a turn while luxuries and spices increased to 6 and 5. As I mentioned in the last report, many factions are sitting on big stockpiles of spices, so this will be a LONG turn!
I only played the Pirate turn of this round so far, since it took quite a while.
Mission and Calico Cat emerge from the Tunnel in a picturesque Pirates CSG scene:
Wow! With Cursed ships approaching the western entrance to the Tunnel, Captain Blackheart and Hammersmith emerge from the fog aboard the Harbinger and Victoire! However, this time the Pirates are able to actually talk to the Cursed, instead of being hissed at by the ill-tempered Wraith. El Fantasma himself appears from the deck of the Divine Dragon. A very long conversation is had. Many things are discussed, most of which I won’t discuss here. XD I can say that the Cursed had planned to infiltrate the Tunnel, possibly to access the Pirate gold island and/or to circle back around the eastern entrance for a surprise attack on the Jades’ unprotected eastern front. However, the Pirates talked and threatened them out of it: not only do the two Pirate 5 masters have sac crew aboard (being able to rip off 20 shots between them this turn alone), but the Pirates have a strong squadron stationed off the northern whirlpool which could trap or intercept any Cursed squadron entering the Tunnel. (the conversation was actually quite long because the more I thought about the situation, the longer it took me to figure things out!) Things are getting complicated in this game. Oh yeah. Very complex. With 3 oceans, over 6,000 points, now 8 fleets, and various alliances, lies, truces, and wars occurring, the game is finally reaching a level of complexity I don’t think I’ve seen in ANY of my games. At the end of the day, no hostile actions or words were exchanged. Instead, you could say that the Pirates made a deal with the Devil – literally. O_O
The Pirates were one of the factions sitting on spices until they were worth 5 or 6, and now they cash in all their chips! Spending 315 gold on the second megalaunch of the day, the Pirates put 16 new ships in the water. Those first 5 on the left are for various roles, with Bonny Peel and Will Turner looking to join Blackbeard in the kidnapping festivities. XD The Stoneheart has built-in reroll for Calypso, a crew that came up huge for the Pirates in Economy Edition and whose one-of-a-kind ability could do the same here in CTO. The Draconum is the second bombardier launched after the French Conquerant, while the Amity will use Ghost Ship to avoid logjams at the kingdom when unloading resources, just like the Hades’ Flame has done recently.
The other 11 ships launched are part of a task force whose goal is known only to the Pirates as of now. Most of the ships (some quite colorful) are launched from Dead Man’s Point, which is full once again.
With this launch, the Pirates have almost exactly the same number of points in play as the Americans, passing the French and nearly tying the Americans at around 1,365 points each. O_O Not only that, but with around 500 points between the Cursed and Pirates, the game has reached 6,500 total points and may even reach a ridiculous 7,000 by turn’s end.
The Stoneheart and Amity begin their journey in the game inside the kingdom:
More action coming soon! I’m getting quite excited about the possibilities, and like I said, things are getting VERY complicated. The strategy and diplomacy will require both finesse and strength in order for a faction to prevail! More is coming soon, though with large quantities of spices still to be cashed in, Turn 61 promises to be one of the longest yet. In fact, how about I record what is currently on my index card of saved up gold and resources for the factions who have stuff: (this doesn’t include what is still physically on their HI’s!)
Jades: 56 spices (with maybe 20+ in physical form too, so they could cash in for nearly 400 gold this turn)
Cursed: 17 textiles (not valuable now)
English: 38 spices (booyah! lol)
Mercenaries: 5 fish, 2 textiles
French: 7 textiles, 8 fish, 178 gold
Americans: 10 textiles, 196 gold
Finally everything came together for the first time in quite a while for a BIG day of play! 😀 Not counting the Pirate turn played yesterday, I essentially played a whopping THREE turns even as the game size approaches 7,000 points!
With the Pirate turn of Turn 61 over, I started the day with the Jade Rebels. In a strange move that displayed a new strategy, the Jades sent the Grendel as “bait” in an attempt to get the Cursed to attack. The Grendel missed both her shots against the Juggernaut, the first ship in the Cursed squadron still pointed at the Tunnel. By the end of their turn, the Grendel was given an AA by Sigurd Andersen to return to the Jade defensive position.
Continuing the tiny-scale attack, the Wiglaf and Wodin team up to knock masts off the Spilled Salt, a ship that is damaged for I think the third time in this game. The Wodin captured the Cursed musketeer with a boarding party, but this was the extent of the Jade strike.
With a large war fleet ready to go, it’s a bit puzzling why the Jades didn’t launch a full attack. Quite frankly, they are scared. They are afraid that the Pirates and Cursed agreed to an alliance on the Pirate turn (which they didn’t, but merely struck a deal), and are wondering if a huge Pirate fleet will suddenly emerge from the foggy Tunnel….
Cashing in a whopping 81 spices for 405 gold, the Jades save most of it but launch the Hlidskjalf and Grand River, the latter of which is a custom Jade 6 master I created way back in late 2011. The GR will be proxied by the Grand Dynasty, which was sunk earlier in the game.
Grand River
Jade Rebellion, 16 points, 6 masts, 5 cargo, S+S speed, Guns: 3S,3S,3L,3L,3S,3S
Junk. This ship’s base move becomes S when she reaches her cargo limit.
After snagging the Brandywine in a brilliant fog raid against an isolated ship, the Sea Hag and Hangman’s Joke take their prize back to the safety of the fog:
Another fog attack! This time the Needle and Behemoth (who has been copying the fog hopper ability) use the Eye to catch the Sea Crane in between the Tunnel and the Jade HI! Behemoth pins the ship, which is likely doomed.
With a rare view looking out of the west, the Cursed strike back! The Jikininki and Fallen Angel are ineffective, but the Death’s Anchor and Executioner team up to doom the Wodin with fire!
However, the Cursed don’t take the bait! They are showing some great patience as of late and seem to be biding their time. However, they are certainly preparing for something….
After agreeing with the Pirates to not invade the Tunnel and the eastern half of Allost, the Cursed turn their ships around. Suddenly almost all Cursed gunships are heading west.
In the Caribbean, an appearance by the Dragon’s Breath has the English on edge and ready for anything. However, the Pirates assure the English they mean no harm unlike Blackbeard and Havana Black. The captain of the Dragon’s Breath says another ship will soon be arriving through the whirlpool, though not a Pirate one….
Cashing in 43 spices for 215 gold, the English launch 9 ships! Most of them are for a squadron that may do whirlpool expeditions. With a 10 turn truce with the Spanish secured, the English are hoping to expand into the other oceans they know about but haven’t been to. (outside of the Westminster who has been presumed lost at sea by the English command)
The first big English launch in quite some time! If not for the truce the Spanish would likely be in big trouble.
Speaking of the Spanish, here are 4 of their ships repairing along with most of their operations.
The French go about their business. With excess ships, the French can afford to have multiple squadrons for different purposes. Currently, the bulk of their battle fleet is stationed around The Flat.
The line of troop transports advances with the help of the lighthouse towards The Flat, which the French plan to turn into a stronghold.
As Pirate ships finally take textiles, the French have a massive concentration of firepower on all sides of the island:
The French arrive in the Caribbean for the first time!! Using directions from the DB’s crew, Guy LaPlante was able to find the Caribbean without having to roll for whirlpool location. Playing a hunch in addition to general orders from Lenoir, LaPlante is in the Caribbean not for the English but for the Spanish. Deleflote’s action allowed the Possession to move towards the Spanish fleet right after exiting the whirlpool, as LaPlante’s mission is one of some urgency.
The crew aboard the York have their worst fears confirmed: the Brandywine has disappeared! Between the gunshots and the Sea Hag giving them the slip, the Americans assume the ship was captured and taken by the Cursed.
Beyond the Brandywine’s masts, you can see a cracked wall of the Castle.
The American venture further east into the Castle area, impressed by its size and height. The crew of the Saratoga moor their ship inside, but will find repairs impossible until more assistance and supplies arrives.
Looking from directly above the west wall of the Castle, American operations on Turn 61. The Louisiana and James Madison are carrying exploding shot into position for attempts at clearing reefs. The American assembly line of ships continues to round the reefs and fog to the north, with the troop transports slowly approaching the Castle.
Cashing in some spices and adding it to their reserves of gold, the Americans spend a whopping 291 gold! However, 250 of it is spent on the third fort upgrade purchased in this game! You can see it on a new American capital ship, the Enterprise! The Enterprise was my second 5 master EVER and is such a veteran of HFS battles and various games that her masts are somewhat loose simply from being taken out and repaired dozens of times.
You’ll also notice the new infantry troops aboard the Nene-nui and Colonial Trader, in addition to even more infantry on the home island.
With Turn 61 in the books, Turn 62 saw a return to the resource value roll of 2, meaning spices would be back down to 4 with lumber king once again.
After speaking with O’Brien, the crew of the Feathered Hat take a little time to explore their surroundings, finding the Castle! However, having only seen the north face of it, the Pirates aren’t fully aware of the Castle’s size or potential.
With a VERY successful trip, some of the Pirate whirlpool squadron returns home! Havana Black is disappointed he missed out but is excited to learn about the developments. The captain of the Dragon’s Breath informs him of the new alliance with the French, in addition to LaPlante’s recent excursion to the Caribbean, where the English look ready for a potential Pirate attack. The Madagascar and Otter will eventually unload their small quantities of textiles at the kingdom, which will be the first time the Pirates have that resource since the DMP island stopped producing it.
With a great view from above, here is the Pirate Kingdom!
The western half of Allost is much more tense, but neither side engages. Hearing shots beyond the fog, the Grand Temple and a Viking 1 master enter the fog west of the Tunnel. The Wiglaf flees from the Cursed, but the Wodin burns to the waterline and is eliminated from the game.
The Cursed continue to move west:
The new English squadron sets sail! In addition, the Ark Royal has been repaired and crewed with a captain, helmsman, and oarsman once more.
Even as one of the smaller fleets in the game, the English are still capable of a “forest of masts” if the picture is taken at the right angle:
Sighting the French tricolor speeding towards them from the Possession’s mainmast, the Santo Columba surges forward to greet the new faction! (new to the Spanish, that is) LaPlante is able to row over in a boat and immediately engages in conversation with the SC’s captain. By the time he climbs back into the boat, the Spanish are furious.
With a line of signals exchanged, Marcus Vaccaro (the current Spanish admiral) becomes knowledgeable of the development. He sails over and hails Admiral Thomas Gunn aboard HMS Lord Algernon. In a surprisingly cordial meeting of the flagships, a deal is struck – the Spanish and English have PEACE! O_O
Clearly something has changed Spanish minds, and the Spanish have lost interest with the War on England. The truce has been abandoned for a full, indefinite period of peace between the two factions. A milestone in the Caribbean for sure!
The Mercenaries take their turn, and Eileen Brigid O’Brien pilots the Celtic Fury towards the whirlpool! She then takes the 10 master through it!! O_O THIS WAS NOT THE PLAN!!
Following instructions laid out by the captain of the Feathered Hat, O’Brien brings her huge ship to the Sea of Allost! Suddenly the Celtic Fury is in Pirate waters! What could this mean??
The French go immediately after the Mercs in the turn order, and L’Heros meets with the Sunrise Fire. The crews exchange many words, with the captain of the Sunrise Fire somewhat puzzled but mostly playing dumb, knowing the sly nature of the Feathered Hat’s captain….
The plan was for the Celtic Fury to reinforce the French squadron at The Flat, making that area by far the most stable in the entire game with nearly a dozen French 5 masters and now a 10 master right around the island. However, the CF has disappeared from Karkuda entirely. Now, we know that the Mercenaries are playing on their own and have duped the French. However, it’s unclear if Nemo ordered O’Brien to do this or something else entirely. Perplexed but calm, the French use their southern squadron of 6 gunships to approach the submerged Mercenaries running resources to their sub hideout. Also, it’s worth noting that although they heard gunshots beyond the north wall of the Castle, the French don’t know about the Cursed.
At The Flat, L’Afrique drops off 4 infantry units. The Geographe approaches with more as the Felicite speeds off on her own business as a fast support gunship that has been given autonomy by Lenoir. At this point, due to the considerable distances involved, Lenoir is acting commander of the French battle fleet, while Gaston oversees operations closer to home. Gaston is still the main French admiral, but Lenoir is currently in command of far more firepower.
Again similar to that old game I played, I can’t get enough of this massive display of firepower the French have. Between the beauty of their ships, my love of 5 masters, and how similar their 5 masters are for gameplay, it’s just a perfect fleet!
Gaston himself turns around to sail towards the sub hideout, having got wind of the recent development. Since you see what the faction sees, check out what is visible to the Bourbon and Ange – shipwrecks in the distance!
Not wanting to believe the French, the captain of the Santo Columba calls Guy LaPlante (Diplomat of France! lol) over for an extended visit. The more the Spanish hear, the more they believe. The Spanish are outraged.
The York and Gold Eagle meet up and word is passed on about the Brandywine’s likely fate. The Americans have a bit of a morale loss, as the Brandywine had been an accurate vessel during the battle against the Pirates, setting at least one Pirate ship aflame while taking no damage. She was also one of the first ships to explore the Castle and the only ship to scout the eastern side until now. At the bottom, the Speedy Return loses a mast to the reef barrier, which the Americans are getting more confident with.
The Americans are in operating mode. With both wars somewhat on hold, the Americans are devoting major efforts to the Castle. The Louisiana was successful at blowing up a reef! This will help clear the way for American ships to access the eastern 2/3 of Karkuda more easily. In addition, note the impressive spending headed towards the Castle, with a fort upgrade, army units, and various ships sailing there.
With a view of the American HI from the west this time, many of the captured Pirate ships are finishing repairs. However, the Americans plan to trade them all in at once for a big influx of points to spend that turn. The Americans also rearrange their army units and resources to point their cannons and muskets more to the east.
This gives a small idea of the scope of this huge game. American logistics are slowly being optimized, but more reefs will need to be cleared before Preble is satisfied. The American-French truce is becoming a little more tense, as both sides have lines of battle set up within shooting distance of each other. The French line guards The Flat while the American line guards troop transports and fragile ships heading south towards the Castle. It remains to be seen what interest the French have in the Castle, if any.
Turn 63!
Mission uses his own EA to sail over and greet O’Brien! Eileen is extremely impressed with the Pirate operation and has agreed to join the Pirates!! It started with Nemo giving her some autonomy over how to handle certain situations, but it was mostly the Feathered Hat’s captain that persuaded O’Brien to take the CF into Pirate waters to at least check out their activities. O’Brien chose the Pirates after being disappointed by how tiny the Mercenary fleet is and seeing how controlling the French could be. With the Pirates she hopes to find her own way and not answer to the whims of Nemo or Gaston. In addition, the Pirates have offered higher pay than Nemo did. XD However, Mission already has a mission (lol) for the Celtic Fury….
Calico Cat takes the Revenant near the kingdom for the first time, while the Pirates now have quite the force near their southern whirlpool. The Deliverance and Fool’s Hope may join up with the Pirate whirlpool squadron. At the right, Calypso is in play aboard the Stoneheart, a ship the Pirates will want to keep safe.
Using a ladder she later takes aboard, the Ranger loads infantry units. A ship launched solely for ferrying random cargo (shipwrights, army units, ladders, etc), this is her first mission of the sort after sailing around aimlessly after being launched. In the background are some colorful sails, namely the Bloody Jewel and Rum Runner.
The Pirates still have good support around the eastern end of the Tunnel. The various 2 masted gunships have been patrolling for many turns now. On the contrary, recent launches sail south on a mission. Bonny Peel aboard the Akua Lapu and Will Turner aboard the Fleur de la Mort hope to capture enemy crew and turn them into gold! The question remains: which faction might they go after? The Jades and Cursed aren’t far away, but both have massed fleets full of warships. The whirlpool opens up any of the other factions as potential prey, and of course the Pirates could always split up as well. You can also just see the outline of the Royal Rover not even halfway in the Tunnel.
The most recently launched Pirate squadron meets with even more gunships at the northern whirlpool!
I count 22 ships ready to sail through the whirlpool on the next turn or two, and I believe all but the Thrud have captains and helmsmen.
Not satisfied with their infantry numbers, the Pirates cash in lumber from the Hades’ Flame to launch the Panama Sun with a helmsman and three infantry units aboard. You can also see the gold waterfall, the Pandora, and the Darkhawk II. The Pirates continue to source metals from Pistol Island, which may result in another big windfall eventually.
The Sea Crane predictably loses her fight against Behemoth and the Needle!
The Behemoth prepares to hop home while the Needle takes the Jade ship under tow just like the Hangman’s Joke did with the Brandywine.
Speaking of the Brandywine, the Cursed got her home quickly with another fog hop to the Roost!
Halls of Valhalla? Cursed sea monsters head west along with the regular gunships.
The Cursed are sailing towards the edge of the ocean, while 4 cargo ships dock at Broken Horn Island to load valuable lumber.
The English take in 9 spices while their new gunships head west:
The Santo Columba speeds southeast towards the English and the only Caribbean whirlpool.
Puzzled by the Aube, Voleur, and Bourbon trying to get his attention, Nemo actually surfaces the Nautilus! However, he keeps up the lie that the Mercs are actually helping the French and still under their command. Part of the reason he came to the surface is that he himself doesn’t understand why O’Brien took off, and he’s truthful about that to the French. The French are being fooled by Nemo, but both factions are left in the dust by Ms. O’Brien.
The French discover Fish Island but the Mobilis and Devil Ray refuse to surface.
At the eastern food island, the crew of La Dijon finds that metals have replaced food as the island’s resource! French cargo ships are always coming and going, but the Harbor is more deserted than it’s been in a while.
The Geographe drops off army units, and the French continue to fortify The Flat. At the left, you can see the French line of battle, full of capital ships. There are eight 5 masters in the staggered line with two more and the Hercule up north. At the right, another 10 gunships are sailing slowly along the west wall of the Harbor.
The French-American situation in Karkuda. The Americans have a very impressive line of their own, which now stretches just about the entire distance from the south to north. The Georgetown is at the southern edge of the ocean near the Castle, with the Paul Revere and Yankee the northernmost ships above the lumber island. At the bottom right, the Vermont and Speedy Return could discover Nemo’s Submarine Hideout and the French on the next turn. You can also see the Carolina ducking under a Castle arch.
Part of the reason I was able to play nearly 3 full turns was due to the lack of combat, which will likely change soon. Throw in less time overall to play, and things will slow back down again in terms of how many turns can be played in the short term. However, the game is getting more exciting and it’s basically a convoluted mess at this point between all the possibilities, alliances, and lies going around! Stay tuned!
Warning: short report here, and the next few will likely be as well.
Turn 64 begins with yet another random resource change! For this one turn, metals would be worth 6 again and textiles 5! This would result in a bunch of launches since those resources haven’t been valuable in a while.
The Pirates send the Xiamen’s Claws through the whirlpool and she arrives in the Sea of Karkuda!! Christoper Moody is in a bad mood! XD
Using an AA from Jean Lafitte, the Xiamen’s Claws spots the American flagship and rams the President! Preble himself is under attack! The XC hit with her 2S guns to damage the President and eliminate a canoe heading home with spices from Ruby Island. However, the 5 is the boarding roll for Preble, who narrowly escaped a brutal fate. The XC rolled a 3 to lose the boarding party 9-8 (the XC gets +1 to boards), losing her helmsman. The President had reroll to save the American crew, but if both their rolls had been low, Preble himself would have been massacred along with the captain and helmsman by Moody! O_O Making a statement, the Pirates strike the American core directly with a surprise whirlpool assault.
The Americans are under attack! Or, they will be once the Pirates take their next turn to actually shoot. Including the Xiamen’s Claws (an underrated Pirate gunship option I must say), the Pirates send 14 ships through the whirlpool! The Thrud is the only one without a captain aboard, and some HI raiders are among the lot. It’s a decent squadron of mostly average gunships that will put American defenses to the test yet again. However, this time the Pirates plan on fighting harder and longer, as their spending indicates….
To give you a sense of what the Pirates have been thinking about (since I’ve mostly just done that in detail for the Americans so far), they were not planning this as of last night. That squadron of ships and some others were actually going to invade the Caribbean and attack the English instead! O_O However, a few things changed their mind. First, the Dragon’s Breath reported back last turn, saying that the English had some ships defending against whirlpool attack and possibly a large squadron heading there in the distance (which is true). Second, the Pirates are generally aware that the Americans have one of the biggest fleets in the game, while the English likely do not. The Pirates certainly know this between their defeat at the hands of the Americans and their alliance with the French providing information about the Second Fight at The Flat. Finally, the Pirates would still like to strike the English (and hopefully soon), but for now they are concentrating their war effort against a faction they want revenge on, and a faction that we know (as the witnesses of the point counts) MIGHT be the Pirates’ biggest rival long-term especially with the French as an ally.
Cashing in 26 metals for 156 gold, the Pirates spend it all on 9 additional gunships!! After their “meh” gunships went through the whirlpool to Karkuda, it was evident that some of them weren’t crewed well enough. Hence, a medical barge. The Raven’s Neck carries regular fighting crew but has the cargo available to also carry 3 shipwrights. She will sail to Karkuda in the hopes of providing repair assistance to Pirate ships in need. Medical barges are best as durable ships that can fight if need be but usually stay back from a fight to distribute shipwrights to retreating vessels, possibly elongating their stay on the battlefield. It’s likely that the battle against the Americans will be too chaotic and crowded for this kind of finesse strategy to work, but the Pirates want to properly support their attack unlike the first battle. Below the RN’s deckplate are 7 more average or somewhat subpar gunships that the Pirates consider expendable (unlike the Revenant for example). The Pirates are simply going to throw massive points at the Americans in an effort to weaken them, distract them, and possibly even raid their HI. However, though these ships may even be less effective than the ones that just entered Karkuda, they are crewed better. All the ships have an oarsman and/or shipwright aboard, ensuring that they will be ready for battle after any potential whirlpool damages. (losing the oarsman or repairing for a turn AT the battlefield rather than having to lose an important mast or helmsman) At the top, the Obago is separate because she will stay behind with the other anti-English ships (such as the Revenge and Black Mongoose, who get +1 to cannon rolls against the English). Therefore it was a dual launch, with most of the ships launched to combat the Americans but at least one to augment the slowly growing squadron which may infiltrate the Caribbean at some point.
Mission leads the Celtic Fury and other ships towards the Tunnel. Up top, sheer firepower awaits the Americans and (probably at some point) the English. The Full Moon, Fuchuan, Zanzibar, and Poison Dagger can reach the whirlpool next turn, and they’ll probably join the fight against the Americans. The Golden Medusa and White Rose will likely stay behind from the battles and be reserved for conflicts later in the game. The Black Mongoose and Revenge will wait for reinforcements, while Blackbeard has his own agenda. The Recreant and Accused will likely stay behind after their disastrous experience in the first American battle, but add them and the Kirbac to the squadron just launched from Dead Man’s Point, and the Pirates have some serious firepower at their disposal near whirlpools. In fact, doing a quick count reveals about 34 gunships between the ones in Karkuda and the ones at DMP or near the northern whirlpool!
The Jade Rebellion turn was mostly uneventful, save for this. The Hlidskjalf AND Grand Temple both got very favorable fog rolls to luckily come out near the Needle to give the captured Sea Crane assistance! However, even with decently accurate cannons, the two ships only shot 2/6! This leaves the Needle able to sail back into the fog on the Cursed turn, at which point the Sea Crane will be lost.