Attacks coming from land, sea, and AIR

If this is too long and you won’t read it, you can see a few summaries of the action here and here.  There is also a video on my Instagram, as youtube and IG occasionally see exclusive footage of the action before the official battle report is posted.

The Americans begin their turn with their fight against the Spanish. The Kentucky has a miserable turn.
However, the Saratoga set the Santo Columba on fire, and the Enterprise has nearly reached the battle area:

The Zanzibar and Thrud are captured, with the Full Moon next.

The Americans continue to clean up the battle area, sending various gunships north to combat the French.

At the right, the Colonial Trader will soon reach the Castle to provide some infantry reinforcements.

Just to show the debris:

As I showed in one of the videos, the Americans have lost their line of battle in the northern area. The Congress is trading broadsides with the Hercule, but the Paul Revere is fleeing for repairs and the Yankee burned to the waterline.

In a huge morale victory for the Americans, the Monaque is dismasted and set aflame even more! This will probably doom the ship, making it the first French 5 master to sink in this game. On this turn it was a joint effort by no less than 4 different ships, as the Aaron Burr, Overton, President and Boston all got shots in.

With the President shooting, that means Commodore Preble has arrived! The American admiral hopes to reinvigorate the American defense, and brings with him some considerable reinforcements.

The Saratoga, Hudson, Intrepid, and Franklin are all a turn or two away from helping out.

Two other considerable foes are also approaching the French line: USS Kettering got Decatur’s EA this turn to speed northeast at S+L+S x2, while the Concordia also heads for the battle. You can also see 5 other American gunships along with the cheerleader ship Seminole heading northeast.

With the Saratoga and others stopping the Spanish advance, the Speedy Return may yet be able to repair at the Castle soon. The main American rival in the game is quickly shifting from the Pirates (handily defeated twice at the southwestern whirlpool) to the Franco-Spanish alliance, who not only threaten to defeat the Americans in what could be called the Third Fight at The Flat, but also threaten to take the Castle itself!

American “graveyard” for Turn 70. They lost over 50 points’ worth of stuff, a rarity due to the mast elimination and sinking rules in addition to how frequently fleets have fled and repaired during and after battles. It’s not that the Americans aren’t being cautious at all, it’s just that these three ships were all caught in the middle of intense gunnery from hostile ships with firepot specialists.

The Pirate turn

The Black Cat and Freedom emerge from their fog bank to escape via the whirlpool!

The Pirates RIP INTO the English invasion!!

The Pirates inflict high casualties, with almost all the English ships taking damage.

The Pirates are determined to limit or STOP the flow of English ships arriving from the Caribbean. To that end they have placed as many ships at or around the southeastern whirlpool as possible. By completely clogging the whirlpool, the English can probably be contained. The Pirates experienced the other end of this very recently, when they couldn’t send enough ships to Karkuda due to the battle area being too crowded, which was multiplied by the initial American refusal to capture ships and the small handful of English gunships that are still right around that whirlpool. Here, the Pirates use ships from the northern whirlpool of Allost to warp to the south. The Pride simply stays where she is and repairs to do her part in the blockade, while the Revenge, Black Mongoose, White Rose, Black Arrow, and Sister’s Rage suddenly appear from the northern whirlpool to block the English from arriving.

Havana Black takes the Deliverance to Ocean’s Edge!

The Fool’s Hope didn’t have a good turn against HMS Forge, but the Feathered Hat, Dragon’s Breath and Deliverance all did considerable damage for the Pirates. The severely damaged Bruja and Obago move to the outside to allow healthier Pirate ships to take their place, but the Pirates have an “all hands on deck” strategy here for repelling the English. They will NOT let them get anywhere in the Sea of Allost, let alone get near Mission’s Kingdom.

Also, one of the Pirate infantry units on the gold island eliminated a crew from the Hastings!

The Centurion and Thirty Tyrants repair at the northern whirlpool where they’re joined by the Black Cat and Freedom, the last Pirate ships to escape the American onslaught. Fresh Pirate ships begin to surround the northern whirlpool, where the Pirates will keep a close eye out for invaders.

The four Pirate gunships launched last turn speed south towards the English battle, and are joined by a few support gunships. You’ve probably noticed that the Pirates have a solid home fleet, with various smaller gunships on patrol duty all the time. A full half-dozen of them can be seen here along the eastern side of the reefs, though some have been called to act against the English. The Draconum is the personal “bodyguard ship” for Calypso and her ship, the Stoneheart.

Back inside the Tunnel! The Pirates complete drilling operations from the ladder attached to the Celtic Fury’s tall mast! However, they’ve hit something they can’t get through!!

Unbeknownst to them, a huge boulder blocks their path!

Taken for my own amusement, this picture shows what would have happened if they could get through the big stone. I managed to punch a perfect hole right to where the rock was, and it came off the Tunnel since there wasn’t a lot of glue to hold it. XD The mini screwdriver went through the ceiling of the Tunnel, but the rock was there to block it in the game.

I couldn’t get a great closeup of the hole, which looks cooler from the bottom in real life. At this point it’s probably obvious what the Pirates intend to do….

With their home waters threatened, the Raven stops by the entrance to the Tunnel to check to see if things are OK. Her crew are surprised as the Pirates in the Tunnel approach, telling the ship to back off. Those Pirate ships are about to make way for the Celtic Fury to turn around, for Mission is not giving up on his Tunnel operations….

At the other end of the Tunnel, I was quite disappointed to see the Pirate “mini super squadron” fail miserably. The Revenant couldn’t get Calico Cat’s EA, while the Victoire and Harbinger got bad fog rolls that forced them to go back in. However, the Fleur de la Mort eliminated a Cursed canoe (the first time the Pirates or Cursed have had direct combat!) and captured a Viking helmsman via Will Turner’s S-boarding ability.

The Revenant did knock off the Floating Stone’s turtle panels, but overall it was a disappointing effort by the Pirates’ western squadron.

Not wanting any part of a nasty, messy, and deadly Cursed-JR crossfire, the Royal Rover and Sea Nymph turn around on orders from Captain Mission. At this point Mission has spent a lot of time in the Tunnel overseeing the progress.

The Pirates launched the Seref and Empress at Dead Man’s Point.

At the upper right, you may have noticed Plumb Point Lighthouse, the second lighthouse in the game! Vixenishcoder66 is still working on the major ability, but this is the version I’ll use if it comes up:

vixenishcoder66 wrote:

(Rough Draft) Pirates Cove: When an enemy ship enters the range of this lighthouse the player must roll a d6. 1-2 this ship immediately stops and cannot be given any more move actions. The owner of the lighthouse may initiate a boarding party against this ship (no friendly ship is necessary). The lighthouse gets +3 to boarding rolls. If the enemy ship wins the boarding roll nothing happens. The ship may move freely the following turn. 3-4 no effect, 5-6 this ship may be given an additional +S move action. Flavor text: It’s difficult to know who is friend or foe in these waters.

The new lighthouse is a perfect example of the new Pirate strategy, which is to stay at home and build up for when other factions come for them. It’s a structural investment very close the the Kingdom itself, and should allow the Pirates to gather spices faster, which is currently a valuable resource.

To the JR-Cursed War

The Jades get the party started! The Wiglaf hits the Sea Hag with stinkpots (which I use the green dice for when possible), while the Needle just barely escapes being dismasted by accurate Corsair gunships.

The Meshud breaks from the rest of the battle fleet to head west, as the Jades realize their surplus of ships heading due north but a potential shortage in the far west.

Blasting away at the Cursed! The Jade Rebels focus their fire on the Executioner, which bursts into flames!

The legendary Flying Dutchman is also engulfed by a blaze! The Scorpion and Fire Djinn were actually quite pathetic against the FD, going a combined 1/7 (though the Scorpion pinned the Hades’ Realm with her sickle). However, one ship really shined here: the Valkyrie. This Viking one master gets +1 to her cannon rolls against the Cursed, and Warlord Thorfinn (from the flavor text) was ready to fight today! The ship got two 6’s in a row to set the FD aflame with fire shot, bailing out her inaccurate comrades!

Closeup of the action:

The Jades were trying to prepare for the possibility of another devastating wave attack from Namazu. The Grand Path repairs, while the Beowulf eliminated part of the Clear Wind’s iceberg so it wouldn’t do further damage to Jade ships if the wave pushed it towards them. Other ships headed home for repairs, while the Grendel was chain-towed a bit. The Hrunting hides in the fog, letting the Donar take over against the Monkey’s Paw, though she is ineffective.

A largely pathetic effort by the Jades up north! The 1 masted longships go 4/6 to finish off the Cursed canoes, but the Strix and Knight’s Errant are still undamaged. The real failure came when the Floating Stone went 0/2 (with her reroll providing the second shot) and the Grand Mountain went just 2/6 and saw her exploding shot backfire!! Instead of the Revenant being damaged and aflame, the Jades had almost nothing to show for their efforts near the Tunnel.

The Revenant was hit by a stinkpot specialist, but she can simply duck into a fog bank if the Pirates continue to avoid combat in this area.

Of course, the flood of Jade Corsair ships continues:

At the right along the fog banks, the galleys cleared a path so the Polaris could finally move towards some icebergs in the north. Two of the best JR ships, the Grand Temple and Naegling, are still stuck in the fog due to the Cursed L-movers and their own poor fog rolls. That wall of fog has proven to be pretty annoying to the Jades, as each bank only has 1-3 locations on the western side and ships often find themselves in adjacent fog banks or staring at the huge southern wall of the Tunnel. Overall I can count at least 40 ships that have been directly involved in the battle at one point or another, with the front stretching from Broken Horn Island to the western Tunnel entrance.

The Sea of Allost, which has now become the biggest hotspot of activity after Karkuda was so bloody just a few turns ago:

If you stared at the previous picture long enough, you would have noticed some ladders atop the Roost, with infantry now clearly visible as well… this isn’t looking good…. O_O

SHAL-BALA TAKES TO THE SKIES ONCE AGAIN!! This time the dragon is not alone!!

The undead (thematically) Cursed troops clamber onto the ladder, which Shal-Bala grips firmly in its claws!!

Shal-Bala circles and picks up speed!

SHAL-BALA SWOOPS IN AND DROPS THE LADDER OF HORDES UPON THE JADE VESSELS!!!!

The ladder splashes into the sea and the Cursed menace is upon us! Undead hordes storm the decks of the galleys nearby!

The Slaughterfest begins!! O_O

Now, I do have rules for these. When the infantry are dropped onto the decks of ships, they function as an immediate boarding party. When dropped from the air, the infantry have a boarding base of 4 due to the surprise nature of the attack and being dropped from the sky. If I can remember to do it right, their boarding stat will drop by one each turn. This means that if they survive, they stay on the ship and can initiate a boarding party on the next turn, but they will have a boarding base of 3 and so on.

In this case the Ivory Star was the only ship capable of fending off her attackers! However, the Jades have been crewing their ships to the max, and the other three ships only lost oarsmen this turn. However, the fight aboard those galleys is ongoing!

The Sea Hag can’t reach the safety of the beloved (to the Cursed) fog, since her helmsman is affected by some stinky stuff. The Needle escapes, while the Poor Adams finally emerges from her own fog bank to dismast the Grand River!

The Fallen Angel beings towing the Jikininki, while the Whydah really wallops the Hrothgar! She burns, while the Fenrir also loses a mast. The Executioner uses her shipwright to put out her fire, saving the ship for at least this turn (house ruled if illegal). At the right, the Flying Dutchman succeeds with a Broadsides Attack to dismast the Scorpion!!

The Cursed continue dealing damage on a successful turn, knocking masts off the Fire Djinn and hitting the Donar with Fear. Without as many targets as before, and with Davy Jones sick of being selfless, Namazu submerges and retreats deeper into the Roost. However, her escort the Serpent’s Fang (a fitting name given her ability and usage) sets the Beowulf alight! (her crew was also scared by the Monkey’s Paw XD)

With no more canoes, the Rook’s Folly takes her tribal chieftain out of the fog and into the path of the Jade advance. You may have noticed a shocking development off her bow…

With the help of a cannoneer, the Knight’s Errant goes 3/3 and sinks the Sleipnir!! One of the worst ships in the game and carrying a rank-4 armament, this could be her finest moment EVER in Pirates CSG. XD

Davy Jones finally gives his action to his own ship, rather than Calypso’s or Deleflote’s ability! The Guichuan moves a glacial pace towards the battlefield, while the Divine Dragon finally rows home for extensive repairs that will take 10 turns (8 of them due to the “recoil” of Neptune’s Trident).

From above the Roost, showing how crowded it is:

A rare shot looking along the front wall of the Roost towards the east:

After a few turns of intense broadsides, many ships are showing signs of severe damage:

An extremely rare (and difficult to get) shot looking north to south in the Sea of Allost.

Take it in since you won’t get these views often:

The Cursed are in full retreat from the Sea of Karkuda! It’s occurred over the course of 3 turns I believe, but now Terrox is the only Cursed game piece left in this ocean:

The DJC version of the Nightmare finally succumbed to her flames, sinking at last. She had a trying experience in this game, but managed to redeem herself on her final voyage after two atrocious efforts. Some considerably damaged ships return from the battle at the Harbor; the Cursed are happy to see them afloat but they won’t be able to help out in the War against the Jades quite yet. The Nightmare was the only ship the Cursed lost in the battle against France, a solid accomplishment given how quickly and totally they were surrounded at the Harbor.

The Turn 71 graveyard for the Jade Rebellion and Cursed.

The Caribbean factions

The English dismast the Fancy and capture the Kin Tai Fong, meaning the Pirates have been completely eliminated from southwest Karkuda! The Americans and English have had limited contact in this battle, and the English have not told the Americans about their alliance with the French (in fact these ships may not know about it depending on when they went to Karkuda vs. the Forge meeting the Dauphin Royal). The Americans say the English can take what Pirate derelicts they capture, but this would just be the Fancy and KTF at this point. The English are simply happy that all four ships survived the LONG and messy battle, though the Henry VIII is the only one in good condition.

Speaking of whirlpool battles, the one in the Sea of Allost is expanding and getting hotter! The English have a GREAT turn against the Pirates, putting some ships in major trouble with accurate cannon fire.

An AA from CRGO allowed the Guy Fawkes to move and shoot right after coming through the whirlpool from the Caribbean, and here she sets the Tejon aflame. This AA also allowed for an extra ship to come through the whirlpool in the space the Guy Fawkes would have occupied.

However, the Pirate strategy was quite effective, as the Guy Fawkes and Apollo are the only two English ships able to make the whirlpool journey.

The Hastings knocked over a Pirate infantry unit, hence the post title given the other actions that happened earlier.

The English do particularly well in the southeast portion of the area, setting the Rickets and Dolphin aflame. The Deliverance suffers damage at the guns of the Iron Prince.

The battle is quickly becoming quite substantial and fiery:

The next Pirate turn will be a big one. If the English cannot be contained, they may be able to gain a solid foothold in Allost that would threaten Pirate trade.

The Spanish continue their improbable run of success, essentially beating the Americans on their own turf with a smaller force! The Santo Columba fought despite her quarterdeck being in flames, setting the Saratoga on fire for revenge. The crippled Santa Ana got a weird fog roll to exit between the two ships, blocking the Santo Columba from American cannons on their next turn but setting herself up to be captured or dismasted. However, the Santa Ana hit with her firepot specialist as well, and the Saratoga is now an inferno!!

The Granada sets the Gold Eagle aflame while the Asesino blasts apart the Kentucky, eliminating both a mast and cargo. On the other side of the Castle, the Acorazado used Master Gunner Rogelio Vazquez to shoot American infantry off a rampart, where they fell into the water on the other side!

Making matters worse for the Americans, the 5 Spanish reinforcements are almost there!

With more eventually on the way!! One of Spain’s finest is launched, El Principe de Asturias. She carries a captain, helmsman, oarsman, artillery unit, and two infantry units. It’s time to take back the Castle!

Took almost the same shot with the flash just to highlight the huge contrast in styles:

Thanks for reading! Within a week I plan to do a “faction situation analysis” in addition to a point count!

THE BIGGEST EVER

The French scuttle the Geographe to try and get Terrox to leave the Harbor.

The destroyed dock has finally been completely cleaned up, with half of it sinking and the other half disposed of. However, the damage dealt by the Cursed attack will take a while to repair fully.

With the Cursed basically gone, the French set about defending the whirlpool that Davy Jones/Calpyso created. Some cargo ships are finally able to enter the Harbor now that the battle has ended!

The Nautilus submerges to safety as the French have no way of getting at the Mercs right now. I have gone back to my original ruling on ram damage, which means that submerged submarines cannot do any ram damage. Each major faction only has a couple ways of dealing with submerged submarines, and it doesn’t seem fair for the Mercs to be able to endlessly take masts off enemy ships when nothing can be done about it.

A good strategy! With ships simply waiting their turn to enter the Castle waters in the battle area, some ships head south. They will round the terrain to the west and come at the Americans from the south. The Mercury is standing guard there, but it will be good for the Franco-Spanish to have another angle of attack.

By maneuvering perfectly, the French manage to extract the Monaque!

The Pequod is captured, with the Aaron Burr and Sioux derelict. This was taken before the end of the French turn.

The French win the battle up north and advance into American waters!! The Congress is dismasted by the Hercule and Mont Blanc, with the Superbe leading the charge west.

Deleflote gave the action of L’Argus to the Crete Argentee, who towed the Monaque to The Flat, extinguishing the flames and saving the ship!! This is a cool part about campaign games: you have so many ships available for support and rescue that oftentimes the most impossible maneuver or task can be accomplished due to the sheer amount of actions given out.

The Ville de Paris sets the Concord aflame, while the Soleil Royal helps to plug the gap in the French line.

The Solitaire has captured the Aaron Burr.

The graveyard for this faction turn, with the Peacock sunk by the Martinique and some fires put out. The destroyed dock is no more, but will live on in infamy!

Shot at by 4+ ships and an American artillery cannon, the Charlemagne goes from undamaged to derelict!!

Preble uses the President to capture the ship, as the French didn’t put an oarsman aboard!

The Saratoga and Hudson tow the ship down the chain, but where has she gone now?

Captured!! The Philadelphia received Preble’s AA this turn, allowing the ship to warp the French capital ship home and save her from the fires! In an extreme rarity, the ship went from French hero ship (the first to tow the Monaque out of the line to save her) to American capture! Going from healthy to derelict and aflame, the Americans have captured a big prize. This also swung the momentum completely the opposite way, as the French had a huge morale victory by saving the Monaque, but an even greater morale loss when the Charlemagne was nabbed before their eyes!

The 3+ American gunships in the way of the Santa Ana and Santo Columba hold their water, dismasting the SA after the Saratoga moved out of the way into a fog bank.

The Enterprise got bad fog rolls, but the Hornet and Mohican join the repositioned Mercury at the southeastern edge of Castle waters.

The Gold Eagle simply puts out the fire started by the Granada, the Harlequin misses the latter, and the Kentucky finally knocks a mast off the Asesino de la Nave.

The Jarvis and Kettering team up to hit the Superbe. The Kettering has turned into a mach speed weapon, going from the southwestern battle to the northern area of the French battle in just two turns with the help of extra actions from Commander Steven Decatur.

There seems to be a “danger zone” right where the Castle, Flat, and lumber island intersect. The area has been the place of the hottest action so far in this battle, and the masts are piling up. The Monaque, Charlemagne, and Pequod were all dismasted right around there.

Albert Crenshaw pushes the Albany home with all speed, but she might not make it. The Nene-nui succeeded with exploding shot, knocking out a reef that makes the 5-beach island more accessible!

American logistics in the southwest: towing and whirlpool defense patrols.

The Full Moon has been captured, ending the final symbol of Pirate resistance in the area. The Americans captured around 14 Pirate ships in the battle, which could be a high for any single battle in any of my physical campaign games.

Here you can see seven of those prizes, along with USS Jackson, who is receiving some fighting crew after leaving her cargo hold open for infantry earlier in the game.

Speaking of infantry, the Providence and Carolina load three units each. The Americans hope to unload them at the lumber island for some cheap defense against the French. However, we’ll eventually see if they’re too late….

The American graveyard for this turn. The second reef was destroyed by the Louisiana off Ruby Island, making American passage to the Castle easier!

In just the second turn of the battle, the Pirates have utterly defeated the English!!!

With an incredible turn, the Pirates dominate in their home waters. The Deliverance went 4/4 to knock 2 masts off the Guy Fawkes, and was followed by the Charles setting the Belle of Exeter on fire.

You may have noticed that the Tejon, Dolphin, and Rickets are not aflame anymore. The Pirates rolled three 5’s in a row to extinguish their flames, allowing those ships to hold their positions in the defensive circular line! The Revenge didn’t get her revenge against the English, going just 1/4. However, the White Rose and Black Mongoose were there to bail her out, going a combined 6/7 (or 5/7, either way great shooting). The BM went into the whirlpool itself to rake three English ships by the stern, scoring a hit on each.

The Fool’s Hope, Cutlass, and Raven damage the Forge and Wycliffe:

HMS Hastings gets hit a whopping SEVEN times during the turn, getting ravaged by 5 different ships.

Of the ten English ships in the area, none have more than 2 masts remaining.

With a wide-open area and two factions ready to go at it, the battle area has accumulated considerable wreckage and debris in a very short time.

Various ships in the Pirate fleet doing various things. A couple ships at the far left head to Dead Man’s Point for repairs, while some severely damaged ships north of the shipwreck look to repair as well. The Pirates are setting up a total blockade of the northern whirlpool, to prevent any hostile ships from coming out of it. At the bottom, support gunships patrol the reefs, guarding against attack.

Here you can see about 7 Pirate gunships speeding south to assist against the English, but it’s likely they won’t even be needed!

With the Tunnel as empty as it’s been in weeks, the Celtic Fury receives an AA to get into position. If you’re wondering, yes this means the Pirates didn’t even need both AA’s (they got both this turn) to do all that damage against the English, although I think the Fool’s Hope was given the other AA.

The ladder is raised once again, and Pirates will soon clamber up!

Here you can clearly see the hole left by the Pirate rock-blasting operations in the western half of the Tunnel; Mission has chosen the next spot on the eastern side, not far from the entrance.

With the Crusher and Celtic Fury just visible in the Tunnel, here are the Piratical activities of Turn 72.

Captain Mission’s Pirate Kingdom! The Pirate fleet is truly gigantic and contains a large percentage of their ships released by Wizkids. The ocean is just teeming with gunships at this point; I would estimate that any hostile ship dropped almost anywhere in the eastern half of the Sea of Allost would be set upon by at least half a dozen Pirate ships on the following turn.

From the foremast of the Foresight, the southern and northern entrances to the kingdom structure itself.

The Pirates and Cursed don’t like each other at this point, but neither side wants to engage. From these pictures you can see how close some of their game pieces are by the northern whirlpool, but both sides have adopted a kind of “convenient ignorance” when it comes to acknowledging the presence of the other. (a cold shoulder based on self preservation you could say)

It’s a curious thing that these Pirates aren’t nearly as excited about the shipwrecked gold as they were about the gold island. Captain Villanueva of the Rum Runner has been assigned to get the gold he himself discovered, but it remains to be seen if other Pirate ships will be sent over the reef.

Now for some rare views!

Looking from the northeast corner to the west:

From just above the newly constructed Plumb Point Lighthouse:

Didn’t get the right focus here, but massive size of the Tunnel and Roost dominate the horizon.

Difficult to get these shots from the corner. XD

I really like this one a lot though; it shows the Tunnel from a weird angle and shows the gold waterfall in the kingdom.

The current texture of the kingdom is not conducive to standing them upright, but the Pirates hired a bunch of infantry this turn, continuing their new theme of home defense over whirlpool expeditions.

The newly launched Bonnie Liz carries a few 2L ladders.

Maybe one of the coolest closeups yet:

Jade Rebellion turn

The Fallen Angel and Sea Hag lose a mast each, as the Jades reposition their ships and shoot on the way by.

The Hrothgar puts out her fire but misses the Pale Moon twice.

This part of the sea is on a bit of an incline, which has combined with dense wreckage (fast becoming one of my favorite Pirates CSG phrases XD) to make moving ships difficult. The Hrothgar is literally sailing over her own debris along with main masts from the Grand River (repairing herself with a shipwright at the right) and Executioner, possibly with more masts underneath those. O_O

The Fenrir captures the Executioner! Again, the reason they’re a bit apart is because the Executioner was getting caught on the Fenrir’s mizzenmast, which may be stuck under the Ragnarok and above the submerged Locker. What a mess! XD The Scorpion repairs with a shipwright, while the Fire Djinn hits the Flying Dutchman with a firepot for the second turn in a row!

As the Scorpion pitches to larboard, the Tiger’s Eye and Donar are mostly ineffective against the Monkey’s Paw and Sickle. The Hrunting is nearly trapped in the fog; when she tries to come out, almost any die roll will send her crashing into a friendly ship, which I usually play as forcing the ship back into the fog bank.

Sadly, the Beowulf may be doomed. Bucking the trend of ships putting out their fires (I think 4 ships in a row between the Pirates and the Hrothgar), her flames have spread to the forecastle.

The Corsair galleys in this picture are given actions, forcing them to fight the Cursed hordes who fell from the sky last turn! The Nubian Prince and Janissaries’ Blood win their boarding parties to send the Cursed troops to Davy Jones’ Locker, but the Majestic loses her helmsman. I may have the infantry cut down masts if they win a boarding party against a ship with no crew left.

The Ivory Star tries to come to the rescue, but it looks like the Beowulf will burn. The IS does knock a mast off the Sickle, who will probably retreat to the nearby Roost for repairs. At the right, the flood of healthy and pretty Corsair galleys continues, though they’re running out of places to sail.

The Asgard unknowingly joins Behemoth and Mist Walker in a fog bank, while the Polaris finally gets back to being an icebreaker! The Polaris was delayed in the Tunnel wall of fog banks by Cursed L-movers, and now has finally been able to sail north to smash a huge berg.

The Jades continue to fail in the northeastern area of the battle, though many of their ships are still advancing towards the combat area. The Pirates have simply fled, with the Fleur de la Mort turning around into the Tunnel and the Revenant hiding in the fog.

Wreckage, debris, and stormy waters. As I said last report, this most intense area of the battle has seen major damage dealt on both sides, so naturally it may be the first area to quiet down a bit. It’s still hectic obviously, but the SEVERE damage done to most of the gunships has left them shattered and their crews exhausted.

Craziness! Just as the Cursed line of defense begins to falter, the Jades are too exhausted to advance (just like in MANY real life battles, both on land and at sea). Various galleys are straggling towards the far west slaughterfield of action, but fog banks and their own allies are getting in the way right now.

A less impressive view from above, but cool nonetheless. It was perhaps inevitable that these two factions would have a major clash after a decent period of inactivity, and here we get to see a full-scale war with a battle front that stretches the entire length of their territorial boundary.

Here I liked the contrast between the white BC sails and the black sails of the Rook’s Folly and Harbinger:

Due to the Poor Adams, fog hoppers, and Cursed submarines, the battle has nearly reached the Jade resource island!

The Leviathan and Spilled Salt may get into action soon, seen at the top of the frame:

~~~~~~~~~~

IT WAS TIME!!!! At the end of Turn 71, I did another point count!!!!

You are not ready for this! XD Here are the three oceans:

9,078 POINTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

O_O

The point count was insane! I had been planning it for a while, but wanted to try and catch it on some kind of peak, though there haven’t been many launches in a while. When the random resource roll wasn’t a 1 at the beginning of Turn 72, I knew it was time for another epic count. With the current resource change lasting for another 4 turns (out of 8 total) and no random changes occurring for a while, I wanted to do a point count before the game starts shrinking due to all the combat. After hitting 6,000 last time, I wanted to hit 8,000 to obliterate the game’s own record. I knew it was a good possibility given all the launches and how much time passed since the last count, but 9,000 wasn’t even on my radar. XD

Here we go!

Turn 71 point and ship count for Command the Oceans, November 11th 2017

Pirates: 105 ships, 1,840 points
Jade Rebellion: 62 ships, 1,187 points
Cursed: 61 ships, 1,138 points
English: 52 ships, 923 points
Spanish: 27 ships, 417 points
French: 101 ships, 1,804 points
Americans: 96 ships, 1,660 points
Mercenaries: 5 ships, 109 points

Totals: 509 ships, 9,078 points 

O_O

As compared to the last point count (October 6th), there are now FIVE fleets with OVER ONE THOUSAND POINTS!!!! O_O With the English not far behind!!

Overall, I thought it was cool to see how close the rivals were. The Jades and Cursed are nearly on completely equal footing, as are the French and Pirates. The Americans are the third-largest fleet but can certainly hang with the top two, while the JR-Cursed war threatens to whittle those down to a less competitive level. I see the English as the dark horse right now (as I plan to elaborate on when I do the factional analysis post), but their current struggles against the Pirates could dent their hopes quite a bit. The Spanish and Mercenaries realistically have almost no chance of winning the game, unless they can team with a very loyal ally and betray them at the very end after the ally’s fleet is decimated by war against the other strong factions. However, it’s clearly anyone’s game! Six out of the eight fleets are serious contenders right now, so the finish over the next 4-6 weeks should be anything but predictable.

Time for some stats:

Points per ship:
Pirates: 17.5 points/ship
Jade Rebellion: 19.1
Cursed: 18.7
English: 17.8
Spanish: 15.4
French: 17.9
Americans: 17.3
Mercenaries: 21.8

Average: 17.83

Surprised to not see the Cursed atop this list! Though they aren’t far behind the Jades, who have a VERY high percentage of gunships in their fleet, having operated with the same seven cargo ships for almost the whole game. (not really counting the Mercs who have two 32-point subs with the Nautilus and Terror maxed out) The average is also quite in line with my historical average, with Economy Edition having an average of 17.46 points per ship at the largest point count in that game, which is my second-largest physical campaign game. Thus, we can have a very solid estimator for CG sizes based on ship counts alone, simply multiplying by some number between 17 and 18 to get a solid estimate of the total points in play.

By percentage:
Pirates: 20.2% of the points in play
Jade Rebellion: 13.1%
Cursed: 12.5%
English: 10.2%
Spanish: 4.6%
French: 19.9%
Americans: 18.3%
Mercenaries: 1.2%

From this you can think about the various alliances (French/Spanish, French/English are pretty much the ones remaining at this point lol) or try to come up with scenarios where a faction could have a path to victory.

By ocean:
-These are extremely flawed at this point due to all the whirlpool traveling and battles, but serve as an indicator of the factional strength contained in those oceans, not the number of points actually sailing those oceans right this turn.

Sea of Allost: 4,165 points
Caribbean Sea: 1,340 points
Sea of Karkuda: 3,573 points

It’s OVER NINE THOUSAND!!!! XD 

And now for the pictures of the full deckplate areas. This shows the original Pirate fleet location, although they now have more points allocated in Room #2 than #1 lol. The Guichuan is there since the Cursed area is full.

Nearly spilling over into the JR area:

The rest of the Pirate fleet! (with a column of English deckplates here as well haha. When you don’t know how the game will turn out it’s difficult to project deckplate space for future expansions)

Getting to the Jade Rebellion area…

Those crew at the bottom right are on the Grand River, my custom proxied by the Grand Dynasty.

The Cursed! At the upper right, I have stacked most of their crewless sea creatures to save space.

The Cursed recently spilled over onto a bookshelf in Room #2:

As promised, here is Wraith’s haul! He has been in play for a LONG time now, possibly 50+ turns. This is the result of his 6’s, though no named crew yet. Overall, 43 points of crew! If you’ve read this far into the report you get a little nugget of new information. XD I am allowing the Cursed to use any crew captured with this ability on any of their ships, as if they were normal Cursed crew. (whether or not that breaks the existing rules XD)

The English!

Despite having the 3rd-smallest fleet (at a whopping 923 points lol), the English have deckplates in three areas now.

The Spanish:

Similar to the Jades, they have needed to go underneath the Caribbean table to fit.

The Mercenaries, showing the setups on the Terror and Barracuda for the first time.

The French!!

The Americans! (with a big section of captured Pirates extending out from the right column lol)

I was actually going to do a bit more too haha – if I remember, I’ll try to take a picture of the entire GIANT deckplate area in Room #2 (where you see the French, some Pirates and some English above) and also count how many deckplates are in that area alone. XD It’s also the area where the English and Franco-Spanish were in Economy Edition, but with my extremelyconsolidated deckplate system for this game (necessary due to space constraints – 500 ships in the game!!), that area now has an unprecedented amount of stuff in it.

At 9,078 total points, this game is now far larger than Economy Edition and VASSAL Campaign Game 1 combined. It’s more than 3 times bigger than EE, and more than twice as big as CG1. Certainly seems unbelievable, but with all the pictures above, you can count the points if you want. XD

Enjoy it while it lasts, since I won’t likely be able to do this again for a LOOOOOONNNGGGG time. By that I mean like 3+ decades. XD

Anyway, thanks for reading, and I’ll be back with stuff I forgot lol. Won’t be able to play tomorrow but I hope to resume on Monday!

Postimage wasn’t working right (“internal server error”) when I tried to upload these pictures, so I used imgur instead.

This is the Cursed Turn 72. The Sea Hag escapes, and the Fallen Angel tries to tow the Jikininki out of the battle area.

The Hrothgar has been dismasted! However, Cursed gunnery was quite inaccurate in the hottest part of the battle this turn, in the western area. The captured Scorpion is set aflame once again by the Flying Dutchman.

The subs have surfaced! In a desperate slugfest full of hatred, both factions are just trying to put as many shots on hostile targets as possible. Future plans be damned if needed – this is an all-out fight!!

The Fire Djinn is hit with shots and Fear, but the Leviathan (at the left) is still submerged. The Cursed have a strange problem right now: at the top of the photo are the Tiger’s Eye, Donar, and Ivory Star. All of those ships have immunity to L-range guns, and funny enough the Cursed have recently had almost exclusively L-range cannons in that area. However, the Spilled Salt has gotten back in action, though she went 0/3 in her return.

The Cursed gunships in the northeastern area of the battle continue to defy expectations! The Strix dismasts the Loki, while the Rook’s Folly goes 2/4 (on rank-4 cannons) to take a mast off the Meshud. The Knight’s Errant uses her cannoneer to shoot 2/3 and damage the Grand Mountain.

The Cursed sea monsters have nearly reached the battle, while the trio of subpar gunships have somehow held back the tide of Jade ships without even taking damage yet.

The Guichuan is in a fog bank! Who knows what she might do next turn… Davy Jones could copy the fog hopping ability, or perhaps use one of the face-down UT’s (shown earlier in the game atop the Roost) for an advantage…. In addition, the Cursed have some reinforcements coming! Brachyura has finally left its spot behind the Roost and may attack soon. Terrox becomes the last Cursed game piece to return from the Sea of Karkuda, having lost just one segment to the Geographe. Various Cursed ships return home for repairs and to unload food.

The Cursed don’t have much spending power these days, but the Grim Reaper is launched! She carries a nice complement of fighting crew to optimize her effectiveness, and the Cursed also relaunched a Death’s Anchor flotilla. The Grim Reaper will give the Cursed a much-needed presence in the middle area of the battle where you can see the Serpent’s Fang defending the entrance to the Roost itself (all by herself).

Pure carnage, with desperation and exhaustion taking over in the western area of the battlefield:

I thought I’d end this short report with the “faction situation analysis” that I’ve been hinting at.

Alliances:
French/Spanish (growing stronger by the turn in the Battle for the Castle)
English/French (weak/French don’t care about it right now)

Wars (faction who declared war listed first)
Jade Rebellion-Cursed
Americans-Pirates
Americans-French
Spanish-Americans (may have forgot to mention that the Spanish declared, but I guess it was pretty obvious lol)
English-Pirates

Other relationships
Pirates don’t like the Cursed or Jades (Cursed betrayed their trust, Jades recently fired on them)
Americans like the English (latter helped out in the Second Battle of the American whirlpool), but don’t know about English/French alliance
French don’t like the Mercenaries
French hate the Cursed
French hate the Pirates
Mercenaries don’t like anybody, but are intrigued by the Cursed after their attack on the disliked French

In my opinion, the Pirates and the French are in the best position to win the game right now. They have the largest fleets and considerable home island areas that will be difficult to penetrate by attack. The Cursed and the Pirates are probably the most-hated factions, though the Americans are at war with three different factions right now.

The English are in my opinion the dark horse candidate. However, their embarrassing blowout loss to the Pirates has put a serious dent in their hopes.

The Jades and Cursed hate each other more than any other two factions, and it’s quite possible that this battle (the fourth major engagement between them I think) will run until one faction is decisively victorious and the other possibly eliminated. The Jades would do well to ally with some of the non-Sea of Allost factions, but they still have not visited either of the other two oceans.

The French have major leverage, with two allies who both originate from the Caribbean. However, being on bad terms with the other two largest factions (Pirates and Americans, who combine for about 3,500 total points lol) means they will likely have to fight like hell to finish first.

The Pirates have adopted a home defense/isolationist strategy, but have the most enemies of any faction in the game. Only the Spanish don’t dislike the Pirates, and that is more from lack of contact than anything else. The Jades and Cursed aren’t particularly fond of the Pirates, but the Pirates dislike those two more than those two dislike the Pirates (Cursed wanted the French to turn on the Pirates but don’t want to fight them right now, while the Jades are neutral against the Pirates but feel they need to be hit so they don’t run away with the Sea of Allost once the JR-Cursed situation runs its course). The English, French, and Americans all hate the Pirates, and the Mercenaries aren’t fond of them either of course. (due to the Cursed attack on the French, the Mercs would have got wind by now of the Celtic Fury being in the Pirate fleet)

It will be interesting to see if any of the factions can mend any broken relationships, and if any potential surprise alliances can shake up the game. In the meantime, there’s a lot of animosity. XD Of course, what else would you expect from a crowded campaign game with 8 factions, over 9,000 points, and 71+ turns in the book? 

The Carnage Continues to Mount

(literally)

This report is for the rest of Turn 73 and all of Turn 74!

The resource on Diamond Rock has changed back to spices! This would seem to benefit the English greatly, but it might not when the resources change again in a few turns….

Gunships are making way for the damaged ships from the Sea of Allost:

The English begin a major regroup and repair effort, and similar to the Pirates (who they just lost to), they will likely be very hesitant to launch whirlpool attacks going forward.

The Spanish follow through on their plan to launch one of their best ships!

The San Cristobal is here!

She will head straight for the whirlpool and into the Sea of Karkuda. You may have noticed that the Cristal del Obispo loaded Alejandro Malaspina and both Spanish infantry units, though the Cristal has been used as a cargo ship in this game….

The doors to the sub hideout close after Nemo’s Nautilus goes inside!

Inside the sub hideout, Nemo unloads food and looks to repair the Nautilus in safety.

The French see the Sunrise Fire out of the fog, and immediately load their cannons and sail after her.

At the Battle for the Castle, various damaged gunships hide in the fog and wait for suitable exit rolls.

The Santo Columba sets the Gold Eagle aflame once more, and the Serpiente dismasts the Harlequin!

The Santo Columba also used S-boarding to win a boarding party, with her crew victorious in a short skirmish against American infantry.

With an SAT, the Corazon Dorado emerges from the fog to capture the Harlequin!

And immediately tows the new prize into a different fog bank for safety! The Monte Cristo’s gunners are lining up some shots at the pesky American artillery unit on the rampart:

Down it goes with a splash! With that, the Spanish have established a true foothold in the northeastern corner of the Castle. They have surprised everyone in play by their courage and determination, and if the Americans cannot hold the other parts of the Castle, they may actually lose the battle!

Just to show some of the wreckage at the French-American battle, though it will become even more dense by the end of this report.

The Intrepid is nearly dismasted by a team of French gunships!

The Neptune retreats as the Dauphin Royal fully enters the fray. You can see that the recently launched cohort of French blockade runners have reached the battle area, and they make an immediate impact. Right now the American strategy is to get Lenoir within cancelling range of the Concordia, either to cancel the ship’s ability (cannons cannot be eliminated) or Gus Schultz’s Eternal if the French can land a final hit on the ship.

The Neptune is likely to be saved by her proximity to Paradis de la Mer at The Flat.

Looking from the northeast at the line of French gunships protecting the Neptune, Martinique, and Concord from further harm:

In the far northwest part of the battle, the French put some hurt on the Americans! The Nene-nui and Kettering are hit three times each.

The Kettering cancelled the Gaule’s captain. However, Deleflote countered by giving the Gaule a shoot action, which ripped through the Kettering and set the valuable longship aflame!

The French put forth two new gunships at the end of their turn. The Descharges is loaded with great crew, while the Intrepide will tow a new Mont Blanc flotilla.

A few French reinforcements: both ships were launched from The Flat, while the Bonaparte heads west after being ordered to break off from whirlpool blockade duty. The Atalante adds a fourth ship to the fresh French vessels.

Just like they are up north, the French are blockading the whirlpool the Cursed created to ensure no hostile ships emerge from it.

The ever-busy Harbor:

The American turn begins with utter failure! The 1 is just a reminder for me to mention how many bad rolls the Americans got in the southern part of the battle. The Mohican and Atlanta were horribly ineffective.

The Americans managed a little better near the Castle itself, setting the Granada on fire.

The Soleil Royal and Belois lose masts due to the French counterattack:

The Intrepid will try to flee for repairs, while the Julius Caesar sets the Republicain on fire.

Lenoir cancelled the Saratoga’s captain, so the Hudson shot at the Dauphin Royal instead. Unfortunately Phillipe Amqui was killed by a musket ball!

The Americans don’t have enough backup ships coming up in reserve to properly support resistance in the northwest area. The Nene-nui tries to block and save the Americans time, while the Swamp Fox misses a Broadsides Attack with a 1. Reinforcements are coming, as you can see the Blackwatch, Adventurous, and Jackson. The Kettering puts out her fire but Commander Steven Decatur retreats for repairs, knowing the extreme value of his ship.

Preble on the run! The President scurries home to put out her fires, while a few more American gunships are headed to beef up the offensive near The Flat.

A very crowded American HI, with most of the space taken up by repairing ships. In the middle-right, three more American gunships are headed north towards the battle, but they are a few turns away.

Including the canoes, I count 21 ships docked at the American HI. As hoped for, the Albany has been saved!

Some Pirate captures are still being towed home. After a LONG delay due to the huge battle against the Pirates, the James Madison and Louisiana are finally able to load spices!

The French threaten to break through in the northwestern area, which would put them pretty close to the American HI.

Smoke rises in the distance:

The well-positioned artillery and infantry atop the northwestern wall of the Castle have found their mark a few times against the French:

Here is the majority of the battle area, with fresh gunships sailing in for both sides.

One of my favorites of the day:

Just a partial glimpse at the scope of this campaign game:

A close-quarters engagement characterized by sudden dismastings and various burning ships:

The French have at least 4 gunships headed to reinforce each section of the battle (far south, Castle/Flat, and northwest), but the Americans have no reinforcements going to the Castle right now. They can launch there, but the Pirates and Spanish are the only factions with current high-value resource flow.

Amqui “died”, but little do they know, he was reanimated by the spectral Wraith and will now fight for the hated Cursed!

Turn 74

The Sunrise Fire explores and finds luxuries on Pearl Island! This was a preset resource; the island is full of valuable pearls, so luxuries are the only resource this island will produce.

The Pirates have done it!!!!!

The Pirates have tunneled all the way to the top of the Tunnel!!

The hole is near the eastern entrance:

Cleaning up now that the English have gone. In a very timely effort, the Black Pearl had Tia Dalma aboard to cancel the oarsman aboard the Belle of Exeter, allowing the Cutlass to capture her! If this hadn’t happened, the Pirates would have had to sink the Belle (requiring considerable effort at 6 hits total), eliminate her crew one by one via boarding parties to capture her (likely losing some of their own crew in the process), or let her escape and get shot at by 4 cannons (musketeer aboard) in the meantime. With Tia Dalma’s arrival, the Pirates snag a nice prize and deny her further usage to the English.

The Guy Fawkes is also captured, but the Wycliffe will burn.

The Revenge manages to keep the fires at bay (barely), and she should be able to put them out next turn! However, she could easily roll a 1 or 2 before moving, which could require a Pirate rescue attempt.

With an EA, Calico Cat pilots the Revenant out of the Tunnel and towards Dead Man’s Point for minor repairs. In this picture alone you can also see about 8 other ships headed there…

… with more arriving from the northern area. The Rum Runner returns to the Sultan shipwreck to load gold, though the Pirates should really send a smaller ship out there due to the reef damage to larger ships.

A regrouping Pirate Kingdom:

It was an odd Pirate launch: the Amity gets a helmsman while docked in the kingdom, but also takes aboard some supplies….

WHOAH!! In a huge group effort, the Jades hit the Guichuan 17 times, ONE HIT away from dismasting her!! O_O

This was the risk the Cursed were willing to take on: sending any ship deep into enemy territory runs the risk of that ship getting completely annihilated by the counterattack. No less than eight JR ships fired upon the Guichuan this turn, with the Grand Wind getting 7 shots in (between her SAT and reroll). The Virtuous Wind, Sea Wind (2’s hit with 3 friendly ships within S!), and Majestic (cheerleader ability) were quite useful, but despite rolling well the Jades couldn’t get that final cannon in range (Silent Death was close but not quite there) to dismast the ship. Of course, as we’ll see, the Guichuan wasn’t in that much danger anyway….

It was a bit of a morale victory for the Jades, as the Cursed flagship gets soundly beaten and will take FOREVER to repair. XD

The Jades didn’t do so well in the other theaters of the battle, missing the Pyre completely and failing to dismast the weakened Pale Moon. The Whydah is set aflame, but it will be difficult for the Jades to extract the captured/recaptured ships (Hrothgar, Executioner, Scorpion).

The Tiger’s Eye shoots off the tail of Leviathan, while the Donar repairs and the Ivory Star knocks a mast off the Spilled Salt.

Various Jade and Corsair ships turn around: between the ice, fog, and general stalemate situation, the Jade Rebels have not been able to penetrate the Roost as they had hoped to by now. Some progress has been made in the west and northeast areas of the battle, but it has been incredibly slow and bloody progress.

Case in point: the Meshud manages to set the Knight’s Errant aflame, but the Grand Mountain and Sultan’s Sword go about 1/5 combined. Those two are pinned by the sea monsters, who could completely stop the Jade advance in its tracks.

The Beowulf, Golden Peacock, and Naegling all repair as the Jade Rebellion home island sees its biggest threat since Shal-Bala swooped in so long ago:

The Jade turn begins with the Guichuan predictably escaping! After the ship turned ghostly, Davy Jones copied the sac ability and killed his explorer, allowing the Guichuan to move into a fog bank. From there DJ can copy the fog hopper ability again to get home. Although the trip was actually kind of a failure (the Jades didn’t lose any ships or crew, while the Cursed flagship will be out of action for 9+ turns), the Cursed were happy to only use one of their two “secret weapon” UT’s… Davy Jones had been prepared to use Necklace of the Sky in an emergency to get out of the predicament, but still has it at his disposal for a future opportune moment….

You probably noticed Shal-Bala’s successful swoop attack, one of the dragon’s only attacks to follow the standard rules.

One of the Guichuan’s biggest masts fell atop the quarterdecks of the Jade cargo ships, with it balancing in most improbable fashion! XD The Guichuan did roll for Fear on the way out, with the terror affecting three Jade ships.

Almost every Cursed ship in the western battle area has been utterly shot to pieces. The Pyre is the healthiest thing they’ve got over there, with the Poor Adams and Whydah (both with just one mast remaining lol) covering the retreats of the Hrothgar, Executioner, Flying Dutchman, Fallen Angel, and Jikininki. That’s right, two severely damaged ships trying to form a line of battle so the numerous mastless ships beyond cannot be captured or sunk on the next Jade turn. XD Indeed, the western part of this giant battle has been one of the most intense exchanges of cannon shots in naval history. As is usual for this war, neither side has really gained the advantage. The factions have simply blasted each other to pieces.

If you stared at the last picture long enough, you may have noticed the submerged Locker making her way underneath the wreckage:

LOL! The sub can barely make it through the dense forest of masts and spars, which have been cut down by cannon balls and shrapnel.

Burning wildly, the Flying Dutchman struggles to make it home. The Fire Djinn lived up to her namesake in this battle, though she has now joined the Hrunting hiding in the fog. The (nearly dismasted) Pale Moon is towing the Executioner, while the Hrothgar and Fallen Angel (towing the Jikininki) attempt to reach the Roost on oar power. The Spilled Salt has fled into the fog, and while the Monkey’s Paw is still healthy, she rolls a silly four 1’s in a row to miss all Jade/Corsair ships in range. XD

You may be wondering why Brachyura is just sitting there. Well, the Donar and Ivory Star are immune to L-range guns (and therefore crab claws XD), so the Grim Reaper and Death’s Anchor are called upon to do the job instead. The Grim Reaper has a great debut broadside, setting the IS aflame. 4 ships repair at the Roost, while Namazu’s wave attack is delayed by the partial retreat of the Jade ships the beast was targeting.

The Knight’s Errant burns to the waterline, opening up a hole in the Cursed defense. However, the Grand Mountain and Sultan’s Sword lose 3 masts between them to the sea monsters, with Calim and Calypsos not even in action yet.

Cursed trade could be hit for the first time next turn, though the Jades will likely only be able to put a few shots on the cargo ships.

The Monkey’s Paw is continuing to prove herself… as one of the worst ships I’ve ever owned. On all 3L guns, her shooting percentage in this game may be under 33%, and I wouldn’t be surprised if it was just a paltry ~20%. Like I said, on this turn she rolled four 1’s in a row to miss all her shots.

It’s not as dense as “the spot” in the French-American battle, but the wreckage accumulating in the western Sea of Allost is considerable indeed.

The English have a weird turn, advancing some of their gunships into “Spanish” waters just to make room for the plethora of ships moving from the whirlpool towards the English HI:

Considerable Spanish reinforcements are coming to the Sea of Karkuda…

… as the Principe, Cristobal, and Cristal make their way towards the whirlpool.

The Monte Cristo dismasts the New Orleans, while the Santo Columba captures the Gold Eagle!

With no other targets to attack, the SC also used her cannons and S-boarding to eliminate no less than 3 American infantry units!

A fruitful alliance: the Corazon Dorado tows the Harlequin to the Harbor, where the French have invited the Spanish to repair. The Santa Ana rows there, while the Profeta makes her way to the Castle battle. I really like how this picture shows the different hull colorings and artwork, particularly in the top/top left areas of the photo.

Paradis is in range! The French cannoneers in the fort can finally shoot again, and smash some lumber off the Concordia.

The French do fantastic in the northwest once again, hitting the Nene-nui and Swamp Fox three times apiece!

A devastating French attack! The Dauphin Royal gets Gaston’s AA, dismasting the Hudson. The Coeur de Lion knocks the final mast off the Intrepid, while at least three ships get in shots against the Concordia. The Mercure dealt the firepot hit, while the Soleil Royal landed about 3 hits of her own (Montana Mays prevented crew elimination however).

The French blockade runners have done well so far, but of course the 5 masters are the ones doing the really heavy lifting. The “Royal” ships (Dauphin and Soleil) really pulverized the Hudson and Concordia. However, the Julius Caesar and chaos of battle prevented Lenoir from getting in range of the Concordia.

With unspeakable carnage, I had to take some extra pictures. Here the Lamon is partially obscured due to the Hudson’s masts suddenly falling overboard everywhere:

Splintered wood and shredded sails surround the stunned sailors, who have never seen such an intense fight. (and neither have I, at least I don’t think in a regular game (aka non-HFS))Check out the Moulin Rouge coming out of the water – she’s just trying to sail over debris and her bow is struggling to keep pace! XD

At the left, the Mont Blanc is lucky to escape with her oars, while the Scipion shoots at the Horizon and Concordia. I took this shot specifically to show the Scipion and Horizon – they’re at such an angle that you could completely miss them in the other pictures! Both are just underneath the northwestern corner of the Castle, and it’s quite difficult to give them actions on the turns.

Unable to sail in the right direction just yet, the Descharges, Intrepide, and Atalante simply scatter, desperate to make room for the Neptune (saved from the fires!), Hercule, and Congress (captured). The Republicain also saved herself from being burnt, while the Superbe slowly makes her way to The Flat with the captured Buffalo. The Ville de Paris is fully repaired, while Le Bonaparte makes her way to the northwestern area.

The French also launched two of their worst “gunships” this turn, showing that they’ve nearly “completed the fleet” as far as my collection goes.

At the left, French reinforcements have nearly reached the battle. From left to right is an unintentional line of battle: the Cleopatre, Orient, Courageux, Versailles, Vercingetorix, Grand Vainqueur (triple V! XD), and Saber make their way to the battle! The steady stream of fresh gunships is exactly what France needs to hold strong near The Flat and prevent American gunships from rounding the Castle (the reason the French restarted this war in the first place, remember) and attacking the Spanish from the north. Near the lighthouse is an impressive group of vessels and characters: Amiral Cartier and Jordan Dumas make the Delacroix one of the most feared ships on the sea, while the Santa Ana carries Duque Vaccaro, the Spanish admiral. The GV and Saber combine with the Aube to make a truly impressive presence near the island, even if it’s not in danger and some of the ships are damaged.

Following in American footsteps, the French shoot horribly at the southern edge of the ocean! This area seems to be the opposite of “the spot”; cannons continually miss, and perhaps Fish Island is just bad luck for gunners. XD On this particular turn the French went 1/5. With that battle almost completely devoid of “progress” (a side gaining territory or at least ships on both sides getting damaged to force replacements to come in), the Marie Antoinette and La Gaule have gone into the fog.

2 on 2 right now, with almost no damage dealt for a whole round.

After spending a whole turn just to load one batch of pearls, the Sunrise Fire gets a mast shot off by the Lache du Calvados. L’Ange de la Mer is ready to intercept the Sunrise Fire on the other side of shipwreck cove if the Pirates try to escape. Other French gunships are technically stationed in the area (to blockade the Mercs, patrol the waterways, and watch for further Cursed whirlpool incursions), but you can see some of them slowly sailing towards the Battle for the Castle. The French are indeed quite mighty in this game, capable of sustaining a huge battle area that stretches almost the entire length (not “width”) of the ocean while still keeping up considerable ships in reserve to patrol their home waters. Oh, and their Harbor is getting back in the swing of things and valuable luxuries are being unloaded.

Could a French-submarine showdown be imminent?? The Rocher Noir and Espadon make their way towards the sub hideout. However, the stalemate between these two factions is likely to continue, since the Mobilis can cancel the Rocher Noir’s sub-hunting ability. Oh well! XD

At the top of the picture, the Duc d’Enghien is taken off whirlpool blockade duty due to her speed that she can use to reach the battle area faster. Slower and less accurate ships can blockade the whirlpool; more valuable ships are sent to expand French territory and win the War against America.

The Harbor is finally getting more and more cleared out; most of the gunships launched a while ago have departed or will be departing the Harbor next turn.

Cargo ships are not able to dock in their normal places, but within 3-5 more turns the French Harbor will be just about back to normal. Of course, it will never be the same again, since the French will now have a permanent guard fleet on duty. They learned their lesson after the Cursed attack. It remains to be seen if the French plan to rebuild the destroyed dock. They probably will, but the Harbor will have to get a lot less crowded for that to even be possible logistically. It’s not just about the battles! XD Winning this historically large game is going to take serious logistical and administrative expertise!

(earlier) Case in point: two ships you’d probably NEVER use as gunships, here launched at The Flat with full crew complements. The French have a few more gunships left, but may save them a bit unless a more serious need arises. With 5 cannons, the French are just hoping the St. Denis can land a hit or two per turn, with S-boarding a solid option with so many non-vital crew on board. The Colibri may just guard The Flat, but it could just so happen that the most unlikeliest of ships could land a key firepot hit… you never know! 

The American turn begins with Preble sailing desperately for home! The President is nearly engulfed by the flames!

I like how the flash reflects off the final fire mast, making it almost look like a minor explosion or something.

In case you forgot about the title of this report… more on that soon.

Similar to the Pirates and French, the Americans have established a close blockade around their whirlpool to prevent hostile invasions.

Preble barely reaches home safely! It’s a dual meaning here: the President barely had enough wind in her sails (aka move segment distance) to get home, AND there was barely enough space to dock! The American HI is overly crowded right now, with a ton of ships repairing or about to start repairing. The Roanoke couldn’t dock, and the James Madison or Louisiana may be delayed next turn. The Americans may have to compromise between unloading resources and repairing their gunships: there is a need for gunships in the battle, but it would take a few turns for a gunship to move away from the HI for a cargo ship to dock and then to move back to repair. However, the resources could provide a more immediate boost than the long-term repair efforts, especially if the Americans launch a few gunships at the Castle.

The Philadelphia has warped the Jarvis home, but a more interesting development is clearly present: the Pirate captures have begun sailing out! With some of them fully repaired, the Americans have assigned the Pirate gunships to the War on France. With only a handful of useful American gunships left in my collection, there’s not much reason to trade the ships in for American counterparts. As the game has ballooned to a previously unimaginable size, the Americans, French, Jades, and Cursed have all depleted most of their roster of ships to use. This is something I almost never expected to see in a physical game, but it’s really cool to see and experience. Just WOW! XD Anyway, the trade-in rule was almost mandatory earlier in the game, as it was a mark of “good sportsmanship” between the factions. However, with tons of bad blood pouring into the seas from the wounds of battle, and with multiple factions literally running out of ships to launch (and with the game’s end still about a month off!), trading in has become not only impractical, but nearly impossible for certain factions. The Americans will deny the Pirates further usage of the captured ships, though trade-ins may still occur of course.

Utter. American. Futility. The Swamp Fox misses another Broadsides Attack (with a 1 again I believe), while the Jackson goes 0/4 against the Gaule. O_O

The Kettering tows the Nene-nui, and although the American “line” of two ships is quite fragile right now, 5+ American gunships are coming up from the south.

Needed in both areas, the captain of the Blackwatch has chosen to take his ship east towards the hottest action in the entire game right now. You read that right: the action around “the spot” has definitely become the most intense area of warfare in the whole game, with the previous high being the western area of the JR-Cursed battle.

With the Julius Caesar fleeing into a fog bank, the Americans temporarily struggle to fill her spot in the battle area. The Lamon does her best, with the Saratoga and Septem Maria firing off some shots.

The Americans do about average here, but leave the French in a good position for next turn: you can see damage counters on the French 2 masters, which means they were one hit away from losing a mast, but will return fire with both cannons next turn.

The Springfield has towed the Hudson, while the Belois and Soleil Royal lose a mast each. The Concordia puts out her fire, but is struggling to essentially carry the American hopes in the area by herself. This picture really shows the wreckage, with more pictures coming later. XD

It just keeps going and going! The Carolina unloads infantry units, replacing those unloaded by the Colonial Trader not long ago. The Montezuma looks to take the Carolina’s shortcut underneath the Castle ramparts, where her ability (shoot through ships) could be great in the very tight eastern area of the battle.

The Bartlett tows the Sioux. In the background, the Overton, Boston, Intrepid and Julius Caesar are all in various states of severe damage, trying to find their way home through the reefs and fog. American cargo ships are flocking south, due to the lack of textiles on the SW beach of the big island and the battle nearly spilling over deep into American waters.

The Mohican goes 2/3 to finally knock a mast off the Toulouse, while the American guard at the Castle sees significant turnover for the first time in many turns. The New Orleans has rowed to the Castle for repairs, while the Speedy Return and Saratoga depart, having finished repairs.

Thus is the cycle of war in this game: fight, get replaced, repair, fight again, and repeat. When will it end?

The Monte Cristo is set aflame by the Sea Serpent, with the Enterprise inching closer to her long-awaited battle debut.

A somewhat new view from directly above the Castle looking west, showing the absurd intensity around “the spot”.

American operations in the Sea of Karkuda. They have really been struggling lately, losing ground at the Castle to the Spanish and barely hitting anything at the extremes of the battlefield (deep south and far northwest). Their best bet right now is the middle area, but that’s mainly due to the sheer intensity of the epic stalemate and some timely fire hits.

And now for the sheer destruction that is probably unrivaled in ANY game ever of Pirates CSG…

THE CARNAGE CONTINUES TO MOUNT!

The Lamon goes over various spars and masts on her way to shoot at the French. The Septem Maria and Concordia are partially heeled over. These aren’t stormy waters! The vast amount of debris has simply led to some ships being tipped to the side as they struggle to sail in a straight line amid the devastation:

In the most dense area, the sea is hardly visible. O_O

Masts on top of masts. With some of the ships that are repairing, I cannot retrieve their masts due to them being buried. O_O XD As a result, for a few ships (like the Charlemagne already) I will do a “reverse damage counter” system, where a tiny die represents how many masts that ship has repaired in addition to what is actually standing. Of course, once the ships are ready to sail out again, this will result in a “doomsday” scenario (I’m being very melodramatic here XD) where I have to remove most of the ships from the area just to get at the piles of masts below. XD

Complicating matters is the fact that most American and French masts/sails are clean shades of white/blue, so it’s just a wasteland of lumber floating in the ocean.

I truly believe that these pictures cannot do the situation full justice. The carnage is just insane. Even crazier, there is almost no end in sight. O_O Both sides have considerable reinforcements arriving shortly, not to mention future launches. The mountain of debris at “the spot” will have to be cleaned up eventually, but it will grow to even larger sizes before this battle finally ends….

The graveyard for Turn 74, though the Hastings was technically sunk earlier. It was one of the bloodiest turns yet, and the Granada, Wycliffe, and Wiglaf are some of my favorite ships from those factions. I was especially sad to see the Granada go, after her remarkable performances in the Experimental cumulative game, VASSAL Campaign Game 1, and now here in Command the Oceans.

A few stats from today:
-I counted 33 deckplates of sunken ships so far, but the number is actually higher. Lately I’ve been putting the deckplates in a tin instead of back in the binders – this is because there are so many launches that the binders have been considerably thinned out, so I don’t know where each deckplate goes! XD The game’s size will require me to redo the binders after the game, but I don’t mind that since I had just enough “new” ship deckplates to integrate anyway.
-I counted around 32 ships in the current Franco-Spanish vs. American battle, but that is for ships currently involved. Combined with ships that are repairing, fleeing, or sunk, and the number would easily exceed 50.

Of those two MASSIVE wars/battles going on right now, I would say the Cursed and the Franco-Spanish have slight advantages. The Cursed are especially fragile, and with serious American reinforcements steadily arriving through repaired ships, either battle could certainly turn the other way.

With those days of destruction behind me, I look forward to the (somewhat minor) milestone Turn 75! Of course, more destruction is imminent.

I finished Turn 75 and ALL of Turn 76!!

The French defend their food island from the Mercenaries, but the Lyon docks to find that no more bananas are around!

The Marie Antoinette is the latest ship to block off the Americans from retaking the northeastern corner of the Castle. The Flamberge docks at Fish Island, but no textiles are found!

The fog banks along the eastern wall of the Castle have made the battle very cramped and almost akin to a stalemate between small squadrons of ships.

However, the most intense battle in the game continues as usual! The Concordia is dismasted, while the Saratoga and Springfield also suffer heavy damage.

The Blackwatch has almost arrived, but the Ville de Paris and Dauphin Royal are both pretty healthy.

Seven French ships repair at The Flat, with more joining them soon.

Many French ships have yet to enter the battle; here you can see the Saber among others making their way west. La Gaule and L’Aube are still in fog banks near the Castle.

Le Gaule sets the Jackson on fire, while the Auguste continues to surprise with solid accuracy, doing further damage to the Swamp Fox. Le Bonaparte and La Toussaint L’Ouverture are ready to back up when needed.

Three gunships make their way west, while three more head to The Flat for repairs.

The Harbor is now as orderly and organized as it was before the Cursed attack:

Now showing the American turn, La Toulouse is set aflame. The Battle for the Castle is still going as slow as ever.

Ruby Island and Luck Island run out of resources at the same time!!

A busy American HI situation, with many ships coming and going every turn.

The Jackson extinguishes her fire but cannot do damage to the Gaule. The Swamp Fox hits a Broadsides Attack on the Auguste, but the Americans get even better news: reinforcements are coming! The Seminole has brought 5 gunships with her, and captured Pirate ships will also arrive soon.

A grim picture of the war, as the Lamon burns:

The Ville de Paris is surrounded on all sides by carnage and death. The Lamon is putting up a ton of smoke, while the Concordia hits a whopping 6 for 6 (with a musketeer) to dismast the Mercure. The Ville herself is hit a handful of times, losing two masts.

The Concordia hit the Soleil Royal 3 times, taking that ship down to 2 masts.

The hulks of the Concordia, Lamon, and Mercure are partially obscured by smoke and wreckage:

The Blackwatch and Grampus have not been able to make an impact yet.

The Sea of Karkuda. Crazy enough, not even this gigantic 3-faction battle is taking up all the resources of the two major factions (yet). The French and Americans have about 15 combined gunships blockading the whirlpools, and the French have additional gunships that are patrolling the southeast part of the ocean.

Turn 76 marks a resource change! After a huge 8-turn wait that saw no random changes throughout, it was time for a regularly scheduled change. The result was truly momentous. A 5 for value meant that food and metals were the top two resources, with luxuries and spices crashing hard. Even more important was the duration: a whopping 10 turns, the longest of the game so far! With each turn taking about a full day to complete, this change was a big deal to all of the factions. Many factions have been sitting on considerable stores of resources during the last 8 turns, so this turn would undoubtedly see some major cashing in.

The Fleur de la Mort may literally be the highlight of this picture, but the Celtic Fury is busy getting more Pirate infantry to the top of the Tunnel.

Three more units arrive, with the first two from last turn making their way around the island.

Ahoy!

An closeup shot of the Tunnel’s top, showing the grassy areas and the huge boulders lying around.

In the background, the Roost and Shal-Bala’s wingspan make for an intimidating sight.

After the Victoire and Harbinger roll for exit locations, the fog at the western end of the Tunnel lifts! This is an intriguing development, as it makes the Tunnel more obvious and inviting for the Jades and Cursed….

Cashing in metals for around 275 gold, the Pirates spend a chunk of it on some gunships they’ve been waiting to launch for a while. The Black Swan may be their final 5 master launched, while those three in the middle are three of my favorite Pirate ships. In fact, I like all 5 of these quite a bit. 

Dead Man’s Point is even more crowded than usual, with ships repairing from the brief fights against the English and Jades and 5 new ships entering the game.

Jade ships repair and regroup.

You may have noticed that more fog has lifted! When the Grand Temple used her SAT to emerge from two different fog banks (separate move actions), the fog disappeared when she departed the bank! We’ll see if this weather change has any implications for the future gameplay.

The Hangman’s Joke is shot at by the Wicked Kareen, but avoids taking damage with another Cursed UT weapon: Relics!

The Monkey’s Paw and Locker take slight damage, but the Jade Corsairs have almost no firepower left in this area of the battle (5-6 total masts standing).

The Leviathan gets hit with a triple-team, but some Cursed help will be coming soon….

The Virtuous Wind docks at the wild island, but it has no more resources left to give! With the Silent Death leaving a fog bank, more fog is gone. As of now there is a surprisingly large amount of empty ocean space between the front line and the Jade HI.

In possibly a surprise to both you and the Cursed, the Jades press their attack!! Despite Namazu’s presence and the launching of the Loki’s Revenge, the Jades advance essentially into the Roost! The Jackal’s Teeth has knocked a mast off the LR before the latter can even take an action in the game.

The Death’s Anchor is set aflame by the Divan’s Punishment! I know this is illegal, but flotillas have been a bit OP in this game (my own fault, especially since I’m allowing duplicates) so flotillas can be set on fire.

The Terror of Gibraltar finally gets in action. She has terrible cannons, but manages a hit on the Loki’s Revenge.

Flooding the area! The Donar repairs, while the Griffin, Splendor, and Nubian Prince all arrive on the scene. It seems unlikely that the Jades will be able to win this Battle for the Roost (a sub-battle of the current one) with the ships pictured here, but they’ve been waiting and wanting to do this for a long time. Ever since the captain of the Divine Wind told the story of that fateful expedition, the Jade Rebels have wanted to exterminate the Cursed.

The beauty of a campaign game – two months later, the Jades get some revenge!

An incredible effort by the allies in the northern part of the battle! The three Corsair/Viking ships on the right went 5/5 against the Sea Monkey, setting her on fire. The Desert Wind got in action, knocking a mast off the Rook’s Folly. At this point the Cursed have officially lost control of their lumber island.

More empty ocean in the western half of Allost than we’ve seen in a LONG time. A strong Jade push northwards and lifting fog has left a gap…

… but the battle rages on.

An extreme rarity because you have to house rule it to even make it work.

A burning pillar of fire!

The Cursed wanted to be able to use Relics again, so they shot at the Wicked Kareen with the Locker before shooting with the Death’s Anchor flotilla in the background. In the foreground, the Needle has fog hopped back into the fray. The Monkey’s Paw continues to increase her shooting percentage to a more reasonable level, dismasting the Scorpion and Queen of Sheba.

The Madness sets fire to the Tiger’s Eye, possibly dooming the great Corsair ship!

I like how these low-level shots really show the destruction:

The Banshee’s Wail dismasted the Gallows, with the Poor Adams coming out of the fog to capture the ship. Top right: the Whydah looks to repair at a super-crowded Roost. Top left: Terrox is looming, though there aren’t many Corsair ships left in the area that are worth attacking.

Talk about crowded! The Pale Moon will have trouble repairing herself and her towed ally, the Executioner. Making matters worse for the Cursed, they may now have more gunships needing repairs than healthy ones.

Here you can see seven Cursed ships repairing:

A really cool view of the Roost, showing a “cutaway” of the structure. Things are busy but peaceful on the west side, but you can see the first Corsair ship penetrating the main gate.

The Sickle is fully repaired and back in action, dismasting the Donar (again) but losing her smokepot specialist in a failed switchblade attack.

One of the best pictures of a Switchblade in action!

Unsurprisingly, the Cursed were able to dismast the Jackal’s Teeth. However, it took a lot of shots to do it, with the Loki’s Revenge going 4/8 with a sac action and the Bloody Blade going 2/4 (with a cannoneer) to finish off the third mast.

The Cursed bought those 3L ladders and extra infantry for a reason!!

The ladder extends down through a little-shown (if shown at all) hole in the Roost:

What horrors await those willing to climb to the top… ?

Cursed troops descend from above!!

A long distance scaled by the giant ladder:

A long way down…

The infantry unit boarding follows the same rules from Shal-Bala’s earlier swooping strike. In this way the Jackal’s Teeth lost two of her four crew.

The Terror of Gibraltar was set aflame by the Guinee:

Calypsos pins the Meshud, while Fear affects the ships with green dice on them.

There are three distinct areas of this giant battle:

In the west, the Cursed have gained the upper hand and look to clean up the last pockets of Jade rebellion. (pun intended)

In the center, the Jades have caught the Cursed a little off guard, but the Cursed are finally getting some proper support by the main gate of the Roost. (LR, Guinee, Bloody Blade, and now three Death’s Anchor flotillas since the one that burned just got relaunched)

In the northeast, the Jade advance has actually smashed Cursed trade. However, the squids have limited how many ships can get through to the far north, while also dismasting their prey.

It’s official! The Spanish plan to leave the Caribbean for good!!! After sending most of their gunships to the Sea of Karkuda by whirlpool travel, this turn marks the total, absolute change of mindset for the Spanish in this game. They intend to vacate their home island and set up shop at the Castle, trusting that they will capture it by throwing their full might against it and combining their firepower with that of France to oust the hated Americans. It’s about as risky a move they could make, but perhaps a needed one since they’re by far the weakest of the main 7 factions. The San Francisco has loaded their two UT’s, and all Spanish ships are now making their way towards the whirlpool.

With Paradise Island not even producing luxuries, the Spanish don’t have much reason to stay in the Caribbean. Normally the cargo ships with luxuries aboard would at least cash them in at the HI and use the gold for a launch, but in this case luxuries have dropped to 2 gold apiece for the next 10 turns. By that time all of the ships can be in Karkuda, and the Spanish anticipate having full control of the Castle before then.

In the meantime, the captain of HMS Resistance has been meeting with Admiral Thomas Gunn on board the Lord Algernon to discuss the apparent Spanish exodus. If that becomes a reality, the English will have the Caribbean all to themselves! However, the War against Piracy is heavy on the minds of these Englishmen, with revenge as their motivation. The English are not currently in battle with any other faction, which is why I consider them the “dark horse” candidate once again… the Pirates are not in battle now either, but they have made themselves an enemy of literally every faction in the game besides the Spanish (who are allied with the French, who hate the Pirates).

Spanish activity in Karkuda. More fog has lifted near the Castle, while the Profeta and Resolucion will be the next ships to reach the battle area.

The Lache dismasts the Sunrise Fire again, with the Felicite landing an extra hit so the Pirates have to repair hull damage next turn and not just pop a mast back up, therefore allowing the French to capture the ship next turn.

A (finally) peaceful Harbor, with the French spending a bunch of gold on crew to outfit their cargo ships as gunships.

The French still have a bunch of gunships sailing around, but many of the patrol ships are slowly making their way towards the battle in case they are needed there.

If that final fog bank by the Castle disappears, it will allow the Franco-Spanish and the Americans to have a more all-out battle.

The battle from the northeast… you may have noticed a change…

The Concordia has been captured! Lenoir of the Dauphin Royal got close enough to cancel the ship’s oarsman, at which point the ship was truly a derelict and the Orient captured her. This is another momentum shift in this long and arduous battle, making up for the French loss of La Charlemagne.

The Saratoga and Minuteman take additional damage, but many of the capital ships are repairing (or in the case of Le Superbe, trying to repair) at The Flat.

A cool viewpoint showing that the French have more gunships near the battle area that aren’t engaged than the Americans.

A rather grand shot of the spectacle! XD

The Americans are still doing pretty well at the Castle, but more Spaniards are coming….

At the right I see 9 French gunships that are healthy and ready for battle. The French could loose the Concordia back on the Americans since she can fire when dismasted, but they will probably repair her at The Flat.

One of the best combat photos I’ll ever take. The damaged Ville de Paris is shrouded by smoke caused by her own firepot specialist, with friend (Mercure) and foe (Saratoga) alike dismasted around her. Masts and debris litter the battlefield to the point where only small patches of seawater can been seen. An American artillery cannon has been shooting for many turns now from the Castle ramparts, but winning this battle will require a herculean effort.

Truly awe-inspiring:

The Gaule blasts apart the Jackson and sends the ship to a fiery doom!

At the top, the Bonaparte and Descharges are going around the big island in an attempt to surprise the Americans from the northwest.

Once again the natural obstructions (in this case islands rather than fog) make for a severe bottleneck of the battle area. It just so happens this battle is being fought along a territorial border with many things in between, from the island at the left down to Fish Island.

The Auguste dismasted the Swamp Fox, so the Americans will need to find replacements for them to keep up the defensive front.

The Soleil Royal and Mercure will have a tough time even maneuvering to The Flat for repairs.

The War for Karkuda rages on:

The Atlanta and Mohican set the Montreal and Toulouse aflame! The DJC Saratoga adds to the fires on the Monte Cristo, who is now doomed!

Continuing the red-hot American resistance, the Marie Antoinette begins to burn.

With the Lamon gone, a gap opens up at the battle in the center. However, no American gunships are able to fill it yet, a testament to the very gradual French advance.

However, the Blackwatch is finally in action! She hits the Ville de Paris with stinkpot shot, denying her the use of many abilities next turn! (including EA and firepot specialist)

The Moulin Rouge finally lost a mast, as the Springfield tows the Hudson out of harm’s way. Kikowa (aboard the Philadelphia) hopes to warp the Hudson home next turn.

The Providence unloads her infantry at the lumber island, though it too has stopped producing resources. The troops will give the Americans a (likely temporary…) vantage point and platform from which to add musket volleys into the mix of chaos.

Continuing the American success this turn (especially with fire), the Adventurous and Paladin replace the American derelicts and turn the Gaule into a blaze!

The Jackson was scuttled due to her fire, while the Swamp Fox was towed out of the way by the Seminole, an American cheerleader like the Springfield and Hannah. The Lenox has replaced the Swamp Fox to fight the Auguste, backed up by the Niagara.

American logistics at this late stage of the game. With no more resources to gather, the Rattlesnake, Argo, Louisiana and James Madison head to the Castle for crew since the home island is too crowded for more ships to dock. The Constitution, Ghost Walker, Vermont, and Appalachian head north to inject life into the American resistance.

Between that picture and this one, you can see that the Americans still have a very real shot at winning this war. Four Pirate prizes look to back up the American line, showing that the conflict will not end anytime soon. Some canoes stay put to avoid getting in the way, while others head towards the hottest action.

The American home island, where 14 ships are in various stages of the repair process. The Bellevue carries the final metals from Luck Island, while you may have noticed a few new ships that were just launched…

The Americans have cashed in their metals and textiles for a big windfall! Spending 158 of 336 gold, they launch some ships they’ve been waiting on for quite some time. The Thomas Jefferson is one of my absolute favorite American ships, and you can probably guess that it’s the canceller version of DNT. The others are crewed great as well, with the Eagan and Mercury ready to dish out serious punishment. The Hessian is arguably the toughest little 1 master in the game from a combat standpoint: in a game with no ram damage, she becomes even more obnoxious. The canceller ability is key, but 4 cargo spaces and 9 points of cap space allows you to go crazy with crew and equipment. Here she has a captain, helmsman, shipwright, oarsman, and grape shot to be a little devil to the French.

The Hessian, Mercury, Cheyenne, and (relaunched) Minuteman are launched from the Castle, while the Carolina received a captain and oarsman while docked there.

Now for some grand pictures to show the Sea of Karkuda in its bloody glory.

Even from high above, notice the density of those battle areas! O_O

Five fires burn at the Spanish area of the battle… with none of them on American ships.

The lighthouse has gotten some French gunships to the battle area faster, but it was more useful when their resource system was still in full swing (aka before the Cursed attack).

The Americans didn’t really have room (anywhere) to launch much more stuff, but they wouldn’t have anyway. That’s because they’re saving some gold for an experimental purchase….

At the hottest battle area, I think there may be more masts floating in the water than there are masts standing on the ships that are engaged! O_O

A rare view above the western edge of the sea, showing American waters.

The Frontier has loaded infantry units and is likely taking them to the Castle.

A very rare shot looking due east. I love how it shows the custom terrain and structures I’ve made, as well as the relationship between The Flat and the Castle: control one, and you’ll likely be brought into conflict with whoever controls the other.

The Sea of Karkuda:

With that, another report is finished. Soon, the game will be finished. However, that will not be the case unless I make some extreme changes. You have already seen the start of this, with most islands running out of resources when ships dock at them, and with fog lifting to reveal more of the ocean to all the factions. A change of season perhaps. XD

It was always my intent to play this game to true completion, which would mean that the last fleet afloat is the winner. With an ending date goal of 12/20 in mind, I clearly cannot make that happen at the current pace, with over 9,000 points in play and about 3 weeks to go. I didn’t want to change the rules, but I’d rather do that than finish the game with a point count and with a ton of stuff unresolved (wars, storylines, alliances, etc). The following changes will be instituted NOW, at the beginning of Turn 77:

-Back to regular combat rules. Ships do not have to be hit twice to lose a mast, and do not have to be hit twice as many times as they originally had masts to sink.

This will massively speed things up. Ships will sink left and right, at a frenetic pace that will likely far outstrip Economy Edition (when more than 10 ships would sometimes sink on a turn). The weeks-long battles that have been going on will finally be decided, and wars will be fought to a satisfying conclusion rather than stopped artificially when “time is up”.

I am still worried that I will not be able to truly finish the game by around December 20th, but I will do my best. More rules will likely be necessary. Here are the main ones I am thinking about:

-No more launches (likely to be instituted on Turn 80)
-No more repairing, in any way, ever. O_O

These are both likely to take effect, especially the first one (which I’m basically planning on at this point). Thus, this latest resource change will likely be the last outside of any random changes in the next few turns. It’s a fitting end though, since the change allowed most factions to cash in major stores of resources, and lasts for a long enough time (10 turns) that resources and launches will be irrelevant by the time the next change would occur.

As I said, I’m not happy to have to do this, but this thing has to stop at some point. XD I’d much rather have a real conclusion by changing all sorts of rules than have to suddenly stop when a ton of stuff is happening all around the oceans.

Thanks for reading!

I played the first turn using the standard combat rules. The “endgame” process is officially in motion….

Pirate infantry move around the top of the Tunnel! 3 units make their way west, and two units go east.

The Celtic Fury’s explore action got some big 2L ladders to the summit. These were then thrown over the edge of the Tunnel by the troops working on the eastern area.

To the Hades’ Flame waiting below!

The HF was already in position from last turn, and troops clambered up the ladder to join their comrades!

Greetings are exchanged as yet more infantrymen become familiar with the Tunnel’s top.

The Hades’ Flame was also carrying something a bit heavier!

A cannon is hoisted to the top!

One of my favorite pictures so far of the Tunnel logistics:

Overall the Pirates have done quite well with their mission. They have explored the Tunnel at both ends, finally found a suitable spot where they can tunnel to the top, and now have both boots and artillery atop the summit. Quite the impressive show!

Captain Mission’s Pirate Kingdom, more well-defended than ever.

With all Pirate wild islands now out of resources, various Pirate cargo ships receive captains for the final stage of the game, which promises to be the bloodiest conclusion in CG history. The Pirates were already using some very good hybrids as resource ships (Eagle, Grand Barnacle, Darkhawk II, Foresight, etc), so making the change to full-time warship will go smoothly. Some of them even had captains already!

The northern whirlpool of Allost is swarming with Pirate gunships.

A triple line of gunships guards the reef barrier. Calypso now has about a dozen “bodyguards”. XD

Ready for anything, the Pirates will continue to optimize their defenses and wait for the best faction to come to them.

Many ships repair at Dead Man’s Point, as the newly launched ships join the newly repaired ships.

Still blocking both whirlpools, the Pirates are in a very good position.

The kingdom from above:

A few shots out of the east:

And now we move to the JR-Cursed War, where the normal combat rules are seeing their first action of the game.

Already a ton of progress is being made at the battlefield. The Monkey’s Paw is nowhere to be found, sunk by the Sahara and Virtuous Wind.

The Grand Path is going home for repairs, while the Poor Adams and Sea Hag lose masts.

The Grand Temple is finally able to emerge from the fog and return home! The fog bank she was in lifts, and more of the Tunnel is revealed to the Jade Rebels! The Naegling, Sea Wind, and Noble Swan are eager to explore what has been plaguing them for so long after rolling poorly in the fog banks.

The Nubian Prince gets into action with a bang! The Sickle loses two masts and her captain to Aruj Barbarossa. The Crescent Moon is one of two JR “medical barges” (the other being the Marrakesh), and prepares to give a shipwright to the Griffin.

The Splendor knocks a mast off the Demon Gate, but the galleys closest to the Roost cannot find their mark.

The Rook’s Folly sinks and a few squids lose segments, but the Sea Monkey escapes being derelict.

At this point I will try to do “graveyards” at the end of each round or even at the end of some notable faction turns. With regular combat rules in place, the game will now resemble my 2015 Economy Edition game with these massive graveyards. Here are the Cursed game pieces eliminated by the Jade Rebellion this turn, though they also lost the Tiger’s Eye to fire.

The Cursed show their dominance near Broken Horn Island. The Needle rolls badly for her fire mast and is doomed.

Terrox and Brachyura have not been in action here in this war, and now they strike hard on the same turn!!

The Sahara is suspended in the air, lifted out of the water by the strong tentacles:

Success and failure for the Cursed:

The Cursed will have a tough time with the Nubian Prince, but they (re) dismast the Donar and take out the Splendor.

The Terror of Gibraltar and Jackal’s Teeth were predictably sunk, and for now the Cursed have saved the Roost from direct invasion.

The creatures finished off the Grand Mountain (a true combat veteran of this game) and the Sultan’s Sword. Cursed cargo ships are being forced into the line of duty without captains, as the Cyclone and Sea Rat simply block the galleys’ advance to prevent them from sinking the Guichuan (suddenly vulnerable at the Roost with the change in combat rules) on the Jade turn.

Calim rises to the surface in a rage to pin the Sea Dragon:

Wow! The Cursed sink 6 JR ships, as compared to 3 Cursed ships on the JR turn. (that is just the Mermaid to the left, as I put the stuff in the southeastern corner of Allost during the play turn)

An ominous sight: Shal-Bala finishes repairing, and may return to the battle soon! At the left, notice that the Cursed troops scurried back up the ladder just before the Bloody Blade finished off the Jackal’s Teeth.

The Sea of Allost, 77 turns into the game:

The Pirates control the eastern half, and may control the entirety of this ocean if the Cursed and Jades continue to beat the cargo out of each other.

Flash:

No flash:

Already the battlefield looks more empty. Makes me sad, but of course the game must end at some point.

Pure dominance, with a single-fleet point count possibly coming soon for the sake of the record books….

A relatively crowded English HI:

Spaniards heading for the whirlpool and Karkuda…

With Rogelio Vazquez, the Acorazado manages to shoot above the Marie Antoinette and take out a pesky American infantry unit!

You may have wondered by now how the Spanish will retake the Castle. I have devised a custom ruling for it. Enemy ships can “dock” at the Castle and combine their boarding rolls (for example, a 3 master with a roll of 4 would contribute 7) together. If the total score is 25 or more, the Castle is captured and changes hands. Especially this late in the game, I am not interested in automatically destroying the fort upgrade inside used for launches, so when/if the Castle changes hands, so does the ability to launch ships from it.

On this turn the 4 Spanish ships at the right amassed a total score of 21, and failed to take the Castle. The Spanish will try again, and plan to retake the Castle and use it as their new “home island”!!

The slow but steady flow of incoming Spanish ships will continue next turn. The Cristal del Obispo is the latest ship to arrive.

Chaos reigns in the Sea of Karkuda as the Mercenaries all rise to the surface at once!! The Mobilis and Devil Ray don’t have captains, but the French sub hunters are attacked and lose 3 masts total. Nemo captures the captain of the Espadon.

French revenge is swift, and just like that the Mercenaries are almost out of the game. The Terror and Devil Ray are sunk, and only 5 hull segments remain in the Merc fleet.

At long last we get to see the French machine in action, with various gunships all over their home waters ready to assist combat operations at a moment’s notice. It reminds me of how fast and efficiently the Pirates took care of the English not too long ago.

At Pearl Island, the French 2 masters have teamed up to finally capture the Sunrise Fire:

The beauty of French power in this game: even with the Merc uprising (pun intended XD), they are able to maintain their close blockade of the Cursed whirlpool and calmly continue to sail gunships out west towards the real deal of warfare in this game.

As the action develops! The Montreal and Toulouse finally need replacing, and the Epee and Flamberge are happy to oblige. Their American counterparts will also need replacing. In yet another example of equipment backfiring on me, the Auguste rolls a 1 with fire shot.

The French press their advantage!!

You may have noticed some new space opening up: the Saratoga and Hudson were sank (both were already mastless hulks), while the Blackwatch was also sunk!

No less than 10 ships are in various stages of the repair process at The Flat:

About half of those are ready to return to action, while the crippled Soleil Royal will provide additional work for the island’s numerous troops.

The American line has gradually been thinned out, and now the Americans are being pushed back.

The Philadelphia will not be able to warp the Hudson home after all, and the French may finally be able to move into American waters soon.

The Paladin and Lenox lose masts, but the French crews aboard Le Gaule and L’Auguste are utterly spent and will need to be replaced soon.

From near the masts of the Gruesome, the Bonaparte and Descharges continue making their way around the big island.

Here you can see the supply line of fresh French gunships arriving near the battle.

Considerable firepower has yet to shoot, as the Tepant, Grand Vainqueur, Aube, and Saber attempt to find American targets.

The French position looks very strong, as the tide of battle begins to sway in their favor:

The French sunk 4 American ships this turn, including the mighty Blackwatch:

The Speedy Return replaces the Atlanta, and the Flamberge is set aflame by the Mohican:

A unique view of this area from the north:

The Marie Antoinette is doomed to burn. She rolled for a terrible fog exit location, placing her right between the American-Spanish crossfire. In fact, this area has now become “the spot” in the American-Spanish part of the battle ever since the Spanish established their foothold in the NE corner of the Castle.

6 ships are heading to the Castle for crew, while the Overton can finally repair somewhere.

The Cheyenne tows the Minuteman flotilla under the Castle rampart – a nice shortcut for ships that can fit!

Of course, the Carolina has done this before:

The Americans fight back quite well! There’s so much carnage and debris that it’s hard to tell what’s going on, but at the left the Providence has dismasted the Moulin Rouge and Intrepide. The Ville de Paris has been dismasted and set aflame.

At the right, the Cleopatre is not even visible under the wreckage of her own masts:

The arrivals of the Constitution (with Ralph David aboard) and Ghost Walker mean that the French will not be able to advance unchecked into American waters.

Similar to the 2v2 situation near Fish Island, attrition finally favors the Americans! Le Gaule is sunk and the Auguste nearly dismasted, with a solid morale victory for the Americans. The Gaule has been a powerful force in this battle since the start. Her loss combined with that of the Ville de Paris (likely but not guaranteed due to chain towing rescue attempts and even a good fire roll XD) and captured Charlemagne means that the French fleet of capital ship 5 masters is not completely intact.

Here I count about a dozen “gunships” headed towards the battle areas, some more well-equipped than others.

The ones at the left are certainly ready to fight, among them the newly launched Thomas Jefferson and Eagan. The Charlemagne has actually repaired all of her masts, I just didn’t want to deconstruct almost the entire battle area by “the spot” just to find the masts. I’m probably just going to leave as many masts in the water as possible for the rest of the game for maximum carnage. XD

A dozen gunships here, a dozen gunships there – ’tis a HUGE GAME!! XD

Last report I hinted that the Americans were thinking about an “experimental purchase”… I now ask you to consider what that nice open space could be used for… now devoid of fog and without a lot of ships right there….

Hmmm what could it be……… ?

A CASTLE EXTENSION!!!!!

O_O

Spending 100 of their 188 current gold, the Americans have built a new structure that adds onto the Castle development! Real estate in Pirate CSG! XD 

This didn’t come about by some fluke. When exploring the Castle further in somewhat recent turns, the Americans found various maps and plans detailing possible ways to expand the Castle. They were intrigued by the possibility, and with the latest resource change, they finally have the resources to pull it off. The Spanish were aware of these old plans, which is part of the reason they wanted to retake the Castle: before the Americans could do this! The reefs provide a solid base for structural support underneath the new castle area, which has been built right near the battlefield!

The “new” Sea of Karkuda – bet you didn’t see that coming! XD The French now have another giant obstacle (literally) in their path to reaching the American home island. It also serves to shrink the battle area back down even as the lifting fog and new combat rules were beginning to open up more space in the area.

The Turn 77 graveyard. 16 ships were sunk, obviously a high for this game by far and not a huge surprise given the two massive battles going on under the normal combat rules. The Jades and Americans suffered most heavily, but the wars are FAR from over….

More excitement and surprises to come, so stay tuned!

New rule: No repairs can be carried out.

As Turn 78 begins, the Pirates continue to explore the top of the Tunnel.
The Celtic Fury was given an explore action, and a 2L ladder and some supplies have been brought to the top.

Where could those troops be going?

These ones are certainly ready for action!

The cannon has been positioned to fire a wide arc over Pirate waters in case any invaders show up. (this is one of my favorite things about the Tunnel – this hole was already there as part of the foam piece)

The Pirates spend all of their 244 gold on 15 new gunships! To cut costs and put as many ship in play as possible, they aren’t crewed as heavily as the previous handful of launches.

As I said earlier, I wanted to do a point count of the Pirate fleet in particular since I know it’s the biggest fleet ever seen in a game. For the sake of the record books, a full ship and point count was done.

Here are the Pirate deckplate areas:

Behold: Captain Mission’s Pirate Kingdom at its true height!!

The 2L ladder is now just a convenient access point for the Pirates to use, instead of transferring everything through the Celtic Fury.

The new records, set by the Pirate fleet of Command the Oceans:

131 ships (breaking the Spanish record of 111 ships set in VASSAL Campaign Game 1)
2,347 points (breaking their own record from earlier in this game)

O_O

Picture #5000 taken with this camera.